Jump to content

I'm back from the dead. Gonna try and bring a well cared for bell matic back from the dead too.


Recommended Posts

I have a Venus 170 in trays awaiting a few replacement parts. I was criticized for calling Mark’s method of leaving screws in the plate Mark’s method 😉 but I do have issue with the thing that shall not be named Mark’s method of leaving the screws in the plate- what to do with the screws what connect the two plates? Turns out these are remarkably similar and with a bit of wear nearly impossible to distinguish. It took too much time but I believe I have them sorted and the replacement for the one that broke off in the plate is on the way…

With simple movements I’ve always kept the screws isolated with their respective parts, then add a snapshot to unique screws like in a plate set. In the future I believe I’ll do the same with chronographs if I should have enough trays 😀

btw, I have not seen an issue with cleanliness leaving screws in the plate. This Venus was quite dirty and rusty but L&R did the trick. 

Edited by rehajm
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, rehajm said:

I have a Venus 170 in trays awaiting a few replacement parts. I was criticized for calling Mark’s method of leaving screws in the plate Mark’s method 😉 but I do have issue with the thing that shall not be named Mark’s method of leaving the screws in the plate- what to do with the screws what connect the two plates? Turns out these are remarkably similar and with a bit of wear nearly impossible to distinguish. It took too much time but I believe I have them sorted and the replacement for the one that broke off in the plate is on the way…

With simple movements I’ve always kept the screws isolated with their respective parts, then add a snapshot to unique screws like in a plate set. In the future I believe I’ll do the same with chronographs if I should have enough trays 😀

btw, I have not seen an issue with cleanliness leaving screws in the plate. This Venus was quite dirty and rusty but L&R did the trick. 

Don't think it's right to be criticized. The course information, is just that, information. We interpret various items in our own way and adapt them for ourselves. I certainly have. I have taken on board others members and Youtuber's ideas. Some good, some bad. But hey, it's my choice. 

 

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with Ross 100%, there is no one way pretty much in anything, only what works for us. I would encourage anyone to learn from as many sources as you can and make your own approach and standards for what you are doing.

 

Tom

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

55 minutes ago, tomh207 said:

I agree with Ross 100%, there is no one way pretty much in anything, only what works for us. I would encourage anyone to learn from as many sources as you can and make your own approach and standards for what you are doing.

 

Tom

Absolutely Tom, i fly by the seat of my pants in most things i do, this game more so, there is so much to learn. I willingly take on board anything from someone who i think knows more than me on any given subject. But always do i question and like to varify something for myself, thats just the way I'm made. 

1 hour ago, tomh207 said:

I agree with Ross 100%, there is no one way pretty much in anything, only what works for us. I would encourage anyone to learn from as many sources as you can and make your own approach and standards for what you are doing.

 

Tom

Its funny I've been in construction for almost 40 years now, there isn't an aspect of building and refurbishment i dont understand.  New ideas pop up all the time, some work some dont, the old ideas almost always work. I'm also in a builder's forum, some of the advice given there to diyers is absolutely shocking some of it is just downright abuse and insults. When I'm not imparting my hard earned wisdom I'm pulling a bully's pants down, forum etiquette is atrocious in that industry. Watchmaking communities seem to have much more respect for each other, respect each other's thoughts and ideas whether they are agreed upon or not. We all have to find our own way and if thats different then its different as long as it gets us there.

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok so my cousins package came, the missing alarm ring clip came AND the jewel came but the only thing i'm missing is my mainspring grease which comes later today.  Always love when a new cousins package arrives.
image.thumb.png.099abcdfd72cc4f5363c6aa7617493fb.png


Since i can't service the barrels on the 3 watches on my "bench" i decided to jump in the deep end of fixing the alarm spring who's inner coil is out of shape and can't clutch the arbor. Saw a tutorial from my favorite watchmaking youtuber on how to anneal the mainspring to make it pliable without breaking it and it worked, i think this will be adequate.
 
image.thumb.png.dd8abaf0b0bdbdcb8dff10cb6ef6f2ea.png
While it doesn't make a full loop, i don't think i could have done that without breaking it the inner coil is considerably tighter than it was and i think once the arbor is in, if i can get it in it will hug it with a good bit of tension. Hopefully. I've heard from 3 people generics do not fit this particular weird arbor and NOS mainspring will be about 50 bucks which i'd like to avoid. 

Next up, i wanted to make it flat as it was quite warped in the inner coils as you can see. I've never tried to flatten a mainspring with most of the twists in the inner coil and it was driving me nuts. Having it flat on my matt there were so many twists it was almost impossible to tell where they were and what wasn't making it flat and everytime i twisted something because it laid on the mat it was adding a twist somewhere else so i decided to try something smarter and made this little setup so i could see it's natural shape without it's own weight throwing anything off.
image.thumb.png.a562cba3bcab092d5c255866026d09c8.png

After wheel spinning for 2 hours the other way without much progress this worked REAL well! That's a pretty flat boy.
image.thumb.png.90760024f5c8b486a2148153b9f22cac.png
If all goes as planned i hope to have her on my wrist by the end of the weekend!

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, rossjackson01 said:

Birddad

Any chance you could show a close up of the arbour on those winders? I have Chinese set, and the holder is part of the arbour left after milling. Do yours extrude? 

If i don't post a pic tomorrow ping me and remind me. Iirc on the chinese winders the arbor hook is brass? On the bergeon ones it's steel.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Ah so its you thats buying up all the DD calibres 🤨.
    • Hi Richard,  I keep buying CAL.59 movements to practice on 🙂 Not started yet though, I'm gathering tools and building my confidence to start.
    • Problem solved. For some bizarre reason, the hook on the wall of this barrel is not properly centered vertically, but is oddly high on the wall, maybe 3/4 up the way up. When replacing the mainspring, this caused the outer coil to be displaced upwards as well such that it protrudes out of the barrel and caused the barrel lid to not sit quite flush to the barrel. Since this is a motor barrel, the lid is actually the first wheel and inner coil tube/hook all in one piece, with no “snap down” action that would have made the problem more immediately obvious. Maybe with an older mainspring the spring’s end hole was enlarged such that this wasn’t an issue, but hard to say how it ever worked otherwise. Replacing the barrel with one from a different model 1900 where the hook was properly vertically centered allowed the lid to sit flush without mainspring interference and the friction problem went away. The bridge was far too thick to be bent (and isn’t), for those of you thinking that was the problem. Placing the removable arbor in the watch without the rest of the barrel proved that the proper end shake was actually there as long as the overall height of the assembled barrel was correct.
    • You are so true on a lot of what you have said. The main reason for changing the mainspring even if the old one is in good order is because it will take out your thinking that the mainspring is contributing to poor power output or fluctuations in amplitude. If a new spring is fitted that box can be crossed off as a potential source of a problem. Most customers are happy to pay the extra £20 for a new mainspring if they are already parting with a couple of hundred pounds for a service. A new spring is an investment for good running for the future.
    • According to Borel the 814 and 815 use the same escape wheel. It's kind of an oddball being so long.
×
×
  • Create New...