Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Im am currently shopping for my new watch. I have narrowed it down to two. The first is the Sinn 104 st sa b on a fine link bracelet. The other is an Edox 01114 3M BUIN Chronoffshore. The Sinn sports a Sellita 220-1 and the Edox carries the well tested workhorse ETA Valjoux 7750.

 This is where asking for opinions comes in. I was wondering if anyone had any thoughts on which movement is more reliable. From what I've read on the web there isn't much difference, as Sellita is very practiced at recreating ETA's movements. It seems that its kind of a heated debate so I hope I didn't just start a war lol. Thanks in advance. 

  • Confused 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I would say both movements are as you know are tried and tested Sellitia being an builder and supplier of ETA movements in the past, so on that score its down to personal choice in the watch case and design which is entirely yours.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

The sellita isn't a crono but it has a beautiful blue sunburst dial. I tend to go for the look too, once quality is established, but I can't decide between the 2 so I was trying to find something to make my choice for me like maybe one has a better movement lol. Service cost is surely a concern. That helps thank you

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, watchweasol said:

I would say both movements are as you know are tried and tested Sellitia being an builder and supplier of ETA movements in the past, so on that score its down to personal choice in the watch case and design which is entirely yours.

But but...... I can't decide so i was trying to find a clear cut way of something choosing for me lol. Someone else mentioned cost to service one vs the other and that for sure helps. Thank you for your input.

Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Poolshark0 said:

The sellita isn't a crono but it has a beautiful blue sunburst dial. I tend to go for the look too, once quality is established, but I can't decide between the 2 so I was trying to find something to make my choice for me like maybe one has a better movement lol. Service cost is surely a concern. That helps thank you

I love them sunburst dials. They don,t make them as radiant anymore , in modern pieces I mean.

 ETA 7750 movement is superior though and will keep good resale value.

Best wishes.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  when changing my car last year i ,  was in the same dilema,  A merc or a  Bmw both nice motors about the same price, but only one would take a tow bar,  That was the one that won, The Bmw    some times choice is a hard thing to make.

Link to post
Share on other sites
30 minutes ago, watchweasol said:

  when changing my car last year i ,  was in the same dilema,  A merc or a  Bmw both nice motors about the same price, but only one would take a tow bar,  That was the one that won, The Bmw    some times choice is a hard thing to make.

Im very happy this is my only problem at the moment lol.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hi Tom,   Mine machine is working fine but slightly out of sync (I still didnt figured out why as in the biggining it was completly fine, no issues), so I use manual overide button to move between cycles, its abit tricky as I have to watch metal disks which turns things on/off if not it will jump to another cycle (it cause a bit of an issue as it wont spin long enough to remove fluid between jars).   Regarding documentation - one Ive scanned for you was received from Elma after I contacted them, they told me that they dont have any shcemtics for this machines, I only got electronic schema for RM-90 if I recall correctly which is much more advanced and newer. Because machine is not working as I would like it, Im thinking to create a new electronic system for it based on arduino or something like that, Im not a programmer so it might be too diffcoult for me. If mainboard replacement for RM-90 would be cheaper I could use that for my machine - just got that idea  right now :). Still some parts are the same between those two machines - jars, possibly motors, heating plate etc.   Im mostly interested in American pocket watches, actually South Bend only :).   Regards,    Rafal
    • I decided to take it today... Feeling sick.  She apparently got a buyer in NY!  We're in L.A.   Yes, I could probably tell her to cancel the deal, but I won't.  If it falls through I'll take it.  
    • Old post but thought I'd comment, as it is very easy to destroy these bracelets... Michael Young restored a C&I bracelet for my 5512. And even restored, it's really floppy and, well, not spectacular. But, there's nothing like a vintage rivet bracelet- very thin and very light. Feels a lot like a leather strap. (He also repaired the end links via laser welding as the prior owner "customized" it to fit a 19mm lug width watch) But the links/rivets DO wear. Once the links open up (which you can see on the back side) the pins/rivets begin to wear. Michael opens the links and sleeves the rivets to make up the lost space as needed. Then he closes the links. As thin as the metal looks, it is quite difficult to open them without distorting them. The gap where the ends meet on the underside is 0-0.003" wide. really no gap on a brand new one (I recently sold an NOS 19mm Tudor branded bracelet) And as Old Hippy noted: they always look like links have been removed. More modern (9315/93150/93250 etc.) bracelets are tapered on the link edges, so they flow together. Rivet bracelets (both Rolex and C&I) have parallel sides to the links so they are "stepped" from 20 to 18mm at the clasp. Also, the end plates were polished and the links were brushed. C&I rivets are "hollow" (they have a small pin hole in each end) and the Rolex rivets are solid. I don't know if a threaded faux rivet could be used to replace a real one- I think the faux ones are larger diameter.
×
×
  • Create New...