Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hey watch people, i hope we are all well today. I've heard good things about Proxon in the past regarding their hand rotary tools such as the 12volt microdot and 240 volt versions. Does anyone have any experience with their bigger equipment ? I have an old Geneva pattern watchmaker's lathe and another old bigger lathe, not that I've done much with them as yet but i like to prepare for future levelling up in this hobby so when something comes my way at the right price i grab it. Becoming more independent another major piece of equipment to consider getting is a mini milling machine. Proxon have a few different priced models ranging from a meager £300 up to almost £1000. The specifications on the entry model MF70 look kind of ok for the price but some of the important info like runout is missing, it also available for cnc use. Reviews are mixed as reviews are very dependent on the knowledge that the reviewer has, but more positive than negative. Also is a bigger more functional model is the PF230 . Any thoughts would be appreciated 👍

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have been eyeing their lathes and mills as well (fir future purchases).  I do have their Bench Drill Press TBM 115 with the Compound Table KT 70 and i can attest that it is very accurate and very well built.  I also would welcome any review of their bigger tools.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

15 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

The specifications on the entry model MF70 look kind of ok for the price but some of the important info like runout is missing, it also available for cnc use.

this does seem to be a very popular milling machine. Then if you toss in the word CNC conversion it seems to be extremely popular as it's a very easy mill to convert the CNC.

at one time a long time ago I saw someone making a watch with the milling machine and when I went back to find it again of course it's impossible because people failed to use the proper keywords for findability. But I know I've seen at least two people using it for watchmaking projects.

here is an interesting video showing what you can do with the milling machine and one of their lathes. so does an upgrade that in stepping motors and a custom controller that's not CNC at least not yet.

https://youtu.be/iVYIXzO6UtI?si=LkkqeS4KGcOthR5B

then a couple years later basically a new controller but you wouldn't have to build his you can buy something like that already made and now it's full CNC capable. Plus he adds in a really much nicer CNC programs of what most people use it cost a little money but it's not very expensive and it's a rather nice program which is called Estlcam.

https://youtu.be/ADKnGjk6h3E?si=B8LXs6fUQ4rQ3zos

so yes it does seem to be a popular milling machine. But finding affordable milling machines tends to be an issue for some unknown reason they seem to be rather expensive.

 

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, ClaudioCavalli said:

I have been eyeing their lathes and mills as well (fir future purchases).  I do have their Bench Drill Press TBM 115 with the Compound Table KT 70 and i can attest that it is very accurate and very well built.  I also would welcome any review of their bigger tools.

Thanks claudio, i quite like the look of that drill as well, that would be the 3 speed not variable ? Not a bad price if its ok

1 hour ago, JohnR725 said:

this does seem to be a very popular milling machine. Then if you toss in the word CNC conversion it seems to be extremely popular as it's a very easy mill to convert the CNC.

at one time a long time ago I saw someone making a watch with the milling machine and when I went back to find it again of course it's impossible because people failed to use the proper keywords for findability. But I know I've seen at least two people using it for watchmaking projects.

here is an interesting video showing what you can do with the milling machine and one of their lathes. so does an upgrade that in stepping motors and a custom controller that's not CNC at least not yet.

https://youtu.be/iVYIXzO6UtI?si=LkkqeS4KGcOthR5B

then a couple years later basically a new controller but you wouldn't have to build his you can buy something like that already made and now it's full CNC capable. Plus he adds in a really much nicer CNC programs of what most people use it cost a little money but it's not very expensive and it's a rather nice program which is called Estlcam.

https://youtu.be/ADKnGjk6h3E?si=B8LXs6fUQ4rQ3zos

so yes it does seem to be a popular milling machine. But finding affordable milling machines tends to be an issue for some unknown reason they seem to be rather expensive.

 

Thanks for the useful information and videos John. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why buy a drill press if contemplating the purchase of a mill , I have Warco’s smallest mill WM12 and I have added DRO to it and I am happy with it and it’s cast iron not cast aluminium, I even use it for bushing and depthing for that matter but I only do clocks but I can make tools as well, recently made a T rest base for my Pultra & made the upright on the Myford.

Dell

IMG_1062.jpeg.31100a76faeebaab91abc53c5b997627.jpeg

IMG_1961.jpeg.45a1834d46090ca0d402fcca144a9601.jpeg

Edited by Dell
Words missing
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, Dell said:

Why buy a drill press if contemplating the purchase of a mill , I have Warco’s smallest mill WM12 and I have added DRO to it and I am happy with it and it’s cast iron not cast aluminium, I even use it for bushing and depthing for that matter but I only do clocks but I can make tools as well, recently made a T rest base for my Pultra & made the upright on the Myford.

Dell

IMG_1062.jpeg.31100a76faeebaab91abc53c5b997627.jpeg

IMG_1961.jpeg.45a1834d46090ca0d402fcca144a9601.jpeg

Like it Dell. Proxxon have the pf230, a bigger more functional mill that is steel and cast, bit less than a grand.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Like it Dell. Proxxon have the pf230, a bigger more functional mill that is steel and cast, bit less than a grand.

There is a Warco mill for sale on model engineering but can’t remember what model it is but it was cheap and looked in good Nick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

30 minutes ago, Dell said:

There is a Warco mill for sale on model engineering but can’t remember what model it is but it was cheap and looked in good Nick.

Thanks Dell, its been sold , went for 350 bargain. New 950.  If i decide to go for a bigger machine i will look at this model. Much heavier at 50 kg than the  proxxon pf230 at only 17kg. Hows the Chinese quality of it ?

45 minutes ago, Dell said:

There is a Warco mill for sale on model engineering but can’t remember what model it is but it was cheap and looked in good Nick.

Wm14 plus accessories 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Thanks Dell, its been sold , went for 350 bargain. New 950.  If i decide to go for a bigger machine i will look at this model. Much heavier at 50 kg than the  proxxon pf230 at only 17kg. Hows the Chinese quality of it ?

Wm14 plus accessories 

I have no complaints with my mill after tramming it and setting up the gibs, did knacker the sacrificial nylon gear once but that was my fault being to greedy with the cut but easily replaced , if I was to buy one now it would be the later belt driven one but we live and learn.

Dell

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Dell said:

I have no complaints with my mill after tramming it and setting up the gibs, did knacker the sacrificial nylon gear once but that was my fault being to greedy with the cut but easily replaced , if I was to buy one now it would be the later belt driven one but we live and learn.

Dell

Thanks Dell, its a later purchase for this year but a Warco is in the hat. I'm also waiting for those levin collets to be reduced for my lathe. Looking into an er collet conversion kit for it as well which might be an easier, cheaper option, the headstock spindle  thread is 28mm.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Most all my 404 candidates are coming from swap meets and "antiques fairs". One more $4US plus battery and elbow grease. Unnamed digital on a decent ss bracelet. Gains 10 seconds a day so not that accurate...
    • I voted.for the 6.99 assuming £, which works out to $8.74US at the current exchange rate.
    • £4.04 originally worked out to $5, or thereabouts accounting for currency fluctuations. Inflation calculator from 2020 (when the thread was started, though not when Andy coined the term) says we're looking at $6 currently. What currency is the 6.99 inflation adjusted figure cited in the poll? $6 may still seem restrictive, but don't forget that's part of the point. It's a challenge. Thrill of the hunt and all. Diamonds in the rough. Also, and my personal angle on the game, a fun and inexpensive way to learn watchmaking skills.
    • Dear all My first experience servicing a quartz watch after servicing as an hobby my mechanic watches for many years. This is an old Certina that was given to me by a friend, with  a ETA/ESA 9362 movement. Before service I put a new battery and the watch was working. After servicing the movement stopped working. i understand that there might be a lot of reasons for this (including the fact that I used technics and oils from mechanic movements on this one  ), but at this stage I would only need to check if the electronic module is good. Don't have a quartz tester but only a multimeter. You will see on the photos that the battery contact is broken and needs soldering. With the battery in the movement I can confirm that the electronic module had power (1.57v). Question: what basic tests can I do with a multimeter to confirm that the electronic module is good? how to check if the coil is good and if there is pulse in the electronic module? what contacts should I use to test it? (I saw some videos on you tube but was not able to find the specific test procedures for the ETA 9362). Any information to help me check if the reason for the movement to stop is on the electronic or mechanic part of the watch is much appreciated. Many thanks
    • Dear all My first experience servicing a quartz watch after servicing as an hobby my mechanic watches for many years. This is an old Certina that was given to me by a friend, with  a ETA/ESA 9362 movement. Before service I put a new battery and the watch was working. After servicing the movement stopped working. i understand that there might be a lot of reasons for this (including the fact that I used technics and oils from mechanic movements on this one 😞 ), but at this stage I would only need to check if the electronic module is good. Don't have a quartz tester but only a multimeter. You will see on the photos that the battery contact is broken and needs soldering. With the battery in the movement I can confirm that the electronic module had power (1.57v). Question: what basic tests can I do with a multimeter to confirm that the electronic module is good? how to check if the coil is good and if there is pulse in the electronic module? what contacts should I use to test it? (I saw some videos on you tube but was not able to find the specific test procedures for the ETA 9362). Any information to help me check if the reason for the movement to stop is on the electronic or mechanic part of the watch is much appreciated. Many thanks    
×
×
  • Create New...