Jump to content

Do i buy this watch ?


Recommended Posts

Eyup watch peeps. I'm not particularly  asking for help or advice,  just airing  thoughts on my dilemma of whether to buy or not. I'm somewhat patriotic in the way i collect Smiths watches and have a fair few of them in different models in various stages of restored and mid restoration waiting for parts. A missing one to add to the collection is the Everest ( quite pricey depending on the condition and material ). But one has recently entered my radar and i just cant decide if i should buy it or not. The price is very very good for the model, working and the condition is good and completely original. Good except for the dial, the patination is lovely but some heavy spotting.  Its worse than anything I've encountered so not sure how i would even tackle it or should. Any thoughts , input are appreciated people.

Screenshot_20230531-202809_Vinted.jpg

Edited by Neverenoughwatches
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, LittleWatchShop said:

If it were my watch, I would prolly send the dial to have it refinished. It is ugly in the current condition IMHO. This, of course is a very personal decision...but you asked

I agree the dial is terrible which is the cause of my dilemma, but I'm all about originality with watches the exterior especially so refinishing is a non starter for me. The movement is important and has to work efficiently and is nearly always repairable but nobody sees that apart from me. But the case and dial everbody sees, the dial condition is the make or break of my purchase. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

If the price is good I would go for it, or you'll regret it, especially if it fills a hole in your collection. I would do a sympathetic restore and just use flitz or similar on the case and a new worn looking strap and re-lume with tinted (coffee??) lume. This way you'll keep the watches rustic charm and the dial won't stick out like a sore thumb. As for the dial I would only remove any dust/debris etc and wouldn't go any further than that as you may end up snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, Klassiker said:

I think I could get used to the dial.

I agree, they all look x1000 worse under high magnification, even the pristine ones. On your wrist without your reading glasses it will look awesome!

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Waggy said:

If the price is good I would go for it, or you'll regret it, especially if it fills a hole in your collection. I would do a sympathetic restore and just use flitz or similar on the case and a new worn looking strap and re-lume with tinted (coffee??) lume. This way you'll keep the watches rustic charm and the dial won't stick out like a sore thumb. As for the dial I would only remove any dust/debris etc and wouldn't go any further than that as you may end up snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.

In good condition around  £600  this is £200

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Neverenoughwatches  I have seen NOS or LN astral dials in my late watch repairer's estate. 

Educate me of specifications of the dial you want please,  I  may could surprise you with a brand new dial for cheap.

What caliber is under the hood, I'd look it up.

Joe

Edited by Nucejoe
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Eyup watch peeps. I'm not particularly  asking for help or advice,  just airing  thoughts on my dilemma of whether to buy or not. I'm somewhat patriotic in the way i collect Smiths watches and have a fair few of them in different models in various stages of restored and mid restoration waiting for parts. A missing one to add to the collection is the Everest ( quite pricey depending on the condition and material ). But one has recently entered my radar and i just cant decide if i should buy it or not. The price is very very good for the model, working and the condition is good and completely original. Good except for the dial, the patination is lovely but some heavy spotting.  Its worse than anything I've encountered so not sure how i would even tackle it or should. Any thoughts , input are appreciated people.

 

I'd be tempted. I'm a fan of Smiths too and I've been looking for an Everest for a while. What is the movement? I have a 19J Imperial Cal 0104 - lovely watch.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, RichardHarris123 said:

A redial is £100 to £150. Still a difficult question. 

A redial is something i couldn't live with. It would have to be an exact match and aged to be unnoticeable, a tall order for anyone.

1 hour ago, Nucejoe said:

@Neverenoughwatches  I have seen NOS or LN astral dials in my late watch repairer's estate. 

Educate me of specifications of the dial you want please,  I  may could surprise you with a brand new dial for cheap.

What caliber is under the hood, I'd look it up.

Joe

Thanks joe. The calibre is an 0104

47 minutes ago, mikepilk said:

I'd be tempted. I'm a fan of Smiths too and I've been looking for an Everest for a while. What is the movement? I have a 19J Imperial Cal 0104 - lovely watch.

The Imperial and Everest are almost identical apart from slight differences in dial markings and signature. Same calibre 0104 in fact the Everest automatic has Imperial signed on the rotor. I have actually just spotted a really good condition Imperial on Ebay for 250 or best offer. Basically the same watch except for the Everest signing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

39 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

The Imperial and Everest are almost identical apart from slight differences in dial markings and signature. Same calibre 0104 in fact the Everest automatic has Imperial signed on the rotor. I have actually just spotted a really good condition Imperial on Ebay for 250 or best offer. Basically the same watch except for the Everest signing.

That's what I thought. So it's just the name on the dial which makes the Everest so much more expensive (apart from the auto which are rare and expensive).

I read that the 19J movements are the best, which is why I bought the Imperial. Think I might wear it today 😃

1.thumb.jpg.bdd913d01fe0aa90da4b3c98e53e59fb.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 minutes ago, mikepilk said:

That's what I thought. So it's just the name on the dial which makes the Everest so much more expensive (apart from the auto which are rare and expensive).

I read that the 19J movements are the best, which is why I bought the Imperial. Think I might wear it today 😃

1.thumb.jpg.bdd913d01fe0aa90da4b3c98e53e59fb.jpg

That is in beautiful condition Mike. The prices are very similar for the same model. The autos and sub dial Everest are 3x and 4x as much. I must admit i prefer the Imperial the signing is much nicer with the added crown. I think my mind is made up now. 👍

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

That is in beautiful condition Mike. The prices are very similar for the same model. The autos and sub dial Everest are 3x and 4x as much. I must admit i prefer the Imperial the signing is much nicer with the added crown. I think my mind is made up now. 👍

Go for it 😀

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Thanks joe. The calibre is an 0104

 I presumed the caliber show me the feet positions, google shows various bridge layouts. WHAT DIAL FEET POSITIONS DO I LOOK FOR?

I am sure I have seen Smith watch dials in his estate.

Rgds

Edited by Nucejoe
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, Nucejoe said:

I presumed the caliber show me the feet positions, google shows various bridge layouts. WHAT DIAL FEET POSITIONS DO I LOOK FOR?

I am sure I have seen Smith watch dials in his esatate.

Rgds

I cant answer that Joe as the watch remains unpurchased. I appreciate your effort but take it no further please, I've just  looked at the watch again and the spring bar holes have worn completely through both lugs on one side. Cleverly hidden by an extra wide strap, i spotted something and asked the seller to confirm and post a close up. I very much appreciate the thought to source for me Joe.

Screenshot_20230601-122335_Vinted.jpg

Edited by Neverenoughwatches
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

I cant answer that Joe as the watch remains unpurchased. I appreciate your effort but take it no further please, I've just  looked at the watch again and the spring bar holes have worn completely through both lugs on one side. Cleverly hidden by an extra wide strap, i spotted something and asked the seller to confirm and post a close up. I very much appreciate the thought to source for me Joe.

Screenshot_20230601-122335_Vinted.jpg

OK matey , but

First chance I get , I take and send you picture of his Smith dials. 

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

31 minutes ago, mikepilk said:

If any say "Imperial" or "Everest" they are worth getting.

Its often we come across Astrals and the de-luxe that have a dial letting them down. In the range is also the National 15 and 17 there may also be a 19 i cant remember.  I remember reading something about the name National being used to promote sales in an economy slump in the 60s. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hi Bob, Welcome to the forum and thank you for your service.  I would never try to discourage you from getting into this wonderful hobby/profession, but please be aware, it does not cost just a few dollars to get into watch repair.  Tools are expensive and in many instances the cheap knockoffs are worthless, especially when learning.  You can get the tools needed to disassemble, clean, inspect, reassemble and lubricate a watch without spending thousands, but as soon as you start getting into task-specific tools, there are so many and they don’t come cheap.  My suggestion is to start with the basics required to disassemble, clean, inspect, reassemble and lubricate only, and build upon that gradually as the need for other tools arises.  The advice above regarding starting out on working movements is gold. Many of the non-running watches on eBay have been bought, tinkered with, deemed too difficult and then sold again, often with more damage done each time.  Without experience, you clean and service a non-runner and it still doesn’t run. What now? Troubleshooting is difficult as a beginner. This can become very frustrating.  I would encourage you to buy a working movement, and learn to strip and service it. If it isn’t running afterwards, you know it’s down to you, and as long as you didn’t damage anything you know that the parts you’ve got can form a ticking watch. An excellent movement to start with is the ETA 6497 clones from China, such as the ST36. They’re not expensive, and although it finds use in some larger wristwatches, this movement was originally designed for use in pocket watches, so everything is larger and easier to see and handle.  Once you can service a new ST36 and have it running better than it did when it arrived, you’re definitely ready to step up to working vintage watches and then think about repair of non running or poorly running watches.  As far as cleaning solutions go, you will not do better than the commercial watch cleaning and rinsing solutions that are available. You’ll find plenty of suggestions for home brew cleaners online, but the professional products are superior and you want to give yourself every advantage you can, especially when you start working on vintage movements containing hardened decomposed lubricants and often years worth of other dirt and dust. Alcohol is ok for cleaning or rinsing movement parts that don’t contain any shellac. The pallet fork and roller table contain jewels secured with shellac and will tolerate a rinse in alcohol but not prolonged exposure. Methanol dissolves shellac faster than ethanol, and isopropyl alcohol dissolves shellac slower than ethanol. Just in case you don’t know already, the radium on the dial (and likely the hands) of your Dad’s Elgin is highly radioactive. It is safe enough when safely contained within the watch case, but the moment you open the watch and especially when handling the dial or hands you must take precautions against inhaling or ingesting any radium.  Best Regards, Mark
    • I have both sets and use the K&D 99% of the time.  Yes, you have to be careful with the pin.  I use a screwdriver to carefully release the pin from the spring.  Some skill is involved.   I have also modified/replaced the pins in the arbors as necessary.  Yeah, you would think a tool would not require modification, but such is the world of watchmaking.  There is no perfect tool.  Each watchmaker must the tools to his skill, or vice versa.
    • I have the 8-11mm K&D but it doesn't do a great job with modern mainsprings, or I have had terrible luck. The arbor pin protrudes too much and I have damaged more springs trying to disengage the arbor than I have successfully wound and inserted. It seems easier to use with old carbon steel springs. My Watchctaft set gets far more use, though I have to get creative to wind left hand springs
    • It depends on what the gaskets are made from but silicone lubricant should work.  Spray or rub on a generous amount, put in a sealed bag and wait a couple of days.  Test for softness and wipe off the excess.  
    • For hardened gaskets, an experienced watchmaker told me he usually found heat to be the best to soften them up. I tried that on a '70's Tissot where the gasket had turned to essentially epoxy to no avail, but eventually got it off with a 5700 case back opener using a crowbar for leverage to turn the wheel.
×
×
  • Create New...