Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
26 minutes ago, Knebo said:

I can literally see the wobble just by winding it half a turn (with screwdriver on the blench block). I don't have a mainspring winder so I'd have to buy another mainspring if I remove it (and this one is rather expensive). Sorry, you'll probably find that annoying if you are offering good advice and I'm not following it.

No completely understandable knebo. If you have the ratchet hole centered in something and can see deformation in the wheel as you turn it then that answers the problem.  Still very strange though, shame you cant measure the radius of the wheel at different points. Send it to me, its frustrating me 😆

Posted
21 minutes ago, RichardHarris123 said:

You're not getting on our nerves, we like a good mystery.  Let us know how you get on with the new parts

Thanks! I certainly will let you know.

 

31 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

If you have the ratchet hole centered in something and can see deformation in the wheel as you turn it then that answers the problem.  Still very strange though, shame you cant measure the radius of the wheel at different points. Send it to me, its frustrating me

Ok, I will admit that I just put it on the bench block, holding the barrel down and turning the ratchet wheel by its screw. So I'm not necessarily centering the ratchet hole. It could still be the arbor (or its thread/screw) or, worst case, the barrel arbor holes.

I'll try again to measure the radius 🙂 

Posted
41 minutes ago, Knebo said:

Thanks! I certainly will let you know.

 

Ok, I will admit that I just put it on the bench block, holding the barrel down and turning the ratchet wheel by its screw. So I'm not necessarily centering the ratchet hole. It could still be the arbor (or its thread/screw) or, worst case, the barrel arbor holes.

I'll try again to measure the radius 🙂 

Just from the edge of the hole to the teeth

Screenshot_20231101-183423_Samsung Internet.jpg

Posted
23 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Just from the edge of the hole to the teeth

Screenshot_20231101-183423_Samsung Internet.jpg

Yes, that's what I had tried. But very fiddly. Will try again.

Thanks for the encouraging smiley 🙂 

 

18 minutes ago, Nucejoe said:

 I suspect the hole you closed, still can be bushed on lathe or even jeweled, also in all likelihood there are multiple issues anyway.

Rgds

Thanks for weighing in. The problem was already there before I closed the hole. But you are right, I can't exclude the possibility that I damaged the barrel holes during opening and closing of the barrel for the mainspring change (before closing the hole).

Posted
9 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

That me, i used to have hair and eyebrows and ears and pupils etc, i never used to be red either

And good god, you are tiny! Must be great, though, for inspecting watch movements and fault-finding.

  • Like 1
Posted
9 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

That me, i used to have hair and eyebrows and ears and pupils etc, i never used to be red either. 🙂

You might laugh Rich,  its not easy chatting up women looking like that, I'll set my dog on you 😆

1 minute ago, Knebo said:

And good god, you are tiny! Must be great, though, for inspecting watch movements and fault-finding.

I cant fix anything though the tools are far too heavy 🙂

  • Haha 1
Posted
8 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

It can only have come from the factory like this, just not possible for it to have deformed afterwards. 

Or if this is a Mumbai special, then anything is possible. 

  • Thanks 1
Posted

UPDATE

I can now definitely confirm what nobody, including myself, could really believe. The ratchet wheel is NOT ROUND. 

I put it in my staking set, holding it perfectly centered with regard to its hole. Now look at the video/gif. I drew the red line into the video to make it more obvious. 

Looking from above makes it even clearer, but more difficult to film. 

20231102_220618_1_1.gif.c4f2dfe037616e21a6dbabf54f05dfff.gif

 

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
16 minutes ago, Knebo said:

UPDATE

I can now definitely confirm what nobody, including myself, could really believe. The ratchet wheel is NOT ROUND. 

I put it in my staking set, holding it perfectly centered with regard to its hole. Now look at the video/gif. I drew the red line into the video to make it more obvious. 

Looking from above makes it even clearer, but more difficult to film. 

20231102_220618_1_1.gif.c4f2dfe037616e21a6dbabf54f05dfff.gif

 

Must have come from the factory like this. 😉

17 minutes ago, Knebo said:

UPDATE

I can now definitely confirm what nobody, including myself, could really believe. The ratchet wheel is NOT ROUND. 

I put it in my staking set, holding it perfectly centered with regard to its hole. Now look at the video/gif. I drew the red line into the video to make it more obvious. 

Looking from above makes it even clearer, but more difficult to film. 

20231102_220618_1_1.gif.c4f2dfe037616e21a6dbabf54f05dfff.gif

 

 

17 minutes ago, Knebo said:

The ratchet wheel is NOT ROUND. 

It is kind of, sort of an off round. Like white that isn't white its like an off white. Now which brave soul would like to live in my  head for a day 🙂

Edited by Neverenoughwatches
Posted
17 hours ago, Knebo said:

UPDATE

I can now definitely confirm what nobody, including myself, could really believe. The ratchet wheel is NOT ROUND. 

I put it in my staking set, holding it perfectly centered with regard to its hole. Now look at the video/gif. I drew the red line into the video to make it more obvious. 

Looking from above makes it even clearer, but more difficult to film. 

20231102_220618_1_1.gif.c4f2dfe037616e21a6dbabf54f05dfff.gif

 

The wheel IS ROUND, but it's hole is out of center. But You video is not prooving it clearly, as the wheel is actually not centered by it's square hole. But, it is still pritty obvious that the hole is out of center, even without this video.

BUT, if the sqyare part of the arbour is cut out of arbour center too, this can compensate the wheel's hole out of center, if the wheel and the arbour are assembled/matched in the correct way

  • Like 2
Posted
On 11/3/2023 at 3:32 PM, nevenbekriev said:

The wheel IS ROUND, but it's hole is out of center. But You video is not prooving it clearly, as the wheel is actually not centered by it's square hole. But, it is still pritty obvious that the hole is out of center, even without this video.

BUT, if the sqyare part of the arbour is cut out of arbour center too, this can compensate the wheel's hole out of center, if the wheel and the arbour are assembled/matched in the correct way

Very true nev good point, its possible that both the ratchet wheel hole and arbor square are not centered, but once matched up correctly the ratchet wheel may run true.

Posted
On 11/3/2023 at 4:32 PM, nevenbekriev said:

The wheel IS ROUND, but it's hole is out of center. But You video is not prooving it clearly, as the wheel is actually not centered by it's square hole. But, it is still pritty obvious that the hole is out of center, even without this video.

BUT, if the sqyare part of the arbour is cut out of arbour center too, this can compensate the wheel's hole out of center, if the wheel and the arbour are assembled/matched in the correct way

That sounds possible and would be the solution to the mystery why on earth it was fine before my service (because I'm sure I'm not able to reshape a wheel or move it's center). 

Still pretty bizarre! Could it have come from Tissot like that?

But I'll try the four positions!

  • Like 1
Posted
9 hours ago, Knebo said:

That sounds possible and would be the solution to the mystery why on earth it was fine before my service (because I'm sure I'm not able to reshape a wheel or move it's center). 

Still pretty bizarre! Could it have come from Tissot like that?

But I'll try the four positions!

Please let us know if Nev was right, its been bugging me since you posted the question 😅

  • Like 1
Posted
On 11/3/2023 at 4:32 PM, nevenbekriev said:

The wheel IS ROUND, but it's hole is out of center. But You video is not prooving it clearly, as the wheel is actually not centered by it's square hole. But, it is still pritty obvious that the hole is out of center, even without this video.

BUT, if the sqyare part of the arbour is cut out of arbour center too, this can compensate the wheel's hole out of center, if the wheel and the arbour are assembled/matched in the correct way

 

18 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Very true nev good point, its possible that both the ratchet wheel hole and arbor square are not centered, but once matched up correctly the ratchet wheel may run true.

 

7 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Please let us know if Nev was right, its been bugging me since you posted the question 😅

 

Ok, so... no. That's not it. Tried all four positions and it never runs true. I also couldn't see any off-centered-ness of the arbor square itself. 

I'll have the new ratchet and arbor towards the end of next week, I hope. 

  • Like 1
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

So.. good news!! 

New ratchet wheel arrived and everything works just fine. 

While it now definitively confirms where the problem was, we will probably never know how the ratchet wheel ended up with such a bizarre off-center hole. 

I'm also very happy that the hole-closing on the bridge and barrel arbor holes seemed to have worked well. Sure, I'll only know in a few years if the repair was long-lasting, but at least for now it doesn't seem to cause any increase in friction - quite the opposite: Amplitude is very high with nice, stable traces.

Here a picture at full wind and dial up:

20231114_214549.thumb.jpg.4d8eb68e9ca2809660dc80fcd0f4cab5.jpg

 

And before you say anything, dear @JohnR725😅, here are pictures after 24h in dial up and vertical crown down positions:

Dial up at 24h:

20231114_201125.thumb.jpg.7a1edc40de4eb76d2d5d84c60208a224.jpg

Crown down at 24h:

20231114_201023.thumb.jpg.04c4d74ed108115ed19bd7d03ecfc465.jpg

  • Like 3
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

Hello everyone, 

I can now report the my work on this watch is done. Apart from the regular movement service, the bizarre ratchet wheel and correcting the sideshake of the barrel, it took a lot of careful work to clean the dial and buffing the hands and hour markers. Also gave it a new crystal and some very light manual case polishing with Cape Cod cloths.

It is now going back to its owner, who's grandfather had bought it. 

I had some additional troubles with the automatic module, specifically the wear on the rotor bearing. While the rotor wasn't touching the movement when gently turned, it did rattle and touch when shaken a bit. I had to order three rotors until I finally got one that was in good enough shape. Thankfully not too expensive. 

Here are some pics of the final product:

20231128_161128_resized.thumb.jpg.53b9ca37775fa84697356ba904205c31.jpg20231126_142354.thumb.jpg.83323654d3a2975ab72b8a40773b1674.jpg20231126_142403.thumb.jpg.5de119134066570029e558205535f41a.jpg

 

Edited by Knebo
  • Like 3

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • A helpful way in aid of assembly is to place all the wheels in their respective places, place to plate on the top and fit a couple of the nuts onto the pillars. This stops all the wheels wobbling about as they are lightly held by the plate, you can manoeuvre the pivots into their holes, using a tool , usually home made or can be bought on eBay. I made my own. As the pivots align and fall into place screw the nuts down a bit to keep up the tension on the plate untill all wheels are in place then tighten down sufficiently to keep the plate in place whilst checking the end shake on ALL wheels and their location when all is good only then tighten down the plate.
    • I'd say my Pultra 10 lathe. It is just so well made and everything fits so tightly together.
    • Welcome to the forum, enjoy. 
    • Yes, the specific old tools do exist, but may be having one is not needed as they are not cheap, and also You will be able to do without it well enough. My advice will be to use regular depthing tool and adjust it for the exact distance between pallet fork and escape wheel bearings from the watch. Then remove the shellac from the pallet that now doesn't pass the ew teeth and move this pallet in. Then put the pallet fork and ew on the depthing tool and check how they lock. They should not lock when the pallet is in, but You will little by little move the pallet out and locking will appear. Then move just an idea out for reliable work and apply shellac, then check if things are still the same. You have to observe where the teeth fall on the pallets - it must be just a little below the edge between impulse and rest planes. Then You must check how everything behaves in the movement This Potence tool is so ingenious, but actually, the traditional way to do the things is much more simple. Arrange the parts not on the pillar plate, but on the cover plate. Only the central wheel will remain on the pillar plate, secured by the cannon pinion.
    • There is a tool that was made for setting up and adjusting escapements of full plate watches.  There were two styles, the picture below shows both of them.  The lower tool held a movement plate and the vertical pointed rods were adjusted to hold the unsupported pivots of the lever and escape wheel.  There was also a version of this tool that had 3 adjustable safety centres so that the balance pivot could be supported by the tool :  The other version I’m aware of is the Boynton’s Escapement Matching and Examining Tool came as a set of two or three clamps that gripped the watch plate and held the safety centres for the pivots : These do turn up on eBay from time to time.  For some escapement work, you can set up the parts in a regular depthing tool, with the centres set according to the distance between the corresponding pivot holes on the movement.  I hope this helps, Mark
×
×
  • Create New...