Jump to content

Mainspring strength allowance


Recommended Posts

Greetings good folks. I'm wondering, the watch I'm working on specifies a mainspring - Elgin part#817 with .775 strength. I happen to have part #817 but with .008 strength. Would that be ok to use? Is there any tolerance when it comes to mainspring strength or does it have to match exactly?

Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is that an Elgin pocket watch you're working on? I do see some #817's for a 16s Elgin with various strengths. It depends on how many jewels your watch has. The lower the jewels, the thicker/stronger the spring needs to be, and vice-versa.

The problem is that the strengths I'm seeing in a Swartchild catalog from the 50's, are between .185mm and .200mm. Another list I have shows two strengths listed as .190 and .205.

So, is it a pocket watch?  How many jewels?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 3/10/2022 at 6:32 PM, SndChsr said:

I'm wondering, the watch I'm working on specifies a mainspring - Elgin part#817 with .775 strength. I happen to have part #817 but with .008 strength.

American pocket watch mainsprings can present an interesting challenge today. I  have some images for you to show the problems.  Catalog pages from the Elgin parts catalogs 1915 you can see there are four different strengths of your mainspring. The catalog conveniently gives you a clue of strengths versus number of jewels. They even have a lighter than normal spring because occasionally for some of the higher jewel count watches the Springs would be too strong.

Then I have an image out of a list of modern mainsprings. This is where things get really interesting in that the modern white Springs typically for the same thickness can be stronger than the original Springs. The other bigger problem with modern mainsprings are the availability of them is limited. The one time the readily available but the Swiss don't like to make mainsprings for American pocket watches so the ability to get modern Springs is decreasing. Or for some watches they just consolidated all of various sizes into one spring. So the unfortunate reality can be can have a listing of a lot of different sizes which are lucky to get just one.

 

On 3/10/2022 at 7:39 PM, MrRoundel said:

It depends on how many jewels your watch has. The lower the jewels, the thicker/stronger the spring needs to be, and vice-versa.

If you look at the catalog page that I have it does list the mainsprings suggestions for the number of jewels in the watch. Usually it's not a problem of using a spring of a different thickness.

Then it wrong the strength mainsprings and problems I found have been extremely limited. Occasionally a seven jewel watches unhappy with the week mainspring because basically it's worn-out. Or one occasion I had a Hamilton 21 jewel watch that had too much amplitude. This is where eBay is nice I found the weakest mainspring they made an original spring it solved my problem.

Elgin mainsprings modern 16 size.JPG

Elgin mainsprings alternative light ones that no longer exist.JPG

Elgin mainsprings sizes and shapes.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Personally I would salvage the missing screws from some donor movement.  I also bought a random selection of screws "Assortment of Stainless Steel Watch Screws" for next to nothing.  As for using an Alum solution - I had great success with that removing a rusted stem from a stainless steel crown.  The best piece of advice I read on doing that was to keep the solution warm so that the reaction didn't take weeks!  I did it in a couple of hours with the solution in jam jar and the jam jar in a saucepan full of water which I left on an induction hob maintaining about 60C in the Alum solution.
    • I decided that it was time to tackle the piece that I'd set aside as my first project. The subject in question is a Gruen Veri-Thin pocket watch.  It winds and "runs".  On the time grapher, it has reasonable amplitude (240 or so depending on the position), but was loosing close to a minute a day.  The stem also has the annoying tendency to just come out when pulled, which makes it super hard to set the thing.  As with many things this one started sideways and just got more so.  I was able to overcome the mangled "tab" on the back case cover (a well placed, very sharp knife enabled me to get in when I couldn't get a purchase on the mangled tab with a case knife.)   I was then sort of shocked to find that one side of the dial was held down with some sort off tape or adhesive material as someone had broken the dial foot screw on that side and left the broken screw in the mail plate. The loose stem does in fact seem to have been a poorly tightened setting lever screw, but I'm afraid there may still be gremlins in the keyless works.  While I was able to get the stem to stay in by putting everything in the right place and tightening the setting lever screw (before I took it all apart for cleaning and inspection), it just didn't seem to all sit right. The final gremlin showed up when I was taking off the lower cap stones for the balance and escape wheel (yes the Gruen 380 seems to have a cape jewel on the escape wheel).  The balance stone came off fine (but that in fact is the smallest screw I've ever seen.  When I turned the movement around to get the one off the escape wheel setting, I found that the screw head had been mostly sheared off.  After some reading and looking at what I had, I decided to try and tease what was left of the screw out of the hole by nudging what was left with the corner of my smallest screwdriver.  After 20 minutes or so, I was able to get the remains of that screw out. The picture I'm including of the disassembled movement was taken before I got the second cap stone off, so in the picture, it's still attached to the main plate (for those looking carefully, you'll only see the one cap setting in the pic.) Now I'm left with: A broken dial screw inside the main plate that needs to come out A broken cap stone retention screw that I have in my parts tray, but that is strictly useless and needs to be replaced. The need to get another dial foot screw I'm contemplating solving the first problem by soaking the main plate in an alum solution.  I think the main plate is brass and shouldn't be affected, but I have not been able to confirm.  This seems like the easiest option as I can't really access both sides of the screw to use the pricey Bergeon tool (which I don't fancy buying unless I have to.) I have located a couple of donor movements and have questions out about whether or not the include the dial foot screw and prompting for pictures of the dial side so  evaluate the cap stone settings.  I've also found that a supplier in this country does have the cap stone settings, but isn't overly clear about whether the screws are included. Are these the types of things that one can scavenge out of assortments or is it best to just grab one of the donors assuming that they look like they have what I need?  
    • I visited this place last year just before they closed their counter service - amazing shop (filled from floor to ceiling!) and the guy that was working there was really knowledgeable and helpful!. Their website isn't as good as Cousins but I understand that if you fill out the contact form they have stuff that isn't on the site. https://gleave.london/mineral-flat-bottom-domed/
    • As always in this game the answer is “it depends “ because the first one worked out ok doesn’t mean all will. A case could be made in a way that it would not really matter much, sounds like your first example. However a case could also be made so that only a tension armoured crystal could be used. Generally you replace like for like to maintain the integrity of the watch.   Tom
×
×
  • Create New...