Jump to content

3 jaw chuck

Stevelp

By Stevelp
in Tools & Equipment

 Share

Recommended Posts

Stevelp Watch Enthusiast

Stevelp

Posted
Posted

Hi everyone, I hope you are all safe and well!  I recently got my hand on a small Boley 8mm lathe as I would like to try to broaden my skill set.  I’m looking into getting a 3 jaw chick for it but what I’m finding all seem to be fairly expensive, like in the 300-400 USD range for used.  I’m just wondering if anyone out there would have a suggestion of a brand or maybe has hands on experience with something that is more affordable?  I won’t be using it a whole lot therefore something more affordable would be great.  

83136644-82DF-4333-B135-4748758BC248.jpeg

rodabod Distinguished Member

rodabod

Posted
Posted

They are so expensive because they are very useful and not enough of them were made. That said, I’d be loath to pay more than £150 for one. Have a look for ones made by Burnerd - they were often included in Pultra sets and will work with Boley threads. Another option for a cheap range of larger chucks is to get an ER chuck with an 8mm fitting. 

watchweasol Distinguished Member

watchweasol

Posted
Posted

Hi  worth a try.     Thanks for the information jdm.    Some times its cheaper to purchase a lathe  and use the chuck, some lathes go for around  150 ....170, chucks on their own are around 230/250  Burnerd  chucks about the same NOT cheap.

rodabod Distinguished Member

rodabod

Posted
Posted
16 hours ago, vinn3 said:

a 4 jaw chuck would be a better investment.

This might sound like a dumb question, but what is the practical difference, other than there being an additional jaw?

A other much cheaper part which I would recommend is a jacob’s chuck. I have fantastic ones by Bergeon and Jacob’s USA and they are so quick and easy for drilling. 

  • Like 1
Specializedjim Member

Specializedjim

Posted
Posted

I have one of the cheap Chinese chucks and I actually find it quite good. I still use collets for precision work but for large diameters I find it ok. One thing I do find is that sometimes my lathe struggles a bit to spin the extra mass of the Chuck. 

vinn3 Distinguished Member

vinn3

Posted
Posted
Just now, vinn3 said:

CHUCKS;  jacob's  with 1/2 " x 20  thread US  will fit on some  unimat lathes.    a 3 jaw  chuck ( like a jacob's)) is suposed to be "dead center" and fast,     the  4 jaw chuck,   you set it to dead center or  off center for special jobs.  very veritile !  better choice at twice the price.   vin

 

jdrichard Distinguished Member

jdrichard

Posted
Posted

There is a US company called Sherline. They sell quality lathes and have 8mm lathe 3 jaw chucks with an adapter. I did a review on YouTube.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Klassiker Distinguished Member

Klassiker

Posted
Posted
On 5/21/2020 at 3:40 PM, rodabod said:

This might sound like a dumb question, but what is the practical difference, other than there being an additional jaw?

A 3-jaw chuck is self-centring. All 3 jaws tighten in unison, so you are at the mercy of the build quality or wear in terms of how centred your workpiece will be. On a 4-jaw chuck, the jaws adjust independently. It takes longer to set up, but by using an accurate measuring instrument e.g. a dial gauge, you can centre exactly. You can also hold non-round workpieces, or set up purposely off-centre.

  • Like 1
jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
1 hour ago, Klassiker said:

All 3 jaws tighten in unison, so you are at the mercy of the build quality or wear in terms of how centred your workpiece will be.

Not just the build quality, but the intrinsic limits of geometry and tolerances. Since the driving element a spiral groove that is common to all jaws, which must also work reversed, some design compromise must be taken so keep it acceptably smooth.
For example, on my Unimat 3 copy I have less than 0.01mm runout at the spindle chuck spindle register, but about 0.12mm with a precision 7mm round bar in the 3 jaws - which is the same as the Ebay example above.
There are ways to improve concentricity on  self-centering chucks, but in the end if precisions is needed either use collets, independant jaws, or turn between centers. There can be more ways also, as machining is full of ingenious methods.
All that being said, here we are talking about hobbyist / non-precisions chucks only. I'm sure that watchmaker's and and professional machines chucks have a different precision class. 

1 hour ago, Klassiker said:

On a 4-jaw chuck, the jaws adjust independently.

Not all 4 jaws chucks are of the independant type, and not all sellers do specify. Look for square sockets on the body in line with the center of all jaws. Below an self-centering 4 jaws chuck, again for the Unimat 3. These are mostly used for woodwork where high precision is not important, but you need to grab square section parts often. SAN-OU-Lathe-Chuck-50Mm-Mini-4-Jaw-Rever

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
rodabod Distinguished Member

rodabod

Posted
Posted

I’m not sure that I could be bothered with setting up a 4-jaw every time I wanted to do something simple like mounting a drill bit. My 3-jaw chuck is not for extremely accurate work. I’d like to measure it though. 

jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
13 hours ago, rodabod said:

I’m not sure that I could be bothered with setting up a 4-jaw every time I wanted to do something simple like mounting a drill bit. 

Nobody said that you have to use independent jaws all the time. Each machining tool has a purpose, and similar tools can overlap with another for certain tasks.

rodabod Distinguished Member

rodabod

Posted
Posted

Agreed. But I don’t think a 4-jaw is something I happen to need for my watchmaking lathe. Vinn says “4 jaw is best” but not for my needs. I’m not drilling main plate holes or anything like that.... I can’t think when I would have benefited from one. 
 

That said, I have used a 4-jaw a few times when making some tools on the larger clockmakers lathe. 

jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
9 hours ago, rodabod said:

Agreed. But I don’t think a 4-jaw is something I happen to need for my watchmaking lathe.

The issue with this topic is that it was started about watchmaker's lathing, then quickly migrated to general (hobby) machining. Similar but different  subjects, it's good to know a it of both.  

rodabod Distinguished Member

rodabod

Posted
Posted

Perhaps it did migrate, but someone initially stated that 4-jaws would be better, without referencing hobby machining.

I think there is a reason why self-centring 3-jaw chucks are the usual choice for watchmaking. I rarely do any eccentric turning, but I do have a faceplate which I can use.

Back to the original post: I can recommend getting a Burnerd or similar quality 3-jaw (German, Swiss, English, American). The Sherline chuck which jdrichard describes sounds promising too.

jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
6 hours ago, rodabod said:

Perhaps it did migrate, but someone initially stated that 4-jaws would be better, without referencing hobby machining.

Right. But we know well that our long time member vinn3 here is more familiar with machining that watchmaking :-) 

Stevelp Watch Enthusiast

Stevelp

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Wow, thanks everyone, there's a whole lot of awesome information happening here!  This went a whole lot deeper that I thought it would.  I think a 3 jaw is still the most fitting for what I'm looking to do.  jdrichard, great video!  What you have there is exactly what I would be looking for and after looking into it those pieces are way more affordable than what I have been finding on ebay. 

jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
42 minutes ago, Stevelp said:

I think a 3 jaw is still the most fitting for what I'm looking to do. 

For my curiosity, which is what?

Stevelp Watch Enthusiast

Stevelp

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I would like to try my hand at doing some different types of case finishes (circular brushing, radial lines of sunburst finishes etc.), and I,ve seen these finishes done on small lathes with the 3 jaw and the results looked quite good.   Would the extra steps in setting up the 4 jaw be evident in the results that I would get?

vinn3 Distinguished Member

vinn3

Posted
Posted
8 hours ago, jdm said:

Right. But we know well that our long time member vinn3 here is more familiar with machining that watchmaking :-) 

     if you are new to running a lathe,  use a 3 jaw,  jacobs' and collets.  most nubies are afrade of a  4 jaw because it takes much more time to  get it "on center".  with some experience,  a 4 jaw can be put on center in15 seconds.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • AndyGSi
      Where it begins

      By AndyGSi · Posted

      So it's what people call a Citizen C Mark and was the first centre second movement they produced in 1950. This lines up with the serial number which dates yours to March 1951.
    • mcoulton
      Hour Counting Wheel Assembly - Valjoux 7750

      By mcoulton · Posted

      Hello I'm trying to install the Hour Counting Wheel assembly in a Valjoux 7750. The issue I'm having is the Hour Hammer Wheel keeps fouling on the Hour Hammer and the Hour Hammer Counter Lock. I believe it's because the Hour Hammer Counter Wheel is pinned to the Calendar Bridge. The latter prevents me from installing the Hour Hammer Counter Wheel separate of the bridge and seeing how it interacts with the other Hour Hammer components. These are my questions: 1.) Should I take the pin off? The one holding the Hour Hammer Wheel to the  Calendar Bridge? 2.) Can this pin be removed? 3.) Any tips for installing the whole assembly if I'm not meant to remove the pin? I've included pictures to better illustrate what I'm writing about. Thanks in advance for any help that can be provided. 
    • Ruehara
      Seeking advice on installing watch crystal.

      By Ruehara · Posted

      The crystal seems to be exactly the same as the old one, bought from Cousins using the model number of the watch. I tried again to manipulate it into the case but still having no luck. I think I will have to reduce the size slightly but am worried that once it's in, it could be loose. Before I do that I think I will try and design a custom shaped die for my crystal press and 3D print it. 
    • BobG
      Regulating is too touchy

      By BobG · Posted

      What you’re saying is that if the entire coil is lifted or tilted either up or down it is due to a slight twist in the spring? Usually next to the stud?  I’ve chased this before and in one instance the spring came out of the stud and I had to reinstall it and secure it in place.  Do you find that the angle (not twist) the spring leaves the stud not only affects how it centers in the regulator pins but also the coil spacing? This could be caused by a distortion in the spring as it grabs and release the pins. I find turning the stud counter clockwise opens the coils 180 degrees away from it. So do I adjust the stud in relation to the regulator pins or to the coil spacing?  I also find that unless I remove the balance from the cock I can’t see the slight distortions in the spring. In my picture the distorted spring looked fine when installed. Do you use Alex’s technique of sliding the regulator arm up and down the curve to find distortions or can you visually see them?    Gettin back to positional variation for a moment. The angle of the regulator block is set by the factory and I’ve noticed it’s always the same. I have seen that sometimes the pins are too closed and grab or can grab the spring. If you open the pins to do the curve check what guide do you use to close them back down to the correct angle? 
    • Birbdad
      Regulating is too touchy

      By Birbdad · Posted

      So if anybody overrides what i say, listen to them haha. I'm not an expert but i've just been in this boat a dozen times as i used to mess up hairsprings bad, but the good part of that was that i got to learn how to fix them.  What made my life SO much easier was learning how to adjust the hairsprings with the balance installed on a disassembled mainplate, unless it's a very serious problem or on an inner coil you can't get to i would recommend trying this in part because the spring will mostly ALWAYS look flat when the balance wheel is not installed on the cock. Install the balance wheel back in the cock and the cock with the cap jewels in the mainplate, with it installed even the most imperceptible twist will be pretty obvious. Just make sure the balance jewels are also installed. In these movements, if 99% of the time any twist or problems gonna be around the terminal curve, twists often near the stud, especially if you've been removing their awfully designed studs from the balance cock. If there's a reliable way to install those things without introducing a minor twist to them i haven't found it. they're an awful design. INstall the balance on you mainplate WITH your capstones/chatones and look sideways across the balance under magnification. Look for the highest or lowest spot of the now not flat hairspring. 180 degrees from that high or low spot is where your twist will be. You have to be VERY careful with twists as the tiniest over or under twist brings it out of flat. If the area i have to untwist is near the stud i just use a pair of #5 tweezers or some very sharp fine curved tweezers and gently see which way i twist it corrects the twist, then i hold the very fine point of the tweezers on the hairspring and just gently squeeze and check it and see if it started to correct it, then i rinse and repeat. Tiny adjustments is what you want, don't close them all the way, and dont' introduce a flat spot in them. it's just a little nudge by closing the tweezers on it at an angle. .  If the twist is not near the stud, i grasp the hairspring with some very fine curved tweezers as gently as possible while still holding it then i do that same sorta tweezer squeeze with my #5's. 
×
×
  • Create New...