Jump to content

Issue with Bulova 23


Recommended Posts

Hello all,

was working on servicing this Bulova 23 I got at a pawn shop.  It was running before, but stopping.  I stripped it all down and cleaned it.  I was putting it back together and oiling it today and I finally got the balance back it and this is what it is doing.  I have checked the banking manually and it looks ok so I am guessing the balance is the issue?  Any help is appreciated.

https://photos.app.goo.gl/CS44qkVSn1YwgFmt8

it is like the balance banks everything correctly and then stops

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It looks like something is rubbing or scraping. The above suggestions seem likely.

For these watches, it is common for the hairspring to rub against the arms of the balance wheel or against the underside of the balance cock.

You might confirm that the wheel isn't rubbing against the pallet bridge or the center wheel.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Observe the coil from side view of the balance while running, a close up video of balance looking streight down on the bridge and side view showing the coil helps.

Coil should be flat, level with concentric circles and not foul itself.

Judging from the previous video, amplitude seems good which is a sign of hairspring free from rubbing, however you give the balance plenty of swing when you nudge it,  instead gently move the wheel see if it picks up and go at some point. (I think the balance is out of beat)

I always put just  the balance complete and bridge back( no other part)  on the mainplate for final adjustment leveling etc.  it will give you almost 330 access to the HS  around the balance wheel 

What happens if you turn a gear, third or center ? 

 

 

 

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'll second that it's a good practice to replace just the balance complete prior to assembly so you can get a good look at the hairspring.

After doing that, you can add the pallet fork and bridge to see how the fork and jewel interact.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks so much for all the suggestions, troubleshooting alone is super frustrating.  I did inspect the teeth on the escape wheel under magnification for a full rotation and didn't see anything out of the ordinary

 

Here are some more videos of it running.  Excuse the potato quality.  I was filming from my ipad through a magnifier.  Though it seems to have decided to start running since last night.  The only thing I did different since this was to give the balance complete a lighter fluid bath

Bulova 23 issue https://imgur.com/gallery/PN5Ocr7

 

Edited by Wdschell
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Solved I think...

I decided to give everything another look and low and behold the pallet fork stones basically fell out while I was inspecting it.

I decided to check them with just a little pressure and the moved.  Best to get a new fork or can these be glued back in?

IMG_20210302_142944__01.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, Wdschell said:

 Best to get a new fork or can these be glued back in?

Pallets are usually shelaced since it wont harm the base metal forks are forged out of, Marks shows how to make this tool to warm the fork on and shelac the pallet jewels, I use epoxy five on cheap pieces.

 Pallets adjustment is no easy task, nevertheless if you like to give it a try, there be plenty help and advice besides Marks lessons.

I couldn't find a link to relevent threads , some one may have more luck than I and find em.

 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Loose pallet jewels would do it. This is an uncommon fault, so it's worth reflecting on the cleaning procedures to see if something could have dissolved or softened the shellac. You might also check the roller jewel, which is also secured with shellac.

Replacing the jewels is not too hard, but replacing them to the proper depth is another matter. It's interesting and worth trying, but you might source a replacement pallet fork for now while you read up on it.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, WellAdjusted said:

Loose pallet jewels would do it. This is an uncommon fault, so it's worth reflecting on the cleaning procedures to see if something could have dissolved or softened the shellac. You might also check the roller jewel, which is also secured with shellac.

Replacing the jewels is not too hard, but replacing them to the proper depth is another matter. It's interesting and worth trying, but you might source a replacement pallet fork for now while you read up on it.

Dang I didn't think about the roller jewel dissolving too.  I used some generic jewelry cleaner on the fork.  I just lighter fluid on the balance complete.  I'll check it.  I am currently sourcing a 10bzac movement for the fork.  I think Dave's watch parts has one.  Waiting to hear back

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, Wdschell said:

pallet fork stones basically fell out while I was inspecting it.

It's extremely unusual that the pallet stones fallout I would definitely change your cleaning fluid. Sometimes they can be loose but usually there's visually still shellac on them

Then if you decide to put the stones back in they have to go in a specific location. The angle on each stone is slightly different so you have to put the right stone in the right slot. Then a course comes the fun of adjustment which is why we use shellac because it allows you to warm it up shellac softens the stones can be moved in and out as necessary.

Then you want to be careful when you using generic jewelry cleaners or other cleaning fluids because interesting things can happen that normally wouldn't happen if you're using proper fluids. Jewelry cleaners are not usually expecting all sorts of different metals and that can result in interesting undesirable consequences also.

7 hours ago, Wdschell said:

the impulse jewel is safe

.Roller jewel's especially on American pocket watches do tend to suffer more than the pallet stones. So in the case of a pocket watches it's always worthy to check the roller jewel to make sure it still  locked in place.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just wanted to update this thread again. 

It was indeed my fault for using the wrong cleaner to clean the pallet fork.

I got the new parts movement yesterday, installed the pallet fork and was having the same issue.  The escape wheel looked fine but since I had another I went ahead and swapped it in and voila, it is ticking away and I cant hear or see anything wrong with it now.  I inspected the old gear, but I just cant see anything wrong with it.  Even compared it to the one I swapped in. 

Looks great on the time grapher now.  Thanks for all of your help in this.  Mostly, I need to bounce ideas off of someone when troubleshooting and you guys were awesome for that.  I am sure I will be around again as I think my Seiko 6139 has a loose canon pinion ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • These types of hairsprings become weak with age and very fragile. Which I expect it is that giving you trouble, and that wheel is not the correct one, if it were not bent I don't think the movement would run as the teeth are not the correct height. The problem you have is price which depends on you. It can be repaired but is it worth it to you, because there is little value in the clock. A wheel can be made and hairspring replaced. Or hang on to it and keep looking on ebay which is your best bet for replacement parts or even a complete movement but it will be like finding a needle in a haystack. 
    • I did that also for a few movements - well, mainly in/around the train jewels. I made big efforts to epilame the mainplate WITHOUT getting Epilame into the Pallet fork jewels (where it's not supposed to be, right?). I made litte barriers with Rodico around that jewel and used drops from a syringe to apply on the rest.  However, I've now stopped doing this. For three reasons: 1. It's a hassle and consumes more of this liquid gold. 2. I didn't see the need when using HP1000/HP1300 lubricants and grease for most part. The two places where I'd use 9010 (i.e. escape wheel and balance) receive Epilame in specific places... or the cap-jewel-setting of the balance suspends the oil sufficiently be capillary action (see my "conflict" about using Epilame on the balance jewels).  3. Lastly, and here I really wonder about yours and others' experiences: I felt that applying Epliame to the train jewels left them looking hazy (borderline dirty) compared to the (painstakingly achieved) sparkly clean results of my cleaning process. I just can't help but think that the Epilame residuals would mix with the oil and cause more friction/wear. I don't know.    simple: it'll stay there. It won't move any further. That's exactly what is happening if you epilame a cap stone. You end up placing the 9010 right on top of the epilame and the oil will sit nicely on that spot.
    • There are some parts on Ebay for the seiko 6020A, it may just be a waiting game for someone to strip one down, NOS will be more scarce . K would strip your movement down to the module then start looking at other seiko movement to see if that coil is used, then seek out a seiko part dealer. Also Retrowatches youtube owner Mike may give you some advice try him on his site . He also hangs around amateur watchmaking groups.
    • I would agree, in order to work harden something you need to exceed it's yield strength when it moves from the elastic zone to the plastic zone and you get permanent deformation and work hardening which is fairly close to its failure point, relatively speaking and dependent on the material/alloy of course. In theory you can load something constantly within its elastic range and not suffer work hardening issues.
    • Probably easier to get a complete new movement - but CousinsUK list it as discontinued. Maybe someone on here knows a substitute movement ?
×
×
  • Create New...