Jump to content

Straightening the banking pins


Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

I can't find an answer to this question.  What is the best practice for physically straightening a bent banking pin, without a special tool.  I'm worried that by trying to straighten it, it will break.  I thought about trying to find a metal tube to slip over the pin, but maybe tweezers or pliers would do the trick.

I've read posts about WHEATHER or not to straighten the pin (or how to adjust it), but that's not my question.  Thank you.

Watch: Standard Watch Co.  BD006110; size 16.  Watch is currently a non runner.

banking pins.jpg

standard w co.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, arron said:

Hi Guys,

I can't find an answer to this question.  What is the best practice for physically straightening a bent banking pin, without a special tool.  I'm worried that by trying to straighten it, it will break.  I thought about trying to find a metal tube to slip over the pin, but maybe tweezers or pliers would do the trick.

I've read posts about WHEATHER or not to straighten the pin (or how to adjust it), but that's not my question.  Thank you.

Watch: Standard Watch Co.  BD006110; size 16.  Watch is currently a non runner.

banking pins.jpg

standard w co.png

Something makes you think that it should be straightened ?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Something makes you think that it should be straightened ?

7 minutes ago, arron said:

I know it's hard to see in the photo but the pins are definitely not straight.

so the banking pins are not straight but would straightening them fix any problem or generate new problem? In other words are they bent for a reason for instance this tool

b57171_pic5a_cmyk.jpg.1e432eab89d0bfbe74155a348e0f3194.jpg

comes in a whole bunch of sizes and allows you to bend the baking pin for a specific reason.

Now as you can see for the tool is designed to Billy go in and adjust when the balance wheels in place when you don't have the balance wheel there because you want to make it nice and straight then you wouldn't need something fancy like this. But sometimes having a tube to put over it is nice because it allows you to see things a little better. If you had access to staking set punches for instance sometimes one of those will fit over the banking pin if there's enough room. You might Billy do it with your tweezers.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I wonder if the bent pins are the reason it's not running.  I'll try putting it back together before re-positioning the pins and see what happens.  I'd prefer not to mess with them and run the risk of breakage if I don't have too.  And thanks for suggesting the staking set; that thing comes in all kinds of handy but for some reason I overlook its utility until its pointed out to me.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, arron said:

I wonder if the bent pins are the reason it's not running

was the watch running before you serviced it?

Things like banking pins do not happen by accident somebody did it before you and did they have a reason why? Although a lot of times people have no idea what the banking pins are for and because of that they like to play with them which leads to problems.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, arron said:

I know it's hard to see in the photo but the pins are definitely not straight.

They may not be straight for a specific reason.

5 hours ago, arron said:

I wonder if the bent pins are the reason it's not running.  I'll try putting it back together before re-positioning the pins and see what happens.  I'd prefer not to mess with them and run the risk of breakage if I don't have too.  And thanks for suggesting the staking set; that thing comes in all kinds of handy but for some reason I overlook its utility until its pointed out to me.  

The small stakes that come in little cylinder wood containers are a perfect size to slip over the banking pins of a wristwatch. But as other folk have suggested these pins may be set up correctly bearing in mind that they make different things happen at the two far ends of the lever. Its easy to assume that they should be straight considering that everything else in a watch is straight up and down. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

John, it is a non runner; wound tight.  the balance seems good though.

 

I'm glad I posted before doing anything.  This will be a good learning experience.  I'll see if, and how, it runs before taking the next step as you have all suggested.  Have a nice day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, arron said:

John, it is a non runner; wound tight.  the balance seems good though.

usually what I like to do with nonrunning watches is to see if I can get them to run before I service them if I can. Sometimes there so incredibly sticky with lubrication that that's basically impossible.

I've attached a handout with a light reading on escapement's. I wouldn't necessarily assume that the Bent banking pins are the cause your problem because they're buried so far deep in the watch that they were that way by a watchmaker not by some casual person trying to tweak their watch to get it to run so more than likely the watch runs with the Bent banking pins because somebody bent them possibly because they change the pallet fork or something. But before bending them anywhere else you really need to evaluate whether escapement is set up correctly or not. That is why you have a handout with some light reading

Escapement handout wostep nscc.pdf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well, this explains why the watch wasn't running.  The impulse jewel is broken off.  Based on some research it sounds like the only practical thing is to look for a donor movement.  I've searched ebay and can't find the exact model, mine is the grade 95.  So the plan is to set it aside and see if one turns up eventually.  

standard balance.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, arron said:

Well, this explains why the watch wasn't running.  The impulse jewel is broken off.  Based on some research it sounds like the only practical thing is to look for a donor movement.  I've searched ebay and can't find the exact model, mine is the grade 95.  So the plan is to set it aside and see if one turns up eventually.  

One of things I always like to do with incoming watches and you're making an observation the watch is not running but if you get the balance wheel to rotate you always look to make sure that the pallet fork is moving. It's actually quite common on pocket watches for the balance to move the pallet fork not because of roller jewel missing..

Then from the look at your balance wheel it appears to be a single roller versus a double roller watch? The reason I bring this up is single roller watches require longer roller jewel's so often times modern assortments will not have a jewel long enough.

Then it's so sad  the roller jewel's been stolen by a previous watchmaker and now we have to throw the whole watch away because you don't have a roller jewel  if only there was something you could do?  No murdering another watch to seal its roller jewel is not an ideal solution.. If only we were dealing with watch repair we would have something to do  like  replace the roller jewel?

Then yes occasionally have a weird sense a humor it's based on your research and the outcome of your research that you get a weird paragraph up above.

Then we're going to need some tools and a few more tools after that plus it be really nice if the ruler was unfortunately broken off rather than falling off because that means there should be a little piece left that you can measure. Otherwise we have to do it the other way

So if you don't have the old jewel  you need a roller jewel gauge they, of course in a variety of styles and shapes  you could use a machinists or an automobile shop feeler gauge. In other words you need something to stick in the slot and measure its width  and then the jewel is just a tiny bit smaller.

image.png.29d31839d771bf747a648c35900c478c.png

We also need some shellac and roller jewel of the suitable size and a heck of a lot of patience to get up to go into its hole. Then yes they do make special tweezers reporters but you still have to get the roller jewel into those so  doesn't really matter the roller jewel is a pain in the something to get into the hole.

Then a variety of tools to hold it when you heat up and apply the shellac. Then once the shellac smelted in the jewel is not go fallout you can  gently straighten it out and get it where it's supposed to be.

image.png.cc696ee7211e52c8b5b3ffd17dc35b04.png

 

Here's a better picture of the tool for holding newly roller table.. You will also note this is a double roller watch shorter roller jewel

image.png.6e474cf56062534585ab457fe18afa56.png

Yes the pictures make it look so easy

image.png.7c2b4c06deafb02443e89b7510678b24.png

Then looking up to the assortment a roller jewel's is a good thing to do I done it before except of course it helps to have the right assortment  like a vintage assortment versus a modern assortment

or  what about this website? Let me just snip something out for you

image.thumb.png.7abc5ee582738f9d30e2120be9f0446e.png

Then on another page he has one of these

image.thumb.png.25c0a2045eece8a3fb5ed463dc15440f.png

Okay this will get you started

 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Nucejoe said:

When was soldering gun invented ? 

Who needs a soldering gun when you have a blowtorch.

Personally on my long list of projects that I haven't got around to doing I was thinking about the heater cartridge out of the 3-D printer. Figuring out a way to hold the roller table holder and my pallet fork holder Plus of course throwing in temperature control so I can free up my hands to play with the shellac.

Traditionally watch repair they used alcohol lamp. Except in between used alcohol dries up and then you grab a small butane torch which is not what I recommend doing because it's really hard to do a good job and really easy to do something bad. But unfortunately at work that's all I have is the small butane torch. Fortunately I almost never do a roller jewel and even less likely to do a pallet stone.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, arron said:

Well, this explains why the watch wasn't running.  The impulse jewel is broken off.  Based on some research it sounds like the only practical thing is to look for a donor movement.  I've searched ebay and can't find the exact model, mine is the grade 95.  So the plan is to set it aside and see if one turns up eventually.  

 

Try emailing Dave at  https://www.daveswatchparts.com/  he has some Standard movements and parts.

You may be able to find a new roller, or balance.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I find replacing a roller jewel one of the most fiddliest's jobs to do. Getting the jewel in place at the correct depth and dead straight is easier with the roller table removed in my experience rather than having it still attached to the staff. I still use the tool in Fig12 above, as no direct heat is given to the roller table and the shellac has some time before setting hard

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You can improvise with some basic tools.

Grab the roller table in a pin vice,  wiggle and pull to detach the roller table from staff,  soak in lighter fluid for an hour then grab it tight in a pin vice to push the broken jewel out. 

 Put thick grease on the hole impulse jewel is to get inserted in, you are using grease as you would rodico, the difference is once you have inserted the jewel in, grease  rinses off with chemicals easy.

So you rinse off the grease, flip the jewel over and grab in pin vice tight.

Shelac is a pain and making a mess is OK as long no shelac get on the impulse face of the jewel.

Trying to handle this task with a pair of tweezers is what makes fiddly, so punch a small  hole in a tooth pic to place the jewel in, next press it in futhure into the tooth pick, then the jewel can be inserted into roller hole.

Loosing the jewel is easy and a bummer, don't ask me how I know.

Frankly a used jeweld roller table get this watch out of your hair.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I installed the donor pallet fork and now the watch is running, but only for 10 seconds. The lower side of the pallet fork only seems to go into the hole when I add the bridge. A visual check shows lower and upper are properly seated. I'll check the hairspring.
    • I get that, but you're making unnecessary work for yourself. Resign yourself to having to give the movement a final clean and lubrication once you've fixed the problem. You probably won't need to redo the balance or the barrel in any case. The oil captured between the hole and cap jewels will still be good even if you've had it in and out of the movement half a dozen times.
    • Thanks, some great advice. I have to go over the train every time I refit anything as each wheel has it's own bridge (cock?). They have a tiny amount of play so you can tighten them down in slightly different positions. This changes the gear mesh. I went through all that when I first started having issues with it. Movement works isn't fitted at the moment and nor is the seconds hand. The only reason I'm cleaning it every time is because each time I assemble it, I lubricate it. Mainly because you have to remove the balance wheel and hairspring to oil the top balance jewel. It's a pain so I always live in hope it will be going together for the last time. As the top one has to be oiled, so does the bottom one. Then I may as well do the train wheels.... I could just do the whole thing dry, but if it works, I'll still have to disassemble the balance again and it's always a risk. The hair spring is pinned, the cap jewel screws are underneath (stupid design. To be fair, the 3 separate bridges is a stupid design too).   I'll play with it more tomorrow and gather some more info, pics, and maybe some video.   Thanks for all the advice.
    • It's not great, IF you did the test without the pallet installed. Assuming 18000 beats per day, 25 seconds is 125 beats or about 62 oscillations. You should get 100 or more. If the pallet was in place when you did the test it means nothing. Either way, this is not the principal issue. I was going to mention that I recently worked out that I get much better pics with a loupe held in front of the phone camera than trying to shoot down the microscope. I use a 20x loupe, but try with whatever you have. The roller jewel (or impulse jewel) could be an issue, particularly if it is loose, but this is also not the main issue. Get some clear pics so you can ask the experienced members here about it after you have addressed the main issue. Nothing in the escapement explains the rapid deterioration you're seeing 20 minutes after winding. That suggests an issue in the train rather than the escapement. The failure to self-start after it has been running a while confirms that power is not getting to the escapement. If it was me, and I was confident I had eliminated the barrel as the source of the problem, I'd be looking further down the train. I'd first make sure the canon pinion was out to eliminate the motion works as a source of the problem. Also make sure the centre seconds pivot is removed, if it has one, or the seconds hand if it has sub-seconds. If that didn't make a difference I'd then work my way through each wheel starting at the centre wheel. Is it sitting level? At the right height? Does it have just enough end shake? Does it have excessive side shake? What happens if you touch the upper pivot with a piece of pegwood with just a little bit of power in the mainspring? What about the lower pivot? Once I was certain there was no problem there I'd move on to the third wheel, and so on all the way down the train. Just because the train runs freely with the pallet out does not mean it has no problems as excessive side shake (for example) will only be an issue when the train is under tension. Finally, I advise you to stop re-cleaning until you have fixed it. I know the temptation, but it's just a distraction. You need to be systematic and methodical.
    • If you short the two blue wires together, does the unit chime? I have a similar chime unit that is designed to work with a quartz movement with an hourly trigger switch.  I'm not aware of any movements or chiming units that chime quarterly.
×
×
  • Create New...