Jump to content

Gruen 522CD (Felsa 4019) balance pivot not going into jewel jewel

dieale2

By dieale2
in Watch Repairs Help & Advice

 Share

Recommended Posts

dieale2 Member

dieale2

Posted
Posted

Hello folks, I am practising on a Gruen 522CD. I installed the train wheels and escapement to make sure the watch is running fine. I use my microscope to inspect the jewels and pivots because I can't see them with a 20X loupe. I found that the balance pivot won't go into unless I force the balance cock down with the cock screwed in. Maybe I need to bent the cock down? That seems pretty barbaric.

Below you can see the pivot barely moving into the jewel. The bottom pivot does the same thing.

guren_cal_balance_pivot.thumb.jpg.79b00e2b1396886ffb0e3d79265fb0b6.jpg

jguitron WRT Addict

jguitron

Posted
Posted

[emoji848]


I think I need more info.

Is it that with the cock screwed down you have a gap between both pivots?? And you have to drive the pivots into the jewels to engage them? That would be a bad endshake situation and before bending cocks I’d adjust jewels.

On the other hand, I can’t make much out of the pic, but it don’t seem right to me...is the jewel opening deformed and that’s why the pivot doesn’t engage? Is it a capped jewel?

Cheers!



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

rodabod Distinguished Member

rodabod

Posted
Posted

Going back to the start: did this watch run at all before you started working on it?

Check the pivots are not "mushroomed". It may be easier to fit the balance without the cap jewels in place, plus you can see more easily.

wolfwatchwerks Member

wolfwatchwerks

Posted
Posted

I had a similar problem with an omega 39.5L. Balance was bent a little bit. Returned it back to normal and all  was fine. The bridge on those (omega) is very thin. Check that it's not bent. Then possibly the staff is bad/worn. Incorrect jewel seating. Remove the balance and place it on a flat true surface with reg. removed, (not sure but may have to remove the jewel anyways if it protrudes above the cock) and check for gaps. If you can see any amount of a gap at all this is incorrect. If it looks good there are other problems already addressed in previous comments.

dieale2 Member

dieale2

Posted
  • Author
Posted
19 hours ago, jguitron said:

emoji848.png


I think I need more info.

Is it that with the cock screwed down you have a gap between both pivots?? And you have to drive the pivots into the jewels to engage them? That would be a bad endshake situation and before bending cocks I’d adjust jewels.

On the other hand, I can’t make much out of the pic, but it don’t seem right to me...is the jewel opening deformed and that’s why the pivot doesn’t engage? Is it a capped jewel?

Cheers!



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Here are some relevant microscope pictures. This is a pretty normal modern movement with calendar complications. The balance is shock protected. The first photo was me shooting at 200X through the upper balance jewel. Sorry for the lack of context.

Quote

Going back to the start: did this watch run at all before you started working on it?

Check the pivots are not "mushroomed". It may be easier to fit the balance without the cap jewels in place, plus you can see more easily.

The watch didn't run at all at the start. The pivots do look a bit "mushroomed"?

Quote

Remove the balance and place it on a flat true surface with reg. removed, (not sure but may have to remove the jewel anyways if it protrudes above the cock) and check for gaps. 

I put the balance cock on a jeweler's anvil and it looked straight on. I included a picture of the cock sideways. Looks straight to me.

 

 

guren_cal_balance_cock.jpg

guren_cal_lower_balance_pivot.jpg

guren_cal_upper_balance_pivot.jpg

guren_cal_bird_eye.jpg

MrRoundel Super WRT Addict

MrRoundel

Posted
Posted (edited)

Wow, that lower pivot looks like it either has metal worn, displaced, or replaced, as if there's a glob of solder on the tip. It doesn't look good. I wonder if it's possible that you could polish the pivot down on a lathe or in a pivot-polishing tool? I'd be considering finding a new staff for it though. Good luck.

Edited by MrRoundel
  • Like 1
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • GPrideaux
      Bulova Rubaiyat 1920/21

      By GPrideaux · Posted

      I'm sure it's the ancien. My measurements: A = 342. The slight bend in the pivot would make much less than a thousandth of a mm difference to this so I don't think 348 is plausible unless there has been significant wear on the pivots. B is hard to measure without first removing the balance wheel. I measured to the other side of the balance wheel as best I could (263) then subtracted the thickness of the wheel (69) to get 194. This could easily be three or four hundredths out, so 195 looks right. (196 could also be right.) J couldn't be measured. I did my best to measure where the balance wheel has been riveted on and got about 95, so 85 before riveting is plausible. (60 is not.) G again couldn't be measured without first removing the roller. I get 37 where the staff emerges from the roller so 41 at the other end of the taper seems plausible. (43 is also plausible to me.) K = 60. (Definitely larger than 55.)   I've never replaced a balance staff; it'll be a new adventure for me. I'll have to read up on how to maximise my chance of removing the old one without damaging the balance wheel without having access to a lathe. I also need to explore how to remove the roller without damaging it. I won't actually place an order until I've gone through the rest of the movement. With the number of issues I've already found, I'll be amazed if I don't have more surprises in store. There are some watch part suppliers in Australia but nothing like Cousins or Otto Frei or Jules Borel. AllTimeCo is fine for basic parts for modern watches: batteries, bands, some crowns, stems, seals, movements, some tools, etc., but not really anything for vintage watches. Australian Jewellers Supplies is similar. Cousins charges about £9 for shipping to Australia which is about AU$19 and not too bad (considering Australian parcel post is $11) but I still want to minimise the number of times I'm paying it. I need to explore other options closer to home. There may be something in Singapore or China that would have what I want and ship it faster/more economically.  
    • steve1811uk
      Rolex 3135 rate variation with temperature

      By steve1811uk · Posted

      Hi, I just finished the service of a Rolex 3135. Amplitude is great, 295 degrees horizontal after 2 hours and 280 after 12 hours. Vertical positions are 25 degrees down on those. I am however seeing a rate variation with temperature. I have 0 SPD on wrist, say 38 degrees and +7 SPD at 18 degrees room temperature. That equates to +0.35 SPD which is within spec I believe (+-0.5 SPD/ Deg C max). It just seems more than I would expect from such a high quality movement. To put that in context, I see similar rate variation with temperature for a Seiko 7S26. Just wondering what you guys see. Thanks, Steve.
    • Endeavor
      Beginner advice - cleaning in an apartment

      By Endeavor · Posted

      For years I've done it the el-cheapo way (read: cleaning by hand). Bought a 2nd Elma S15(H) ultra-sonic, including proper cleaning-fluids (Elma WF Pro (cleaning) & Elma Suprol Pro (rinse)) and entered a complete different cleaning world. These cleaning fluids are none-water based and not that easy to obtain. Initially I bought these fluids in Germany "SKSONIC" (www.sksonic.de) but last year they stopped shipping international. Perhaps they resumed international shipping? You can always ask them. You could also ask @VWatchie, he lives "next-door". As for the fumes; I use the ultra-sonic in my garage, partly for the fumes, but more for our dog ...... he goes "bananas" when I switch on the ultra-sonic. Oh, next on your list (if you consider watch-repair as a long-time hobby), a Microscope (up to 50x is enough).  Pegwood leaves, observed under the microscope that is, whole tree-trunks behind 🫣 Ultra-sonic, in combination with proper cleaning fluids, takes care of the cleaning.
    • evenflow
      Greetings

      By evenflow · Posted

      Thank you 
    • evenflow
      Removing the hairspring from a ETA 2846 balance

      By evenflow · Posted

      How do I remove the hairspring from an ETA? 2846. Balance  staff pivot is broken and I need to transfer the spring over to a new wheel. But the spring stud is not removable. It seems it almost looks like a snap ring at the top of the balance cock or am I missing something?
×
×
  • Create New...