Jump to content

1920s Silver Cased Swiss Watch help required


Recommended Posts

Hi, I am looking for some help with a recent eBay acquisition. It's what I believe to be a 1920s watch. Brand is Medana.

Help needed:

Watch movement: I don't know the manufacturer or type. It is marked with a 'J' and has a cylindrical escapement. Diameter is 27.96mm which is 12 and 3/8 ligne.

Mainspring: Does it look set? Barrel inner diameter is 11.2mm. Spring height 1.7mm and thickeness 0.16mm. How do I find a suitable replacement, assuming it is set as I don't know the length without bending it into a straight length.

Curb pin: There's only one. Would this be positioned on the outside or inside of the outer turn of the hairspring? It needs replacing anyway as it is really rough and is also loose, possibly too short (looks like a bad repair). Going to try and make a replacement with brass wire. Hole that it goes into is 0.45mm. Would there be an easier way to solve this?

Hairspring: It's coned and the final turn needs a tweak but I should be able to solve that.

Glass: 27.85mm diameter domed with a knife edge profile. Dome height is 2.8mm external. Any idea which series of glass I should be looking at here?

Thanks in advance for any help received. Steve.

IMG_20220602_123530445.jpg

IMG_20220602_122225016.jpg

IMG_20220602_120718477_MP.jpg

IMG_20220602_115105492_HDR.jpg

Screenshot_20220602-141850.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't know what the "J" signifies, Do you have a pic of the keyless work - it will help to ID it in BestFit.

The mainspring is set. As it will need replacing, there's no problems straightening it to measure.

The hairspring needs quite a bit of tweaking - good luck with that !

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, mikepilk said:

The mainspring is set. As it will need replacing, there's no problems straightening it to measure.

That is never necessary. The formula for MS (or any other regular spiral) length is accurate https://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/spiral-length-d_2191.html

Applied to watchmaking

http://theindex.nawcc.org/CalcMainspringLength.php

So you can keep the original part in case no replacement is available after all, future reference, or just out of respect to for non-destructive science. 

 

Edited by jdm
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, jdm said:

So you can keep the original part in case no replacement is available after all, futur reference,or just out of respect to for non-destructive science. 

 

But I like breaking things ! 🤣

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, mikepilk said:

Don't know what the "J" signifies, Do you have a pic of the keyless work - it will help to ID it in BestFit.

The mainspring is set. As it will need replacing, there's no problems straightening it to measure.

The hairspring needs quite a bit of tweaking - good luck with that !

Thanks, will try and get a pic of the keyless works. Hairspring isn't too bad. The really rough part is the bit further on from where it was pinned.

15 minutes ago, steve1811uk said:

Thanks, will try and get a pic of the keyless works. Hairspring isn't too bad. The really rough part is the bit further on from where it was pinned.

Barrel arbor was 3.7mm diameter. Picture of keyless attached. Hope this helps.

Screenshot_20220602-160257.png

IMG_20220602_155913543.jpg

IMG_20220602_155953343.jpg

IMG_20220602_160000659.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Hi steve,

 Before spending money on mainspring and other parts,  I would test if the oscilator runs without putting up a stiff fight. Build your oscilator, install the escapement and gear train without the barrel and  turn a gear of the train to see if oscilator runs  with normal amount of persuasion, in case it desn't cooperate, it might take a lot of work to get it to run. 

Good luck pal.

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Nucejoe said:

 Hi steve,

 Before spending money on mainspring and other parts,  I would test if the oscilator runs without putting up a stiff fight. Build your oscilator, install the escapement and gear train without the barrel and  turn a gear of the train to see if oscilator runs  with normal amount of persuasion, in case it desn't cooperate, it might take a lot of work to get it to run. 

Good luck pal.

 

 

Pretty sure it will run. Before disassembly it would run for about 5 seconds and stop and upon inspection it had a lot of issues.

Hairspring badly coned and tilted, rubbing against balance arms 

Very dirty movement.

Second hand pinion badly bent (straightened now)

Dial loose (missing one dial screw).

Set mainspring?

Lots of dried oil.

I think I will try and get it running with the original spring first and take it from there. I've tackled the hairspring already, pretty flat now. Pinning it back is going to be a challenge as the stud is fixed. Probably need to fit the hairspring to the balance and then pin it. I will also need to make and fit a curb pin. I think as there is only one curb pin then it should bear against the outside of the outer coil, but I am no expert regarding that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/2/2022 at 8:32 PM, steve1811uk said:oil.I will also need to make and fit a curb pin. I think as there is only one curb pin then it should bear against the outside of the outer coil, but I am no expert regarding that.

There should be another pin - it looks like the remains of a brass pin may be in the regulator.. I’ve not fitted a new pin but would guess it pushes in, possibly with a slight taper, from the side which the remaining pin protrudes from, then is lightly riveted on the other side to hold in place.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 hours ago, JonathanGrainger said:

There should be another pin - it looks like the remains of a brass pin may be in the regulator.. I’ve not fitted a new pin but would guess it pushes in, possibly with a slight taper, from the side which the remaining pin protrudes from, then is lightly riveted on the other side to hold in place.

Hi, There's only one hole in the regulator arm so I am guessing it only ever had one pin. Up to now, my best guess is to fit a new brass pin in place of the old one which tbh wasn't fitted too well and was very fat. That one was extremely loose and just pulled out with tweezers. I will then widen out the outer turn so the new curb pin can fit inside of the final turn, just resting on the curb pin. Unless anyone has a better idea or more experience with low cost (1 jewel) cylindrical movement. Steve.

IMG_20220604_140626648.jpg

IMG_20220604_141041366.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 6/4/2022 at 3:54 PM, steve1811uk said:

Hi, There's only one hole in the regulator arm so I am guessing it only ever had one pin. Up to now, my best guess is to fit a new brass pin in place of the old one which tbh wasn't fitted too well and was very fat. That one was extremely loose and just pulled out with tweezers. I will then widen out the outer turn so the new curb pin can fit inside of the final turn, just resting on the curb pin. Unless anyone has a better idea or more experience with low cost (1 jewel) cylindrical movement. Steve.

IMG_20220604_140626648.jpg

IMG_20220604_141041366.jpg

It's just dawned on me, occasionally cylinder watches have a single wire which is bent back on it's self to give the effect of having 2 pins, forming a "U".

I just a had a flashback to disassembling one - having to unhook the regulator due to that arrangement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, JonathanGrainger said:

It's just dawned on me, occasionally cylinder watches have a single wire which is bent back on it's self to give the effect of having 2 pins, forming a "U".

I just a had a flashback to disassembling one - having to unhook the regulator due to that arrangement.

Thanks Jonathan, I think that's going to be an interesting task making that with my rudimentary tool set. Fingers crossed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • While you might have seen it as a humorous/Dramatic remark was done very deliberately so I could get an answer. Let me quote myself? The simplistic of this entire discussion is the group would like the last forever.   If you go to the top of the discussion group you'll find something to click on that says staff. Then you click on Mark's name and you find out interesting things? For instance he was last here on Saturday so yes he is here. If there is a crisis or a problem he is going to be here. You will also find a list of his activity although that's only the public activity. There's a lot of work that goes into running message boards and he probably does a lot of stuff in the background that we don't see to keep it going. Unfortunately message boards do not run themselves. Then regarding this did you notice you can message Mark and ask him. Then if somebody, we could elect somebody from this discussion such as @Neverenoughwatches To reach out I would really keep the message super simple like? You could refer him to this discussion but I would really keep it simple Like for instance the group enjoys his message board and what could we do to keep it going Forever? Then regarding all of the other suggestions comments helpful remarks or ideas? When was the last time any of you bothered to read the message board rules? This is covered which is one of the reasons I did the dramatic things I did to provoke a response of the basics as opposed to starting to suggest or seemingly suggesting all sorts of ideas which are covered by one of the rules found in the section on rules. In other words I'm going to quote something from the rules of the message board.  
    • For me any input from Mark would be great. If he's keeping a close eye i would imagine he has read about our concerns here. But specifically i would like to know if he is ok with us collecting each others contact information for those of us that wish to provide them. 
    • Hello and welcome from Leeds, England. 
    • Thank you!   Yes I did. I did not notice a difference. Although 9415 is advertised as a thixotropic grease (and I did had high hopes for it), the only advantage at this point I see is that its “easier” to apply than an oil (if one does not use epilame). But this is subjective, I guess. What I did notice though, if you apply a bit too much grease, that definitely slows down the movement. Oil in this case is a bit more forgiving, as its super thin, and it would usually just spread out.  Again, imho.
    • Mark keeps a close eye on his forum. I'm sure if you asked him he will reply, he might not do it right away but you will receive his answer.  
×
×
  • Create New...