Jump to content

Help with ETA movements please


Recommended Posts

Hello. I am trying to source a hair spring (does not need to be balance complete) for an ETA 2408. Could you please advise if the hairspring on an ETA 2390 is compatible, and for my own future reference, how do I find such information please? Kind regards, Deggsie

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The hairspring often are matched by what they call vibrations, so the first you should look so it vibrates/oscillates at the same frequency. Next you have to match the diameter of the spring with the diameter of the balance Wheel. If they are the samme then it might work.  next you look at the balance staff, If these are the same the chances for success has increased enourmously since the collar on the hairspring will sitt tight on the balance staff.
At RANFFT you can find the most except the diamater of the balance Wheel.
http://www.ranfft.de/cgi-bin/bidfun-db.cgi?10&ranfft&2&2uswk&ETA_2390

http://www.ranfft.de/cgi-bin/bidfun-db.cgi?10&ranfft&2&2uswk&ETA_2408

Edited by HSL
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you for your reply. It seems it will be taking quite a chance to buy the eta 2390 spring in the hope all the criteria match when I receive it. I think I will hold on an wait for the eta 2408 to come along on eBay. I might be lucky - no hurry. Thanks again, Deggsie


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Compatable , a HS out of eta2390 fits on 2408, streigtht away also the space to accomodate the guest is readily available in the new surroundings, the main problem remains, the new  HS and BW team should vibrate to the design beat together, For instance to 18000 beat/ hr. That is how many loud beats we or timegrapher hears per hour.   At this point you are dealing with the length of the HS. The longer the length the longer the period.. To get the beat you need for time keeping of the watch, the only alteration at our disposal is to shorten the HS preferably in increments to approach and not pass by the 18000 beat/ hr vibration. Shortened too much, you need another HS to start all over.

You can vibrate balance wheel- HS outside the movement on a tool specially made for this purpose or vibrate inside your movement.

If the new HS is already too short, it should go back on 2390. You have just lost a bit of the factory poising. 

Regards

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Deggsie said:

Thank you for your reply. It seems it will be taking quite a chance to buy the eta 2390 spring in the hope all the criteria match when I receive it. I think I will hold on an wait for the eta 2408 to come along on eBay. I might be lucky - no hurry. Thanks again, Deggsie 

If you decide to wait Otto Frei has sometimes good tips and trix in how to choose things and in this case they have written a couple lines about it on their page, Reading is Always a good past time.
http://www.ofrei.com/page820.html

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm guessing the part you're looking for is the incabloc and not the  KIF? The part number for Incabloc ETA balance wheel with flat hairspring is 721.

281384193_ScreenShot2019-03-27at11_28_47AM.png.76f15ca9aeda4c9797084ae2ea516d4c.png

When I put this part number into Bestfit, this is what I get for possible replacements:

2144765383_ScreenShot2019-03-27at11_40_09AM.png.38f5717163a825eb74746c26ff81040e.png

MATSYS says only difference between  2390 and 2408 is that Rolex/Tudor uses same balance assembly (2402) with KIF shock protection for its 21Jewel version.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello all. This forum never ceases to amaze me by the way people are so willing to help out. Thank you so much for all of your very useful replies. It certainly helps to know that the ETA2390 HS will be a ‘direct’ donor part into the ETA2408. whilst I appreciate what NuceJoe is explaining about needing to set the length to establish the correct vibration period, it seems in this case that the HS will not require further adjustment? Is that correct?

And to clarify, yes the BW has Inca shock system. [emoji846]

Many thanks again!!

Kind regards, Deggsie


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Deggsie said:

. whilst I appreciate what NuceJoe is explaining about needing to set the length to establish the correct vibration period, it seems in this case that the HS will not require further adjustment? Is that correct?

And to clarify, yes the BW has Inca shock system. emoji846.png

Many thanks again!!

Kind regards, Deggsie
 

I don't think you'll need to adjust the hairspring.

J

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I'm going for an AS movement - the general layout, screw/jewel positions are similar.  
    • I haven't yet but I will take it out tonight! Thank you. Will post pics of dial side tonight too.
    • Did you have a look under the ballance? Often the movement maker/number is hidden there.
    • I wonder if 9415 is based on a base oil of 941? it's interesting what questions bring and the tech sheet answers it's the viscosity of the base oil. Then the impact? There is something we're missing here for that which would have a big influence on all of the house image above is 9514 image below is 941.then always interesting when specifications do not exactly agree? They ledge above for 941 indicates 110 viscosity but the image off the spec sheet is slightly less but I guess close enough   my understanding of the concern of too much 9415 is as we know the loss of amplitude. But why do we have a loss of amplitude? So impact it's basically oil should be very slippery. But what about non-impact? Like the edges of the escape wheel? Another thing that comes to play here is the shape of the escape wheel itself. Notice on the last a more vintage escape wheel with just a flat surface whereas the modern escape wheels usually made out of steel versus grass much much thinner their contact areas greatly been reduced and sometimes I think there even slightly curved. So is it conceivable at everything that isn't a flat surface on impact is going to be sticky? So this is where the shape of the escape wheel will have a big impact literally on how slippery things are. Oh and for all of you obsessed with worrying about too much 9415 I never worry about it because typically I'm doing pocket watches and it doesn't seem to be an issue at all. on the other hand I'm much more concerned about a watch that keeps time for 24 hours as opposed to the concern of the group of keeping amplitude for 24 hours. Then yes some pocket watches have steel escape wheels and do look like the escape wheel on the right.   
    • your balance wheel looks interesting in the watch and because it's at an angle it's changing things a little bit. in other words they hairspring is not centered between the regulator pin in the boot and I also noticed your terminal curve is lacking apparently by design? Because if you look in the second image you'll notice yes there's a terminal curve but not as aggressive a one as you normally see on watches at least most watches.   then in all of your images it looks like the boot isn't quite back where it's supposed to be? out of curiosity how did you remove your balance complete and clear the regulator pin? then just in case you weren't aware it rotates out of the way so you can remove the balance complete without bending the pin. Then it's rotated back exactly 90° and yours looks like it's off by just a little bit in the original image and I'm assuming that you just been the pin out of the way? it's always interesting in horology is the variations in the things. Like the image I have above does have a terminal curve but not the most aggressive and yours is even less but that is the way the watch was made. Then the spacing between the regulator pin in the boot should be relatively small basically if you had two pieces of the thickness of your hairspring that's how much space should be there like in this image. But oftentimes watch manufacturers do not necessarily follow the rules  
×
×
  • Create New...