Jump to content

Recommended Posts

17 minutes ago, HectorLooi said:

Water and carbon steel are not best pals. Looks like you have an older, carbon steel hairspring. And together with brass, a galvanic reaction took place.

A waterless cleaner would be a better bet.

As some have suggested on this forum, would it be perfectly acceptable to just pop all the parts into a jar of lighter fluid?  That would save me a lot of time/headaches in cleaning.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, GregG said:

As some have suggested on this forum, would it be perfectly acceptable to just pop all the parts into a jar of lighter fluid?  That would save me a lot of time/headaches in cleaning.

I have used lighter fluid, gasoline, turpentine in my ultrasonic cleaner before. They can remove the dried up oils but leave the surface looking a little dry and lifeless.

Now I use L&R #111 Cleaner and #3 Rinse. Although they are really expensive here in Singapore, I don't think I would go back to before.

Unfortunately the rust stains cannot be removed by lighter fluid now. Probably a supervised soak in phosphoric acid would work. @Nucejoe would probably recommend soaking it in Coke. ( the cola kind )

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, GregG said:

I have been using water and powdered dish washing detergent mixed in.  I'm generally getting very good results for what is probably the cheapest possible option.  But this most recent movement I tried was strange.  All the parts were separated into baskets, and the balance+bridge was screwed into the main plate to secure it.

I think you can clean the movement plates and bridges using water and soap in the ultrasonic cleaner without risk as long as you don’t clean steel containing parts such as screws, the hairspring, hairspring stud etc.

In practice, that would preclude the entire balance cock, the train wheels, keyless works, screws, springs. For those steel containing parts it’s best to clean in benzine. If you get rust on pivots which are made of steel you are going to have to polish/burnish them.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, GregG said:

I am experimenting with cleaning fluids on some spare movements that I have lying around, and I ran into some anomalies that I'm hoping someone here could explain.

I have been using water and powdered dish washing detergent mixed in.  I'm generally getting very good results for what is probably the cheapest possible option.  But this most recent movement I tried was strange.  All the parts were separated into baskets, and the balance+bridge was screwed into the main plate to secure it.

Everything came out spotless except for the balance.  The cone on the balance staff just above the pivot got rusty/dirty, as did the pin securing the hairspring to the bridge, and most of the top of the bridge.  I rinsed in isopropyl alcohol, although, the rusting started while they were in the bath, which was only about 35C.  I noticed that there was some grit or grime that was coalescing around the screw head, which mostly washed away after I drained it.

Anyone know what's going on?

IMG_20220416_224601.jpg

IMG_20220416_224647.jpg

IMG_20220416_224731.jpg

Hi Greg. To me it looks like the screws around the balance assembly have reacted first to the water based solution and the rust formation has just started to spread out. Another reason I would never use anything water based again. In the right hands and the right equipment  and being able to fully and quickly dry ie. In a dedicated movement cleaner the water based is probably ok. But me as a beginner, as soon as watch parts are removed from a water clean the oxidation process is on its merry way of making your life difficult. I've posted something that may be of use to you under the topic cleaning fluids. I would love to hear any thoughts that the experts have regarding isopropyl versus naptha. Alcohol based vs petroleum based.

Edited by Neverenoughwatches
Link to comment
Share on other sites

You fellas who are getting rust after using water mixed with (fill in blank), and deciding water based cleaners cause rust- please remember that there are professionals (like me) with many years of good, rust-free results with water based cleaners that were made for cleaning watches.

 

And for the some-dozenth time, no problem at all to dip your balance and fork in alcohol to soak off water used for rinsing. 15+ years of using water based cleaner and doing just that, never lost a roller jewel or pallet stone.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, GregG said:

As some have suggested on this forum, would it be perfectly acceptable to just pop all the parts into a jar of lighter fluid?

As mentioned already. Lighter fluid it's not an horological product, it's not recommended by any school or book, it's made to burn not to clean,  so it contains additives.

What you want instead is petroleum ether, available on Ebay and other places es, it has guaranteed purity and is cheaper per quantity.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, nickelsilver said:

You fellas who are getting rust after using water mixed with (fill in blank), and deciding water based cleaners cause rust- please remember that there are professionals (like me) with many years of good, rust-free results with water based cleaners that were made for cleaning watches.

 

And for the some-dozenth time, no problem at all to dip your balance and fork in alcohol to soak off water used for rinsing. 15+ years of using water based cleaner and doing just that, never lost a roller jewel or pallet stone.

How do you rinse off the water based cleaner? Do you use distilled water or is there a horological rinse for it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

48 minutes ago, HectorLooi said:

How do you rinse off the water based cleaner? Do you use distilled water or is there a horological rinse for it?

It depends. If using my machine with the distiller integral, I will go straight into the alcohol, then dump it and let it refill (about 6 minutes) for a clean rinse. I have another ultrasonic (pics below)* with 3 little tanks that gets used a lot for general quick cleaning of a part or two; the first bath is the water based cleaner, 2nd is the 1st alco rinse, which takes off the bulk, and the 3rd a clean alco rinse, dryer is to the right.

 

For clocks I use a water based cleaner that I mix up from a recipe from the Finnish watchmaking school. To conserve alcohol, with those parts I rinse in water, pat dry with a towel (what I can conveniently), then into alcohol, then on a larger Greiner dryer.

 

I know Elma recommends distilled water followed by Suprol Pro to displace the water prior to drying. As I have always used Greiner solution, I stick to their method of alcohol, or water then alcohol.

 

* This little ultrasonic is another example of the Greiner cleverness- the 1st and 3rd tanks have ultrasonic transducers in them. The 2nd one is just a simple bath. By switching them around, whichever one in the 1st position will turn on its ultrasonic transducer if the number is facing forward. Works by induction. Super cool!

20220417_125121.jpg

20220417_125136.jpg

Edited by nickelsilver
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, jdm said:

As mentioned already. Lighter fluid it's not an horological product, it's not recommended by any school or book, it's made to burn not to clean,  so it contains additives.

What you want instead is petroleum ether, available on Ebay and other places es, it has guaranteed purity and is cheaper per quantity.

Good old jdm still on about lighter fluid. It never done any harm to hairsprings or pallets or shellac when I used Ronsnol lighter fluid. I have left hairsprings in it for days and pallets. 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, oldhippy said:

It never done any harm to hairsprings or pallets or shellac when I used Ronsnol lighter fluid. I have left hairsprings in it for days and pallets. 

I never said ot implied that lighter fluid does any damage - of course it doesn't. I just said that with less money you can buy half a liter of pure product example

 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/142061406816?hash=item2113850a60:g:vjQAAOSwgc1axeUo

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

30 minutes ago, oldhippy said:

You said. As mentioned already. Lighter fluid it's not an horological product, it's not recommended by any school or book, it's made to burn not to clean,  so it contains additives.

I was pointing out that none of what you said harmed any of the parts I used to clean with Ronsnol. That is all. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, nickelsilver said:

You fellas who are getting rust after using water mixed with (fill in blank), and deciding water based cleaners cause rust- please remember that there are professionals (like me) with many years of good, rust-free results with water based cleaners that were made for cleaning watches.

 

And for the some-dozenth time, no problem at all to dip your balance and fork in alcohol to soak off water used for rinsing. 15+ years of using water based cleaner and doing just that, never lost a roller jewel or pallet stone.

I agree water based cleaners can give excellent results, and have been used traditionally. However, in the hands of hobbyists without the correct equipment or technique can lead to rust! This is normally due to leaving in water rinse for too long, or leaving wet before drying for too long.

Interestingly, I never had rust developing in Elma red (max 5 min) but only after rinsing with water. I think if you’re not using the integrated machine you have to be really quick with your water rinse then wash in the alcohol solvent.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, HectorLooi said:

How do you rinse off the water based cleaner? Do you use distilled water or is there a horological rinse for it?

You normally have a quick dunk in water, then rinse twice in alcohol (or suprol). But I have had someone tell me they take it straight out of Elma Red and rinse in benzine… I don’t quite agree since Elma red and benzine aren’t miscible so you can’t quite clean it well like that…

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, jdm said:

I never said ot implied that lighter fluid does any damage - of course it doesn't. I just said that with less money you can buy half a liter of pure product example

 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/142061406816?hash=item2113850a60:g:vjQAAOSwgc1axeUo

 

Hi jmd. If its OK for me to mention my figuring on that ebay price, that works out at 4 x the price of the lighter fuel that I buy. Can you clarify that the listing is correct. Thank you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, jdm said:

As mentioned already. Lighter fluid it's not an horological product, it's not recommended by any school or book, it's made to burn not to clean,  so it contains additives.

What you want instead is petroleum ether, available on Ebay and other places es, it has guaranteed purity and is cheaper per quantity.

Hi jmd . Can I ask at what level of experience is it not recommended  to by any school or book. Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, HectorLooi said:

Would that be ethanol or isopropyl alcohol? 

If that's for me- isopropyl, which is pretty much the standard alcohol used in watchmaking. The machine I mentioned with the built in distiller was discontinued in the early 70s I believe, and in talking to the guys at Greiner one reason was people were using them to distill ethanol (the boiling temp is close enough), haha.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, nickelsilver said:

You fellas who are getting rust after using water mixed with (fill in blank), and deciding water based cleaners cause rust- please remember that there are professionals (like me) with many years of good, rust-free results with water based cleaners that were made for cleaning watches.

 

And for the some-dozenth time, no problem at all to dip your balance and fork in alcohol to soak off water used for rinsing. 15+ years of using water based cleaner and doing just that, never lost a roller jewel or pallet stone.

My blank was fairy liquid 😭

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ifibrin said:

You normally have a quick dunk in water, then rinse twice in alcohol (or suprol). But I have had someone tell me they take it straight out of Elma Red and rinse in benzine… I don’t quite agree since Elma red and benzine aren’t miscible so you can’t quite clean it well like that…

What is Suprol please ifibrin 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Hi jmd. If its OK for me to mention my figuring on that ebay price, that works out at 4 x the price of the lighter fuel that I buy. Can you clarify that the listing is correct. Thank you.

Hi again jdm this is the naptha I use in lighter fluid form is it different from the one in your listing ? I pay 89 pence per 100mm. Thanks

20220417_152639.jpg

20220417_152658.jpg

Edited by Neverenoughwatches
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, ifibrin said:

It’s a waterless rinse for use after washing with Elma Red.

 

A15E3ED4-0641-4BC6-BAB1-9505A1C295C4.jpeg

Thanks ifibrin. It doesn't really say on there what it actually is. It says what it isn't and what it does and its characteristics. Could that be because they don't want to give away the ingredients or that is simply just an alcohol that is easily available at a much cheaper price than they are offering. 

  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Does it say 17 jewels on the dial or on the movement ?
    • Hello and welcome from Leeds. 
    • Lots of rust on that hairspring Nev, would you even try to clean it up ?
    • How do you find the working distance from microscope lens to movement? Is it comfortable enough to get tools in?
    • Once you have the collet closer bits off, and the pulley off, there are two nuts on the spindle. These must be removed. There is a large nut in the back of the headstock with two holes, remove this with an appropriate wrench. The front large nut comes off too. The spindle now comes out- but wait- there's more! There is a spacer between the outer races of the bearings; the spindle will almost certainly come out "assembled" with both bearings and this spacer (it can actually come out front or back-ways with the large nuts off the headstock). You have to manage to press out the spindle from the rear bearing, get the spacer off, then remove the front bearing, now you can get to the key.   Imagining you get it all apart without causing any damage to the bearings, now the fun part starts. You must apply preload to the bearings, and this is a very tricky endeavor. Basically once you have the bearings back on, and are in the casting, you snug up the rear nut (one of the two) on the spindle, checking the play of the spindle with at least a 0.002mm reading indicator, until there is zero axial play, then just a little more, then snug up the second nut to lock things in place. Of course snugging up the second nut influences the preload, so you can go back and forth a few times to get it right. Too much preload and bearing life diminishes, too little, and you get poor performance, poor surface finishes, ball skidding, etc.   When I replaced the bearings in one of mine many years ago, I was surprised to find that the bearings were regular deep-groove bearings, but of a higher precision class than normal. I replaced with dimensionally identical angular contact bearings, class P4. In trying to set the preload, I just about lost my mind, so called Barden (the high precision arm of FAG bearing makers, and who made my new ones) and a nice engineer told me that the folks at Leinen were either crazy, or really good- he also said it's 100% A-OK to set up deep groove bearings with preload like this, but best is angular contact. In this bearing setup, the standard way to do it is to have a spacer between the outer races, and another between the inner races. Leinen has the former but not the latter, haha. His advice was to make an inner spacer. The trick is it has to be the exact same length as the outer spacer, within like a micron.  Then you just tighten everything up and the preload is set, because the bearings (the new ones) are ground in a way that they have proper preload in that situation. Easy. Sort of- if you have the means to make the other spacer!   Just to note- Schaublin does the preloading as Leinen did on these on their lathes using angular contact bearings. There is a procedure in the manual, where you tighten the nut until axial play is zero, then a certain number of degrees more. This works on their setup as the nut itself locks without a second nut, and they spent the time to figure it all out in a repeatable way.   I say all this not to scare you off from dismantling your headstock, just to give a heads-up what you're up against to get it back to where it was before.
×
×
  • Create New...