Jump to content

What do you think of this.


oldhippy

Recommended Posts

The seller says its condition is refurbished. How do you refurbish something that is only about 20 years old.  It's a modern reproduction just look at the wheels and pinions, not one single blemish in the brass. All yours for an expensive over the top price of. Even the case is a repro.   

£1,100.00

https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/294336860334?hash=item4487d810ae:g:pkgAAOSwjG5hGPbB

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For those that aren't familiar of the movements here is an original it's somewhat incomplete proper anique movement. They are very much like the birdcage movements you find in a 30 hour Longcase  or a Lantern clock.  The main difference is the style of the cage and the position of the hammer.  

s-l1600.jpg

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Functionality, reproductions have the possibility to be far superior compared with an original article, due to improvements in materials and manufacturing over time, (some call this idea "a value add").  But... all to often, these unidentified replicas end up being nothing more than cheap crap worth less then the box they shipped in.  Reproductions, regardless of which way they go, can have their place, as long as they are priced fairly and both the buyer and seller understands what is being bought and sold.

Shane

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, oldhippy said:

For those that aren't familiar of the movements here is an original it's somewhat incomplete proper anique movement. They are very much like the birdcage movements you find in a 30 hour Longcase  or a Lantern clock.  The main difference is the style of the cage and the position of the hammer.  

s-l1600.jpg

O.H. - in the photo, is that a verge wheel I'm seeing?  Would this clock have a foliot instead of a pendulum? How old would this one be?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • @dibs1 Hopefully you see this and post an update. @Knebo Would you happen to know what is the end-shake tolerance for a cal 15xx rotor or is there such a metric? Also, is there a specified height of the rotor?   I got the watch serviced which addressed the rotor grinding against the base plate and case back (i have checked by moving the watch in a circular motion to spin the rotor and have tested it dial up and down) however whenever the watch is shaken lightly the rotor touches the caseback and makes a ding. What is unusual is that is only happens when the rotor is resting at the 9'o clock position. The axle was replaced and reading around it seems that  spring clip, jewel and axel are the three parts that individually or together are causing this issue.
    • Yes, barrel size.  A 11mm spring will push out into a 11mm barrel, no need to go 0.5mm smaller. 
    • Hello All, I’m looking for advice about how to interpret the mainspring specs described in the GR documents and in the catalogues of online sellers such as cousins.  My problem relates to interpreting the value describing barrel size - I’m unsure what the last number REALLY refers to.   For example: 1.10x.0105x360x11  (This refers to GR2628-X) Does the “ 11 “ here refer to the barrel inside diameter of the calibre OR to the diameter of the wound mainspring before insertion? For example if my measured barrel inside diameter to 11mm, I would normally select a wound spring size a little smaller, say 10.5, wouldn’t I?  Or, does the barrel diameter described in the catalogue specifications take that into account and I would therefore order a catalogue size 11 for an 11mm barrel ID? Hope this makes sense. I can’t find clarification of this anywhere. Many thanks for any enlightenment. Cheers, John
    • Let's say, like in a watch, you have  a 70 tooth 4th wheel, which needs to make a turn in one minute, with an 18,000 beat escapement. 15 tooth escape wheel as usual, and a 7 tooth pinion on it.   70 x 15 x 2 /  = 300  That's 300 beats, and there are 5 beats per second, so divide and you get 60s, one minute- all is well. If we do 70 x 15 x 2 / 8 that equals 262.5. With an 18K balance, which will let the escape wheel move one turn in 6 seconds, the 4th wheel will have made like 1.14 turns. So the time display is running fast. But this comes to like 7.5 seconds over per minute, which is about double your gain (maybe I'm wrong- I'm mathing on my phone while writing on my phone 😄) but pretty sure the gain is more than you are observing.   A possible culprit is that crown/4th wheel isn't running true, and a tooth is slipping past a pinion leaf once per revolution. I've seen this. If the platform is original and it's a nice piece they are often pinned, so the depthing isn't an issue. If the platform isn't pinned, check the depthing. And at any rate check the crown wheel between centeres and make sure the teeth are running true.
    • Fast responses - thank you. Yes, I mentioned the 18000bph to illustrate that it's not a matter of touching coils, over banking, shortened hairspring etc. I even took off the platform and temporarily fitted a another NOS one also with 8 leaves and beating 18000 but the colossal gain is the same. I'm resigned to buying and fitting a new Gorge platform plus a 7 leaf pinion escape wheel but only if I think it will work; otherwise it's a waste of £200 and a couple of hours work. Hence the underlying question is: all other things being equal, what would the timekeeping effect be? Is it a simple 7/8ths as fast? Logic tells me it is but can it be that linear?
×
×
  • Create New...