Jump to content

My intended “Royal Oak” needs a bit of polishing


Recommended Posts

4 hours ago, VWatchie said:

A good tool makes you enjoy the work you do with it, while a bad tool has the opposite effect!

CousinsUK_Rotary_Tool.jpg.776bdaa509207a4d7d4fb843afef797a.jpg
Unfortunately, this rotary toolkit from CousinsUK is of the latter type. Admittedly, it does its job decently well but is not very efficient as the polishing head vibrates strongly which means that only part of, rather than the entire felt tip comes into contact with the surface being polished. Maybe worth the money (£35 + tax) but if you want to have fun at work, you'll probably have to look for a more expensive alternative.

NutBefore.thumb.jpg.6ab6b524f6b7506d07d5abddb9bc83fe.jpg
It would be foolish to try to polish your finest watch the first thing you do when learning, so I appointed this nut to be my guinea pig.

I found this video that shows how I went about it.


NutAfter.thumb.jpg.c38f7cee236fcb7af2518255289f0e64.jpg
Here is the result of my first attempt and it turned out unexpectedly well if I do say so myself. I first sanded the surface with a sandpaper-like accessory to get a reasonably even scratched surface. Then I polished it with green Dialux and finally with Polinum (using my substandard rotary tool).

WatchCaseBefore.thumb.jpg.35cd306f765ef1ac2a04b668c4b73d50.jpg
Warm in my clothes, it was time to try polishing at least part of the case on my beloved and recently serviced Vostok "Panerai" Amphibia with a ministry case. I have had the watch for almost 10 years but have used it quite sparingly (because there are so many other watches to choose from in the watch box).

WatchCaseAfter.thumb.jpg.ba0772f55f2d4f521ca476ad97ab4128.jpg
This time I chose to start with Polinum because it has a less abrasive action (I believe). I polished for about two to three minutes as I thought the results looked good enough. I have to say that I was once again surprised by the result even though it wasn't quite perfect, but nothing is or can ever be perfect, right? Anyway, I won't be using my lousy rotary tool again, at least not for polishing watch cases. However, it was good enough to give me a bloody tooth, so now I've started looking at alternatives.

Proxxon2.jpg.53ebbd5bad2f860ee03c63cd71040c77.jpg
The first option comes from Proxxon (a German manufacturer if I'm not misinformed) and is called 230/E Micromot.

Proxxon1.jpg.9f03a46e0fefe774002e29fc42e3af45.jpg
It can be bought separately without accessories and without a toolbox, but I need a box for storage because I don't have a workshop.

Proxxon3.jpg.4978bd57397af1bc560193ddd7fc4378.jpg
In addition, I was thinking of ordering a Proxxon 110/BF flex shaft for it because I think it is more comfortable and precise, especially when sitting for long periods of time.

DremelFortiflex.jpg.edb328b6185019cb433058f67921d49a.jpg
The other option I'm considering is a Dremel Fortiflex. The presumed advantage is that it has a foot pedal, a significantly stronger motor (which is probably not a significant advantage when polishing watch cases) and that the accessories are attached with a chuck just like on a drill, which I think can be more precise, i.e. minimise vibrations in the accessories. The downside for me is the storage as it doesn't come in a tool box.

I have also looked at Fordom rotary tools but then the price tag seems to go up even more.

If you have experience with any of these tools mentioned or can recommend any other rotary tools, in addition to those already mentioned in the thread (thanks), for polishing watch cases it would be very valuable and appreciated if you could share.

Bearing wobble can be common with cheap tools, but not always the case, it can be a hit or a miss . I have a 12volt  cordless one that was £20 which can run a 25mm felt wheel with good stability. Keeping the accessory short and tight up to the chuck collar will give the least wobble, even if you have to cut down the length of the shaft.  A variable speed angle grinder with a good quality flexi shaft could give you the best of both worlds.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Galilea said:

What all can you do with that? Seems like a lot of power.

I prefer to use the small felt wheels myself for the majority of polishing which give more control and less chance of smoothing out a case. But many youtube pros use good size polishing mops and laps mounted on full size machines. Handy to have both for different applications. With more experience and aquired skill, leaning towards the bigger devices would probably be a natural transition 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

53 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

I prefer to use the small felt wheels myself for the majority of polishing which give more control and less chance of smoothing out a case. But many youtube pros use good size polishing mops and laps mounted on full size machines. Handy to have both for different applications. With more experience and aquired skill, leaning towards the bigger devices would probably be a natural transition 

After you, watch wizard. 😎

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, VWatchie said:

A good tool makes you enjoy the work you do with it, while a bad tool has the opposite effect!

CousinsUK_Rotary_Tool.jpg.776bdaa509207a4d7d4fb843afef797a.jpg
Unfortunately, this rotary toolkit from CousinsUK is of the latter type. Admittedly, it does its job decently well but is not very efficient as the polishing head vibrates strongly which means that only part of, rather than the entire felt tip comes into contact with the surface being polished. Maybe worth the money (£35 + tax) but if you want to have fun at work, you'll probably have to look for a more expensive alternative.

NutBefore.thumb.jpg.6ab6b524f6b7506d07d5abddb9bc83fe.jpg
It would be foolish to try to polish your finest watch the first thing you do when learning, so I appointed this nut to be my guinea pig.

I found this video that shows how I went about it.


NutAfter.thumb.jpg.c38f7cee236fcb7af2518255289f0e64.jpg
Here is the result of my first attempt and it turned out unexpectedly well if I do say so myself. I first sanded the surface with a sandpaper-like accessory to get a reasonably even scratched surface. Then I polished it with green Dialux and finally with Polinum (using my substandard rotary tool).

WatchCaseBefore.thumb.jpg.35cd306f765ef1ac2a04b668c4b73d50.jpg
Warm in my clothes, it was time to try polishing at least part of the case on my beloved and recently serviced Vostok "Panerai" Amphibia with a ministry case. I have had the watch for almost 10 years but have used it quite sparingly (because there are so many other watches to choose from in the watch box).

WatchCaseAfter.thumb.jpg.ba0772f55f2d4f521ca476ad97ab4128.jpg
This time I chose to start with Polinum because it has a less abrasive action (I believe). I polished for about two to three minutes as I thought the results looked good enough. I have to say that I was once again surprised by the result even though it wasn't quite perfect, but nothing is or can ever be perfect, right? Anyway, I won't be using my lousy rotary tool again, at least not for polishing watch cases. However, it was good enough to give me a bloody tooth, so now I've started looking at alternatives.

Proxxon2.jpg.53ebbd5bad2f860ee03c63cd71040c77.jpg
The first option comes from Proxxon (a German manufacturer if I'm not misinformed) and is called 230/E Micromot.

Proxxon1.jpg.9f03a46e0fefe774002e29fc42e3af45.jpg
It can be bought separately without accessories and without a toolbox, but I need a box for storage because I don't have a workshop.

Proxxon3.jpg.4978bd57397af1bc560193ddd7fc4378.jpg
In addition, I was thinking of ordering a Proxxon 110/BF flex shaft for it because I think it is more comfortable and precise, especially when sitting for long periods of time.

DremelFortiflex.jpg.edb328b6185019cb433058f67921d49a.jpg
The other option I'm considering is a Dremel Fortiflex. The presumed advantage is that it has a foot pedal, a significantly stronger motor (which is probably not a significant advantage when polishing watch cases) and that the accessories are attached with a chuck just like on a drill, which I think can be more precise, i.e. minimise vibrations in the accessories. The downside for me is the storage as it doesn't come in a tool box.

I have also looked at Fordom rotary tools but then the price tag seems to go up even more.

If you have experience with any of these tools mentioned or can recommend any other rotary tools, in addition to those already mentioned in the thread (thanks), for polishing watch cases it would be very valuable and appreciated if you could share.

I have and use the Proxonn Micromot 60/EF. I think I bought it around 2006. It gets daily use, and is still working great; and I use the "universial" chuck on it, not the little collets. Tools run amazingly true- I'm really suprised. It has thousands of hours of professional use on it, far more than it was intended for, and it simply keeps going. I did have to open up the power supply box finally a year or two ago to glue up the support where the motor plugs in. Not surprising considering how many times it's hit the floor with me being a klutz. Highly recommended tool.

 

I'm not an expert case polisher, but I can say that prep work is at least as important as polishing. If there are deep scratches, they should be taken out with a fine file in extreme cases, or in lesser cases and/or post-file, using abrasive paper on a backer. 3M Imperial lapping film with adhesive back is widely available and very high quality; grits from 30 micron to perhaps 12 or 3 would be suitable for pre-polishing work. 30/20/12/3 is what I generally use, might through 9 in between 12 and 3 sometimes. For a backer it's usually a roughly file-shaped piece of metal, brass, steel, whatever, sometimes wood. With careful work here the risk of rounding everything over is greatly diminished when actually polishing.

Edited by nickelsilver
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, nickelsilver said:

I have and use the Proxonn Micromot 60/EF. I think I bought it around 2006.

That sure sounds reassuring. The one I have my eyes on, the Proxxon 230/E has a stronger motor and won't be needing a transformer power supply unit. Anyway, as you've been happy with yours I feel confident I would be too.

Also, thanks for the polishing tips! Super appreciated! 🙂👍

Link to comment
Share on other sites

440475574-419463590.thumb.jpg.254f31a7f1e91a16f357f7de058aa366.jpg

This is the favorite among jewellers and watch polishers. A hanging motor with around 200W. Fantastic torque. 

I used this type of motors in dental school until we moved to the new building where tabletop micromotors replaced them. The hanging motors were tough but a bit noisy. The only problem was the flexshaft, they can break occasionally. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a look at the Foredom SR and CousinsUK (and others have them). Pricewise they seem OK, and I'd really like to have a foot pedal. There are also cheap Chinese clones but I will definitely stay away from those.


Nevertheless, I was not impressed when I saw the close-up in this video. The rotating head will likely vibrate like crazy when the RPM increases. Fine if you're working on large objects like a motorcycle but for watch cases I think not. After all, working on watches we are in the business of extreme precision so I think all tools should reflect that and I'm really surprised you'd use them in dental school 😱

https://youtu.be/QfwG6F1-vlg?t=62

Compare with the above video. Sure, the steel collets must be bought separately, but I believe it could be well worth it. I'll think I'll go with the Proxxon unless the Foredom shown in the video was somehow faulty?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Foredom has many different style handpieces. If you look at the photo in my original post, that is the dental style handpiece with a fixed 3/32" quick change chuck.

Of course we didn't use Foredom motors in dental school. We had German made KaVo motors. They are probably extinct by now.

This video will introduce you to some handpiece options.

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, VWatchie said:

I had a look at the Foredom SR and CousinsUK (and others have them). Pricewise they seem OK, and I'd really like to have a foot pedal. There are also cheap Chinese clones but I will definitely stay away from those.


Nevertheless, I was not impressed when I saw the close-up in this video. The rotating head will likely vibrate like crazy when the RPM increases. Fine if you're working on large objects like a motorcycle but for watch cases I think not. After all, working on watches we are in the business of extreme precision so I think all tools should reflect that and I'm really surprised you'd use them in dental school 😱

https://youtu.be/QfwG6F1-vlg?t=62

Compare with the above video. Sure, the steel collets must be bought separately, but I believe it could be well worth it. I'll think I'll go with the Proxxon unless the Foredom shown in the video was somehow faulty?

 

Big price difference between the clones and the genuine Foredom motor. I nearly bought one a while back at a silly price of less than £100 . I noticed the accessory wobble in the video, that might be just down to the shaft of the bit being bent or poorly milled. Difficult to say if it was the chuck itself, i would think any vibrations would be down to both the handpieces and the motors.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had a long good look at the FOREDOM SR with the quick-release handpiece shown in the picture in @HectorLooi's post, and my impression is that it would indeed be precise and professional. Add to that the FCT foot-operated speed control and I think this would be one of the best options for any serious/professional polisher when it comes to rotary tool polishing. I was on the verge to pull the trigger. However, although I'm always serious about what I do, I'm not a pro and I'm not going to polish watch cases or other jewellery on a daily basis, so in the end, I just couldn't defend it. After all, my initial idea was to be able to touch up a watch case on occasion and not do a complete polish overhaul.

As a matter of fact, even the Proxxon Micromat 230/E (shown in my previous post) would likely be overkill in my case, but for less than a third of the price of the FOREDOM I think I could defend such a purchase to myself. I'm almost ready to pull the trigger (please tell me to 🤣) and if I do I'll let you know what I think.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, VWatchie said:

I had a long good look at the FOREDOM SR with the quick-release handpiece shown in the picture in @HectorLooi's post, and my impression is that it would indeed be precise and professional. Add to that the FCT foot-operated speed control and I think this would be one of the best options for any serious/professional polisher when it comes to rotary tool polishing. I was on the verge to pull the trigger. However, although I'm always serious about what I do, I'm not a pro and I'm not going to polish watch cases or other jewellery on a daily basis, so in the end, I just couldn't defend it. After all, my initial idea was to be able to touch up a watch case on occasion and not do a complete polish overhaul.

As a matter of fact, even the Proxxon Micromat 230/E (shown in my previous post) would likely be overkill in my case, but for less than a third of the price of the FOREDOM I think I could defend such a purchase to myself. I'm almost ready to pull the trigger (please tell me to 🤣) and if I do I'll let you know what I think.

Andrew Berry knows his stuff, i watch a lot of his videos. It did feel like he was promoting the Foredom though. I'm still tempted to buy the clone at almost a quarter of the price, i suspect i do a bit more case polishing than you watchie and will do more myself when i get around to plating, but still maybe only an hour or so a week.  A lot of power tools come from china, i have a few for my work job and some are ok, so thinking i might take a risk.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...
On 8/14/2023 at 9:20 PM, VWatchie said:

As a matter of fact, even the Proxxon Micromat 230/E (shown in my previous post) would likely be overkill in my case, but for less than a third of the price of the FOREDOM I think I could defend such a purchase to myself. I'm almost ready to pull the trigger (please tell me to 🤣) and if I do I'll let you know what I think.

So, I did pull the trigger on the Proxxon Micromat 230/E, and I'm super happy with it and can wholeheartedly recommend it. It's truly a night-and-day difference between my Proxxon and the lousy tool I got from Cousins. The vibrations are minimal and it's so quiet it bothers no one. IMO, worth every penny! 🙂

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • To me this is a simple solution but not just for UK. I know a lot of us are not into facebook groups. But Mark has one, so does Mike Bolton of my retro watches, so does Kalle Slapp. They cost nothing to run, my daughter runs a few dog groups with thousands of members. And it does not have to be actively used, just because you are not interested in facebook ( i wasn't for a very long time ) that doesn't mean you have to participate on it or read anything posted , that is anyone's choice to do so, you give or take what you want from it. Seems the ideal meet place to me, join it , make one or two posts just to say " I'm here " then set it aside for a rainy day. If or when that day comes then discussions can take place as what to do next.
    • Hi Bob, Welcome to the forum and thank you for your service.  I would never try to discourage you from getting into this wonderful hobby/profession, but please be aware, it does not cost just a few dollars to get into watch repair.  Tools are expensive and in many instances the cheap knockoffs are worthless, especially when learning.  You can get the tools needed to disassemble, clean, inspect, reassemble and lubricate a watch without spending thousands, but as soon as you start getting into task-specific tools, there are so many and they don’t come cheap.  My suggestion is to start with the basics required to disassemble, clean, inspect, reassemble and lubricate only, and build upon that gradually as the need for other tools arises.  The advice above regarding starting out on working movements is gold. Many of the non-running watches on eBay have been bought, tinkered with, deemed too difficult and then sold again, often with more damage done each time.  Without experience, you clean and service a non-runner and it still doesn’t run. What now? Troubleshooting is difficult as a beginner. This can become very frustrating.  I would encourage you to buy a working movement, and learn to strip and service it. If it isn’t running afterwards, you know it’s down to you, and as long as you didn’t damage anything you know that the parts you’ve got can form a ticking watch. An excellent movement to start with is the ETA 6497 clones from China, such as the ST36. They’re not expensive, and although it finds use in some larger wristwatches, this movement was originally designed for use in pocket watches, so everything is larger and easier to see and handle.  Once you can service a new ST36 and have it running better than it did when it arrived, you’re definitely ready to step up to working vintage watches and then think about repair of non running or poorly running watches.  As far as cleaning solutions go, you will not do better than the commercial watch cleaning and rinsing solutions that are available. You’ll find plenty of suggestions for home brew cleaners online, but the professional products are superior and you want to give yourself every advantage you can, especially when you start working on vintage movements containing hardened decomposed lubricants and often years worth of other dirt and dust. Alcohol is ok for cleaning or rinsing movement parts that don’t contain any shellac. The pallet fork and roller table contain jewels secured with shellac and will tolerate a rinse in alcohol but not prolonged exposure. Methanol dissolves shellac faster than ethanol, and isopropyl alcohol dissolves shellac slower than ethanol. Just in case you don’t know already, the radium on the dial (and likely the hands) of your Dad’s Elgin is highly radioactive. It is safe enough when safely contained within the watch case, but the moment you open the watch and especially when handling the dial or hands you must take precautions against inhaling or ingesting any radium.  Best Regards, Mark
    • I have both sets and use the K&D 99% of the time.  Yes, you have to be careful with the pin.  I use a screwdriver to carefully release the pin from the spring.  Some skill is involved.   I have also modified/replaced the pins in the arbors as necessary.  Yeah, you would think a tool would not require modification, but such is the world of watchmaking.  There is no perfect tool.  Each watchmaker must the tools to his skill, or vice versa.
    • I have the 8-11mm K&D but it doesn't do a great job with modern mainsprings, or I have had terrible luck. The arbor pin protrudes too much and I have damaged more springs trying to disengage the arbor than I have successfully wound and inserted. It seems easier to use with old carbon steel springs. My Watchctaft set gets far more use, though I have to get creative to wind left hand springs
    • It depends on what the gaskets are made from but silicone lubricant should work.  Spray or rub on a generous amount, put in a sealed bag and wait a couple of days.  Test for softness and wipe off the excess.  
×
×
  • Create New...