Jump to content

Vostok Komandirskie Stops at a Specific Second


Recommended Posts

I have a new-model Vostok Komandirskie that has been a great daily-wearer for about a year. The other day, though, I noticed that it had stopped. I had just wound it at the time, so this was quite unexpected. I gave it a light wap with my palm and it started up, but it has stopped a couple of times since after running for various amounts of time.

I notice that it always stops with the second hand in one position on the dial, which made me think that it could be something with the hands themselves, as I am unaware of anything in the movement that would lead to such a result. When I inspect the hands, however, they appear to be aligned and I can see no reason they would bind up. Also, the watch stops with the second hand in the same place even where the hour and minute hands are in completely different places. Any thoughts on what would cause this result and how to go about fixing it?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sounds like you got some lint or dust particle in your gear train.

Komandirskie would be a great watch to start learning watch repair with. It's built like a tank and would be an ideal watch for a novice.

Watch Mark's videos on how to service a mechanical watch. He even has one on the Komandirskie.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks, everyone. I appreciate y'all confirming that the problem likely lies somewhere in the gear train. @HectorLooi, can you tell me where I can find Mark's videos? I'm afraid I don't know who that is, but I'd love to dig into some resources and take a crack at this. And you're right, @JohnC, the Vostok is a great watch to get started with, since I don't have to be afraid of breaking the bank if I mess it up by getting in over my head!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

     " ‌A new-model"   So has the back ever been removed?  thats when dirts can fall inside the watch. Otherwise hand rubbing on crystal or the other hand is very likely. 

A test for diagnosis would be to remove the seconds hand and wear it for couple of week. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, smithincalifornia said:

. @Nucejoe, . I tried removing the second hand, but the watch just stopped again a couple hours later. 

This eliminates the No one suspect " seconds hand"      that is;  "no rubbing of seconds hand on other parts" 

Dose your watch have a date complication?  in which case the issue manifests every 24hrs when the date disk is suppose to jump. 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I would cut my losses, keep it for parts. Buying a balance complete would be a Sunk cost fallacy. 
    • I recall a video on YT from Steffen Pahlow where he talks about getting himself a Chronometre (for which he paid more than he would have liked), but in his words "I had to. It is a Chronometre." I am wondering if you have more watch there than what you are aware of? Especially with what @Neverenoughwatches mentioned about two springs.
    • If you are having counter tops ( i think thats the amercan term ) and some cupboards underneath where you dont require working legroom then that corner doesn't have to be a difficult access void. Lazy susans , we ( kitchen fitters ) call them cabinet carousels or you could just have two adjacent doors with a corner post fixed to one of them, though it does make for a long reach to get to the very corner. But a carousel is a good access solution, also there are sliding steel baskets available but these are bloody expensive and typically problematic, i really think they are a crap idea. What i like about fully fitted worktops, very tidy looking, no loss of space, and sidewards pinged parts are hopefully going to stay worktop side and not end up crunched on the floor.
    • Aren't corners of rooms a bugger though as it is really difficult to use the space underneath the intersection of the two benchtops. Lazy Susans are an idea I suppose. Somewhere to be able to put tools/soldering iron/testing machines that aren't needed on the bench top all the time. It is a bit tight in there, but at least I won't have to move great distances to get to another area. I need to get hold of another chair to have at the cleaning bench. I'll stand all the time at the lathe and I already have the stool for the workbench. Need to get the power sorted now and move the LED lights for over the workbench. There are four downlight in the ceiling that are currently halogen bulbs. Really quite bright so that's good. Ceiling fan as well. What else could one hope for?
    • So all that glitters is not gold when it comes to buying from ebay ( in fact very very rarely) i bought this as554 a few months ago. It was it's dial that attracted me to the joblot, which turned out to be printed on a postcard, that was the first red flag. During disassembly many faults were discovered as listed above,  but i was prepared to soldier on and see what i could achieve. I managed to make a setting lever for it which was a great learning experience and also correctly shape and de rust the hairspring.  Turning my attention to the balance assembly i have hit a road block. The staff broke when removing the roller but that wasn't so much of an issue as it was quite deformed anyway.  I also had several AS554 staffs that I could replace it with, problem is they dont measure up the same. I thought i had identified the movement correctly but what i think has happened is some heavy modification has taken place to make an incorrect staff fit. A nos staff is a slack fit on the balance wheel, the roller and the collet. The balance wheel has also been filed to within an inch of its life. I'm starting to doubt my identification of the movement either that or someone has converted the movement into a pure nugget of trash. Bit disappointed as i managed to get the train to spin lovely and put a good few hours into the setting lever. A balance complete might be the only option if one is available but you know when you are just wasting money. My thoughts are to make and modify something else to fit and work if that is possible, any ideas anyone ? 
×
×
  • Create New...