Jump to content

I've entered the rabbit hole


GuyMontag

Recommended Posts

I forget just how I decided to start learning about watchmaking, but here I am. Other than my Garmin watch that I use to track my backpacking activities, I only own one "real" watch, a 1928 Bulova Surrey that I bought on Ebay 15 years ago. I think it was probably that watch that sparked an interest as it stopped running many years ago and has just sat in drawer ever since. I remember looking at ways to service it over the years and I think I just figured I'd try and see if I couldn't do it myself and here I am ?

I've gone through the first two of Mark's courses and have been practicing on some scrap watches I got off of ebay. I'm a retired dentist and some of the hand/eye skills do seem to carry over but as I watch some of the videos I have filmed of myself as I've stripped and then rebuilt movements I do see that I'm a bit heavy handed. I need to add another fine motor gear or two into my repertoire ?

It looks like there is a great community here and I'm looking forward to climbing that road to where I can at least service that beautiful Bulova in my drawer. OK, I'm off to post my first of what I'm sure will be one of many questions ?

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I figured I'd post the watch that started me on this journey. It really is quite gorgeous. I saved the photos from the original ebay listing. The listing said, "ART DECO 1930s BULOVA ENGRAVED CASE WATCH NEAR MINT"

I've since learned that the watch is not from the 1930's but is a 1928 Surrey. Also, not mentioned in the listing is that it was recased in an Illinois Watch Co. case. I actually like this case much more than the original Surrey case so I can't really complain about that. The only real issue is that the movement just kind floats in the case since the movement isn't actually attached to the case in any way.

 

Surrey.JPG

  • Like 7
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
5 hours ago, Michael1962 said:

Welcome to the forum Guy.

Can you manufacture your own movement ring? ( I've forgotten the correct term) to put around the movement to secure it in the case?

As @clockboy said, nice looking watch.

I think that would be beyond my capabilities at this point, but something I hadn't thought about so I'll keep that on the back burner in case I ever do get that level.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, GuyMontag said:

I think that would be beyond my capabilities at this point, but something I hadn't thought about so I'll keep that on the back burner in case I ever do get that level.

Movement rings don't have to be made of metal. You could use a piece of acrylic, like a mouthguard/splint type of material and cut it into shape.

I not sure if there are prefabricated rectangular movement rings, but there are prefab round ones.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, HectorLooi said:

Movement rings don't have to be made of metal. You could use a piece of acrylic, like a mouthguard/splint type of material and cut it into shape.

I not sure if there are prefabricated rectangular movement rings, but there are prefab round ones.

That's true, I didn't think of that. I'm sure I can MacGyver something like that up ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was thinking of some type of sheet plastic/nylon as well. Cutting a rectangle and removing the centre would be easy. I am not sure how you would go about working out the thickness required? Might just be some thickness and depth measurements. And then how to sort of make the ring 'clip' onto the movement.

Look at some other movement rings to get an idea of what you would want your to be fashioned like.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What about something like this? The tabs that would go between the back of the movement and the caseback could be moved to where required so they sit on plates or bridges. Just need to add a groove in one of the sides for the stem.

Another idea would be to work out the dimensions, draw it up and get someone to 3D print it.

Bulova Movement Ring.pdf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Michael1962 said:

What about something like this? The tabs that would go between the back of the movement and the caseback could be moved to where required so they sit on plates or bridges. Just need to add a groove in one of the sides for the stem.

Another idea would be to work out the dimensions, draw it up and get someone to 3D print it.

Bulova Movement Ring.pdf 42.2 kB · 2 downloads

Yeah, that looks like a great idea. I'll give something like that a shot when I service the service the watch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll admit I'm jealous of the watch. As soon as I saw it I thought it looked great. Wife liked it as well. I agree with you on the case. I don't know what the original case looked like, but that one just works.

I have looked at a lot of the watches in a jewellers where I live and not one of them grabs my eye like yours.

It's a keeper. ? 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 2/27/2021 at 4:16 AM, GuyMontag said:

It looks like there is a great community here and I'm looking forward to climbing that road to where I can at least service that beautiful Bulova in my drawer.

If you successfully completed Mark's first two courses I think you're ready to take on that gorgeous Bulova of yours. It's basic design should be very similar to the Unitas 6498 used in the courses. It probably won't have anti-shock springs but Unless you haven't already noticed, Mark has a bonus video named "NON SHOCK PROTECTED VINTAGE WATCHES – VINTAGE WATCH REPAIR TUTORIAL" which will become available as soon as you've passed the test quiz for Level 2.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Michael1962 said:

I'll admit I'm jealous of the watch. As soon as I saw it I thought it looked great. Wife liked it as well. I agree with you on the case. I don't know what the original case looked like, but that one just works.

I have looked at a lot of the watches in a jewellers where I live and not one of them grabs my eye like yours.

It's a keeper. ? 

Ha, thanks ? Yeah, it really jumped out at me too when I first saw it. I'm sure I paid more than it's "worth", but I don't care, I just love the look of it.

2 hours ago, VWatchie said:

If you successfully completed Mark's first two courses I think you're ready to take on that gorgeous Bulova of yours. It's basic design should be very similar to the Unitas 6498 used in the courses. It probably won't have anti-shock springs but Unless you haven't already noticed, Mark has a bonus video named "NON SHOCK PROTECTED VINTAGE WATCHES – VINTAGE WATCH REPAIR TUTORIAL" which will become available as soon as you've passed the test quiz for Level 2.

Yes, the 10AN has rubbed-in jewels with no shock protection. I did watch that video of Mark's and will definitely reference that when I service the Bulova. Just as I started Mark's course I picked up an ebay lot of 120 scrap movements with a number of vintage Bulova's. I've since stripped down and reassembled a couple of them, both of which didn't work and now do, so I think I probably could tackle it as well. I do want to work on my hand skills a little more though as I still occasionally slip and I don't want to scratch up anything. I also don't feel 100% about evaluating how clean jewels are and I think I really need a microscope. I'm about to order an Eakins scope, an Amscope clone from Aliexpress and I think that will help.

I've also since acquired more than that one vintage Bulova. In fact, I've probably "acquired" more than is good for me. I have a few more vintage Bulova's, Hamilton's, Elgin's, and a couple of vintage chronographs including a WWI chronograph which if anything will be a kick in the pants to keep on learning. All of these were described as working but most of them were not when I received them.  Is there no honor among collectors?

Edited by GuyMontag
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I found it on Ebay. I think I had a search of "watches"  and "lot". There seems to be a steady supply of scrap job lots that come up. I didn't look too closely but here is one with 100 watches:

https://www.ebay.com/itm/Watch-lot-100-watches-and-large-batch-of-stretch-bands/133687337260?hash=item1f2062e12c:g:ZGEAAOSwjqNgR5PB

I don't worry too much as a buyer on Ebay. Buyer's have all the power, at least here in the US, not sure about elsewhere. Ebay will, 99.99% of the time, side with the buyer and refund the buyer no matter the circumstances. I've had friends who have sold high dollar amount items on Ebay only to have the buyer claim the item wasn't as described. At that point Ebay asks the buyer to return the item (at the sellers expense) for a refund, and the buyer can fill a box full of rocks and send that back, claiming that is what they received and Ebay will side with the buyer.  I will never sell any high dollar item on ebay. As a buyer, Ebay is a scammers paradise.

 

 

Edited by GuyMontag
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, GuyMontag said:

Yes, the 10AN has rubbed-in jewels with no shock protection.

Yes of course, rubbed-in jewels as well. I didn't think of that. I've actually avoided these really old watches so far. Replacing and adjusting these rubbed-in jewels seems pretty tricky.

 

7 hours ago, GuyMontag said:

I do want to work on my hand skills a little more though as I still occasionally slip and I don't want to scratch up anything.

If that's slipping with your screwdrivers I have a couple of suggestions if I may (you didn't ask for my advice). Firstly, make sure you use the correct width of blade for the screw at hand. Secondly, dress the blade well so that it fits the screw slot securely, and thirdly (and perhaps most importantly) keep the screwdriver as perpendicular as you possibly can over the screw. If the screwdriver is tilting in one direction the blade will slip in the opposite direction. Also, small screws require a lot less torque than larger screws. I don't know how many small screws I've damaged by over tightening them and slipping out of the screw slot.

 

7 hours ago, GuyMontag said:

I also don't feel 100% about evaluating how clean jewels are and I think I really need a microscope.

Yes, you do need a microscope! I got myself a cheap Chinese 20X/40X stereo microscope early on and I've never regretted it. It is a blessing. With it I can clearly see what's going on and the result of it. Be it oiling, fitting something really minuscule such as a Seiko anti-shock spring for an escape wheel, and so on. If interested you can read more about my experiences here

 

7 hours ago, GuyMontag said:

All of these were described as working but most of them were not when I received them.  Is there no honor among collectors?

Nope, it's usually all about making a buck! I'm very much into Vostoks, Poljots, Raketas, and so on and they're basically always sold "as serviced" but they never are. Well, perhaps dipped in a can of naphtha, left to dry, and then flooded with some seed oil.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hello and welcome to the forum.    Enjoy
    • The problem with oil in particular 9010 is it likes to spread. This is why you're supposed to use epilam anywhere it's used to keep the oil in place. Then you want to splurge on money you could buy 941 it's actually an oil that existed before 9415. Then the problem with the grease yes it stays in place but if you have too much you lose amplitude. Then if you get really obsessed with this he would follow Omega's recommendation for escapement lubrication. One of the problems with internal documents of the watch companies is typically are never going to see Them.But a few of them out in the wild for instance at this link Below I searched for the keyword of working. In particular working instructions of the Omega watch company for which there is way more than This but this is all they have. So you want to download number 40 as were going to talk about that and also download Number 81. Plus anything else that looks interesting https://www.cousinsuk.com/document/search?SearchString=Working Then number 40 covers lubrication of the watch. Most interesting is lubrication of the lever escapement under three different conditions with Lubrifar Which you probably no longer have has been washed off without which is what you have and then a course with epilam. Notice how they go supers super minimalistic with the 9415 because if it's too heavy you lose amplitude. Then if you lose amplitude the group will be disappointed with you and the end of the world will come.      
    • You would always get an answer John, you dont need to be dramatic or humerous to get one, but it was appreciated anyway 🙂 Kind of, for those of us that wish to stay in touch and continue to learn from each other in case the forum ever dissappears then yes i suppose so . I  hope that you would also count yourself in , what we learn from you is invaluable,  how you benefit from that exactly I'm not sure, being able to teach ? I did say is it ok to ask mark for some input John and suggested that he might read the thread that explains how some of us feel. I dont see how its really discussing forum policy, but in all honesty i wish i had never even bothered now.
    • While you might have seen it as a humorous/Dramatic remark was done very deliberately so I could get an answer. Let me quote myself? The simplistic of this entire discussion is the group would like the last forever.   If you go to the top of the discussion group you'll find something to click on that says staff. Then you click on Mark's name and you find out interesting things? For instance he was last here on Saturday so yes he is here. If there is a crisis or a problem he is going to be here. You will also find a list of his activity although that's only the public activity. There's a lot of work that goes into running message boards and he probably does a lot of stuff in the background that we don't see to keep it going. Unfortunately message boards do not run themselves. Then regarding this did you notice you can message Mark and ask him. Then if somebody, we could elect somebody from this discussion such as @Neverenoughwatches To reach out I would really keep the message super simple like? You could refer him to this discussion but I would really keep it simple Like for instance the group enjoys his message board and what could we do to keep it going Forever? Then regarding all of the other suggestions comments helpful remarks or ideas? When was the last time any of you bothered to read the message board rules? This is covered which is one of the reasons I did the dramatic things I did to provoke a response of the basics as opposed to starting to suggest or seemingly suggesting all sorts of ideas which are covered by one of the rules found in the section on rules. In other words I'm going to quote something from the rules of the message board.  
    • For me any input from Mark would be great. If he's keeping a close eye i would imagine he has read about our concerns here. But specifically i would like to know if he is ok with us collecting each others contact information for those of us that wish to provide them. 
×
×
  • Create New...