Jump to content

Interchangeable ETA parts


AP1875

Recommended Posts

I’ve got some spare parts lying round and the plan was to use them for a custom project watch.

 

I’ve used the following parts

 

ETA 2840 gear train, barrel, motion works, pallets and balance.

 

Clone 2824 keyless

 

ETA 2824 main plate

 

I’ve assembled everything up to the pallets and it all works nicely however, I can’t for the life of me to get the pallet fork to work with the 2840 escape wheel. I was under the impression the 2840 was just a cheaper version of the 2824 used in swatch watches with no calendar works or hooks for the dial feet.

 

Should these parts be interchangeable and this is worth persevering with or have I hit a dead end?

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2824 is a 28800 hertz movement and the 2840 is only 21600 hz so they wont work together. I don't know if you using the 2824 pallet fork or 2840 pallet fork? Maybe the mainplate has a different distance between the escape wheel and pallet fork? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2824 is a 28800 hertz movement and the 2840 is only 21600 hz so they wont work together. I don't know if you using the 2824 pallet fork or 2840 pallet fork? Maybe the mainplate has a different distance between the escape wheel and pallet fork? 



I’ve seen people use 3 hz 2840 parts with a clone 2824 main plate before with no problems. I’m using the 2840 pallets and balance.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

38 minutes ago, AP1875 said:

Only difference is I’m using an eta 2824-1


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

There is some difference between the 2824 and the 2824-1,2.  Have you checked the pallet fork. Maybe the stones has moved? 

Are you using the 2840 escape wheel to? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is some difference between the 2824 and the 2824-1,2.  Have you checked the pallet fork. Maybe the stones has moved? 
Are you using the 2840 escape wheel to? 


Sorry I should’ve just said 2824-1 from the beginning I have just added confusion by saying 2824.

I’m using a 2824-1 mainplate.

I believe the only difference from 2824-1 to the 2824-2 is the keyless works.

I have tried 2 2840 pallet forks, so it’s either me or it’s not meant to be. I am using the 2840 escape wheel.

I might pick up a 2824-2 mainplate on eBay they’re only €10 and give it one last try.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, AP1875 said:

 


Sorry I should’ve just said 2824-1 from the beginning I have just added confusion by saying 2824.

I’m using a 2824-1 mainplate.

I believe the only difference from 2824-1 to the 2824-2 is the keyless works.

I have tried 2 2840 pallet forks, so it’s either me or it’s not meant to be. I am using the 2840 escape wheel.

I might pick up a 2824-2 mainplate on eBay they’re only €10 and give it one last try.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

Hope it works out. Let us know how you get along. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • After a bit further research could it possibly be an AS 970?
    • Latest project was a non-running ebay purchase with an FHF70 movement. I stripped and cleaned it, reassembled it, and got it running. So far so good, nothing damaged AFAIK.  I was oiling the top jewel on the balance (the one in the cock) which was a slightly unusual shock setting. I removed the spring (3 leaves) which was part of a chaton holding the cap jewel. This left the hole jewel behind which I retrieved with rodico and then lost it. I was taking it off the rodico, very gently as I thought, with tweezers, and then it just disappeared.  Fast forward a week, I got a donor movement, non-running, with the plan to just take the shock jewel that I’d lost. It was the same movement but had standard incabloc settings, and was steel rather than copper/brass.  I changed the cock and balance complete and it ran, not very well. I switched the lower jewel setting, cleaned and oiled both jewels and the replacement balance. Without the pallet fork the balance swings very nicely with a puff of air. With the fork in place, balance out, it flicks side to side nicely with power in the mainspring.  Put them together and it doesn’t run. The impulse jewel sits in the fork and it stops.      Any suggestions how I proceed? In case you didn’t follow that I have 2 FHF70 movements, nothing broken as far as I can tell, but mixing up the balance wheels and jewel settings results in a non runner. 
    • Oh and this almost perfect third wheel pivot and slightly set mainspring  Ah ok yes i see what you mean, good idea. I'll try that if i fluff this one up. The image isn't great quality but i like the idea though.
    • Why cut the paper, cut a square around the image and grind to it. 
    • I did try that last time Rich , i traced the image from the Bestfit book which is the actual size. But its more difficut to cut the shape from paper than it is to grind the steel to shape. This way is pretty easy and the final shaping is done when fitting the part. There are a couple of things i will do differently next time, clamping the 2 pieces together with a drill press will help to hold while scribing the shape in. This was a bit tricky having only one hole, if using the pins and cork the drill size needs to match the pin diameter so there is no movement at all from the template. This movement hasn't finished frying me yet, damaged thread in the plate crown wheel hole and two rubbed in cracked jewels, thats gonna be much more fun.
×
×
  • Create New...