Jump to content

Chinese ‘Horia’

chadders1966

By chadders1966
in Tools & Equipment

 Share

Recommended Posts

chadders1966 WRT Addict

chadders1966

Posted
Posted

Hi

Thought I’d post about this tool I’ve bought via Aliexpress. I think it was listed as a Horia clone but seems very well made to me. I have a second hand Horia with a 3mm bore, this has a 4mm. Can’t see that much difference really, but I actually bought it more for the anvils and pushers which cost a fortune for the Horia ones.

I got it in a sale so all items together cost me £140. Even if I’d been charged VAT etc. it would only have been an extra £35ish. The price for brand new Horia 4mm tool, pushers and anvils on Cousins is currently £1800, so a bit of a saving. The whole lot seem well made and finished, measurements are accurate.7D86ED22-8503-422C-9084-E411F70837C8.thumb.jpeg.e0d55da496817653aa38fa5b0128cf21.jpeg

  • Like 2
chadders1966 WRT Addict

chadders1966

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Yes, I remember seeing that thread before now thanks, interesting stuff. As I said I already have a Horia tool, and a Seitz set as well. Personally I prefer the micrometer style control of the Horia over the lever style as I find the more precise control useful for a number of operations.

As mentioned I was attracted to this tool mainly for the pushers and anvils, a lot more sizes than come with the Seitz, although not the variety and a fraction of the price of the Horia equivalent. What struck me was the standard and finish of all components, better than I expected for the price. Although I am usually an advocate of good second hand tools over cheaper, less well made new ones, I do wonder with this one. Anyway I thought it was worth mentioning as an option because of quality and value.

  • Like 1
jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
12 hours ago, chadders1966 said:

As I said I already have a Horia tool, and a Seitz set as well.

Look like you're well set when it comes to precise pressing then :)

12 hours ago, chadders1966 said:

As mentioned I was attracted to this tool mainly for the pushers and anvils, a lot more sizes than come with the Seitz, although not the variety and a fraction of the price of the Horia equivalent.

I think that as long one has enough time and a lathe, the real watchmaker approach is to turn your own piece for the job at hand.

chadders1966 WRT Addict

chadders1966

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I understand what you mean and I think that, provided you have the equipment as you say, it is a good idea to know how to make items yourself. You never know when you might have to do so, particularly with obsolete parts for old watches.

However if you can easily pick the items up for less than a couple of quid a piece like I did in this instance I am not going to spend the time and effort making it. If that makes me not a ‘real watchmaker’ that’s fine as I wouldn’t  claim to be one anyway - whatever’s simplest and easiest suits me fine ;).

  • Like 1
jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
33 minutes ago, chadders1966 said:

If that makes me not a ‘real watchmaker’ that’s fine as I wouldn’t  claim to be one anyway - whatever’s simplest and easiest suits me fine ;).

Neither am I and normally I also aim for effectiveness and simplification but especially at this time of long days at home I become really fond of my small lathe (not a watchmaker's) which is giving me a lot of satisfaction. 

  • Like 1
chadders1966 WRT Addict

chadders1966

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I certainly agree with you there. In the last few weeks I’ve been enjoying myself making some interesting tools on my Sherline mill/lathe that I’ve never found time to do before. Although as usual with me I haven’t actually finished any yet. I need to get back to working on watches :)!

AP1875 WRT Addict

AP1875

Posted
Posted (edited)

I really like this set, it has worked perfectly for me a few times.

What I don’t like is I overpaid a lot for it! The seller has dropped his price quite a lot. I don’t know why now, I was watching this item for a while and the price fluctuated maybe 5 or 10 pounds during that time.

(also the listed price now is not the cheapest it’s been either!)

Edited by AP1875
jdm Distinguished Member

jdm

Posted
Posted
2 minutes ago, AP1875 said:

What I don’t like is I overpaid a lot for it! The seller has dropped his price quite a lot. I don’t know why now, I was watching this item for a while and the price fluctuated maybe 5 or 10 pounds during that time. (also the listed price now is not the cheapest it’s been either!)

AliX sellers are extremely wary of their prices in relation to competition. On items, like this one, that just few sellers carry they will happily apply a higher margin. And a much higher one when they are only one carrying a particular item  - something that usually doesn't last long, but it happens nevertheless. I have seen specialized items which were cheaper to purchase in EU with VAT and all, than on AliX. Notified the seller and they didn't care.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • RichardHarris123
      Hello from Denmark

      By RichardHarris123 · Posted

      Hello and welcome from Leeds, England. 
    • Birbdad
      Regulating is too touchy

      By Birbdad · Posted

      I agree with hector it's probably the regulator curve, it almost always is on these movements. So i work on these movements a lot and iv'e managed to fairly consistently get them running at like 50 degrees more amplitude than that with deltas in the 3 range and on the wrist deviations of sub 1 second a day. They ALWAYS require work to get there though. The main thing is shaping the regulator curve and this is really finnicky and definitely something you practice on a movement you don't care about when you're new (I'm still new) but if the hairspring is flat and the coils are evenly spaced and the regulator curve is properly shaped and it's pretty wild how accurate these movements can get.  But, it does sound like your regulator curve maybe needs a bit of reshaping. You can easily mess up the watch learning to do this so warning if you don't want to live with your current results but I"m not an expert, it's just speculation but there's a pretty easy way to check.  This is a good video showing how to see if your terminal curve is properly shaped. Just make sure the regulator pins are open when you test this.   He takes off the balance wheel to shape it. I do it with the movement disassembled but the balance on the mainplate. I use a homemade tool from a sharpened dental pic to do the adjustments (Tiny tiny TINY adjustments) and i use the regulator pins themselves to sorta brace the spring against to bend it very tiny amounts and just keep checking it by moving the regulator arm down it till it stops moving the hairspring. Taking off the balance wheel over and over again is a good way to slip and destroy your hairspring and will make the process way slower. I try to avoid removing the balance wheel from the cock it on these movements due to how difficult it is to get the hairspring stud back into the balance cock. It's super easy to slip and twist your spring then you got way worse problems.  Since these are mass manufactured and unadjusted the regulator curve is NEVER perfect but once you learn how to reshape them it's pretty easy to do and you can get REALLY low deltas with really low positional error and pretty remarkable accuracy.  Definitely with it powered down and the balance on the movement with both balance jewels in place look across the spring to see if it's perfectly flat, then check the regulator curve how he does it in the video. I would bet money even if it's not your main issue the regulator curve is not ideal also. 
    • Embezelled
      Where it begins

      By Embezelled · Posted

      Thanks. Damn, first breakage. This picture of the movement is from the sale listing.  
    • AdsettsEdberg
      Hello from Denmark

      By AdsettsEdberg · Posted

      Hello all, New member here, hoping  to gain knowledge about something that has been of interest for years.  Cheers!
    • AndyGSi
      Where it begins

      By AndyGSi · Posted

      So the stem is snapped and will need replacing but luckily there's enough left in the crown to unscrew without a problem. Will need to see photos of the movement to identify it.
×
×
  • Create New...