Jump to content

Cannon pinion loose


Recommended Posts

I've changed hands on a couple of eta 2824 /2836 movements and a chronic fear of mine is that I will "loosen" the cannon pinion in the process.

I have done this already a couple of times and can tell I've caused some damage when the minute hands starts to loose or gain time compared to the hour hand.

What is the proper way to fix and...is there a surefire way to avoid this? I have a few watches I'm needing to remove the hands from, but I'm paranoid I'm going to mess up the wheels...

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just changing hands should not cause the canon pinion to slacken if it was in good condition in the first place.  If the canon pinion is slack on the calibre you mention, it will have to be replaced due to the type it is.  Friction is not governed by the internal diameter of the tube, it is factory set where the large wheel is attached to pinion.

Is there a possibility you have inadvertently enlarged the hole in the hand when fitting it?

 

IMG_3022.PNG

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Occasionally the pinion separates from the large wheel. I then have to "press" it back on. Could this cause some issue? It always seems to be a nice tight friction fit...but for some reason the hands on the movements of question move sporadically...

It's possible the hands were loosened. I'll take one apart tomorrow to see if that is the issue...thanks


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, italiansub said:

Occasionally the pinion separates from the large wheel. I then have to "press" it back on. Could this cause some issue? It always seems to be a nice tight friction fit...but for some reason the hands on the movements of question move sporadically...
 

Your canon pinion is knackered if it has been separating from the wheel.  Replace it with a new one and that will sort your problems.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If you are using hand remover tool the trick is to pull straight up and not to a side, these tools tend to place themselves even under the hands, when you see its even under neath a little pull is all that's needed. Are you sure you are using the correct size tool as there are different ones.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guys, the original question has been answered.  

You have drifted far away from the original post, you should really start a new thread on hand removal tools to discuss the merits of each type.

I'm locking the thread now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Geo locked this topic
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I agree with @JohnR725. Oil on an epilamed surface is essentially the same as water on a waxed surface. The same physical properties are at work (surface tension vs. adhesion). 
    • I think we all get a lot out of this group, and it has been pivotal in my development by the sharing of knowledge, experience and learning from more seasoned experts such as @JohnR725 and others (you know who you are!) as well as fellow novices. I think that having a backup communication plan in reserve so that if there is a future problem just makes good sense. I don't think anyone is trying to undermine the forum, but if something unthinkable happens, like the Ranfft website for example, then it would be good if those who are willing can still keep in contact. Speaking personally, and I know I risk a charge of heresy, it would be good if Mark could be a little more visible in this forum, and maybe give any insight from time to time on the future/progress of forum and instructional videos etc. even if its just to confirm the status quo. I appreciate he is a busy man with a full time job, but so are most of the rest of us and to post a few lines every now and then shouldn't be too much to ask to reassure the restless villagers. Best outcome for me would be a message saying something along the lines of: "Hi guys, all good, no planned changes... enjoy the forum, will message again next month!" Just my two cents.
    • A nice looking watch !! Did you try 9010, instead of the 9415, on the pallet jewels / escape wheel? And if you did, did you notice a difference?
    • Knocked out another 404 last night...when you are in the zone! This watch was a non-runner which I picked up as part of a lot of 8 watches, so works out to be $3.12 per watch. Before:   And the finished watch, new crown and stem and the crystal was cracked so was replaced. I also replaced the mainspring as the original was the old steel type spiral and very 'set' - all else is original: The Movement was a AS 1686, but in reading around a little the ACCRO watch company were sued for their use of the five point crown on their Jacques Pere range as it resembled Rolex, see below: ACCRO then reverted to just ACCRO on their watches - I have done some sniffing around the internet and haven't seen another example of ACCRO and the crown together on a dial so maybe I have something unusual, or maybe I was looking in the wrong places 🙂.  
    • This watch was damaged when I got it. I didn't break the escape wheel pivot, and I bodged a fix with epoxy to see if I could get it running. I'm not yet ready to get into lathe work, or shellacking jewels, and may never be. But I'm learning plenty with each watch I tackle. 
×
×
  • Create New...