Jump to content

Really magnetized pocket watch


Recommended Posts

Hi all. 

I recently acquired a really lovely Molnija pocket watch in great shape overall. I have dismantled it and already cleaned it and have noticed that all the parts appear to be highly magnetized as evidenced by all the parts sticking to each other like that nasty stuff to a blanket. I don't have a demagnetizer but will have to get one without question, which leads to a couple of questions; hopefully I'm not repeating something that's already been answered in the forums.

First question is should I go for the Etic demagnetizer that Marc mentions in one of his videos, or get the cheap Chinese equivalent - or is it not equivalent, or would it be better to get the more expensive tunnel type that you pass the whole watch through? Sorry, that's three questions in one, but they are related.

Second question is, can I still assemble the pocket watch while I wait for the demagnetizer to arrive then demagnetize the assembled watch in one fell swoop - or should I wait for it to arrive then individually demagnetize the parts first before assembly?

Third question is how on earth did the parts become so magnetized in the first place; Is Russia now a hot-bed of magnetic activity?

BTW, I can't afford a nice Bergeon demagnetizer, or more correctly I can afford it just, but can't afford the divorce that would shortly follow its arrival. 

Thanks, I'll await your collective wisdom before doing anything else with the watch. 

Cheers from sunny Edmonton

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi all. 

I recently acquired a really lovely Molnija pocket watch in great shape overall. I have dismantled it and already cleaned it and have noticed that all the parts appear to be highly magnetized as evidenced by all the parts sticking to each other like that nasty stuff to a blanket. I don't have a demagnetizer but will have to get one without question, which leads to a couple of questions; hopefully I'm not repeating something that's already been answered in the forums.

First question is should I go for the Etic demagnetizer that Marc mentions in one of his videos, or get the cheap Chinese equivalent - or is it not equivalent, or would it be better to get the more expensive tunnel type that you pass the whole watch through? Sorry, that's three questions in one, but they are related.

Second question is, can I still assemble the pocket watch while I wait for the demagnetizer to arrive then demagnetize the assembled watch in one fell swoop - or should I wait for it to arrive then individually demagnetize the parts first before assembly?

Third question is how on earth did the parts become so magnetized in the first place; Is Russia now a hot-bed of magnetic activity?

BTW, I can't afford a nice Bergeon demagnetizer, or more correctly I can afford it just, but can't afford the divorce that would shortly follow its arrival. 

Thanks, I'll await your collective wisdom before doing anything else with the watch. 

Cheers from sunny Edmonton

As a fellow Canadian, buy the good one it comes with a voucher for a lawyer

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My very particular answer is, wait for the demagnetizer. Of course you can work on the watch and then demagnetize but when metal is magnetized lots of particles are naturally attached to it. The magnetized watch is no different so if you demagnetize after cleaning, chances are all the stuff that was attached to the parts (due to magnetism) will be dancing inside the watch and doubling as "sand paper".

If you decide to demagnetize the separate parts you are in for a surprise since the cheapo demagnetizer (regardless of where it comes from) need some sort of "theatrical performance" on your part to work, i.e. you grab the part and place it on the marked spot on the demagnetizer, press the button and start moving -- hopefully with your other hand -- the part away from the demagnetizer, slowly, evenly and in a wide sort of gesture. Eventually, when the part is as far away as possible from the demagnetizer as you can, you let go of the button and the part should be demagnetized...or you have to repeat your performance over again.

This is impossible to do with a bunch of parts regardless since they all acquire a mind of their own and start jumping in the magnetic field and never get demagnetized...or very little if any...or you have to "perform" for each of the 20 plus parts in a watch, and the screws,  and ...well you get the idea. Not a good idea to do it with a hairspring assembly by itself...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have both the cheap Chinese copy of the Etic, and a vintage pass through tunnel type of de-magger and to be honest they both do the job, although I find the tunnel type is probably slightly more efficient (and looks a hell of a lot cooler on the bench although that's just my weird sense of aesthetics).B)

I wouldn't spend the extra cash on the big name brands, a de-magger is a de-magger, essentially a coil of copper wire. You may get a better switch on the expensive one but if that bothers you then consider picking up a better quality switch from your local Maplins or Radio Shack and swapping it out on a cheap unit. You still save your money and get the best of both worlds.

 

As Bobm12 says it may be wise to de-mag prior to re-assembly. If there is that much magnetic swarf sticking to the parts then I would want to make sure that they are clean before it goes back together, that way there is much less risk of the debris ending up back in the watch.

I actually de-mag the movement prior to disassembly so that when the parts go through the cleaning machine any swarf is easily flushed away from the parts. I once made the mistake of putting the balance from an ESA 9154 (balance wheel electronic with permanent magnets attached to the wheel) through what looked like reasonably clean solutions in the cleaner, only to find it completely covered in iron filings that it had picked up from previous wash cycles when it came out. It took time, patience, and Rodico to sort out but it made me think about better cleaning practice.

It is also good practice to de-mag the re-assembled movement after cleaning as some cleaning machines can induce magnetism.

 

As for de-magging the parts separately that sounds like a right bore. I would replace the balance / balance cock assembly back onto the main plate to constrain it, and then put everything into some kind of container (with lid) and do it all at once like Cad101 has suggested.

 

As for how it got that way, who knows. I used to work in the fabrication department at Lotus Cars and was always advised to take my watch off before going onto the shop floor, mainly because of the spot welders, but leave it sitting on top of a Hi-Fi speaker for a couple of days and you would probably do the trick.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Well I did order an Etic demagnetizer in the end, however delivery is really slow and it won't be here for a few weeks so I had to make do with something else in the meanwhile. I read up in the ether world and there were several seemingly good home made designs that anyone could craft, however when I tried one of them I was stymied when I tried to tear an old transformer apart to use it as the laminations were all glued together with a hard varnish. Back to the drawing board. 

The solution I came up with, and that worked quite well, was to simply grip the edge of neodymium disc magnet in the jaws of an electric drill and rotate it at high speed then hover the parts by it and slowly draw them away. I did this twice with the particular parts I was having trouble with and they become completely and magically demagnetized.

I can't think of anything simpler frankly as most people have an electric drill and the magnets are available anywhere. Total cost was about $1. I'll be interested to compare it to the Etic when it finally arrives, though I'm sure the Etic will win the contest - I really hope so as the Etic is about 80 times more expensive than the simple magnet shown. 

I'm sure you'll all be upset to hear that the Oilers didn't make it to the playoffs - again!

Demagnetizer.JPG

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Awesome and I have no words! I looove that demagnetizer! Had I known that before, I might have saved a lot of money!

Yes, that oilers news are bad news. Any reason they didn't make it?

Cheers,

Bob

PS. I'll be interested in the demagnetizer comparison!

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yes, the seconds hand is the longest and goes almost to the edge of the dial. I can’t quite picture it how you do it on the rubber pad
    • A don't think so it leaked or damaged it because the watch itself works it just the buttons ain't working not connecting with the circuit board have taken more pictures of where the buttons makes contact with the circuit board.
    • I think what peter means oh is once he has fitted the hands and  checked for  alignment if them and that they dont foul, how does he then hold the movement to remove the stem in order to case up. The dial cannot be laid on a cushion or in a movement holder as the hands will get damaged. This can be quite tricky for a beginner, what i do is  to stand the movement on edge on a rubber pad so it doesn't slip. Hold the top edge with one finger then my dominant hand uses 3 fingers to press the stem release and flick out the stem. See below peter, leave off the second hand as this is the longest and gets caught the most, then fit it once the stem is out. Alternatively place the movement in one of the cup style holders, i imagine this is what they are designed for. They only touch the very edge of the dial.  
    • Yes I understand that. What I’m asking is, after the hands have been fitted, it’s been checked that the hands do not touch etc. then I need to remove the stem to fit the movement in the case. I have the push type, I need to turn it upside down and push the setting lever post and pull the stem out. But of course the dial and hands are in place and I have a glossy dial with lume dots and I do not want to cause any damage while it’s upside down pushing on the post of the setting lever.
    • You have answered your own question. You just push the setting lever nipple in or if its the screw in type unscrew it a little. You should always remove any hands and the dial before putting it in your movement holder. 
×
×
  • Create New...