Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
18 minutes ago, ChrisInOz said:

AAAAAIEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!

I've BROKEN THE BALANCE !!!!! 😢😢😢😭

I fixed the problems with the regulator arm,  set the boot correctly,  got the hairspring back into reasonable shape.  The movement looked to be running better,  so I took it over to test it on the timegrapher,  only to accidentally catch the balance wheel against the jaws and break off the top pivot.

What a clumsy fool. I am totally disgusted with myself.

brokenbalance.thumb.jpg.4ba6328f60ccc79ad50f9a3484a32bf8.jpg

 

It's easy done chris, don't beat yourself up. You now have the opportunity to learn something new, an often required proceedure.

  • Like 2
  • Thanks 1
Posted
7 minutes ago, VWatchie said:

Don't worry, Chris! We've all been there, and it's a part of the learning process. You never stop making mistakes, but gradually, you develop strategies to minimize the risks.

The way out here will be to replace the balance staff. However, that's something that requires quite a few tools, such as a staking set and suitable punches. Perhaps the easiest way out will be to try to source a balance complete (balance wheel + balance staff + balance spring) from a donor movement if one can be found.

Thank you for the encouragement. 🙂

I do have a staking set, but I have yet to learn how to use it.  It is a K&D 18R set with a mixture of different brands of punches,  some K&D and some Levin.

I will look for a donor movement too.

I was servicing this watch in order to give it to a friend who admired it,  so I would like to repair it if possible.

  • Like 3
Posted

Don't be so hard on yourself. We've all been there! One slip and hours of work down the drain. It's in the nature of the job/hobby. A huge sense of satisfaction when you finally get the job done is the other side of the same coin.

That top pivot was scrap anyway. 😉

5 minutes ago, ChrisInOz said:

I would like to repair it if possible

And you will, even if it takes longer than you hoped. Now you are going to learn how to replace a balance staff. All good!

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Posted (edited)

We've all done it Chris. The pivot looked bent anyway, so you would have needed to change it - I have heard rumours of people straightening pivots, but some have also claimed to have seen unicorns 🤣

If you search Ebay for 'balance complete eta 1260' you will find some. Make sure you get the non-Incabloc version

You will see some Renata balances, the number for the non-inca version is 164

image.png.d16a8089442ffd840fc9869b27c9a463.png

Edited by mikepilk
  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 2
Posted
9 minutes ago, mikepilk said:

have heard rumours of people straightening pivots, but some have also claimed to have seen unicorns 🤣

There are two grazing in my back garden right now Mike, one is looking kinda frisky, so I may be buying Swatch out when the offspring  arrives. 

  • Haha 2
Posted
3 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

There are two grazing in my back garden right now Mike, one is looking kinda frisky, so I may be buying Swatch out when the offspring  arrives.

That's nothing, a rocking horse has just taken a S$%t in my garden.

  • Like 1
  • Haha 3
Posted
10 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

There are two grazing in my back garden right now Mike

I do occasionally see unicorns around Watford, Rich 🤪. They come in to the gardens to scrounge peanut butter sandwiches, which they are very fond of.  It was in the distance, and they move quickly, but I got a pic of one doing that just recently 

20240906_112251.thumb.jpg.548c923012b97322ba3f69b345c30610.jpg

  • Like 1
  • Haha 4
Posted
1 hour ago, mikepilk said:

I do occasionally see unicorns around Watford, Rich 🤪. They come in to the gardens to scrounge peanut butter sandwiches, which they are very fond of.  It was in the distance, and they move quickly, but I got a pic of one doing that just recently 

20240906_112251.thumb.jpg.548c923012b97322ba3f69b345c30610.jpg

Ah.. but there is only one,I have two going at it like........🤔..unicorns. 🤣

1 hour ago, RichardHarris123 said:

That's nothing, a rocking horse has just taken a S$%t in my garden.

Bag it up Rich and slap the log on ebay.

  • Haha 2
Posted
7 hours ago, mikepilk said:

You will see some Renata balances, the number for the non-inca version is 164

Thank you.  You anticipated the next question I was going to ask.

I noticed several of them available in various places, and various brands,  but I'm not sure how to identify which are the non-inca versions among them.

This one,  for example: would this be a non-inca version?

s-l1600.thumb.jpg.b3f4cf09147abde18e57fb75c5877e55.jpg

Also,  I have an old specification sheet for the movement, downloaded from Cousins,  that gives a part number 721 for the balance complete,  but there seems to be a whole range of completely different balances that are sold under this number.  Can you help me to understand the significance of that please. 

Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, ChrisInOz said:

Thank you.  You anticipated the next question I was going to ask.

I noticed several of them available in various places, and various brands,  but I'm not sure how to identify which are the non-inca versions among them.

This one,  for example: would this be a non-inca version?

s-l1600.thumb.jpg.b3f4cf09147abde18e57fb75c5877e55.jpg

Also,  I have an old specification sheet for the movement, downloaded from Cousins,  that gives a part number 721 for the balance complete,  but there seems to be a whole range of completely different balances that are sold under this number.  Can you help me to understand the significance of that please. 

If you search online for "Ebauches SA Dictionnaire Technologique" you'll find a catalogue with the parts numbering system. The specific part you're showing has "DAnc" under the 721. That tells you that it has a non-hollowed out roller for a shock protection system.Screenshot_20250327_040831_AdobeAcrobat.thumb.jpg.a11fa924f091bce716e629df4c01e78c.jpg 

On ebay you can also see Renata parts that will tell you on the package if it is for a shock or non-shock protected movement by mentioning "inca". The Renata catalogue can be found as a pdf online (cousins uk for instance) as well and tells you you'll want Renata 164:Screenshot_20250327_044220_AdobeAcrobat.thumb.jpg.abdf089fdc17f49a81ceba9670708488.jpg

Edited by caseback
  • Thanks 1
Posted
54 minutes ago, caseback said:

If you search online for "Ebauches SA Dictionnaire Technologique" you'll find a catalogue with the parts numbering system. The specific part you're showing has "DAnc" under the 721. That tells you that it has a non-hollowed out roller for a shock protection system.

Thank you for the information.

Just to make sure I understand correctly,  does "non-hollowed-out roller"  mean that this part is NOT for a shock protection system. The English translation is a little ambiguous.

The German text appears to say "lever disc not countersunk for shock protection"  which would imply that this is the right part for me.

Posted
1 hour ago, ChrisInOz said:

Just to make sure I understand correctly,  does "non-hollowed-out roller"  mean that this part is NOT for a shock protection system. The English translation is a little ambiguous.

No, it shows that there are apparantly 2 different versions for use with a shock protection: one with a hollowed out roller and one which has a non-hollowed out roller. You need the simple 721, so without the DAc or DAnc added.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Posted
5 minutes ago, caseback said:

No, it shows that there are apparantly 2 different versions for use with a shock protection: one with a hollowed out roller and one which has a non-hollowed out roller. You need the simple 721, so without the DAc or DAnc added.

OK, that's clear now.  Thank you again.  🙂

Posted
On 3/27/2025 at 2:01 AM, mikepilk said:

You will see some Renata balances, the number for the non-inca version is 164

 

On 3/27/2025 at 1:58 PM, caseback said:

On ebay you can also see Renata parts that will tell you on the package if it is for a shock or non-shock protected movement by mentioning "inca". The Renata catalogue can be found as a pdf online (cousins uk for instance) as well and tells you you'll want Renata 164:

My thanks to you both for the assistance.  🏆

I have ordered a Renata 164 balance complete from an eBay seller.

renata164-b.jpg.e27f56bea9d1c3f0b4c94360e7f1dfd5.jpgrenata-164a.jpg.0c7bea5f67e4eedeb5aab8e333f4a3aa.jpg

As a training exercise I also plan to replace the staff on the existing balance.  Looking at the online Ronda catalog,  it seems that I need the 2971 staff for the non-shock balance,  so I have also ordered one of those.

rondaStaff.thumb.jpg.ca4f1519dfc3c2e2ebd239f86fae6dff.jpg

Fairly sure I don't have one of the necessary punches,  and one stump for my staking set.  

I would welcome any advice on the best techniques for removing and replacing the roller and hairspring.

 

Posted
13 hours ago, ChrisInOz said:

I would welcome any advice on the best techniques for removing and replacing the roller and hairspring.

 

I'd say these are questions on which the search function will provide you with all the info you need. 😉

  • Thanks 1
Posted
5 hours ago, caseback said:

I'd say these are questions on which the search function will provide you with all the info you need. 😉

Thanks. I have found some excellent threads now.  I will study them in detail.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Thank you very much for your tips @nevenbekriev. When I broke these, I was grasping them with steel tweezers parallel to the fork slot, grasping them on the top and bottom of the stone. I do want to learn this procedure for to be successful on old watches, and I will practice when I have more spares and supplies.
    • You need to bring the pad to the dial, that way you've got more control on how much pressure you apply.
    • Sorry I have this thread forgotten. Now, why the stones break? Several reasons: One - the old stones are crunchy. Be careful! Two - wrong tweezers. Use brass ones. Three - wrong approach. The best way is not to grasp the stone close to working side. Grasp it for the middle part, the tweezers direction to be perpendicular to the stone. Use oscillating tilting movements when moving the stone.  Now several tips that are not read from the books, but found in my practice. They are good for my way of correcting pallet stones position: You don't need the heater for adjusting the stones position. The heater will be needed only to glue/fix the stone when the adjustment is already done.  The stone should seat tight enough in the slot without gluing. Tight enough so the movement will work normally and thus checking if the adjustment is correct is to be done before gluing. If the stone is loose in the slot, then heating and melting the shellac will make the stone move in by the capillary force. So, if the stone is loose in the slot, then find out if the stone is not correct or the slot is opened. If the slot is opened, then (in steel pallet forks) it is good idea to anneal locally only the small part that forms the slot before trying to close the slot. Also, put in the slot something slightly thinner than the pallet to limit the amount of bending If the stone must go out, the shellac can stay in place, it will not make the adjustment harder. Just bend the stone to break the bond between the shellac and stone. Then heating only will glue the stone again if the shellac is not old and degraded. If the stone must go in, then the shellac mus be removed from the slot bottom as to make space for the stone to go in. I often use pallet stones from USSR Slava alarm clock for pocket watches repair. Slava pallet stones are usually bigger (wider) than needed) and I grind/lap them to correct size for the slot. Grinding is of the side that never contacts the EW teeth. It is enough to put the stone on the lapping plate, pres on it with finger and move it forward/reverse several times while pressing, then check in the slot.  
    • I used a small ultrasonic for years until it died, but it does need to be large enough to fit jars in to hold your parts, and small parts ideally are in mesh baskets within the jars so you are not fishing them out one by one with tweezers. So the one you linked might be too small and this kind of thing really the minimum workable size
×
×
  • Create New...