Jump to content

Cleaning/replacing/... a mainspring when still learning the ropes


Recommended Posts

Hi everyone,

 

I wondered what your suggestions would be for someone starting out in the hobby.
 

When you haven't got mainspring winders yet do you best:

  • Just leave it in the barrel and assemble everything after cleaning the rest
  • Take it out, measure it and buy a new one (don't know if that's feasible for older watches)
  • Take it out, measure it and get an appropriate mainspring winder
  • Something else....

Thanks for the advice!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could just buy a couple of the most common sizes. Best Chinese sets are allegedly good. Manual mainsprings are easy to wind by hand but automatic springs are trickier because of the bridle in the end. Buying new springs is also an option. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, LuigiMeister2800 said:

Hi everyone,

 

I wondered what your suggestions would be for someone starting out in the hobby.
 

When you haven't got mainspring winders yet do you best:

  • Just leave it in the barrel and assemble everything after cleaning the rest
  • Take it out, measure it and buy a new one (don't know if that's feasible for older watches)
  • Take it out, measure it and get an appropriate mainspring winder
  • Something else....

Thanks for the advice!

Watch the YouTube videos in how to hand wind.

It was 15 month before I obtained a set of winders. Only used them unsuccessfully since. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Maloccio has given the options, I still do it by hand, but if you are not sure just buy the winder to suit you purpose at the time. That way over time you will build a collection of the ones you use the most and. Not some ornaments which never get used.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, LuigiMeister2800 said:

Hi everyone,

 

I wondered what your suggestions would be for someone starting out in the hobby.
 

When you haven't got mainspring winders yet do you best:

  • Just leave it in the barrel and assemble everything after cleaning the rest
  • Take it out, measure it and buy a new one (don't know if that's feasible for older watches)
  • Take it out, measure it and get an appropriate mainspring winder
  • Something else....

Thanks for the advice!

All depends what you are working on. If the right mainspring is available and the money to buy one each time isn't an issue then a new one would be the best option. Downside is you dont get to aquire the skill of winding mainsprings. Which eventually if you work on a lot of old watches you will need.

28 minutes ago, watchweasol said:

I still do it by hand,

Yey old timer, my hero 👍

1 hour ago, LuigiMeister2800 said:

Hi everyone,

 

I wondered what your suggestions would be for someone starting out in the hobby.
 

When you haven't got mainspring winders yet do you best:

  • Just leave it in the barrel and assemble everything after cleaning the rest
  • Take it out, measure it and buy a new one (don't know if that's feasible for older watches)
  • Take it out, measure it and get an appropriate mainspring winder
  • Something else....

Thanks for the advice!

In my eyes leaving it in the barrel isn't an option, when I started i thought about it and i tried it. I soniced the barrel upside down in the hope it would clean it, it did but not to an acceptable level at all. No way are between the coils gonna get clean or all of the bottom of the barrel. You have to bite the bullet and just get stuck in, have it out and hand wind it back in if there's no option of a winder. Practice ,practice and practice and when you're done practicing......... you've guessed it , practice some more.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you should acquire some mainspring winders, you use/need them in the future, hand winding is a last resort for what ever reason, too much distortion especially from beginners, I think sometimes it is better to hand clean with arbor out and reassemble than hand wind, but I have winders so just my opinion.....new is a great option like Neverenough said...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • One way is to file it by hand. Good file with sharp edge is needed. Another way is with the aid of milling attachment. There is one more way, thyat is really only on the lathe, but the arbor has to be attached perpendicular to the axis of the spindle. Will be easier to show pictures than to explain this.
    • giving up so soon? then the feelings of frustrations is common for all of us. At work I've requested a cannon? To be technically correct I like to get a black powder cannon as I think I be quite enjoyable to fire some of the watch movements off into the distance never to be seen again unfortunately I don't think I'm going to get my request. So yes we all have frustrations like I have a frustration with this discussion I don't suppose before you run away you could give us the size of the movement and a photograph of the dial side with the keyless parts.  as I'm still rather curious about who made this watch.
    • It wasn't a rookie mistake Nev , i should have know better with me being a joiner. After a hole another a wider bit has nothing to keep it to center and the outside of the flutes draw the drill bit in fast because of no material present. I must have done it thousands of times in timber and plastic . It was a senior moment mistake. 😄
    • Don't give up. You just need patience and practice. Don't use force or try to screw down the plate before making sure everything is in place. My first few watches took me like 45 minutes to get the train wheels in. Now it usually takes me less than a minute. Make sure that all the bottom pivots are in their respective holes before putting on the top plate. Then apply gentle pressure with a pegwood or gloved finger. Start from the barrel, 2nd wheel, 3rd wheel.... and finally the escape wheel. You can feel the plate drop each time you get a pivot in. If you experience the pivots that you have already gotten in coming out of their holes when you work on other wheels down line, you can put 1 or 2 screws nearer the barrel side in but don't exert any force on the screws. Just lightly turn the screws until you feel pressure and backoff 1/4 turn. This will prevent the plates from separating.  I use a homemade tool with a brass wire, shaped like an oiler to lightly touch the wheels to guide them into place. I find that an oiler made of hardened steel can leave scratches on the brass wheels. Once you think you have gotten all the pivots in, test it by using a blower to blow on the escape wheel. It should spin freely. Continue applying pressure on the top plate with the pegwood or finger until you lightly tighten all the screws. Don't tighten fully yet until you reconfirm that the wheels are able to spin freely. And reconfirm again after you have fully tightened all the screws. What you are experiencing is normal. All of us have gone through it. Don't work on watches when you are tired or frustrated. All of us can tell you what that leads to. But I'm sure you'll experience a few hard lessons even after reading this advice. It's only human. Go forth and practice. Good luck!
    • by the way this is very confusing to me? You have a 7s26a and you're comparing it to a 7s26b which is confusing to me because they're not the same? Watch companies are rather amusing when it comes the part numbers seemingly watches with similar  numbers as you're implying should be exactly identical but in this case they are very very dramatically different for instance the 7s26a balance part number is 0310 020 the 7s26b has a different part number 0310 197 as the part numbers are entirely different there must be a reason it noticed that I made two terms in the quote above in bold regulator pins are versus the etachron  system. In addition to changing the regulation part more than likely they change the hairspring. So this would typically main you wouldn't build a swap balance completes from one type to the other because they will be entirely different. this is where looking at the technical guide might yield some amusing information. you'll note in the 7s26b  service guide it explains what the difference is. It makes a reference to the balance staff which is totally inconsequential for this discussion. But the really big difference is the A  version has conventional regulator pins and the B  has is the Etachron  system. In @Jon excellent images up above he didn't explain something? if you look carefully at the images below you'll notice that the outer terminal curve is different  as a guest to accommodate the etachron  system it looks like the terminal curve is farther out. So yes exactly as the parts list indicates the balance completes will look different because they are different. Because they are different there are not interchangeable. so basically because the letter changes at the end in this particular case we end up with two separate balance completes as proven by the parts numbers. Balance completes that are entirely different to accommodate the regulation system conceivably with entirely different characteristics of timing as they are entirely different. So your observation of the balances are different shape is correct they are different.      
×
×
  • Create New...