Jump to content

Dilemma


Ammar

Recommended Posts

Hello everybody,

Last year I posted about a Dogma ladys watch that had a bad balance.

 

I've been trying to find a balance ever since with no success it seemed to me like it's impossible to find a parts movement with a good balance  I literally have like 8 movements laying around with broken balaces.

I finally managed to find a donor movement but I am scared of taking the balance off and oiling the end stones and messing up the balance again, what would you do if you were me?

Also, on the new movement, the main bridge is jeweled at the second wheel hole but in the same time I like the engraving on the original movement, Should I go with the jeweled bridge or keep the one with the "Dogma" stamp but no jewel.

(I know that I can buy parts off ebay but the difference in currency and shipping would cost me more than what I've paid for the 9 movements combined together)

 

20201013_105829.thumb.jpg.fed4c6244026bd24c23e8ba750eedd67.jpg.52c4781df1f28fc5e5e1ad53f752ba8a.jpgScreenshot_1.jpg.f8b304cc26d2e1e5fa2010f7ea3430e2.jpgfile:///C:/Users/Mohammad%20Dalati/Downloads/20201013_105829.thumb.jpg.fed4c6244026bd24c23e8ba750eedd67.jpg

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Ammar, 

 These two variants differ in that the old one has fixed stud holder and the new one got mobile stud carrier ( beat adjustor). I go with the newer version and replacing the gears bridges should technically make no difference. 

Good luck.

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Nucejoe said:

Hi Ammar, 

 These two variants differ in that the old one has fixed stud holder and the new one got mobile stud carrier ( beat adjustor). I go with the newer version and replacing the gears bridges should technically make no difference. 

Good luck.

 

Yup, the mobile stud is a plus, I didn't notice it when I bought the watch though, I was so excited to notice tbh, the difference between those two movements is that the old one is FEF 250 with a sub seconds hand an the newer on is FEF 250-1 with no sub seconds hand, and as pointed out by you looks like the stud carrier is another difference between those two. 

Oh and also the capped escape wheel and jeweled second wheel, it's a nice movement overall. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Eyup Ammar when you say broken balances what are we taking about ? 

Broken pivots and mangled hair springs, it's a mess and I;m not the one who caused it I'm just unlucky.

I think you are saying that I should've  put a hair sprig from one movement on a balance wheel from another which I considered but all the balance wheels I have are broken, the mind boggles.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Ammar said:

I'mnot sure I understand what you want to say.

Sorry ,   I was talking about which one of the two watches I assemble to a complete watch.  if the subsecond dial looks better I assemble that to a watch, by the same token I go with the center second if its dial looks better. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Ammar said:

Broken pivots and mangled hair springs, it's a mess and I;m not the one who caused it I'm just unlucky.

I think you are saying that I should've  put a hair sprig from one movement on a balance wheel from another which I considered but all the balance wheels I have are broken, the mind boggles.

All the staff pivots are broken ?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Ammar said:

I'mnot sure I understand what you want to say.

As Joe and Klassiker have said, the hairspring should really stay with the balance wheel. But then you will have to buy a new staff and fit it. The hairspring is matched to the balance wheel, swapping them around will give you timing issues. But this may still be better for you than changing a staff. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Nucejoe said:

Sorry ,   I was talking about which one of the two watches I assemble to a complete watch.  if the subsecond dial looks better I assemble that to a watch, by the same token I go with the center second if its dial looks better. 

 

Yes The sub second dial is way better and that's what I used actually, I serviced the movement yesterday but the hair spring is bunched to one side even though the coils look absolutely fine when its off, so I'll have to investigate that on Monday.

 

13 hours ago, Klassiker said:

Change the staff on one of the balances with a good hairspring. Don't interchange the hairsprings and balances if you can avoid it.

 

12 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

As Joe and Klassiker have said, the hairspring should really stay with the balance wheel. But then you will have to buy a new staff and fit it. The hairspring is matched to the balance wheel, swapping them around will give you timing issues. But this may still be better for you than changing a staff. 

Yea I know that but I was thinking of it as a last-ditch effort if I don't manage to find a balance complete, I cant fit a staff because I don't have the tools to do it unfortunately.

And yes all the staffs I got are broken it might be a problem with this particular movement I'm not sure and couldn't find anything online about it, it's a nice movement though I enjoyed working on it even though I absolutely hate ladys watches.

 

And by the way, if anybody needs parts for FEF 250 movement apart from the balance just let me know I have loads of them. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Neverenoughwatches said:

Around 8 i guess.  You were determined though i would have stopped at 3 😁 

Well here's the situation, I'm as stubborn as an old mule so if I put something in my mind it's going to be done somehow. I also was planning to give this watch to my mum but I got her another one so I told my fiance that I have a nice vintage watch for her and you know women she has been nagging me about it for a while so I had no other choice.🤣

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Ammar said:

Well here's the situation, I'm as stubborn as an old mule so if I put something in my mind it's going to be done somehow. I also was planning to give this watch to my mum but I got her another one so I told my fiance that I have a nice vintage watch for her and you know women she has been nagging me about it for a while so I had no other choice.🤣

Haha bless you Ammar, she will be over the moon with it when its finally finished.  Finally. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Lots of rust on that hairspring Nev, would you even try to clean it up ?
    • How do you find the working distance from microscope lens to movement? Is it comfortable enough to get tools in?
    • Once you have the collet closer bits off, and the pulley off, there are two nuts on the spindle. These must be removed. There is a large nut in the back of the headstock with two holes, remove this with an appropriate wrench. The front large nut comes off too. The spindle now comes out- but wait- there's more! There is a spacer between the outer races of the bearings; the spindle will almost certainly come out "assembled" with both bearings and this spacer (it can actually come out front or back-ways with the large nuts off the headstock). You have to manage to press out the spindle from the rear bearing, get the spacer off, then remove the front bearing, now you can get to the key.   Imagining you get it all apart without causing any damage to the bearings, now the fun part starts. You must apply preload to the bearings, and this is a very tricky endeavor. Basically once you have the bearings back on, and are in the casting, you snug up the rear nut (one of the two) on the spindle, checking the play of the spindle with at least a 0.002mm reading indicator, until there is zero axial play, then just a little more, then snug up the second nut to lock things in place. Of course snugging up the second nut influences the preload, so you can go back and forth a few times to get it right. Too much preload and bearing life diminishes, too little, and you get poor performance, poor surface finishes, ball skidding, etc.   When I replaced the bearings in one of mine many years ago, I was surprised to find that the bearings were regular deep-groove bearings, but of a higher precision class than normal. I replaced with dimensionally identical angular contact bearings, class P4. In trying to set the preload, I just about lost my mind, so called Barden (the high precision arm of FAG bearing makers, and who made my new ones) and a nice engineer told me that the folks at Leinen were either crazy, or really good- he also said it's 100% A-OK to set up deep groove bearings with preload like this, but best is angular contact. In this bearing setup, the standard way to do it is to have a spacer between the outer races, and another between the inner races. Leinen has the former but not the latter, haha. His advice was to make an inner spacer. The trick is it has to be the exact same length as the outer spacer, within like a micron.  Then you just tighten everything up and the preload is set, because the bearings (the new ones) are ground in a way that they have proper preload in that situation. Easy. Sort of- if you have the means to make the other spacer!   Just to note- Schaublin does the preloading as Leinen did on these on their lathes using angular contact bearings. There is a procedure in the manual, where you tighten the nut until axial play is zero, then a certain number of degrees more. This works on their setup as the nut itself locks without a second nut, and they spent the time to figure it all out in a repeatable way.   I say all this not to scare you off from dismantling your headstock, just to give a heads-up what you're up against to get it back to where it was before.
    • Do, write a nice letter to Santa. I do all disassembly and assembly under the microscope. I consider it a necessity.
×
×
  • Create New...