Jump to content

What is happening with this hairspring ?


Chopin

Recommended Posts

When removed from the balance bridge, this (Seiko 7S28A) hairspring seems to be perfectly round and OK yet when it is mounted onto the bridge it looks like this.

I'm assuming it shouldn't sit like especially since, despite being serviced, the movement doesn't keep accurate time. It either runs fast by around a minute per hour or too slow by a minute per hour (depending on how you regulate it).

IMG_6175.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Would just 2 bends make this work, technically ? If I manage to get it right hat is... I'm talking about the part just before it starts to coil around.... The bends near the outer end of the hairspring seem comparable to those in the photos from the link...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Chopin said:

Would just 2 bends make this work, technically ? If I manage to get it right hat is... I'm talking about the part just before it starts to coil around.... The bends near the outer end of the hairspring seem comparable to those in the photos from the link...

It's a subtle combination of the shape and angle before the regulator, and the dog leg (bends) after it. You will not find any exact description or video of how exactly it has to be done, they say it's a matter of experience, trial and error. I suggest you practice first on an HS which in not repairable, because it seems this one still is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

52 minutes ago, Chopin said:

Do you have any idea if I can find just the HS for sale somewhere like cousinsUK ? They have the complete balance but I feel like it's too much for what I need...

Only the balance complete is sold. It is even cheap compared to C version. The assembly is not made to be separated ever. But your doesn't need replacement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's difficult to be certain but looking at your pics the hairspring is fine until it is attached to the bridge. Therefore I would deduce that the fault is at the bend made as it attaches to the end stud. Also the hairspring should be centred between the regulator pins not touching. The curve of the hairspring should be uniform and as the regulator arm is moved the hairspring should still remain in the centre in all positions. 

However be warned the tiniest of adjustments to a hairspring can make big differences so go really careful when adjusting.

5a2d41cdb9151_hairspringerror.png.4ee99f9633ddd3c566ff397c834eb302.png

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was thinking that if I made 2 bends in the marked area it would all be OK ? It seems to be missing those 2 bends almost entirely.

Thanks for pointing out @clockboy. You're right about what you've said so I guess that bend should be slightly corrected as well.

asdasd.jpg

Also, just to be clear, in case I mess this up. CousinsUK has "Balance Complete" for almost 10GBP. Does Balance complete mean the balance wheel + hairspring on it ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Chopin said:

Also, just to be clear, in case I mess this up. CousinsUK has "Balance Complete" for almost 10GBP. Does Balance complete mean the balance wheel + hairspring on it ?

Of course. Once again, practice on something else first. Forming a dog leg, or any other HS manipulation, is not easy or intuitive.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I find given advice with hairsprings is very difficult because manipulating them is really a touch and see before any adjustment exercise. Looking at the pics again this morning if it was me I would just move gently the bend at the end stud away and see if it moves the hairspring to a better centring position.  If so this is where to begin HOWEVER because the spring has already been manipulated it will be weak so be very very gentle when moving it

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well it didn't work. At first glance I managed to do what had to be done but when I install it into the movement the hairspring won't really work. It just won't rotate unless I force with the tweezers but it won't run on it's own.

I'll just order a replacement from Counsins. Does "Balance Complete" mean that it has the hairspring, balance and balance staff all together ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

58 minutes ago, Chopin said:

I'll just order a replacement from Counsins. Does "Balance Complete" mean that it has the hairspring, balance and balance staff all together ?

Yes, as answered above already. Note, most likely you are not installing the balance correctly. A distorted Seiko balance runs poorly, but it does run.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Chopin said:

If I fiddle around with it, it'll start but only function for 10-20 seconds. If I'll put the movement crown up for example it seems to stop.

I suggest that you give up with this mov.t. Too many variables and chances that is bust for good. You can buy an NH36 to replace it which will have better features, and use the old one to practice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Correction. It seems that it works fine dial up but works very bad dial down... I guess further correcting should be made...

Holding the hairspring horizontally it seems that at the end towards the stud it's a little warped/bent...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...
On 12/11/2017 at 1:28 AM, Melt said:

Check out the second dog leg after the regulator, this is what's missing and will bring the balance hairspring concentric again.

underescapement6441.jpg

L C ,  A raw hairspring is slapped on the wheel, bend like in the pic melt shows above.

If I remember right you are good at hairspring R/R , you will get much better bends if hairspring is laid on flat white sheet of paper.

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • So I found what I believe is the setting lever screw! Am I right in thinking the screw next to the click is the correct one for the setting lever? However if it is, it doesn't fit in the hole which I believe is for it! I can get the lever to sit nicely on the stem and line up with a hole, but the screw only goes as far as the shoulder and stops. It's as though the hole is too small! The dial side has been disassembled by the way, the other wheels are in my tray
    • When faced with say a pocket watch bridge which is cracked, silver soldering to repair is often the only option (hopefully someone wasn't there before hand with soft solder). I can generally do this succesfully and tidily with a small torch and miniscule pieces of silver solder, but on parts which were mercury amalgam gilded the heat can have have a deleterious effect on the finish.   I keep wondering if there's a good way to refinish these - and despite having the needful items would rather avoid using the mercury process.   In the past for electronic work I've gold plated PCBs but this involved gold potassium cyanide solution, which also doesn't realy belong at home. I've read that there are now safer alternatives but couldn't find more detail (and importantly how similar are the results to amalgam gilding, since I wouldn't want to refinish the whole watch). Pointers would be very welcome (and yes, I know solutions containing gold won't be cheap!) Alan
    • The first one is an Unruh max stake for pushing out staffs
    • Ok so with the great answers for my previous question may I ask what these two attachments are used for. The one with the red knob is I assume used for hand setting the seconds hand? Jon      
    • According to Cousins site I need to look at document G22 as I think I need an ATGB at 304 but I cant find this size in G22 doc. The last thing I want to do is order the wrong one😳  Unless I cant see the wood for the trees 😆 I could be looking at the wrong style, I assume its classed as Round plastic Armed  https://www.cousinsuk.com/product/wide-ring-gold-atgb
×
×
  • Create New...