Jump to content

Help, please with watch gaining time

Bill3

By Bill3
in Watch Repairs Help & Advice

 Share

Recommended Posts

Bill3 Watch Enthusiast

Bill3

Posted
Posted

I would be most grateful for some help with a watch that I have been working on.  The watch is an Elgin wrist watch, serial number C453730, that I bought in a not running condition.  It has 17 jewels and all the original parts are there.  I cleaned and lubed the watch and when reassembled, IT RAN!  My success was short lived, however, because it gained about three hours per day.  I moved the adjustment lever located over the hairspring, all the way toward the "S" but that made no difference whatever.  One positive aspect is that the watch is consistent in it's time gain, always three hours a day.  I have included a picture.  Any help or suggestions would be appreciated.  Thanks in advance.

Bill

Augusta, Georgia, USA

image.jpeg

oldhippy Distinguished Member

oldhippy

Posted
Posted

I suggest you have a very close look at the balance and hairspring. It could still be dirty. Make sure you always demagnetise the movement before starting work on it. If you do not have anti magnetic screwdrivers or tweezers, you should also demagnetise those as well. If you get into the habit of this each time, it could save you a lot of time and hassle.   

Chopin Super WRT Addict

Chopin

Posted
Posted

Could be a hairspring problem as suggested. When it was taken out of the movement was it perfectly coiled/round or did you notice any bends ?

Also, you adjusted the regulator but that one cannot correct such a big time inaccuracy. If it was a few minutes then you could fix it through the regulator.

Best to keep it in the middle for now so that it won't mess up your diagnostics.

One other issue is that the hairspring might be out of beat. You can control that one through the 2nd stud near the regulator. (it's close to the screw in your photo) Did you somehow move that by mistake ?

wls1971 Distinguished Member

wls1971

Posted
Posted

Its hard to tell from the pictures but you need to closely inspect it under a loop, are you sure you have not got two coils of the hairspring between the regulator pin that would cause such a massive gain. It almost looks to me like you have the overcoil and outer coil of the hairspring going through the regulator.

noirrac1j Distinguished Member

noirrac1j

Posted
Posted

Did you oil the hairspring pivot when you re-assembled? Looks like the first two coils are touching, which could be due to fouling: either oil or dirt.....take the hairspring out and clean it again in Naptha. Also, demagnetize.

J

  • Like 1
jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, Chopin said:

One other issue is that the hairspring might be out of beat. You can control that one through the 2nd stud near the regulator. (it's close to the screw in your photo) Did you somehow move that by mistake ?

Such old watches do not have an adjustable end stud. Beat error can only be corrected rotating the HS collet. Beside, that would not cause 10,800 sec/day fast rate.

rogart63 Distinguished Member

rogart63

Posted
Posted
52 minutes ago, noirrac1j said:

Did you oil the hairspring pivot when you re-assembled? Looks like the first two coils are touching, which could be due to fouling: either oil or dirt.....take the hairspring out and clean it again in Naptha. Also, demagnetize.

J

It looks like a  brequet hairspring .

noirrac1j Distinguished Member

noirrac1j

Posted
Posted
4 hours ago, rogart63 said:

It looks like a  brequet hairspring .

Yes it might be, but Breguet overcoil doesn't account for the thickness of that first coil. I'm not sure if that alone explains +3 hours a day, but I'd start with that hairspring. It doesn't look right.

 

J

  • Like 1
JohnR725 Distinguished Member

JohnR725

Posted
Posted

Usually when we see pictures we have a hard time seeing what we need to see. But occasionally when you look at the picture it will give you a magnifying glass. So the parts that we're looking at that we were struggling is now attached. Also slightly misleading there's an over coil which is over the outer curves we really need a sideways you but all of us on the group instantly recognize hairspring problem.

Not only are the coils stuck together but it doesn't even look like the over coil is alignment with the regulator pins it looks like it's on one side. So everyone above has given great advice you need to clean your hairspring it appears to be stuck together. Magnetism with this type of balance wheel it should be a nonmagnetic hairspring but it's they still get affected with magnetism they shouldn't be stuck together like this though.

 

hairspring not good.JPG

Bill3 Watch Enthusiast

Bill3

Posted
  • Author
Posted

What a great forum!!  I asked a question yesterday and already have 10 helpful answers.   I am working on cleaning the hairspring again, inspecting it, demagnetising the watch, and trying to figure out why the first loop of the hairspring looks as if it is stuck to the next loop.  

Thanks everyone who responded.  I will post again as soon as I have finished this work, reassembled, and let it run long enough to see if the problem is resolved.  

Thanks again,

Bill

 

Bill3 Watch Enthusiast

Bill3

Posted
  • Author
Posted

This is a follow up comment on my earlier question about my watch that was running fast.  I had many great answers, most directed toward the hairspring.  As suggested, I demagnitized the watch and all the tools to be used in the repair.  Then I removed the balance wheel, hairspring, and the plate holding the mechanism in the watch and soaked them in Naptha overnight.  Then I reassembled the watch, wound it and let it run for 24 hours.  A dramatic change had occurred.  It gained, not three hours, but three minutes!  

Thanks to all who gave me such good advise and helped put this watch back in service.

Bill in Augusta, Georgia, USA

 

 

  • Like 2
noirrac1j Distinguished Member

noirrac1j

Posted
Posted
50 minutes ago, Bill3 said:

Yeah! sounds like you solved the problem. The 3 minute gain is fine for a watch this old, and you can probably get it to run a little tighter if you had a timegrapher, but hey.... Good job!

J

vinn3 Distinguished Member

vinn3

Posted
Posted
On 1/6/2018 at 3:32 PM, Bill3 said:

I would be most grateful for some help with a watch that I have been working on.  The watch is an Elgin wrist watch, serial number C453730, that I bought in a not running condition.  It has 17 jewels and all the original parts are there.  I cleaned and lubed the watch and when reassembled, IT RAN!  My success was short lived, however, because it gained about three hours per day.  I moved the adjustment lever located over the hairspring, all the way toward the "S" but that made no difference whatever.  One positive aspect is that the watch is consistent in it's time gain, always three hours a day.  I have included a picture.  Any help or suggestions would be appreciated.  Thanks in advance.

Bill

Augusta, Georgia, USA

    good job, hair spring looks a little out of shape,  easy fix.  vin

 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • AndyGSi
      Watch of Today

      By AndyGSi · Posted

      So where did you take it? Was it the Sons of Timp?
    • AndyGSi
      Looking to try servicing an old movement

      By AndyGSi · Posted

      I'd leave the Benrus till you've got more experience as information and parts are non existent and donor movements are expensive. I know it's based on something like an ETA 2370 but what they changed and what's still compatible is unknown.
    • Nucejoe
      Hello and thank you in advance.

      By Nucejoe · Posted

      Hello and welcome to the WRT forum.
    • RichardHarris123
      Watch of Today

      By RichardHarris123 · Posted

      No, a light. PS, it's a Unicorn   hehe. 
    • watchhammer
      Looking to try servicing an old movement

      By watchhammer · Posted

      As a fellow newbie who's made a bunch of mistakes over the past year or 2 I'd like to offer my experience. I didn't start with a new practice movement, I started with 1970s Tissot that I loved. If I could do it over I would still use a vintage watch for my first movement. I wouldn't, however, chose one I cared about or that was expensive. It also had a calendar complication- dont do that. I learned a lot about part compatibility and movement families right away though! Emmy watch and Ranfft are great resources for this! I would start with the Benrus and go ahead and find a parts movement right away YOU WILL BREAK AND LOSE PARTS! Get good tweezers, it's much harder to handle tiny springs than YouTube would suggest. And be extra carful, pivots don't like to be forced into jewels - bridges are a real pain in the ass at the start. Don't be afraid to use your bare hands to hold parts/bridges and handle the movement. Finger cotts can come later. Be as carful as possible with hairsprings, this can ruin all the fun!  Buy a cheap demagnitizer. For me, I think its fine to buy cheap tools in the beginning and replace as you go. But some things I wish I'd have spent more money on right of the bat - TWEEZERS and Rodico (don't get the fake stuff). There's a great thread here on Chinese tools. I used a cheap digital microscope for a long time. I got quite good at working under it even with no depth perception. It's probably better to just use loupes but I think it helped me be more mindful and it was great for inspection. I now have a stereo microscope and if you get really into this hobby, it's a must. I cleaned everything by hand in the beginning. This is great for getting familiar with each part and learning to inspect for faults. Peg your jewels! I still hand clean a lot of parts before the ultrasonic. I still use JUST Naptha and IPA and I think thats adequate for my hobby purposes but maybe I'll have moved up in another year. I swish the shellaced parts in IPA for a few seconds to rinse (don't tell anyone). I used to dry each part on a sheet of paper with a puffer. Again, this is good for getting to know each part. I now dry everything in a food dehydrator. Im not going to give any advice on oil because thats suicide. But... until very recently I used just mobius 8000 and Molycote DX for everything. I dont know if I would do it differently If I were to go back but its definitely cheap and it will teach you how to apply oil.  Take a picture after every move even if it's just scratching yourself.  Wind mainsprings by hand until you decide you like the hobby, spend that winder money on tweezers and parts movements. This place is great, there are a bunch of incredible KNOWLEDGEABLE guys willing to help you. Unfortunately, this is as much as I can help, as I'm nowhere near their level.  Oh... and buy a big magnet. Still one of my favorite watches and it reminds me of all the broken pivots and pinged springs every time I put it on.   worth every penny.      
×
×
  • Create New...