Jump to content

Do you see anything strange in this balance wheel?


Recommended Posts

22 minutes ago, Delgetti said:

Is it possible for you to take of the automatic device? You just need a good screwdriver with the correct dimension and take out the 3 blueish screws of the automatic bridge:

 

Yes I can do it. Then what?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, rogart63 said:

 

Red line should turn in one direction regardless of which direction you turn the rotor.2017-03-13_12-51-51.jpg.b06b34353a8b91135f58ea7545cb1e5b.jpg.42e89c9e77f1f924ff0b928962be930f.jpg

What are you indicating with the red line? The  red wheel or the bronze ratchet wheel? Because the red one alternates direction while the bronze one is skipping the click, it seems.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, chriz74 said:

Any idea of why this skip could occur?

It's difficult to say, but as has already be suggested, my first guess would be wear to the auto-wind mechanism. It would require closer inspection. 

If this was my watch, I would probably find someone like Mark Lovick to send it to, but that's just my opinion. Saves you the hassle of dealing with Rolex who are trying to maintain a monopoly. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I took the rotor apart and took pictures then I assembled it back. One thing for sure now the ratchet wheel is not moving at all, only by manual winding. It seems to me that the part under the rotor is ok. Do you see anything?

KHjdfPa.jpg?1

 

sPSH5f1.jpg?1

 

EJI0M6C.jpg?1

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, chriz74 said:

What are you indicating with the red line? The  red wheel or the bronze ratchet wheel? Because the red one alternates direction while the bronze one is skipping the click, it seems.

I mean the bronze ratchet wheel. That should turn when you rotate the rotor? Are you sure you can work on this kind of movements? If you don't understand how a automatic watch  works?

How can you see that the reverse wheels are working? They turn? 

But do they click or engage? And transfer the power from the rotor to the ratchet wheel? And the mainspring? 

There are small little clicks inside the reverse wheels that need to engage the small ratchets on the outside of the reverse wheel? 

 

Edited by rogart63
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have only seen your video on an iphone, but I think the driving wheel (the wheel with the four holes in it) is turning when you move the rotor. Is it possible, that the connection within this part, the connection between the bronze driving wheel and the little wheel on it, is loose?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, chriz74 said:

Looking at my second picture it seems like one tooth of the center little wheel is slightly bent, at the top.

Yes, one of the pinion leaves looks slightly bent. Now, if this is true then here is some speculation:

- The auto winder may be broken as a result of extreme force against the winding pinion.

- Either the auto winder tried to wind the ratchet wheel which was somehow fixed, or the ratchet wheel wound against the auto winder pinion*

* looking at the direction that the pinion leaf is bent, I'm wondering if either the auto winder reverser function failed and it tried to wind the wrong way. Or, when manual winding, the auto winder jammed which meant that the ratchet wheel damaged the pinion while winding. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, rodabod said:

Yes, one of the pinion leaves looks slightly bent. Now, if this is true then here is some speculation:

- The auto winder may be broken as a result of extreme force against the winding pinion.

- Either the auto winder tried to wind the ratchet wheel which was somehow fixed, or the ratchet wheel wound against the auto winder pinion*

* looking at the direction that the pinion leaf is bent, I'm wondering if either the auto winder reverser function failed and it tried to wind the wrong way. Or, when manual winding, the auto winder jammed which meant that the ratchet wheel damaged the pinion while winding. 

ok but could this bent leave affect the whole auto winding to not work at all?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, Delgetti said:

I have only seen your video on an iphone, but I think the driving wheel (the wheel with the four holes in it) is turning when you move the rotor. Is it possible, that the connection within this part, the connection between the bronze driving wheel and the little wheel on it, is loose?

good point, I'll disassemble it again and check that. But I will do it in the afternoon. I'll post back.

P.S. let's say the connection is loose, a new wheel is needed or it can be tightened?

Edited by chriz74
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well guys, I contacted authorized Rolex Service center that sits 100 Kms from my home town. I decided to go there tomorrow morning and let them check it. I told them about the auto winding not engaging the ratchet wheel. They told they will be able to diagnose and fix it while I am waiting for as little as 100 euros + parts if needed. Unless a complete servicing is required, which I think it's not.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Deggsy said:


I am a novice so please excuse my input if it is rubbish. But might the fact that 'something is slipping' point to a problem with the mainspring or problem with it being unhooked? As I say I'm a novice but I read of a similar issue and wanted to share that with you.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It would be a good idea if the watch wasn't winding at all, but since it winds and runs fine when hand wound, IMO it rules out the mainspring (I'm also not a pro, so take this with a grain of salt ;) ).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, chriz74 said:

Well guys, I contacted authorized Rolex Service center that sits 100 Kms from my home town. I decided to go there tomorrow morning and let them check it. I told them about the auto winding not engaging the ratchet wheel. They told they will be able to diagnose and fix it while I am waiting for as little as 100 euros + parts if needed. Unless a complete servicing is required, which I think it's not.

Good news! Make sure you ask them what they did after they fix it!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Technician inspect the watch carefully, many parts to be changed, proposed full service. Accepted. Regarding the automatic device he told the pinions of the reverser wheel are damaged. Also told the beating of the rotor has to be replaced, one jewel is crooked, other parts worn out etc.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Main Spring unhooked perhaps?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Automatic mainsprings don't hook into the barrel, they are meant to slip to avoid damage to the winding gear. If it was unhooked from the abour, then it wouldn't wind by hand.
Seems the problems been solved anyway, just general wear and tear.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites


Automatic mainsprings don't hook into the barrel, they are meant to slip to avoid damage to the winding gear. If it was unhooked from the abour, then it wouldn't wind by hand.
Seems the problems been solved anyway, just general wear and tear.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Thanks for telling me. I have not worked on an automatic yet so obviously these a lot to learn [emoji51]


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Hello there, the watch was serviced for 640 euros, they gave 2 years international warranty and a 5 years warranty from the lab, they are very confident in their work. They replaced a lot of parts in the movement, reverser wheels, driving wheel, ratchet wheel, some other wheels, the barrel, the mainspring many screws and some other tiny parts. They put a new glass and crown and new gaskets. They also regulated the timing, polished and pressure tested the case. They have a video online of their lab if you want to check it:

 

Edited by chriz74
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, chriz74 said:

Hello there, the watch was serviced for 640 euros, they gave 2 years international warranty and a 5 years warranty from the lab, they are very confident in their work. They replaced a lot of parts in the movement, reverser wheels, driving wheel, ratchet wheel, some other wheels, the barrel, the mainspring many screws and some other tiny parts. They put a new glass and crown and new gaskets. They also regulated the timing, polished and pressure tested the case. They have a video online of their lab if you want to check it:

 

The price doesn't sound too bad considering all the replacement parts. I hope this finally puts the issue to bed. ^_^

Link to comment
Share on other sites




  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • The 73 was my setting lever make Mike, same piece fitted to your 72. I enjoyed working on the movement, fair quality. 73 wasn't front loading,but a tight spacer ring that i had to fit onto the movement before casing up. I had to adjust endshake on the third wheel  so apart from the make everthing else was good. 
    • Well it's arrived, and it's a pleasant surprise. A 11.5''' 21 jewel FHF 72. It's running (just) and looks in great condition.  It needs a good service, and new crown and strap.  It's a front loader but doesn't have a split stem. There's a small lever (visible when you remover the bezel), which when moved, frees the stem and the movement from the case (a new one on me).  
    • Hello and welcome from Leeds, England. 
    • Hi All, I'm Geoff and I've been working on/with watches and clocks since I was thirteen. My dad was a watchmaker and while he did not want me in the field as a profession, I've always maintained a pretty good working knowledge. In the '70's I kinda got pulled back into things because Quartz revolution began and he only had limited electronic knowledge. So we combined skills. He the watchmaker and me the electronics tech. Being here in NY helped because we got to know the folks from Bulova, Seiko, Citizen, and WOSIC. H.B. Freid was my Dad's teacher and I was fortunate enough to get to know him too. I still maintain a bench here at home and occasionally work on watches for friends although the hands aren't what they used to be. Not going to be working on any FHF59 or AS1012's any time soon. Oddly enough though my years working with the field taught me how to work on almost anything else mechanical and mostly electronic. Since I was the one in the family who maintained Dad's cleaning and timing machines. those experiences carried over quite nicely into the worlds of recording and audio as well as others. I look forward to the discussions and maybe still learning a trick or two. Cheers to all and nice to be here.  
    • The best and almost only way to achieve the magical £ 4.04 individual watch cost is via the loophole ploy of job lot buys Ross. Dividing down the outlay by the number of watches purchased. I've managed it many times in the past, this then gives you the extra edge of choosing any watch from that lot. Maybe we should have an all time winner, whos prepared to troll  through the last four years of posts and pick some worthy contenders. Unfortunately i have a poorly shoulder so i cant raise my right hand and my left shoulder is out in sympathy for my right shoulder. Put your right hand up if you think i talk a load of bull 💩     🖐 Tom's comment is purely restricted to  the Bergeon culture of " lets rip off everyone on the planet " Voted , i thought to keep it in pounds as originally designed and out of respect for Andy . Personally i would have kept the £4.04 as I'm very traditionalist and dont like change but i know how hard you overseas guys are finding it and i believe in fair play. I expect to be posting the occasional Omega or Longines but then you brought this on yourself so dont get jealous Scott 😆
×
×
  • Create New...