Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

Hello all. My first post-introduction post on the forum, so please bear with me. But I wanted to reach out to this community as I am hoping that someone in the watch-repair realm has come across this anomaly.

I recently came across an interesting 1984 16800 Rolex Submariner with an 8.2 mil serial. At first glance everything seems to be in order. However, upon close examination the dial reveals something interesting ... it looks like it's been stamped/struck twice. Comparing the text font and other features, with the exception of the double stamping it looks to be a MKIV dial with all the right features. But the fact that it seems to have been overstamped certainly raises some questions.

I've posted about this issue on Rolex Forums, and there are two prevailing views there: (1) I've never seen this before and is therefore a fake, and (2) everything about the font/dial looks genuine and it is likely a factory error that got past QC.

In addition, I've reached out to several well-known watchmakers and all that have seen the pictures say that they see no indication of a counterfeit dial, though only one has said that he's heard of a double-strike dial in the past.

I also took the watch a local Rolex AD which has an on-site Rolex trained tech. His verdict, "there is nothing in this watch that would indicate that any part of it is not genuine." Particularly with respect to the dial, in his opinion the text looks correct, the spacing looks correct, the texture of the lume plots show the characteristic waffle pattern, the lume reacts to UV light as it should. Basically he's never seen anything like it but he also couldn't find anything that would make him believe that it's a refinish job and he thinks it likely got past QC without being noticed.

With all that, I am curious if anyone here has come across a Rolex dial like this. Am I holding a one-off fake or a one-off genuine?

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated. Also, if anyone has any thoughts on where else I could go to get a more definitive answer, I'd love to hear those suggestions.


Thanks
 

Click on any of the pictures for higher resolution versions.

 

<a href="https://ibb.co/0qWhmT0"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/H7MnB6c/20210430-095820.jpg" alt="20210430-095820" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/SPH2Nkz"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/KXBY6tJ/20210430-095745.jpg" alt="20210430-095745" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/jyG1WS6"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/Lx62J3k/20210430-095544.jpg" alt="20210430-095544" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/wYnCVFw"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/DLBkhH8/20210430-095644.jpg" alt="20210430-095644" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/BBb7DC0"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/L1mqwZV/20210430-084134.jpg" alt="20210430-084134" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/w7xj3H9"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/9hCSzXF/20210430-084300.jpg" alt="20210430-084300" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/rs3MznY"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/m80t2Qk/20210430-084203.jpg" alt="20210430-084203" border="0"></a>

 

 

Edited by s0nic2
Posted
14 minutes ago, s0nic2 said:

Hello all. My first post-introduction post on the forum, so please bear with me. But I wanted to reach out to this community as I am hoping that someone in the watch-repair realm has come across this anomaly.

I recently came across an interesting 1984 16800 Rolex Submariner with an 8.2 mil serial. At first glance everything seems to be in order. However, upon close examination the dial reveals something interesting ... it looks like it's been stamped/struck twice. Comparing the text font and other features, with the exception of the double stamping it looks to be a MKIV dial with all the right features. But the fact that it seems to have been overstamped certainly raises some questions.

I've posted about this issue on Rolex Forums, and there are two prevailing views there: (1) I've never seen this before and is therefore a fake, and (2) everything about the font/dial looks genuine and it is likely a factory error that got past QC.

In addition, I've reached out to several well-known watchmakers and all that have seen the pictures say that they see no indication of a counterfeit dial, though only one has said that he's heard of a double-strike dial in the past.

I also took the watch a local Rolex AD which has an on-site Rolex trained tech. His verdict, "there is nothing in this watch that would indicate that any part of it is not genuine." Particularly with respect to the dial, in his opinion the text looks correct, the spacing looks correct, the texture of the lume plots show the characteristic waffle pattern, the lume reacts to UV light as it should. Basically he's never seen anything like it but he also couldn't find anything that would make him believe that it's a refinish job and he thinks it likely got past QC without being noticed.

With all that, I am curious if anyone here has come across a Rolex dial like this. Am I holding a one-off fake or a one-off genuine?

Any feedback would be greatly appreciated. Also, if anyone has any thoughts on where else I could go to get a more definitive answer, I'd love to hear those suggestions.


Thanks
 

Click on any of the pictures for higher resolution versions.

 

<a href="https://ibb.co/0qWhmT0"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/H7MnB6c/20210430-095820.jpg" alt="20210430-095820" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/SPH2Nkz"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/KXBY6tJ/20210430-095745.jpg" alt="20210430-095745" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/jyG1WS6"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/Lx62J3k/20210430-095544.jpg" alt="20210430-095544" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/wYnCVFw"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/DLBkhH8/20210430-095644.jpg" alt="20210430-095644" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/BBb7DC0"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/L1mqwZV/20210430-084134.jpg" alt="20210430-084134" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/w7xj3H9"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/9hCSzXF/20210430-084300.jpg" alt="20210430-084300" border="0"></a>
<a href="https://ibb.co/rs3MznY"><img src="https://i.ibb.co/m80t2Qk/20210430-084203.jpg" alt="20210430-084203" border="0"></a>

 

 

Sorry but the pics are not showing.

Posted

Looks like I was having issues with the pictures and now I can't edit the original post, so apologies for that.  Hopefully this works:

20210430_084134.thumb.jpg.8e85faa6a51f7ddf283d894a6ad4bf34.jpg

20210430_084203.thumb.jpg.63dbea9b896275712d4d3f50f91f40d7.jpg

20210430_084300.thumb.jpg.7c2ab8e52249a6457c4092cb3fe8d903.jpg

20210430_095544.thumb.jpg.9e05b61cc1e8481c86678d66235e5549.jpg

20210430_095644.thumb.jpg.81ca0182840155931ee3d347aca29690.jpg

20210430_095745.thumb.jpg.f8e47f5c81ef98fa26ce72c546f23007.jpg

20210430_095820.thumb.jpg.3862eca8db514ecce29943e51d37f30d.jpg

20210502-211446-resize-10.thumb.jpg.e9b59f25c3ca42006bff4a0487208d1e.jpg

20210502-211537-resize-83.thumb.jpg.b1747c4e376279be1235fe5c87ad3d0f.jpg

20210502-211746-resize-34.thumb.jpg.cf761f530c2d6f82d4edcafc64adec5a.jpg

20210502-212003-resize-32.thumb.jpg.5a7f4250807fbd131b71655b65a05cb8.jpg

20210502-212022-resize-8.thumb.jpg.d83b88cde5b68a8d2f12c31415ad0bd0.jpg

IMG_001.thumb.JPG.f230efebdf3c9cce21e9bf95ad7d48f9.JPG

IMG_002.thumb.JPG.5e461dca7f22ac3f4d789c1863fedf0d.JPG

IMG_003.thumb.JPG.37b7e43e4efce4cade5a655ef523c243.JPG

IMG_004.thumb.JPG.77779e322150153270ca7bae9393fc59.JPG

IMG_005.thumb.JPG.873688469a0f655ea3144c2925fa1632.JPG

IMG_006.thumb.JPG.e8467fec17947e3904d94c14719626e1.JPG

IMG_007.thumb.JPG.84fd19aa28461ede1845e31caab40892.JPG

IMG_008.thumb.JPG.218d84266adf83170568fa77d0e920bc.JPG

IMG_009.thumb.JPG.73a9b173c491027f2ab6e15b0b5bacb4.JPG

IMG_010.thumb.JPG.c90c8c9114bf819bbd3483893cd3e551.JPG

IMG_011.thumb.JPG.44c97a51a8684ab5b970e6741ddebf2d.JPG

IMG_012.thumb.JPG.4205a62af6f1625d8fe91023684fa8f2.JPG

IMG_013.thumb.JPG.f6aa19005c32b66d9d0f0b1f967cac47.JPG

IMG_014.thumb.JPG.93408e72159f584874cd4d14e01b5c3b.JPG

IMG_015.thumb.JPG.41151426dec126ae37f2f6bca8734a6b.JPG

IMG_016.thumb.JPG.faae598b449503b1f8520a12973d38e9.JPG

IMG_017.thumb.JPG.be241d8c01f50a7525d3e204846f401e.JPG

IMG_018.thumb.JPG.9445eb7fc1e0569ec55adaa52fda9c37.JPG

IMG_019.thumb.JPG.d8882e61977f5235ac14b9b2f052cff1.JPG

IMG_020.thumb.JPG.a25646801a4b888574a97955d66985b2.JPG

IMG_021.thumb.JPG.fee5a109a0373ec5400e4f213714ab88.JPG

IMG_022.thumb.JPG.40d88894133bea9151cb2e66422ed494.JPG

IMG_023.thumb.JPG.ce696d999d7c3ab6418f14b8b31349f5.JPG

IMG_025.thumb.JPG.739093cae99c78797ad3c0c44dc809be.JPG

IMG_026.thumb.JPG.6b919a74eb59f124576c1515ee55a7d0.JPG

IMG_027.thumb.JPG.669b25a0a8310cf1ca35d4d7dbb83105.JPG

IMG_028.thumb.JPG.330fd9e9f9890be99084329ddd03585a.JPG

IMG_029.thumb.JPG.a21dc0ff99bdc209d9bb222c02e4d673.JPG

IMG_030.thumb.JPG.5a5d04756c88b7b3cc9d546f39afadb6.JPG

IMG_031.thumb.JPG.e27a762f48c8ee17f5f77965df233600.JPG

IMG_032.thumb.JPG.7b672045bda0037adb9ab6c726eedd5c.JPG

IMG_033.thumb.JPG.3b8e1680aebda27049a4a7370aa6356a.JPG

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

I wish I could help you but I find this very interesting. I hope it’s legit and it sounds like there’s a good chance it is But there is a guy who has a web article about vintage Rolex dials and how to spot fakes or legit anomalies and he may be able to help. I’ll try to copy the link but just in case it doesn’t work it’s called the Rolex passion report. I don’t know how to contact them but give it a shot.

https://rolexpassionreport.com/21770/the-importance-of-the-vintage-rolex-dial/

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Thanks for this post MikePilk, I just came across a similar problem with an Omega 1022.  The problem I had was the seconds pinion spring was bent out of shape and did not even engage with the wheel properly, so the seconds hand was not moving at all. (no power loss though :) I removed the automatic module so I could access the spring and work on it. Once I bent it back close to the right shape, I experienced the same problem you reported about power loss.  Many tweaks later, and the seconds hand is moving properly again, with amplitude back to good numbers again. Cheers
    • After cleaning up the pivots, I made bushes on the lathe. At this point I've pressed in 6 bushes (3 sets) and the wheels turn smooth. What I can also tell you, is that I'm not looking forward to final assembly. Getting the pivots aligned seems to get exponentially more difficult with each wheel that is added.
    • Islands are interesting places to live depending upon their size and other factors. This is a bigger island and it has a bridge to get there at least on one end. It's also big enough that you don't have to go someplace else to get things typically. It can be a problem if you get a job in Seattle though. Yes I've known of people who commuted from the island to Seattle for a job and I don't quite remember how many hours it took but it took a long time. So basically islands are nice if you don't have to leave very often.
    • Thanks @JohnR725! Everything you say makes a lot of sense and is encouraging to read.
    • isn't it nice to have a decent case open or when the case doesn't want to be opened? In the case of a Rolex watch that supposed to pass specific water resistant testing you probably do need to tighten the back down. But they shouldn't be tightened so much that they risk stripping the threads out. Then the other problem that comes up is the gaskets can start to disintegrate and then getting the back off can be quite a challenge unless you have a really good tool and perhaps some penetrating oil to loosen things up. Yes really nice case marking. When I was in school we were taught to mark the cases and  the American watch and clockmakers Institute even had a? So if you joined at one time they would give you an identification number. They were explaining or giving an example of if the watches ever found in you have a unique number they can perhaps figure out the history of the watch or identify the body it's attached to for instance not that that probably comes up that often. So you got a unique number and even made a special metal stamp that you can purchase. It wasn't a super big aggressive stamp but still it left a mark in the back of the case. Then I heard from people at work on Rolex watches they were using a felt pen indelible but later on they decided that was bad because apparently the ink could release  chemicals although it seems like once it's dry that shouldn't be an issue. Then of course today was nice is you can keep computer records sealed have to mark anything at all I personally find it's best to leave no reference behind that you were even there. Especially when you have a beautiful watch that has no markings at all and now it has your scribbling all over it not good typically if there is a typical and watch repair?  a lot of minor repairs you don't need to do a complete servicing. But beyond a certain point you're going to have to take apart a lot of stuff you're going to disrupt the lubrication even if it looks perfect right now and yes you might as well just go ahead the service the whole thing. also in a watch like this where a lot of things seem to be going on the complete service would be better then you'll know exactly where you stand versus dealing with unknown mysteries for prior repair.
×
×
  • Create New...