Jump to content

First go with a Kommandirskie


Recommended Posts

Just started on my first attempt to restore a Wostok Kommandirskie. Winding stem broken but crown still around with remaining stem in the crown.

 

The 2414 movement appears to be in surprisingly good condition and the casing should be ok with a bit of cleaning and polishing.

 

But...when searching for a winding stem all that show up seems to be kind of ”integrated” stem and crown.

 

Are these generic to fit all kinds of casings?

 

And how does these screw-down crowns work? I suppose there must be space for the stem to move in when the crown is screwed tight?

 

Grateful for some advice from some of the guys with a special interest in these russian wonders!

 

5297e5e02084586929c30797456d9d69.jpg55d3d738f15c7450815a373d0487198c.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's kind of a slip  clutch set up.and the length is determined  by the case.for the  most part all komandirskie cases are interchangeable. You can order new stems directly  from meranom. Fixing old ones is not practical. 

Edited by yankeedog
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So the stem moves in/out inside the crown with a slip/lock function to allow for the screw down action? Makes sense.

I checked briefly the supplier you mentioned but couldn’t find any stems. Maybe I need to contact directly.

And there’s an overwhelming number of styles and casings still in production.

Any idea what mine could be called? From my point of view it looks like one of the more common with its 2-coloured bezel dots.

If the supplier is easy to communicate with, I guess I can send him a photo?

Are they easy to deal with, from your experience?






Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

go to meranom.com, click on shop, click on komandirskie classic parts, you will see it. it is listed as a crown.it will set you back a whole $3.00 US..It ought to fit, but even if it does not. it's not a loss to cry over.I do believe they will answer inquiries. for not a lot of money you can get a new case

Edited by yankeedog
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I believe  the komandirskie  stem is of the same type as the amphibia.  Is has a loose and wobbly  feeling  about it.it is normal  for the type..supposed  to stop shock  from being transferred  to the movement.  To me that sounds like hype.

Edited by yankeedog
Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is alot of mechanical  incest in the amphibia / komandirskie  lines ..biggest  differences are stainless vs plated case on komandirskie..thicker  crystal  / case back and fatter gaskets on amphibia. All dials and movements  will  pretty  much  swap  out provided you have a back that  will  accommodate  a rotor on an automatic and the correct retainer ring and stem. I am pretty  sure that all komandirskie  with 24xx movement  use the same stem while amphibia  stems vary in length  according  to case type. I may be in error  of course  .but this is my understanding  . The 22xx are another  animal  entirely.  The dials will not interchange with the 24xx and the stems have a different  business  end and do not interchange either.you can however  retrofit a 22xx into a 24xx case provided  you have correct stem and ring. Case crown threads being the same. Earlier  komandirskie  did not have a threaded crown..I think they got them when the transition  from 22xx to 24xx happened. 

Edited by yankeedog
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the added discussion. I mailed Meranom and had a quick response that the offered stem likely work but no guararantees. Sounds reasonable enough to take the chance for 3$ :)

Beginning to realize that these watches are both simple and complex at the same time. But it’s fun that the Vostok factory is still producing in spite of decades of turmoil. And the brand characteristics is maintained.

I will start to service my 2414 movement, order a new stem and try to make a wearable watch out of it.





Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, Ruairidh said:

That would be a sensible idea as although a very rugged movement the one found in the amphibia has a habit of being very inaccurate. 

I am not  too crazy about the 24xx series. I think the 22xx series  is simpler more accurate  and more robust. It is very  much like  their  2809 but smaller  and built  to looser specs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

d4d43229414326b0c0b7955700ca928a.jpg

Hi again...

Got started on servicing the 2414 and immediately ran into a new problem.

Turns out the centre wheel shaft, driven by the main spring barrel has come loose from its wheel and no force is being transitted further to the wheel train. The wheel still sits securely on the shaft but spins freely.

Never experienced this problem in any movement before.

The attached photo shows the splines like arrangement that I presume is supposed to ”bite” into the wheel brass to secure it.

Would the appropriate thing to do to use my staking set on those shaft splines like teeth and hammer away (well not really...) to secure the wheel?






Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Think I managed to tighten the grip on the wheel with some light tapping in the staking set. I guess I will see if it holds up...

There seems to be a few people offering scrap movements for spares on ebay but not at all as many as one can find with some of the more generic ones.

Meranom was helpful and replied back quickly on my crown/stem enquiry. But apparently he doesn’t accept orders below an amount that makes the 3$ plus postage, customs fee etc.spin off to a lot more than I paid for the watch to start with.






Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Have a box full of Vostok parts if you need anything bsoderling. I need a crown for a Vostok swing lug i am about to service . Have a few contacts that could have that . Maybe they have a crown for you watch also . I  bought  parts from Ukraina . They sent it from Holland . So was inside EU . I think they have crown. I shall see if i can find it . 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, vext01 said:

Sorry to hijack the thread, but has anyone ever encountered a service manual for these Vostok movements? Even if they are in Russian language, even the diagrams would be of help.

Thanks

Strictly speaking you should start a new thread, however this link may help, not strictly a service manual, but in some ways every bit as good.
https://forums.watchuseek.com/f54/vostok-caliber-2414-service-notes-very-long-many-pics-226237.html

.. and of course, Mark's video is an excellent resource too.

A search of Watchrepairtalk will give you more useful tips.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, AndyHull said:

Strictly speaking you should start a new thread

Oops. My apologies. Next time I will.

1 hour ago, AndyHull said:

That is indeed very good! Thanks for the link!

1 hour ago, AndyHull said:

.. and of course, Mark's video is an excellent resource too.

Until now I've been using youtube videos, but I find it's also nice to have the service manual on-hand. I've been unable to find any for vostok movements.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, vext01 said:

Until now I've been using youtube videos, but I find it's also nice to have the service manual on-hand. I've been unable to find any for vostok movements.

There are some manuals available, but there doesn't seem to be one source for everything. A bunch of useful stuff is here -> https://forums.watchuseek.com/sitemap/f-54.html

If you want USER manuals you could try here -> https://www.russian-watches.info/russian-watches-user-manuals/
.. but who ever needs a USER manual :D

Finally, a bunch of Russian watch sites... https://forums.watchuseek.com/f54/russian-watch-links-interest-13891.html

Google translate may be required unless your Russian language skills are up to the task.

Edited by AndyHull
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Hi all,

Just wanted to wrap this one up and show where it ended.

Finally decided to purchase the stem/crown from ebay seller ”bestrus” who was able to point me towards the correct item for the somewhat older style casing I have. He even threw in an extra free dial that looks ok and may come handy at some point.

Only the yellow crown available, these are apparently getting quite rare.

Rivetting the wheel onto the stem (that this thread started with) seems to work ok. Came loose once and had to redo the operation with a bit more force. Crossing my fingers it will stay put...

M/s turned out to be broken but found a close enough one in my small stash that gives an amplitude up around 300 degrees, fully wound.

Picture attached. Nothing fancy and a bit rough around the edges but quite ok as a start and I will definitely keep my eyes open for the next one.

61f5f4a5b7cf0fed83980ab821ea4f47.jpg


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • That's one beautiful timepiece! Love the big crown in proportion to the case. Perhaps a ladies' watch, but I don't think so. I have a "modern Ingersoll" watch, but it has nothing to do with the original brand (Miyota 9015 movement). Interesting synonym for synthetic oils! 😆 There is, of course, a limit to how large a volume of oil epilame can bind and hold in place. If the oleophobic effect is too strong then it can become a problem. I'm not sure where I heard or read it, but as I understand it, the active ingredient in a bottle of epilame is extremely small and more than 99% of the contents of the bottle is just a transfer agent. If the active ingredient becomes too concentrated, which it can become over time, or if the product is of poor quality, the oleophobic effect is amplified. This in turn causes the applied oil to look like a gummed-up ball on the surface of the treated part. If that happens, we know that the active ingredient has become too concentrated. What we want is for the oil to bind but not to the point where it is formed into an excessively round ball on the surface. The highlighted text in the patent that you refer to describes well the problem that can arise with too high a concentration of the active ingredient. However, I would be extremely surprised if the entire amount of oil leaves the treated surface as water on wax would. At present, I am convinced that the analogy between wax and water on the one hand and epilame and oil on the other is incorrect. Epilame is described as binding and that is also my absolute experience. Epilame probably has some repelling effect but that is not its main purpose and that is not how epilame is designed and works. The method of abrading the epilame treatment from the section of the pallet stones coming in contact with the escape wheel teeth seems after even more research to be well established, but if it actually works, if so how and why is beyond what I can currently understand. Perhaps it is just to do and trust that it is based on well-established experience. I am, after all, inclined to think so.
    • Sorry to jump in here, but I didn't want to start a new thread when there's already one regarding the second hand watch market. Can anyone tell me what I should be looking at when buying watches from eBay? I see loads on there for quite cheap, but after reading this thread I'm guessing they're all garbage and not worth the time? I recently bought an old Elco watch for 99p, just to practice on. I'm also really fond of the look of Services watches and Smiths Empire watches. I keep seeing them listed for around 5 or 6 pounds. Are they not worth the time buying? I'm not looking to sell watches to make a profit. I just want to buy watches I like the look of and wear them, but I also don't want to buy things that are going to be impossible to find parts for, or that have already been abused by someone else and broken beyond repair. Any tips?
    • I tried the Moebius 9415 from any sensible amount, down to microscopic a drop (or "super minimalistic"); the size of droplet which makes you really wonder why one would/should apply anything at all? But to no avail, consistently a lower amplitude compared to my Dr.Tillwich 1-3. Of course, as John mentioned above, the Dr.Tillwich 1-3, just like the Moebius 9010, likes to go somewhere else. Since short however, I'm the (proud?) owner of a bottle of Moebius Fixodrop. Can't say that I'm a proud owner of the 9415. So far, I haven't seen or discovered the "magic" of the 9415. Meanwhile, Moebius 🤣 has my money though.........
    • I used to be quite active on The Lotus Forum when I owned my Esprit. I was there for so long, Bibs asked me to be a moderator. I'm not sure how long I did that for, but I think I turned into the second longest serving moderator. When I 'handed back my keys', Bibs made me a Full Forum Member. Normally this is a paid membership. My reward I suppose for helping out for many years. Bibs (forum owner) is quite active on there and if I am not wrong, don't quote me in other words, I think he once said that the money from memberships didn't cover the running cost. He adds money himself to keep it going. Does Mark have any sort of subscription scheme on here? I'll admit that I never paid to be a member on TLF. I should have. I never did. I agree that it would be a good idea that there is some sort of contingency plan for this forum. I intend on becoming more active on here. Life has just been getting in the way recently. I enrolled on Mark's watch course and was keenly doing that, but even that has had to take a back seat for a while. I am looking forward to getting back into that and also starting to do work on the clocks that I have been amassing. To do that successfully, I see myself needing to lean on the other members here. If for whatever reason this forum was to close, I think a great many of us would struggle.
    • I think we are about there, if there were still lots out there then the cost of a watch from 5 years ago would be around the same as it is now (allowing for inflation). Given that the price has gone up several times over we can only assume that supply cannot keep up with demand so we must be at or past peak supply, especially if the trend continues. I see even places like Australia, Ukraine and even South America are selling watches on eBay, picking over their stocks, mixed in with fakes and Frankenwatches etc.
×
×
  • Create New...