Jump to content

Elgin Size 0 Still Won't Run


Recommended Posts

So I replaced the mainspring on this Elgin pocket watch (and it was not easy as getting the arbor inside the spring was such a pain) and would it up and it still will not run. The balance and hairspring look good and in fact if I put a little pressure on the outside of the mainspring barrel, with a toothpick, the balance starts to oscillate. I replaced the mainspring in the first place because I thought that due to age it was not providing enough power the gear train. Now I think there must be something else causing too much friction for the power from the mainspring to overpower. Thoughts?

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

3fd5530ad3eb204d4473042ae7ec7258.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have the same movement that I just rebuilt. Well took apart, cleaned and reassembled. It was running before but not very strong, after my amateur rebuild it is still running weak. Sure this will be a common issue with these watches, awaiting more expert advice.

I have an issue with my stem also, but that will be another post.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have the same movement that I just rebuilt. Well took apart, cleaned and reassembled. It was running before but not very strong, after my amateur rebuild it is still running weak. Sure this will be a common issue with these watches, awaiting more expert advice.

I have an issue with my stem also, but that will be another post.

I made a mistake. It is actually a south bend 0s.a2f50163bf40e18c402543172bf3b324.jpg

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Try this first. Let down the mainspring so that there is no power. Remove the balance complete, pallet bridge and pallets. Now put a little power on and see if it runs through the train. If it doesn't run right down check all the wheels in the train, teeth pinions pivots, stones, bent wheels and end shake. I see with your movement the center wheel top pivot is not jeweled so check the top pivot and hole for wear and the cannon pinon end too and end shake. If everything here is correct look at the barrel teeth and the arbor check for any wear in the top bridge or bottom plate, arbor play in the barrel any type of binding, is the arbor smooth, no signs of wear. I know you said you have a new mainspring, is it the right one, not to high, not rubbing in the barrel or binding. If all this is correct you need to check the pallets do the same here as with the train wheels, make sure the pallet stones are secure and have a good edge on both. Put the pallets back and test with a little power and see if they release, do this all round the escape wheel. If this is working, check the balance, same thing, stones,staff end shake and impulse pin make sure it isn't rough or chipped and that is firm in its fixing. Is the roller good not bent and is that firm and not lose. Is the hairspring good, not bent, tight on the staff, nothing fouling it up. If everything is correct its time to fit the balance and see what happens, you don't need much power to see if it will run. After all that don't forget to oil it correctly. . I think I have covered most. If this still doesn't work get back

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

18 minutes ago, sstakoff said:

Just to be certain - are you positive that you did not install the mainspring backwards????

It has been done before!!!

If the mainspring was in the wrong way you wouldn't be able to wind it up because the arbor would not attach to the barrel arbor.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is true of course. Reading the original post, are we certain that the spring was actually wound??? When you wound it, were you able to "fully" wind it until it stopped???? If it were in backwards, you might "think" you were winding it when in fact, as oldhippy points out, it was not winding at all. If you really only applied minimal force to the barrel with the toothpick and the watch started to run this could explain the issue. Agreed - it's a long shot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks oldhippy for the very detailed diagnostics. I am going to proceed its your instruction. I have wound the spring with a screwdriver and it does wind and it also releases power when I hold back the click and let it down slowly with my screwdriver. I also took photos of the spring upon removal so I would wind it in the right way. As well. It will not all go together if you put the spring in backwards and snap the arbour in and then close the cover. The 1/4 flat part of the arbor that the ratchet wheel fits on to would not work.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No one told me about the criticality of the banking pins. Too wide and the balance stalls too narrow and the palate fork gets stuck. Ahhhhhhhhhhhh. Plus my screwdriver slipped when I was letting down the main spring an hour ago and I had to reinstall the arbor in the spring barrel. Man what a pain. So now it is working. I am going to just let it run for a while - see if it keeps going.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry that's one thing I forgot to mention the banking pins. At the time I didn't think as most banking pins end to be correct unless someone has fiddled with them or have become bent.

In this case, I think someone evil fiddled with the banking pins. I will let it run over night just to get the lubrication spread (not sure if it matters) and then I will reassemble. I don't think the amplitude is great but I just wanted the heart to beat on this one. [emoji56]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, jdrichard said:

I have wound the spring with a screwdriver and it does wind and it also releases power when I hold back the click and let it down slowly with my screwdriver.

Be careful doing that because you can break the screw. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Update. It ran for a few days on one wind. Problem is once I reassembled it with the face and hands etc it stopped running. Seems like friction from the hour and minute gears are causing the problem. Not sure what to do next... I usually never give up when the watch has a chance:(

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Was the watch cased when you ran it??? If not, are you certain that the keyless work was disengaged??

If the watch is a "negative set", then when out of the case the watch will be in time setting position which will likely cause the watch to stop. Check on the side of the movement, next to where the stem enters - there may be a small catch there that you can pull partially out. This will engage the winding mechanism - and relieving the tension of the keyless work. Make sense?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still will not run. I still think there is drag on the dial side somehow? The gear train runs free without the balance attached and when I assembled the balance and adjusted the banking pins I got it running, mind you with poor amplitude. Then when I put the dial back together...would not run. However, if I push the third wheel just a bit, away it goes. Ahhhh

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think now we need to go about this bit by bit. You say when the hands and dial are fitted it stops. So do this, remove the dial and hands and just put the hour hand on and test, if all is ok put the minute hand on and test, if it has a seconds hand that should be next if no hand put the dial on and make sure you have a good fitting washer that goes over the hour wheel, don't case up the movement and don't screw the dial to the movement, just place the dial on the movement. Then get back if all is ok.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think now we need to go about this bit by bit. You say when the hands and dial are fitted it stops. So do this, remove the dial and hands and just put the hour hand on and test, if all is ok put the minute hand on and test, if it has a seconds hand that should be next if no hand put the dial on and make sure you have a good fitting washer that goes over the hour wheel, don't case up the movement and don't screw the dial to the movement, just place the dial on the movement. Then get back if all is ok.

Will get back. At work:)

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • If we use the rub-off epilame method of pallet stones (run dry for a few minutes before applying the epilame) where will the oil go/be transported when it is pushed away from the impulse surface by the escape wheel teeth? Onto the epilame-treated sections of the pallet! Once the oil has been applied/transported to the epilame-treated sections of the pallet where will it then go? Nowhere as the oil will remain on the epilame. So, perhaps the run-dry method defeats its intended purpose leaving the pallet impulse surfaces dry!? If, on the other hand, we do not remove the epilame from the pallet stones where the escape wheel teeth come in contact with them I'd expect more oil to remain where we want it and need it. Yes, I agree, that is the question, and my gut feeling tells me that is exactly the case. Epilame was created to have an adhesive trait and the oleophobic property is just a side effect.  
    • Might that be the viscous nature of oil resisting gravity H  ,  we have been comparing water and hydrophobic surfaces which are similar in principle but water is much less viscous than oil. I guess what we trying to discover is if epilame also has an adhesive trait as well as being oleophobic. Plus the oil dropet has very little mass for gravity to work on, like watching tiny water beads that can grip onto vertical glass until they are connected together to increase their mass then run down. Gravity isn't the only factor at play when oil is placed on pallet stones. The oil receives a lot of bashing that may push it out of position ? Thinking about it if the oil stays in position for 10 minutes enough time for the escape wheel to scrape off the epilame , then  a walled in lubrication has been achieved,  the epilame is no longer beneath the oil ( possibly mixed into the oil )
    • But it also makes it seem less susceptible to gravity. If you place a droplet of oil on an epilame-treated surface the droplet of oil will still stay in place even if you then flip the surface from a horizontal to a vertical position. That is, the oil droplet remains anchored, and that's the purpose of epilame. If it was just a matter of creating an oleophobic surface we could probably use other, less expensive, methods!? I don't know @Waggy but my gut feeling tells me you're spot on (pun intended!). I believe the oleophobic property is a side effect of epilame which is designed to keep the oil anchored.
    • Saturday morning 27/4 Sunday evening 28/4 Monday evening 29/4 Floor has a drain in the middle so I am hoping that there is very little fall on it, if any. Room is about 2.5 x 2.5 metres square. Can only use about 1/2 of one wall on the right of the pictures which has a sliding glass door in it. And only about 3/4 of the wall to the left of the pictures as it has the door to the house in it. Progress. 🙂 
    • This makes much more sense now, the oil is withdrawing itself to make as little contact with the epilame as possible. Same principle as wax on a car creates a hyrophobic surface that makes the cohesive properties of water molecules pull together.  The water beads run off only when under the influence of gravity but still remain cohesively beaded up. And as mentioned earlier a pivot would keep the oil in place on a cap jewel.  Epilame on an escapement would be a different scenario, there is nothing to hold the oil in position if gravity tugs at the bead to move, plus the escape teeth pull the oil about Maybe this is why its suggested to run the watch for a short while to remove the epilame to make two oleophobic surfaces either side of the oil, creating a ring of fire 🔥 around it 😅 The oil is repelled by every surface of the epilame even that which it sits upon. So the oil pulls together to make as little contact with it as possible, but the oil cant float above that area, it can only sit there on top of it. Under gravity the oil could potentially run away as an oil bead, unless the epilame has an adhesive property which i dont think it does ? So something else keeps it in position ie a pivot under a cap jewel . But that isn't the case in a pallet jewel situation. 
×
×
  • Create New...