Jump to content

My First Staking Set Advice


Recommended Posts

2 minutes ago, Waggy said:

I got a Chinese set for about $100 and have used it a few times and very happy - so if you don't get the one on eBay this may be an option for you - check out thread Quality Chinese Tools on this forum

When it comes to tools, especially with this so far i'm finding there's certain things that cheaping out on ends up costing me more. Best i can tell a staking set to a watchmaker is like like a drill press to a fine woodworker. It does a million things and it needs to do them well so i'm thinking i should just go for it with a decent one but yeah i'm on a limited budget. 

I'm probably not gonna go to watchmaking school for over a year so i got a lot of time to keep scouring the bay for deals. This seemed like a great find so i jumped on it. If i don't get it that sucks but i'll keep lookin.

 

 

3 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Haha. As far as i know the Boley is a good make but maybe not the best. If i was serious about a career in watch repair i would want the best i could get and in a complete condition.  Plenty here that can advice you much better than i can what to buy . Earlier this week i could kick myself for holding back on price with a very complete production lathe. It went for 50 more than my top bid yet i originally planned to go higher than it sold for 😢.  For starters the staking set will replace you a broken balance staff which is a common issue. I dont think there is anything else that can install one. 

Interesting. I was seeing posts here listing them alongside bergeon as some of the better ones. I assume the stakes can be bought separately. This seems to be an almost complete set i imagine i can just add whatever is missing in the coming years as i need it.

 

 

1 minute ago, Waggy said:

Used my set for closing up the hole in the barrel bridge where there is too much play in the barrel arbor/bridge. Worked a treat and really improved amplitude. Chronoglide have an excellent video tutorial (look up 'hammertime' on their youtube channel) on the best way to do this with your staking set.

Yeah i've seen that. Love chronoglide's channel. I wonder if i could drive out brass posts from seiko bridges and replace them with less beat up ones with one. THey look like they're just friction fit.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, Birbdad said:

was seeing posts here listing them alongside bergeon as some of the better ones. I assume the stakes can be bought separately

Marshall and K and D are also highly rated. If like me you will probably buy another and then another and end up with 2 or 3 different makes 😀. But as far as this one goes , i would be watching it if it were for sale in theUK. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Marshall and K and D are also highly rated. If like me you will probably buy another and then another and end up with 2 or 3 different makes 😀. But as far as this one goes , i would be watching it if it were for sale in theUK. 

The seller in the notes said something about how they hate the UK and everybody in it and your beer and curry is bland and flavorless so uh....yeah don't look for it and definitely don't bid on it 😇
that said there's a marshall set on there as well for 145 with the wooden box but it's missing well over half of the stakes.

Also i saw talk elsewhere about how these boley sets can function as a jeweling tool with an option add on.  That is very interesting if true...

Edited by Birbdad
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Birbdad said:

The seller in the notes said something about how they hate the UK and everybody in it and your beer and curry is bland and flavorless so uh....yeah don't look for it and definitely don't bid on it 😇
that said there's a marshall set on there as well for 145 with the wooden box but it's missing well over half of the stakes.

Also i saw talk elsewhere about how these boley sets can function as a jeweling tool with an option add on.  That is very interesting if true...

Haha fortunately i don't drink beer and can cook an amazing curry, I'm also happy with my Star set for the time being so dont panic lol. I dont think i would get the Marshall set if its your first. Thats going to hold you up on projects while you search to complete it. A lot more expensive doing it that way as well. Stripping down a set is where sellers make more money. Like the lathe i missed out on. Separately the lathe and accessories would  double its total value. I've seen a few dual purpose staking/jewelling tools, i would probably buy one though ( me  being a tool geek ) i always think each seperate tool has its own purpose. Something designed to do two jobs is going to do twice the amount of work. And can it do the job as well as something specifically designed for its purpose ? Like a washer/dryer, if one side of its function breaks then how will that affect the other side of its function?.   I hope you get it at a good price Col, it usually comes down to luck ,how many want it and how much money they want to part with. If you are up against half a dozen Yorkshire men then you are laughing mate 🙂

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Haha fortunately i don't drink beer and can cook an amazing curry, I'm also happy with my Star set for the time being so dont panic lol. I dont think i would get the Marshall set if its your first. Thats going to hold you up on projects while you search to complete it. A lot more expensive doing it that way as well. Stripping down a set is where sellers make more money. Like the lathe i missed out on. Separately the lathe and accessories would  double its total value. I've seen a few dual purpose staking/jewelling tools, i would probably buy one though ( me  being a tool geek ) i always think each seperate tool has its own purpose. Something designed to do two jobs is going to do twice the amount of work. And can it do the job as well as something specifically designed for its purpose ? Like a washer/dryer, if one side of its function breaks then how will that affect the other side of its function?.   I hope you get it at a good price Col, it usually comes down to luck ,how many want it and how much money they want to part with. If you are up against half a dozen Yorkshire men then you are laughing mate 🙂

Great now I want curry.

But yeah, i hope i get it assuming it is a good one. are stakes for these things sortof a standardized thing? LIke can i buy another brand of stakes and it will fit this one? I think you said you hav ea few, are all the stakes interchangeable? I saw a few posts pointing out some other models did not use the same stakes as others but they looked to be REAL old and maybe more for clocks or something. 

Here's a pic of the marshall
image.thumb.png.1138449830c809e12bc134f14dd2de1f.png

Edited by Birbdad
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, Birbdad said:

Great now I want curry.

But yeah, i hope i get it assuming it is a good one. are stakes for these things sortof a standardized thing? LIke can i buy another brand of stakes and it will fit this one? I think you said you hav ea few, are all the stakes interchangeable? I saw a few posts pointing out some other models did not use the same stakes as others but they looked to be REAL old and maybe more for clocks or something. 

Here's a pic of the marshall
image.thumb.png.1138449830c809e12bc134f14dd2de1f.png

I know there is some interchangability on different brands, i dont know which though. Mine has 4.7mm stakes which is a pretty standard. But a couple of hundredths of a mm might make a difference, which is why i think a complete original set as possible is the way to go. You could ask to see the centering stake, its the most used to accurately line up the base holes with the punch holder. Mine was quite worn so it makes it a little awkward when using the small holes in the base.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

I know there is some interchangability on different brands, i dont know which though. Mine has 4.7mm stakes which is a pretty standard. But a couple of hundredths of a mm might make a difference, which is why i think a complete original set as possible is the way to go. You could ask to see the centering stake, its the most used to accurately line up the base holes with the punch holder. Mine was quite worn so it makes it a little awkward when using the small holes in the base.

I get the feeling the seller doesn't know much about this stuff. It's the wife of a deceased watchmaker.....man are there a lot of those 😞

It does say that some of the stakes say Boley and some say K&D so it does look like there is some compatability. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Thats very possibly due to the combination of having a wife and an obsession with repairing watches. Choose one or the other to live longer.🙂

Long as i'm not screwing things up i find watch repair to be very zen. those 3 repairs and services inbetween my current and first project were an absolute joy hehe

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So i got outbid. There's now a K&D incomplete set in the same price range that allows offers. 

image.thumb.png.a06ad1a9b2d6a9ad1396b4916a1de9e2.png
image.thumb.png.814805ec17e0b2e40212ecf384157dc0.png

image.thumb.png.754f480cf492a0cbab47b19cd1164b96.png

Then there's also this OTHER k&d one that comes with an additional staking tool. Bidding is super low....
image.png.b5c7bd6cb89a28c72033f8747351686f.png

image.png.d348d5603ee600de887ad2fe02908c35.png

Wow there's a lot that got relisted recently or didnt' come up in my search. 
Another vintage K&D
image.png.c9d4996e1cf4d1394e46f5df59769180.png
image.png.03e39e8663477911ec5e0a3547071ef9.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, LittleWatchShop said:

I have two of these.  Not sure how best to use it...so I don't.

image.png.48f4b3779a8090600ad4b68bf87f2e48.png

I picked up a Marshall LIttle Giant over a year ago at a local vintage resale shop.  I was shocked to see it there. Got it for $60

image.thumb.png.ec582cb1bfdbfda9b7b4bbb9926c4ac8.png

Just keep trying on ebay...eventually, you will get a good one at a decent price.

My main issue is that i guess i'm n ot sure what's a good one. Are all staking sets more or less the same in function? I did see talk about some taking different sized stakes. I guess my main concern is ending up with a staking set that uses some obsolete vintage stake width or something. If somebody who knows more than me sees any of those ones i posted as being particularly good please let me know so i can bid. 

I see on yours now what people were talking about how you could reverse the stakes. That seems like a feature i would want.....  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, LittleWatchShop said:

Useful, but not critical. K&D calls this "inverto." Marshall, or K&D are superb brands.

Good to know. Sounds like any of the options i've posted would be fine for the right price i guess. placed a low bid on the double set. I too am curious what that second tool is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, SpringMangler said:

I have a K&D set and the new Bergeon stakes are compatible. 

Ok, that is good to know. Also for what it's worth the seller of the Boley set that many of the stakes were labeled K&D so i'm assuming that means both k&d and boley and bergeon are all taking the same size stakes. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
7 minutes ago, Birbdad said:

complete and went for almost 400

What I have found on ebay is that you must be persistent...constantly monitor and you can get lucky...day of week, time of day, coincident with some national news...distractions that give you the edge.  I have had some lucky buys...and some not so lucky ones too!!

Two of my sets are Marshall, I think...at least one of them is.  Everything is cross compatible in my sets.  You are gonna have some fun!!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, LittleWatchShop said:

What I have found on ebay is that you must be persistent...constantly monitor and you can get lucky...day of week, time of day, coincident with some national news...distractions that give you the edge.  I have had some lucky buys...and some not so lucky ones too!!

Two of my sets are Marshall, I think...at least one of them is.  Everything is cross compatible in my sets.  You are gonna have some fun!!

Yeah it's just in time too. For my current project the correct rotor on the movement is a bit loose and seiko has instructions on how to swap out the bearings with a staking set to tighten it up.

Edited by Birbdad
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yes, barrel size.  A 11mm spring will push out into a 11mm barrel, no need to go 0.5mm smaller. 
    • Hello All, I’m looking for advice about how to interpret the mainspring specs described in the GR documents and in the catalogues of online sellers such as cousins.  My problem relates to interpreting the value describing barrel size - I’m unsure what the last number REALLY refers to.   For example: 1.10x.0105x360x11  (This refers to GR2628-X) Does the “ 11 “ here refer to the barrel inside diameter of the calibre OR to the diameter of the wound mainspring before insertion? For example if my measured barrel inside diameter to 11mm, I would normally select a wound spring size a little smaller, say 10.5, wouldn’t I?  Or, does the barrel diameter described in the catalogue specifications take that into account and I would therefore order a catalogue size 11 for an 11mm barrel ID? Hope this makes sense. I can’t find clarification of this anywhere. Many thanks for any enlightenment. Cheers, John
    • Let's say, like in a watch, you have  a 70 tooth 4th wheel, which needs to make a turn in one minute, with an 18,000 beat escapement. 15 tooth escape wheel as usual, and a 7 tooth pinion on it.   70 x 15 x 2 /  = 300  That's 300 beats, and there are 5 beats per second, so divide and you get 60s, one minute- all is well. If we do 70 x 15 x 2 / 8 that equals 262.5. With an 18K balance, which will let the escape wheel move one turn in 6 seconds, the 4th wheel will have made like 1.14 turns. So the time display is running fast. But this comes to like 7.5 seconds over per minute, which is about double your gain (maybe I'm wrong- I'm mathing on my phone while writing on my phone 😄) but pretty sure the gain is more than you are observing.   A possible culprit is that crown/4th wheel isn't running true, and a tooth is slipping past a pinion leaf once per revolution. I've seen this. If the platform is original and it's a nice piece they are often pinned, so the depthing isn't an issue. If the platform isn't pinned, check the depthing. And at any rate check the crown wheel between centeres and make sure the teeth are running true.
    • Fast responses - thank you. Yes, I mentioned the 18000bph to illustrate that it's not a matter of touching coils, over banking, shortened hairspring etc. I even took off the platform and temporarily fitted a another NOS one also with 8 leaves and beating 18000 but the colossal gain is the same. I'm resigned to buying and fitting a new Gorge platform plus a 7 leaf pinion escape wheel but only if I think it will work; otherwise it's a waste of £200 and a couple of hours work. Hence the underlying question is: all other things being equal, what would the timekeeping effect be? Is it a simple 7/8ths as fast? Logic tells me it is but can it be that linear?
    • Sorry to jump in here guys, but I've read through this whole thread and it seems there are a lot of people who think joining Facebook means everyone will have access to their lives. You could make a Facebook account with a fake name. You could even use your real name if you wanted to and set it to completely private so people can't even find you in a search and you don't have to add anyone as a 'friend', so you won't see anyone's posts. Literally use it to join a group full of members of this site. Admins could even set the group to private and require a password of some sort to gain acceptance into the group, so you can be sure that it's only members of this site that get in. @tomh207 is right, the form with email addresses and names is a bad idea. That will be abused by scrapers. Facebook is only as personal as you let it be. You can be completely anonymous on there if you wish. Don't think of it as Facebook. Just think of it as a watch repair group as that's all you'd use the account for. It doesn't even have to be set up with your current email address. Make a random one on Gmail or any other free provider just for the Facebook account. Tagged you by accident and now it won't let me remove it 😂 @Neverenoughwatches
×
×
  • Create New...