Jump to content

Sellita Interview


Recommended Posts

1 hour ago, tomh207 said:

Watched that a week or so ago. It is really interesting and does rather clear up some of the myths.

 

Tom

 

5 hours ago, mzinski said:

An interesting Q&A video with Sébastien Chaulmontet of Sellita in which he answers an assortment of questions about Sellita. Worth a watch, especially if you think Sellita is a just a subpar clone ETA.

 

Interesting interview. So most of the ETA movements that we see and work on were actually assembled in a Sellita factory. And when ETA pulled the plug on them in the early 2000s when Swatch started to devise their evil plans to take over the world. Sellita pulled up their big boy pants, grew some, invested some serious cash and developed parts manufacturing based on old Patent expired ETAs that they had already been putting together for over 50 years. Well done Sellita 👏 

Just now, Neverenoughwatches said:

 

Interesting interview. So most of the ETA movements that we see and work on were actually assembled in a Sellita factory. And when ETA pulled the plug on them in the early 2000s when Swatch started to devise their evil plans to take over the world. Sellita pulled up their big boy pants, grew some, invested some serious cash and developed parts manufacturing based on old Patent expired ETAs that they had already been putting together for over 50 years. Well done Sellita 👏 

Strange that nothing i have read about ETA has suggested that Sellita put their parts together for them, not by name anyway. I wonder why that is ETA ?

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, tomh207 said:

Watched that a week or so ago. It is really interesting and does rather clear up some of the myths.

 

Tom

It seems Sellita have been popping up all over the place for quite a long time, either by pushing eta out of brands they supplied such as Breitling or because eta have been pulling back of their own accord. It nice to hear this young man Sebastian mention a few times that their parts and movements are available to anyone that needs them. After all you purchase something, you should have the right to repair that purchase yourself. Whether its a hoover, a washing machine, a car or a watch. Restricting parts take away that right.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

It seems Sellita have been popping up all over the place for quite a long time, either by pushing eta out of brands they supplied such as Breitling or because eta have been pulling back of their own accord. It nice to hear this young man Sebastian mention a few times that their parts and movements are available to anyone that needs them. After all you purchase something, you should have the right to repair that purchase yourself. Whether its a hoover, a washing machine, a car or a watch. Restricting parts take away that right.

It wasn't a case of Sellita pushing ETA out, but the other way around. Brands like Breitling and Tag Heuer no longer had access to ETA movements so switched over to Sellita. In fact, I'm working on one right now.

You'll also notice the question asked about the chewed up ratchet wheel issue on the Sellita movements and Sebastian dismissing it as an issue that's been resolved "almost 10 years ago". Well no sir, I have a 2016 Seliita SW200.1 with a chewed up ratchet wheel right in front of me. Take a gander over at Cousins and you'll see that ratchet wheel is a "Best Seller".

Outside of that, I really do like the Sellita movements. Even on their base SW200.1 the main spring barrel arbour holes are jewelled - I can't remember that being the case on the ETA 2824-2 (although I haven't worked on one in a while)

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, gbyleveldt said:

You'll also notice the question asked about the chewed up ratchet wheel issue on the Sellita movements and Sebastian dismissing it as an issue that's been resolved "almost 10 years ago". Well no sir, I have a 2016 Seliita SW200.1 with a chewed up ratchet wheel right in front of me. Take a gander over at Cousins and you'll see that ratchet wheel is a "Best Seller".

I read something about that, the tooth design was wrong, they supposed to have re engineered it and sorted on the 200.1.  Also beware of refurbished 200 and 200.1, indentified by a two letter code under the balance. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It was a statement I came across whilst perambulating the web some time ago, whether its true or not is a moot point, but I am sure if it is as I said it wouldnt be broadcast world wide for sure. Such information is usually gleaned from disgruntled personel through various means.  Many companies use the services of China and India to manufacture products under their name. An expose on TV showed that surgical instruments branded "Made In Germany" were in fact made in India in back street workshops. But EU law states as long as the steel was made in germany it was legitimate. an Independent tester found  up to 40% were not fit for purpose and were rejected on quality issues.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, LittleWatchShop said:

So what is the deal with ratchet wheel teeth?  This is a problem with the Valjoux 72 as well ( I have one with a busted ratchet wheel that I will finally have the balls to service it next year).  Seems like an odd thing to make such a vulnerable wheel.

Apparently Sellita modified the pitch of the teeth a little from the ETA design at the time. At least this is what’s going through the rumour mill; Sellita acknowledged there was a problem that they resolved in the above video but didn’t expand further. Personally I think it’s maybe a poor choice of materials for this specific part, as I’ve not seen this issue on any of the original ETA movements of the same design (even going back to mid 90’s ones). Your Valjoux 72 is muuuuch older so wear is to be expected. You wouldn’t expect it on a 2015 TAG using that Sellita movement. If I remember I’ll post some pics tomorrow.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

it is not a Rumour that Sellita modified the Weels, it is documented by Sellita

look here

https://www.google.ch/url?q=https://www.sellita.ch/scripts/calibres/images/IS%2005_Evolution%20calibre%20SW200%20vers%20SW200-1.pdf&sa=U&ved=2ahUKEwig44XUqfX7AhVP4qQKHQw5DOwQFnoECAsQAg&usg=AOvVaw0QDdoNfkxEmBq3gOVDEgir

hope this helps a bit, i like Facts.....

 

regards,

Ernst

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you @Sirius. That document outlines the changes and updates between SW200 and SW200.1 done in 2008. I said “Rumour” because I’ve not seen confirmation officially, so thanks for pointing this out.

Thing is, the problematic one I have here is already an SW200.1 from a 2015 watch - so it would appear that the issue is still not fixed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, gbyleveldt said:

Thank you @Sirius. That document outlines the changes and updates between SW200 and SW200.1 done in 2008. I said “Rumour” because I’ve not seen confirmation officially, so thanks for pointing this out.

Thing is, the problematic one I have here is already an SW200.1 from a 2015 watch - so it would appear that the issue is still not fixed.

Lucky for you I believe Sellita dates its movements (at least mine for 2019, 2021, and 2022 are). Take a look next to the reference number to see what year your movement is from. 

Also, if the watch had been serviced at any point,  there a slim chance that part got replaced with a bad part. 
3904AA9A-0079-47B0-9A88-BE9701A39987.thumb.jpeg.25a7b8bf915fa3f2eda55b097a149bdf.jpegA5752096-9200-4653-BD1C-831CDD7775B9.thumb.jpeg.99c2377bd9b84d8b3e6007d967e0a596.jpeg7BA20B83-AB3E-4877-801B-BEA02864EB32.thumb.jpeg.e15efd4c938bebe1195ded6b45c5fead.jpeg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, LittleWatchShop said:

So what is the deal with ratchet wheel teeth?  This is a problem with the Valjoux 72 as well ( I have one with a busted ratchet wheel that I will finally have the balls to service it next year).  Seems like an odd thing to make such a vulnerable wheel.

Valjoux 72/23 are known for losing teeth on the ratchet wheel. Not sure why, but there's a shortage of original replacements out there (I've made quite a few).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, mzinski said:

Lucky for you I believe Sellita dates its movements (at least mine for 2019, 2021, and 2022 are). Take a look next to the reference number to see what year your movement is from. 
 

Yessir, here's the specific movement. It's a late 2014 model, in line with being in a 2015 watch. This is the updated version so technically the ratchet wheel issue should've been resolved already.

2020_0101_002845_005.thumb.jpg.075599aa8ed56f871872a6a450041273.jpg

And the offending rathcet wheel. New one on the left, shewed up one on the right

vlcsnap-2022-12-13-09h38m50s809.thumb.jpg.99779dcc8a670d4ff9a972ef5eecd023.jpg

Just for the sake of clarity, I don't want people to think I dislike the Sellita movements - quite the opposite in fact. Like with any product there are some potential issues to be aware of so me carrying on about it is to merely create awareness of the issue. Sellita parts are much cheaper (and more accessible) than the ETA counterparts so in principle I'd support Sellita if given the choice. They're certainly not some mickey mouse company.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Thanks so much for all the tips! I tried both methods. I tried pulling the pins with two pliers but they wouldn't budge. I then tried the method shown in the clip but that was way too much effort and I was pretty sure the bracelet would not have looked right once I was done. I ended up getting a similar bracelet that's easy to resize but I'm glad we gave this a shot.
    • Yes. This machine can function in 2 modes, soldering and spot welding. The spot welding mode can be used for broken screw removal as well as repairing broken mainspring bridles. If your DIY one works fine, then there is no need to buy another machine. But if you are thinking of buying a new machine, I suggest you wait awhile because I heard that there is a new machine under development that in addition to the above 2 functions, has a 3rd mode that can be used to fill pits in corroded metal surfaces.
    • Thanks for clearing that up, I was just going by how it appeared to work in the few videos I had seen on line, especially comparing it to my own manual current based jobby, when they was showing it being used to remove a broken stem it seemed to weld as no solder paste was used. I will see if I can find the video. Did seem to work very well though, just trying not to buy it as my DIY one seems to work ok and i dont do enough to justify the cost, but ghen again we do seem to say that a lot Found the video It's on this sellers page https://a.aliexpress.com/_mtyFJxo You can see solder paste being used for the dial foot but not when removing the broken stem from the crown, it looked to me to be more like the flash from a spot welder which was why I thought it was based on a capacitor discharge like one of those spot welders used for battery pack assembly.
    • Well what do you say, if this is the work of a reputable clock repair it’s pretty poor. It is definitly needing a rebush. What Old Hippy has said holds true. The old bush out the hole tidying up and a new bush pressing in. I my self would drill the hole to remove the punch marks and make a bush to restore the plate but for that you need a lathe. Looking at the bush the condition of the pivot may also need attention, burnishing at the least to restore the surface. It’s not impossible to do it by hand , but will take care and time.
    • Thanks old hippy Its  shame really as it was purchased from a reputable clock repairer for not an inconsiderable sum. As you say it has been botched; even I can I can see that and I'm not a clock repairer.  Plugging holes sounds quite technical; what's involved please? I'm trying to weigh up how much of this I can do myself.  Thanks so far.
×
×
  • Create New...