Jump to content

2893-2 with wrong gear ratios??!!


Recommended Posts

So I have two of the ETA2893-2 movements. One I harvested from a Bulova c869881. And one that I bought "factory new" from those kind Swiss people on Ebay that sell all sorts of Swiss watch parts.

Here is the baffling thing. On the "factory new" version, the 24h wheel lags behind the date indicator drive wheel. Because these both make one full rotation per 24 hour period, they should move identically. And they DO on the movement that I pulled from the Bulova. But on the other one they DO NOT turn at the same rate. For every full turn of the date indicator drive wheel the 24h hand wheel ends up about 1.25 hours short. Or, to put it another way, the date will change at a different time each day until, after 15 days, the date indicator will be 1 full day off. 

Now I know from mechanics that gear ratios are fixed. Which is why I cannot even imagine where the fault is with this movement. Nothing is slipping. And, like I mentioned, it's a brand new movement. 

Any ideas on where to look for the cause of this? (BTW, I've already done a full tear down and service of the one pulled from the Bulova. So complete disassembly won't be a problem if that is what is needed.) Thanks!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just a thought, is the Bulova a GMT complication, but the other a moon phase complication? Not even sure if that would result in the miss-match that you are seeing but it may do.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The 2893-2 is actually a 2892-2 which is slightly rebuild with a new setup of gears.
The hour indicator driving wheel together with the universal hour indicator are the parts that makes you get the GMT 24-hour indication. So, it is not a pure 24-Hour drive.

Otherwise for the date part it is the original setup of gears that will interact.
The watch itself work with a 12-hour setup which is geared as usual.
You got the minute wheel driving the ordinary hour wheel, the hour wheel drives the intermediate date wheel, the intermediate date wheel is driving the date indicator driving wheel.

In a genuine movement it is quite hard to alter the gear ratios since it will affect the diameter of the wheels. The diameter difference will be easy to spot or even make the wheel train go so heavy the movement will stop.

If this “factory new” movement is missing a day after 15 days I would suggest the date indicator is not turning correctly and is skipping a date change, either from bad lubrication causing the finger on the date indicator driving wheel to slip.

If you bought it as a factory new movement you should return the movement to those Swiss people at Ebay that sells all kinds of Swiss watch parts 😉.

2893-2.thumb.png.ea02abf29905bb9b4132bdb6b78a6377.png

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I figured it out.

The Intermediate Date Wheel was not seated properly. Instead of engaging with the bottom set of teeth of the hour wheel it was engaging the top set of teeth. Turns out these are different ratios. The two different sets of teeth on the hour wheel are different but close enough that they can both engage the Intermediate Date Wheel. And that's why the timing of the date change wasn't happening at exactly 24 hour intervals.

Thanks for the input everyone. I appreciate it! 

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yes they all used to chop marks but this guy was so over the top and passionate about it that it still stands out in my memory so vividly.
    • On a different post we were discussing units of measurements. Not wanting to highjack the post, I  thought we could discuss here.  What is the origin of Dennison's. @Waggyonly one lecturer insisting on units of measurement, all mine did.  
    • I used to have a lecturer during my Engineering classes who was always beating a drum about quoting units, I remember one day he was so exasperated with our class he said "quote your units!!!!...I don't care what units JUST QUOTE THEM!!!" My next assignment I calculated the velocity and quoted the units, something along the lines of: "Thus the velocity of the body will be 0.00345 furlongs per fortnight" He graded my work as an F, then crossed it out and gave me an A+, turns out he had a sense of humor after all.
    • Just to add to what @Neverenoughwatches says, the impulse jewel on the balance wheel is also held in by shellac, so avoid exposing the assembly to IPA as well - as stated the one-dip and generic tetrachloroethylene equivalent is safe with shellac so you can use this for your pallet fork and balance assembly. I agree, but worth noting that IPA readily soaks up water, even from the atmosphere: "IPA exposed to the air will absorb moisture rapidly until it reaches an equilibrium value of 65% IPA to 35% water." So you need to refresh it regularly.     
    • The width is otherwise known as mainspring height and strength as thickness for us more modern guys.
×
×
  • Create New...