Jump to content

Mainspring winders at an unbelievable price


Paul80

Recommended Posts

Always on the lookout for low cost watch repair tools I stumbled across this listing

https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005004628144533.html?spm=a2g0o.store_pc_allProduct.8148356.71.174f4787pUZBWU&pdp_npi=2%40dis!GBP!£36.29!£36.29!£36.29!!!!%402100bde716700878353065703e5863!12000029892500559!sh

A set of 10 mainspring winders with steel arbours for a mere £36.29 plus VAT and shipping, these have to be the cheapest set around, anyone tempted 😉 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

They are for specific calibers, the listing says -

3135/2892/2824/7750/2671/2000/8500-1/8500-2/C07111/2235/8200

So, for instance, ETA 2892, 2824, 7750, Miyota 8200, etc. 

If you wanted to you could probably look up the specs for each movement to get the barrel ID,  and the wind direction. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Welp, I got the cheap set in the mail this week, and I also got 4 spare seiko 7009a movements for parts, so a good time to break some more mainsprings.

They aren't bi-directional although I initially thought they were.

As said above, they're definitely made for specific calibers, and the closest I could find for the 7009a barrel was the miyota 8200 set, which is honestly probably too small. There's another set where the winding barrel sat exactly on the mainspring barrel, not inside it, that might have worked, but it seemed like a recipe for disaster.

That said, I managed to obliterate one mainspring through my own inexperience and testing/practising. But the next mainspring I happily got wound up and back into the barrel.

Good enough for a hobbyist I'd say.

IMG_20221211_153954.jpg

Edited by lexacat
  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Hi all, newbie here.

Could someone who has a set of "value" mainspring winders make a list of diameters and winding directions. Looking at the supplied handles, they all look like RH wind but some of the movements listed would require LH winders.

I work mainly on old Swiss movements as a hobby. I need to decide whether to buy a starter set or 2 or 3 individual Bergeon sizes  in RH and add as I go along. 

Thanks all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I went with the individual Bergeon components.  1 handle (works for both LH & RH), 1 winder per size (works for both LH & RH), and individual LH and RH arbors for sizes as needed.

The arbors are really the only thing that is truly LH and RH.  The winders and handles can work for either direction.  I've found that 95% of the watches I've worked on thus far (not too many but a good amount for a hobbyist) have all worked with either a 5, 6, or 7 size.  There are a few oddballs along the way where it required a certain size winder, but the arbor was either too big or too small, so I wound those by hand.  For the most part, I find getting individual components to be a much more affordable way of getting good winders without spending the outrageous amount of money it would require for a full set, of which I'm guessing several would never get used by a hobbyist.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Chrismin said:

Hi all, newbie here.

Could someone who has a set of "value" mainspring winders make a list of diameters and winding directions. Looking at the supplied handles, they all look like RH wind but some of the movements listed would require LH winders.

I work mainly on old Swiss movements as a hobby. I need to decide whether to buy a starter set or 2 or 3 individual Bergeon sizes  in RH and add as I go along. 

Thanks all.

See the section in grey

https://bhi.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/HJ-Mainspring-Winders.pdf

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
On 12/11/2022 at 9:42 AM, lexacat said:

Welp, I got the cheap set in the mail this week, and I also got 4 spare seiko 7009a movements for parts, so a good time to break some more mainsprings.

They aren't bi-directional although I initially thought they were.

As said above, they're definitely made for specific calibers, and the closest I could find for the 7009a barrel was the miyota 8200 set, which is honestly probably too small. There's another set where the winding barrel sat exactly on the mainspring barrel, not inside it, that might have worked, but it seemed like a recipe for disaster.

That said, I managed to obliterate one mainspring through my own inexperience and testing/practising. But the next mainspring I happily got wound up and back into the barrel.

Good enough for a hobbyist I'd say.

IMG_20221211_153954.jpg

Coming back to this again.

Can you tell me if the arbor shafts are interchangeable with the barrel part.        Or, are the bores matched to the shaft diameter for each caliber. I am looking at the diameters of the barrels and, if the shafts were interchangeable, it would give a good selection of barrel/arbor combinations.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Chrismin said:

Coming back to this again.

Can you tell me if the arbor shafts are interchangeable with the barrel part.        Or, are the bores matched to the shaft diameter for each caliber. I am looking at the diameters of the barrels and, if the shafts were interchangeable, it would give a good selection of barrel/arbor combinations.

The bore diameter is matched to the shaft. 
Overall quality is decent for the price. 
Will still buy Bergeon winders as the need arise (have #1, #6, #7 so far) but this is a nice variety to have. 
I originally bought this cheap set for the smaller arbors, to use with the #1 Bergeon drum. Usable but didn’t solve my problem with winding the 1104A mainsprings. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
On 2/1/2023 at 4:06 AM, JohnFrum said:

The bore diameter is matched to the shaft. 
Overall quality is decent for the price. 
Will still buy Bergeon winders as the need arise (have #1, #6, #7 so far) but this is a nice variety to have. 
I originally bought this cheap set for the smaller arbors, to use with the #1 Bergeon drum. Usable but didn’t solve my problem with winding the 1104A mainsprings. 

What is your go to source for buying the individual Bergeon tools.  I found the main Winder Handle as they refer to it, but can't seem to locate the individual winders

Link to comment
Share on other sites

39 minutes ago, Jonno65 said:

What is your go to source for buying the individual Bergeon tools.  I found the main Winder Handle as they refer to it, but can't seem to locate the individual winders

Cousins have them. 

https://www.cousinsuk.com/category/mainspring-winders

https://www.cousinsuk.com/product/watch-bergeon-arbors-for-winders-by-size

Edited by SpringMangler
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Jonno65 said:

What is your go to source for buying the individual Bergeon tools.  I found the main Winder Handle as they refer to it, but can't seem to locate the individual winders

Both Cousins(UK) and Otto Frei (USA) have individual arbors and arbor+drums 

https://www.ofrei.com/page1145.html

 

Edited by JohnFrum
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
On 12/4/2022 at 6:19 PM, aac58 said:

I recently watched this video about that same winder set. It's really affordable and looks quite good, if only I had the information about the diameter and wind direction of those units...

 

 

.

Sizes mm

Left to right top

2000 = 7.2    2671 = 7.1    2235 = 7.8    8200 = 9.8   8500 = 9.0     

Left to right bottom

8500 = 9.3    3135 = 10    CO711 = 10.8   7750 = 12.0    2892 =  10.7

All Right Handed. Left as well if you use brass washers filed out to the same size. insert, then reverse

I purchased some brass washers and have spent some time filing out the innards to fit the outer size of each of the Chinese winders. I now have the facility to place 10 different size springs left or right. It would have been too long to wait whilst I purchased springs of each size. Total cost £6.69p.

Edited by rossjackson01
  • Like 5
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 5 weeks later...
  • 3 weeks later...

I see mention of the Bergeon #5, 6 and 7 being common mainspring winder sizes.  Does this budget 10 piece set cover those sizes?

 

On 3/2/2023 at 4:57 AM, rossjackson01 said:

All Right Handed. Left as well if you use brass washers filed out to the same size. insert, then reverse

I purchased some brass washers and have spent some time filing out the innards to fit the outer size of each of the Chinese winders. I now have the facility to place 10 different size springs left or right. It would have been too long to wait whilst I purchased springs of each size. Total cost £6.69p.

I don't follow you on the brass washers.  Do you have a photo?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, gpraceman said:

I see mention of the Bergeon #5, 6 and 7 being common mainspring winder sizes.  Does this budget 10 piece set cover those sizes?

 

I don't follow you on the brass washers.  Do you have a photo?

Here you go.

On the box above the holders are the washers I purchased. I filed them out to fit each individual wider and have inserted them on the winder.

IMG_20230303_095702.jpg

Edited by rossjackson01
more information
Link to comment
Share on other sites

39 minutes ago, rossjackson01 said:

Here you go.

On the box above the holders are the washers I purchased. I filed them out to fit each individual wider and have inserted them on the winder.

IMG_20230303_095702.jpg

I like the cheat sheet.

You've still got me puzzled on the washers.  How do those let you do left handed?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • This makes much more sense now, the oil is withdrawing itself to make as little contact with the epilame as possible. Same principle as wax on a car creates a hyrophobic surface that makes the cohesive properties of water molecules pull together.  The water beads run off only when under the influence of gravity but still remain cohesively beaded up. And as mentioned earlier a pivot would keep the oil in place on a cap jewel.  Epilame on an escapement would be a different scenario, there is nothing to hold the oil in position if gravity tugs at the bead to move, plus the escape teeth pull the oil about Maybe this is why its suggested to run the watch for a short while to remove the epilame to make two oleophobic surfaces either side of the oil, creating a ring of fire 🔥 around it 😅
    • As with every skill it watchmaking, it takes practice. Notice at the top of the document it says, "Practical work - 40 hours".  I can get the balance wheels 'close enough' to flat, but never seem to get them perfect. Same with gear wheels. Guess I need more practice.
    • Has it got a beat adjustment on the platform or is it a fixed hairspring? in short what you are looking at to get it just about in beat is to get the roller jewel sitting dead centre between the banking pins. So remove the platform and take of the pallet fork and escape wheel to give you clear line of site, sit the platform with the balance in place and with it level look between the banking pins and see if the roller jewel is sitting between them, if it is nice and central its there or there abouts in beat, if its not the the position of the pinned end of the hairspring needs to be adjusted to move the roller jewel into the correct position, thats why I asked if it has an adjustment on the platform or not, if it has its an easier job. 
    • I've managed to adjust it. I'm going to try and explain it as well as I can with my limited horology knowledge but I hope it helps someone in the future. There is a cam to the right of the front plate as shown in the picture. As the clock ticks along, the pin indicated in the gear comes around and slots into one of the silencer cam gaps, turning the cam. The pin completes a full rotation in 2 hours. To adjust the cam to start at the right time set the clock to just before 7. I did 6:45. Then I turned the silencer cam anticlockwise, which spins freely, until it pushed the silencer lever up and was placed just before the drop. Just before the 7AM indicated in the picture. All I then had to do was progress the hands to 7-7:15which made the pin slot into the silencer cam gap and turn the cam so the lever comes down again, unsilencing the clock. That was it. If anyone comes across this issue again I'd be happy to assist. Thanks again to everyone that helped. Hey Transporter! Thanks a lot for the reply. That was a really good explanation and I'm sure it would have made my troubleshooting a lot less painful haha. I'm sure someone will find it useful in the future. Thank you again for taking the time to try and help me out with this.
    • Now I'm completely confused, it would appear that the epilame  is oleophobic  as @Marc states: This oleophobic  behavior can be seen as beading of the droplet (as above) which stops the oil spreading which is supported by what we observe on treated/untreated cap stones (for example), but as @VWatchie states this should make the drops more mobile and is supported by the literature:   A review on control of droplet motion based on wettability modulation principles design strategies recent progress and applications.pdf   However the whole point is that we have less mobile oil so an oleophobic  would see to be the opposite of what we want. In fact this beading and high mobility are desirable properties in things like smart phone covers, see below.  I am fairly sure that epilame doesn't make the droplets more mobile, so maybe its a strange coating with dual properties that are both oleophobic (beading) and cohesive/adhesive resulting in low mobility?? This may explain the high price??  
×
×
  • Create New...