Jump to content

Lost Click !


Recommended Posts

....onto the question about the pinion ... these are pictures which as I say above suggests its a taper pin/arbor arrangement to my novice eye? is there a tutorial/lesson anywhere on removal and refitting?

IMG_0356.thumb.jpg.b923af4dff524f812527c5001a60f8f6.jpg

IMG_0357.thumb.jpg.ee0a0edd021400b22f4ab09db616b2b2.jpg

Also this is a photo of the banking pins ... the one on the right is noticeably splayed?!! is this correct .... and if not how can it have happened?

IMG_0354.thumb.jpg.94e9319a9438d19a58a0a90251a40336.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

45 minutes ago, watchweasol said:

Putting on my Deerstalker (sherlock Homes) I would bet it pinged on to your sleeve or chest and as you went for a coffee it fell off onto thr surface and repained there till you found it.   case closed 

Good work dear Homes. Elementary, when you have eliminated  the impossible, whatever remains however improbable must then be possible as you often tell me. Ahem. Also a monster magnet and a million candle lume flashlight is very handy. I now need a the light thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, watchweasol said:

The banking pins have been bent to overcome a problem the previous repairer had do not straighten them up just leave as is untill the watch is running  then see how it goes, straigtening them now may give you problems later.

Would that fix have been made to solve more than one  issue ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, watchweasol said:

Possible ,but it is guessing why it was done. Thats why its best to service the watch and check out the results. If it operates within its parmeters leave it alone if not investigate.

I was silly enough to almost start thinking it was the constant  tap of the pallet fork that bent them. But then decided that was impossible .

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, watchweasol said:

I was wondering if there is any detrimental effect to the watch having an out of beat balance. I've only ever got zero.zero once. Effecting time  is not that much of an issue, if a watch is as much 30 seconds out that's only 3.5 minutes a week, not many peoples schedule is that tight. And a once a week adjustment is no great shake. And a lot I assume will forget to wind their watch at least once a week anyway so there will be some time setting going on during that week. Would big errors cause an abnormal  wear on the balance pivot possibly 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/13/2022 at 7:27 PM, LeCorbusier said:

....onto the question about the pinion ... these are pictures which as I say above suggests its a taper pin/arbor arrangement to my novice eye? is there a tutorial/lesson anywhere on removal and refitting?

IMG_0356.thumb.jpg.b923af4dff524f812527c5001a60f8f6.jpg

IMG_0357.thumb.jpg.ee0a0edd021400b22f4ab09db616b2b2.jpg

Also this is a photo of the banking pins ... the one on the right is noticeably splayed?!! is this correct .... and if not how can it have happened?

IMG_0354.thumb.jpg.94e9319a9438d19a58a0a90251a40336.jpg

Am I right that this is a pin and arbor arrangement?

What is the process for refitting once disassembled bearing in mind that I do not yet have a staking set.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, watchweasol said:

As the lift angle is calculated from the balance swing it may have a direct inpact the site below explains the lift angle

https://r.search.yahoo.com/_ylt=AwrIS.WuUVhi5ycAIQJ3Bwx.;_ylu=Y29sbwMEcG9zAzIEdnRpZAMEc2VjA3Ny/RV=2/RE=1649984047/RO=10/RU=https%3a%2f%2fwahawatches.com%2fwatch-talk-whats-the

16 hours ago, watchweasol said:

Hi  An out of beat watch,  depends on the error too far out and the watch will stop the further away from 0 will eventually affect the rate. Thats why when regulating a watch get the beat as near perfect as possinle then start the regultion.

The closer the beat the easier the watch starts from a standstill. Some I have need a gentle rotation to get them moving and stop too soon before the power has drained

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, LeCorbusier said:

Am I right that this is a pin and arbor arrangement?

What is the process for refitting once disassembled bearing in mind that I do not yet have a staking set.

 

16 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

I was silly enough to almost start thinking it was the constant  tap of the pallet fork that bent them. But then decided that was impossible .

Would bending the banking pins because Heath Robinson way of freeing up a locked impulse jewel ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The bankings pretty certainly didn't leave the factory like that. The escapement would need to be checked to find out why the entry banking is so bent. A guess from afar: the exit stone has been replaced with a stone too long or moved out for some reason, which means the escapement wouldn't fully escape from the exit side as the fork was against the banking on the entry side. Moving the entry banking pin will allow it to escape, but now in addition to the extra lock on the exit side from the jewel being out too far, there is additional drop and total lock on the entry side. The watch probably runs, but amplitude will suffer very much.

 

I've been trying to find a clear description of the steps to checking and adjusting the lever escapement to share, but so far it's been old confusing texts or nothing. It's not that hard to understand or carry out the adjustments, but without a clear description very daunting. I actually know trained watchmakers from good schools who don't really understand it, so it's not just new/hobby folks who are in the dark. If I have time one of these days maybe I'll put something together. In the repair work I do I probably retouch the escapement on a third of the watches I see- it's an important thing to check and correct.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, nickelsilver said:

I've been trying to find a clear description of the steps to checking and adjusting the lever escapement to share, but so far it's been old confusing texts or nothing. It's not that hard to understand or carry out the adjustments, but without a clear description very daunting. I actually know trained watchmakers from good schools who don't really understand it, so it's not just new/hobby folks who are in the dark. If I have time one of these days maybe I'll put something together.

That would be extremely much appreciated! I'd even be willing to pay for it! Folks, please support this idea by liking @nickelsilver's post above!

Edited by VWatchie
Link to comment
Share on other sites

no one appears to have noticed my question about the arbor pin arrangement which appears to be how the cannon Pinion is fitted?

I need to remove the centre wheel but only have experience of the standard cannon pinion arrangement.

I have found some threads describing knocking the pin through from the Pinion side releasing the wheel ... but no description so far on how to reassemble? Is the pinion simply pressed back down onto the arbor with tweezers, or is the process more involved?

Thanks for any input. 👍

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, LeCorbusier said:

no one appears to have noticed my question about the arbor pin arrangement which appears to be how the cannon Pinion is fitted?

I need to remove the centre wheel but only have experience of the standard cannon pinion arrangement.

I have found some threads describing knocking the pin through from the Pinion side releasing the wheel ... but no description so far on how to reassemble? Is the pinion simply pressed back down onto the arbor with tweezers, or is the process more involved?

Thanks for any input. 👍

Yes, knock it out. If the center wheel is jeweled at the bridge you want the bridge off, and support the center wheel in a hole in a bench block, or better, a staking tool when knocking out the pin. If not jeweled you can leave the bridge on, but still support it on a block with a hole to pass the pin. The pin will go down as far as the top of the cannon pinion, which should be plenty to pull off the CP and the pin out the rest of the way from the center wheel.

 

Going back, push in the pin, (this is with bridge on), support the large end of the pin on a block, and press down the cannon pinion. You may need to press quite hard, or use a staking tool with flat faced punch with hole to pass the pin to get the CP seated all the way.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/15/2022 at 11:42 AM, nickelsilver said:

The bankings pretty certainly didn't leave the factory like that. The escapement would need to be checked to find out why the entry banking is so bent. A guess from afar: the exit stone has been replaced with a stone too long or moved out for some reason, which means the escapement wouldn't fully escape from the exit side as the fork was against the banking on the entry side. Moving the entry banking pin will allow it to escape, but now in addition to the extra lock on the exit side from the jewel being out too far, there is additional drop and total lock on the entry side. The watch probably runs, but amplitude will suffer very much.

 

I've been trying to find a clear description of the steps to checking and adjusting the lever escapement to share, but so far it's been old confusing texts or nothing. It's not that hard to understand or carry out the adjustments, but without a clear description very daunting. I actually know trained watchmakers from good schools who don't really understand it, so it's not just new/hobby folks who are in the dark. If I have time one of these days maybe I'll put something together. In the repair work I do I probably retouch the escapement on a third of the watches I see- it's an important thing to check and correct.

I've seen Mark do the resetting of pallet jewels, it looks a very fiddly guessing game. I assume a lot of practise is needed

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

I've seen Mark do the resetting of pallet jewels, it looks a very fiddly guessing game. I assume a lot of practise is needed

If done correctly there's no guessing at all- that's the thing, haha. But like I said, even trained (Swiss) watchmakers I've known approach it as a guessing game. Not all, but still surprising.

Link to comment
Share on other sites




  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • To me this is a simple solution but not just for UK. I know a lot of us are not into facebook groups. But Mark has one, so does Mike Bolton of my retro watches, so does Kalle Slapp. They cost nothing to run, my daughter runs a few dog groups with thousands of members. And it does not have to be actively used, just because you are not interested in facebook ( i wasn't for a very long time ) that doesn't mean you have to participate on it or read anything posted , that is anyone's choice to do so, you give or take what you want from it. Seems the ideal meet place to me, join it , make one or two posts just to say " I'm here " then set it aside for a rainy day. If or when that day comes then discussions can take place as what to do next.
    • Hi Bob, Welcome to the forum and thank you for your service.  I would never try to discourage you from getting into this wonderful hobby/profession, but please be aware, it does not cost just a few dollars to get into watch repair.  Tools are expensive and in many instances the cheap knockoffs are worthless, especially when learning.  You can get the tools needed to disassemble, clean, inspect, reassemble and lubricate a watch without spending thousands, but as soon as you start getting into task-specific tools, there are so many and they don’t come cheap.  My suggestion is to start with the basics required to disassemble, clean, inspect, reassemble and lubricate only, and build upon that gradually as the need for other tools arises.  The advice above regarding starting out on working movements is gold. Many of the non-running watches on eBay have been bought, tinkered with, deemed too difficult and then sold again, often with more damage done each time.  Without experience, you clean and service a non-runner and it still doesn’t run. What now? Troubleshooting is difficult as a beginner. This can become very frustrating.  I would encourage you to buy a working movement, and learn to strip and service it. If it isn’t running afterwards, you know it’s down to you, and as long as you didn’t damage anything you know that the parts you’ve got can form a ticking watch. An excellent movement to start with is the ETA 6497 clones from China, such as the ST36. They’re not expensive, and although it finds use in some larger wristwatches, this movement was originally designed for use in pocket watches, so everything is larger and easier to see and handle.  Once you can service a new ST36 and have it running better than it did when it arrived, you’re definitely ready to step up to working vintage watches and then think about repair of non running or poorly running watches.  As far as cleaning solutions go, you will not do better than the commercial watch cleaning and rinsing solutions that are available. You’ll find plenty of suggestions for home brew cleaners online, but the professional products are superior and you want to give yourself every advantage you can, especially when you start working on vintage movements containing hardened decomposed lubricants and often years worth of other dirt and dust. Alcohol is ok for cleaning or rinsing movement parts that don’t contain any shellac. The pallet fork and roller table contain jewels secured with shellac and will tolerate a rinse in alcohol but not prolonged exposure. Methanol dissolves shellac faster than ethanol, and isopropyl alcohol dissolves shellac slower than ethanol. Just in case you don’t know already, the radium on the dial (and likely the hands) of your Dad’s Elgin is highly radioactive. It is safe enough when safely contained within the watch case, but the moment you open the watch and especially when handling the dial or hands you must take precautions against inhaling or ingesting any radium.  Best Regards, Mark
    • I have both sets and use the K&D 99% of the time.  Yes, you have to be careful with the pin.  I use a screwdriver to carefully release the pin from the spring.  Some skill is involved.   I have also modified/replaced the pins in the arbors as necessary.  Yeah, you would think a tool would not require modification, but such is the world of watchmaking.  There is no perfect tool.  Each watchmaker must the tools to his skill, or vice versa.
    • I have the 8-11mm K&D but it doesn't do a great job with modern mainsprings, or I have had terrible luck. The arbor pin protrudes too much and I have damaged more springs trying to disengage the arbor than I have successfully wound and inserted. It seems easier to use with old carbon steel springs. My Watchctaft set gets far more use, though I have to get creative to wind left hand springs
    • It depends on what the gaskets are made from but silicone lubricant should work.  Spray or rub on a generous amount, put in a sealed bag and wait a couple of days.  Test for softness and wipe off the excess.  
×
×
  • Create New...