Jump to content

Buyer Beware ?

MilTimeCan
 Share

Recommended Posts

MilTimeCan WRT Addict

MilTimeCan

Posted
Posted

I was wandering around ebay (you never know what you can find) and I spotted a few pocket watches.

While I fully admit not being anywhere remotely close to having any expertise in pocket watches, I thought some of the pocket watch experts here would get a chuckle.

I found this one, apparently an Omega:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Antique-WWI-Imperial-Russian-officers-award-Omega-pocket-watch-NO-RESERVE-RARE/302504949895?hash=item466eb33887:g:Mg0AAOSwEOpZ9OwF 

This one a Lange & Sohne: 

https://www.ebay.com/itm/German-General-award-A-LANGE-SOHNE-A1-GRADE-CHRONOMETER-silver-enamel-watch/322111062708?_trkparms=aid%3D888007%26algo%3DDISC.MBE%26ao%3D1%26asc%3D48736%26meid%3Dc2edbb2340cf4c76b8ce5137abeca126%26pid%3D100009%26rk%3D2%26rkt%3D2%26sd%3D322736087928&_trksid=p2047675.c100009.m1982  

A "one of a kind" Patek, only 99,000 US

https://www.ebay.com/itm/WOW-The-earliest-known-Patek-Philippe-Perpetual-Calendar-Moon-Phase-watch-c1866-/302506227233 

a "ONE OF A KIND WWI Imperial Russian Submarine Captain's Chronograph award watch"

https://www.ebay.com/itm/ONE-OF-A-KIND-WWI-Imperial-Russian-Submarine-Captains-Chronograph-award-watch-/322836262374 

But my personal favorite is this one:

960091053_tp.jpg.7826e011e893263df8ec3ddfa26affe6.jpg   

 

The ad states : Important Historical WWI German Officer's Iron Cross award silvered pocket watch

the seller wants ...harumpf... 5,775 US dollars for it.

There's a just a teeny tiny problem with the description and watch...

just a little one....well maybe more than one, but this one is a problem.

The picture on the watch is quite famous,  it appears in Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_the_Bulge#/media/File:German_soldier_Ardennes_1944.jpeg 

it's from the Ardennes Offensive aka the Battle of the Bulge which occurred in ....

1944

well after World War 1

 

German_soldier_Ardennes_1944.jpeg.thumb.jpeg.5da3b50f79680d851e55794e08e2c6df.jpeg

 

  • Like 2
PJA WRT Addict

PJA

Posted
Posted

I've reported these items to eBay and promised that it'll be taken care of. Hopefully with all of us, joint efforts, it'll make it harder for criminals to operate and abuse innocent people.

  • Like 2
AdamC WRT Addict

AdamC

Posted
Posted
I've reported these items to eBay and promised that it'll be taken care of. Hopefully with all of us, joint efforts, it'll make it harder for criminals to operate and abuse innocent people.

Yep, being new (and naïve) to the watchmaking hobby I got caught on ebay to a much lesser degree with a so-called “Oris” vintage wristwatch. I feel stupid now as this “vintage“ 1960s watch had no patina on the dial or the usual scratches/dings on the case that you would expect from a watch of this era. On opening it there was a bright new shiny “Swiss Made” 17 Jewel movement with a cheap plastic retaining ring. Definitely not an Oris movement. A less than £40 “bargain”. Amazingly it keeps brilliant time though :-)


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
  • Like 1
PJA WRT Addict

PJA

Posted
Posted (edited)
10 minutes ago, AdamC said:


Yep, being new (and naïve) to the watchmaking hobby I got caught on ebay to a much lesser degree with a so-called “Oris” vintage wristwatch. I feel stupid now as this “vintage“ 1960s watch had no patina on the dial or the usual scratches/dings on the case that you would expect from a watch of this era. On opening it there was a bright new shiny “Swiss Made” 17 Jewel movement with a cheap plastic retaining ring. Definitely not an Oris movement. A less than £40 “bargain”. Amazingly it keeps brilliant time though :-)


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

I have also bought a watch for repair at a flea market for about $5 which turn fake. I guess in a way as beginners its part of paying our dues for getting into this hobby.  About the watch keeping time, I have Chinese watches that I've bought for less than $5 about a year ago and they keep time perfectly.:huh:

Edited by PJA
  • Like 1
Chopin Super WRT Addict

Chopin

Posted
Posted (edited)

This should have been enough for a couple of red flags, even so, I'm amazed by how many people still bid...

Item location:
Sofia, Bulgaria
Edited by Chopin
PJA WRT Addict

PJA

Posted
Posted (edited)

let's hope that eBay will block the seller soon. I've reported him about two hours ago on the "Report item" above the item number and also have called them and spoke to a rep, but the seller is still there, unfortunately.

Edited by PJA
oldhippy Distinguished Member

oldhippy

Posted
Posted

There is a lot dodgy stuff on ebay. I am always reporting clocks to them. If you are going to bid and hopefully win the bid make, sure ebay will cover the price.

  • Like 1
jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted

It is right to report sellers of fake or wrongly described items to Ebay. However in case of this seller riaerica2000 I would be cautious, as on his side are 2185 positive feedback (100%) since 2004. And with PayPal handling the payment and routinely siding with the buyer, it's not so easy to pull scams for for a long time. 
 

  • Like 1
wls1971 Distinguished Member

wls1971

Posted
Posted (edited)

Fools and their money are easily parted, the Bulgaria seller has been at it for years he takes some very high end watches and ruins them in a bid to add value by giving them spurious provenance . Other favorite themes include the  1936 olympics , doctors watches, memento mori always featuring skulls.

I cannot see Ebay dealing with him any time soon he as been making good money for years and I should think continue to do so.

Other widely faked watches at the moment are Breitling and Cuevro Y Sobrinos chronographs all derived from 1940's and 1950's landeron based chronographs with dials refinished and movements and cases laser etched once you learn to spot them it is surprising how many are floating around Ebay  especially among Italian and American sellers.

 

Ebay "You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainy. We must be cautious"

Edited by wls1971
  • Like 2
frenchie Distinguished Member

frenchie

Posted
Posted

The funny thing with the Patek is that he posts a picture of the watch from a catalog, and there is also a picture of the moment in the catalog. The movement pictured in the catalog and the one he has pictured on the listing do not match. I reported the item.

As for the Omega, lol!!! I asked him to post a picture of the certificate of authenticity, just for laughs.

I wonder how many people spend more than few $100 on ebay... in my opinion, it's a lot of money to give someone for a product you have not seen with your own eyes. And my wallet can't afford the loss.

 

frenchie Distinguished Member

frenchie

Posted
Posted

Seller's response regarding the certificate of authenticity for the "Omega":

"The certificate comes with the watch and the buyer will receive it

I can't send photos because it contain personal information"

MilTimeCan WRT Addict

MilTimeCan

Posted
  • Author
Posted
1 hour ago, frenchie said:

Seller's response regarding the certificate of authenticity for the "Omega":

"The certificate comes with the watch and the buyer will receive it

I can't send photos because it contain personal information"

ROTFL !!!!!! :startle::wacko:

Watchtime Super WRT Addict

Watchtime

Posted
Posted

In the early years ofcollecting,I too bought Omega,Oris and the like with non existing dails ...frankenwatches ect. Even a "unique" Seiko. Allpart of the learning experience....Lately, I saw a lot of "printed" dails for erotic and ww2 pocket watches...do research before you buy.

vinn3 Distinguished Member

vinn3

Posted
Posted

internet site  adverts are designed to fool.  i sent money to the Bay for a watch bracelet pin pusher,  though it was well designed, it had soft metal and the pins bent - and broke.  the  recovery is " make good steel pins and harden them properly".   vin

jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, vinn3 said:

internet site  adverts are designed to fool.  i sent money to the Bay for a watch bracelet pin pusher,  though it was well designed, it had soft metal and the pins bent - and broke.  the  recovery is " make good steel pins and harden them properly".   vin

Hehe, that exactly the same type of pin pushers I was getting too :)
But I think you're generalizing too much.
I trade watches on the internet, plus I buy all kinds of stuff. Never had a problem, and most sellers and buyers are wonderful. Last week a Chinese seller offered to ship again the item (for free) because it had erroneously been sent as registered mail instead of ePacket!  Of course when I pay cheaply, I receive cheap stuff, just like when I buy at the thrift shop on the corner.

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • mbwatch
      Elgin Grade 315: Runs/stops with dial down/up

      By mbwatch · Posted

      Hmm, if it is sitting that low I am not sure I would blame end shake (which would be to blame if you turned it DU and the hairspring touched the balance cock). If it is sitting so low that the balance rubs on the pallet bridge I would verify that the balance arms are not dished downward and also that the lower balance jewel doesn't have an issue such as being chipped. Or the balance staff is actually too short, which would have caused your earlier end shake problems too. If you install the pallet bridge without the pallet fork and install the balance, is your free oscillation still good or is it immediately bound up on the pallet bridge? (I have an elgin watch like that where someone in the past ground down the pallet bridge significantly) Yes, you'll need to rotate the hairspring but deal with the pallet bridge interference first.
    • docrpm
      Elgin Grade 315: Runs/stops with dial down/up

      By docrpm · Posted

      Ok. So given that I had free oscillations DU/DD for roughly the same time, I reassembled with the pallet fork and bridge underneath, and now I can see two more problems.    1. The arms of the balance are nearly flush with the pallet bridge. Bad. I can speculate as to why…the end shake still looks to be too much. Maybe other causes as well? 2. The balance doesn’t spin freely. In the resting position, it looks like the impulse jewel is outside the jaws of the pallet fork. Not by much, but still outside. If it needs be inside in the static position, then I’m guessing I’ll need to rotate my hairspring collet to change orientation by a few degrees.    The journey continues…
    • stm
      Doxa women's watch (radioactive)

      By stm · Posted

      Ok, that's good to know, thank you.
    • Michalzeszen
      ETA 2472 - how to tackle this crown and stem?

      By Michalzeszen · Posted

      Andy, why you betray me?   I may have good news. I'll share later!
    • Stefango
      Somewhat as reward

      By Stefango · Posted

      Hi. I have been touching watches for quite some years, but haven’t before pretty recently decided to jump of the cliff by trying to do basic service for the first time. It is a simple Seiko 6602 I bought as a renovation movement.  To be honest I struggled. Mainly because I wanted to do everything correctly and with all the right tools etc from the start.  From just having basic tools I invested in quite a lot of things in order to dissemble, clean and lubricate the movement parts. I can say it was a journey.  Taking care of the balance jewels looks really easy watching all the great videos, but god damn… I have been lucky and only shot away things that was found but come on. Anyway. I have now managed to “service” four movements and the result is what makes me want to keep doing this.    The first movement was a Seiko 6602 and it was in a pretty bad shape. When I run it on the Timegraoher now I got an amplitude of 270 and in all positions it stays around +-2s.    I have heard some “amateurs” saying this is a hobby you’ll get stuck to and I am already there. It doesn’t matter if it’s a fancy movement or a simple 6602. The feeling after been struggling and you see the result… it’s amazing! I am still in a state where I am confused and don’t know which watch press tool is best, or if I need the most fancy hand tools etc, but to be honest. This is so stimulating.    Sorry for not really adding anything new to you all pros. 
×
×
  • Create New...