Jump to content

What is this brown stuff?


Recommended Posts

Hi all!

I’ve just disassembled my first watch - a cheap eta clone. 
it was actually running really well (+10 seconds), but I did buy the movement to practice so I pulled it apart, cleaned it, and discovered this brown rust-like colouring on the pallet fork. 
Is this normal? I’m hoping it isn’t rust! 

407F6C54-1C5F-4D4E-83B1-D7B0E014DAA9.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

32 minutes ago, HectorLooi said:

That's shellac. It's used an adhesive to set the pallet jewels in position. That's perfectly normal.

The colour of the shellac can vary from a very light blonde to a very dark brunette.

 

7 minutes ago, grsnovi said:

Shellac has been used for years and its origin might surprise you. Wikipedia is your friend.

Thanks so much for confirming! Huge relief, I thought I stuffed it up when I ran it through a clean!

im hoping to get a microscope plugged in tomorrow so I’ll be able to have better photos .

 

Thanks again!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

56 minutes ago, Watchscience said:

Hi all!

I’ve just disassembled my first watch - a cheap eta clone. 
it was actually running really well (+10 seconds), but I did buy the movement to practice so I pulled it apart, cleaned it, and discovered this brown rust-like colouring on the pallet fork. 
Is this normal? I’m hoping it isn’t rust! 

407F6C54-1C5F-4D4E-83B1-D7B0E014DAA9.jpeg

Hi ws . It has been used traditionally since the use of low friction synthetic rubies in the escapement.  You will also find it used to set the impulse jewel in place on the roller table of the balance assembly. Be careful with cleaning of these parts , ipa solvent can have a tendency to soften the schellac if left exposed to it for too long. Introducing heat to these areas softens the shellac should the jewels need to be reset.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Hi ws . It has been used traditionally since the use of low friction synthetic rubies in the escapement.  You will also find it used to set the impulse jewel in place on the roller table of the balance assembly. Be careful with cleaning of these parts , ipa solvent can have a tendency to soften the schellac if left exposed to it for too long. Introducing heat to these areas softens the shellac should the jewels need to be reset.

 

14 hours ago, grsnovi said:

Be careful as alcohol will dissolve it.

Thanks kindly🙏 
yeah I made sure to avoid any alcohols when cleaning this and anything with jewels - but this is great to know, otherwise I would have gone out of my way to try and get the brown off! 
 

Incidentally, I did clean these at around 50 degree (Celsius) - hope that wasn’t hot enough to displace anything! I’ll get these under a proper microscope today and get some better photos!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

The shellac still looks intact ws.  I dont think you have a problem. What was your cleaning solution ws ?

whew, great to know!

I used a liquid called Shellite (or Recosol R55). It's basically naphta; we're fairly limited to what we can get here in Australia, and everything is super expensive to import!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Watchscience said:

whew, great to know!

I used a liquid called Shellite (or Recosol R55). It's basically naphta; we're fairly limited to what we can get here in Australia, and everything is super expensive to import!

I've not heard of that but sounds like its designed to protect the shellac. I noticed you mentioned cleaning at 50 degrees. Please be careful with naptha around this temperature regarding its flashpoint. Im assuming it was in a glass jar in the sonic bath.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

I've not heard of that but sounds like its designed to protect the shellac. I noticed you mentioned cleaning at 50 degrees. Please be careful with naptha around this temperature regarding its flashpoint. Im assuming it was in a glass jar in the sonic bath.

Yes correct - ultrasonic cleaner in a glass jar.. thankfully nothing went wrong, but i think in future i'll change this to 40 degrees instead. no need to go so hot..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Watchscience said:

Yes correct - ultrasonic cleaner in a glass jar.. thankfully nothing went wrong, but i think in future i'll change this to 40 degrees instead. no need to go so hot..

I think the reduction in temp will have little effect on the cleaning as its mostly the vibrations that get the cleaning done. And much safer 👍. Im curious as to how clean you are getting the parts with this product you are using. I do use naptha but not one specified for cleaning watch parts. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

I think the reduction in temp will have little effect on the cleaning as its mostly the vibrations that get the cleaning done. And much safer 👍. Im curious as to how clean you are getting the parts with this product you are using. I do use naptha but not one specified for cleaning watch parts. 

To be honest, this is the first time i've ever cleaned any watch parts. Not only that, the parts came from a brand new movement which was pretty clean to begin with!

Once I finish putting this one together i'll do my first real full service project with an old trench watch which is super dirty and not working.

I'll pop some photos and my thoughts on the results and let you know!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Watchscience said:

To be honest, this is the first time i've ever cleaned any watch parts. Not only that, the parts came from a brand new movement which was pretty clean to begin with!

Once I finish putting this one together i'll do my first real full service project with an old trench watch which is super dirty and not working.

I'll pop some photos and my thoughts on the results and let you know!

That will be a completely different experience ws. We look forward to hearing about and helping you with that one. There are some very knowledgable  pros here that I'm sure will give you their time with that one.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, Watchscience said:

i'll be honest ..... the whole process so far has been just as hard as i thought it would be! 😛

i suspect (and thoroughly hope) that it gets easier with practice.

Nevertheless, i've loved the experience so far!

Good attitude to have mate. A lot of folk underestimate right from the beginning what is involved and then get sorely disappointed and eventually give it up as a bad job. Some you tube vids dont help either as they make it look far too easy. Some days will be great others you will be tearing your hair out over. This just doesn't  apply to beginners either, guys that have been doing it for years still have problems. Take the rough with the smooth, the good with the bad. Enjoy the challenges rather than fear them and just work through them as you would anything in life. A calm logical approach is your best friend, if frustration starts to ensue be sure you know when you need a cuppa break or else it can end up a watch break. But most of all enjoy this fascinating rewarding hobby whatever each encounter brings. Good to have you here my mate 👍

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I have read some suggestions that it can cause wear , particularly on the fork horns of a fully treated pallet fork. I've had half a kilo of steriac acid powder on a shelf for almost a year now, might have a little play today with a heater and a jar.  I think its because it gets into their cleaning solutions Mike. Theirs or anyone else's that services the watch next time, or if they need to strip back and rebuild. Could preclean but thats all time for a pro. I thought the idea was for the epilame to create a barrier, a wall between the lubrication and anything else, so the lube cant spread.
    • As I'm only cleaning watches in small numbers at home, I pre-clean any significant deposits of old grease and oil before using the cleaning solutions. I scrape off deposits with pegwood and Rodico, and if really dirty, wash parts in naphtha with a brush.  So I'm happy using DX, but can understand why it's avoided by the pros.
    • I think attaching a nut to the lid to pull it off is the least destructive, any damage damage on the outside is going to an easier fix than any created when trying to push it out from the inside. Scratching up the inside of the lid , mainspring or arbor bearing will be risk. Just my opinion.
    • yes the things we read in the universe I did see some where it was either difficult to clean off or it contaminated the cleaning fluid there was some issue with cleaning. I was trying to remember something about grease where as opposed to a substance of a specific consistency they were suggesting it had a base oil with something to thicken it. That conceivably could indicate that the two could separate and that would be an issue. But there is something else going on here that I had remembered so I have a link below and the description of the 9501 notice the word that I highlighted? Notice that word appears quite a bit on this particular page like 9415 has that property all so they 8200 mainspring grease and that definitely has to be mixed up when you go to use it because it definitely separates. just in case you didn't remember that nifty word there is a Wikipedia entry. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thixotropy   https://www.moebius-lubricants.ch/en/products/greases I wonder if what you're seeing is the boron nitride left behind after cleaning. In other words it's the high-pressure part of the grease and it's probably embedding itself into the metal which is why it doesn't clean off and shouldn't be a problem?
    • Yes and no. I use Moebius 9501 synthetic grease and it is significantly runnier than the Moebius 9504 synthetic grease (and I assume Molykote DX) that I previously used. I haven't seen 9504 spread and it is in my opinion the best grease money can buy. However, my current method of cleaning doesn't remove it from the parts, so that's why I have decided to use the 9501 instead. I believe I read somewhere that Molykote DX too is difficult to clean off. Thinking about it, I'm pretty sure my 9501 grease which expired in June 2022 is runnier now than it was when it was new, but whether new or old it always needs to be stirred before use. So, that's why I treat the parts of the keyless works, cannon pinion, etc. with epilame. That was very thoughtful of you and something that had completely passed me by. Not sure what the epilame will do when it wears off in a non-oiled hole. Anyone?
×
×
  • Create New...