Jump to content

My late Grandfather's Olivia manual wind watch restoration; balance staff advice please.


Recommended Posts

Hi there,

New to the hobby and have watched all of Mark's courses - absolutely brilliant. I have practiced breaking down and reassembling a few old pocket watch movements from eBay and feel ready to start my quest to repair my Grandfather's Olivia 17 jewel manual wind watch (an EB 8385-66). From the research I've completed, I understand that the EB 8385 is the model and the 66 denotes the year of manufacture - 1966 - a great year I'm sure many of you will agree! The model was stamped just under the balance  wheel.

It's a non runner and with my new found knowledge I inspected the balance fist to see a broken balance staff pinion. The good news is that there is still power coming through to the pallet fork which is flicking back and fourth nicely with my tweezers, so I'm hoping I just need a new balance staff.

I have ordered a donor watch off of e-bay and plan to take the balance from that and hope that it fits in my Grandad's watch - I can't tell if it's an exact match until it arrives, but I'm hopeful.

What I'd really like to do is replace the balance staff on the original parts, so the heart of his watch is mainly complete - hair spring, balance wheel, bridge etc. I have watched Mark's and others' tutorials on removing and replacing a balance staff, and whilst it looks very difficult, I feel I'd like to try.

So that would mean me getting a staking set etc, but I really need to know which balance staff to order.

One of the kind members (watchweasol) on here suggested I google the ranfft website and I found the article below:

http://www.ranfft.de/cgi-bin/bidfun-db.cgi?10&ranfft&0&2uswk&EB_8385& 

This describes the balance staff as a U3110. I have googled this and can't find it other than what is described on the link above. 

If the donor watch I have ordered is potentially the wrong model, I won't be able to nab the balance staff from that, so wanted to look at options to order one on it's own.

So my question is does anyone know how I could order a U3110 balance staff?

Here is the watch to give the whole thread some context.

Thanks in advance for any help 🙂 

Rich

IMG_5314.jpeg

DSC02197.jpg

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The ranfft site is incredibly useful but the balance staff (and stem) reference numbers are based on codes used by Flume Technik so not overly useful unless ordering parts from Germany via https://www.flume.de/

More universal for balance staff references are Ronda numbers and in this respect https://www.balancestaffs.com/ is a useful reference. This site tell us you need a 5053 balance staff. Clearly you could use this site to buy from but also with the Ronda number you can more likely find on a site like ebay.

Also note that Cousins allows you to look up and order by Ronda number: https://www.cousinsuk.com/category/filter/ronda-staffs-by-ronda-number

Note that anything involving the balance in some way is undoubtedly what fills most people's swear jars the quickest. Balance staff replacement is something valuable to learn ... but not straight away on something (sentimentally) valuable. I'd therefore certainly recommend practicing on something else first.

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

17 minutes ago, WatchMaker said:

The ranfft site is incredibly useful but the balance staff (and stem) reference numbers are based on codes used by Flume Technik so not overly useful unless ordering parts from Germany via https://www.flume.de/

More universal for balance staff references are Ronda numbers and in this respect https://www.balancestaffs.com/ is a useful reference. This site tell us you need a 5053 balance staff. Clearly you could use this site to buy from but also with the Ronda number you can more likely find on a site like ebay.

Also note that Cousins allows you to look up and order by Ronda number: https://www.cousinsuk.com/category/filter/ronda-staffs-by-ronda-number

Note that anything involving the balance in some way is undoubtedly what fills most people's swear jars the quickest. Balance staff replacement is something valuable to learn ... but not straight away on something (sentimentally) valuable. I'd therefore certainly recommend practicing on something else first.

What excellent advice Watchmaker - thank you so much. Also for the warning - I will practice for sure before I attempt it. Trouble is Mark makes everything look so easy in his videos! I'll be sure to let you all know how I get on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, RichDavis said:

What excellent advice Watchmaker - thank you so much. Also for the warning - I will practice for sure before I attempt it. Trouble is Mark makes everything look so easy in his videos! I'll be sure to let you all know how I get on.

Hi Rich, didnt anyone pick up on the 1966 ? 🤦‍♂️. Have a look at Marshall on wristwatch revival. He's a good amateur.  There is one where he replaces a balance staff, only his second time. Sometimes good to watch an enthusiast on tenderhooks. This is the one reason I got a staking set, as broken balance pivots crop up regularly.  I have a few to sort out. One on a lovely venus. Not yet had a go though, so I'm not your man for advice on the process, only on what I've watched. Definitely  good advice to practice on something  else less valuable. I practised over and over with mainsprings replacing by hand. My grandfather's had a few issues, my first repair. I worked through them and it got me into this hobby. If you have the same movement ordered then it's liable  to be a fit. As a compromise how about just taking the balance staff roller and the balance wheel from the the donor, that way all you are doing is taking off the hairspring and cock. Only a few small procedures to work though, leaving out possibly th e most destructive and risky 🤷‍♂️ I had a similar  dilemma with my first, what to change what not to. Obviously  sentimental and want to retain as much as possible, but you might end up breaking your original balance wheel , roller ,impulse

Edited by Neverenoughwatches
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Hi Rich, didnt anyone pick up on the 1966 ? 🤦‍♂️. Have a look at Marshall on wristwatch revival. He's a good amateur.  There is one where he replaces a balance staff, only his second time. Sometimes good to watch an enthusiast on tenderhooks. This is the one reason I got a staking set, as broken balance pivots crop up regularly.  I have a few to sort out. One on a lovely venus. Not yet had a go though, so I'm not your man for advice on the process, only on what I've watched. Definitely  good advice to practice on something  else less valuable. I practised over and over with mainsprings replacing by hand. My grandfather's had a few issues, my first repair. I worked through them and it got me into this hobby. If you have the same movement ordered then it's liable  to be a fit. As a compromise how about just taking the balance staff roller and the balance wheel from the the donor, that way all you are doing is taking off the hairspring and cock. Only a few small procedures to work though, leaving out possibly th e most destructive and risky 🤷‍♂️ I had a similar  dilemma with my first, what to change what not to. Obviously  sentimental and want to retain as much as possible, but you might end up breaking your original balance wheel , roller ,impulse

How much have you done on repairing. Do you feel confident removing hairsprings ?

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Hi Rich, didnt anyone pick up on the 1966 ? 🤦‍♂️. Have a look at Marshall on wristwatch revival. He's a good amateur.  There is one where he replaces a balance staff, only his second time. Sometimes good to watch an enthusiast on tenderhooks. This is the one reason I got a staking set, as broken balance pivots crop up regularly.  I have a few to sort out. One on a lovely venus. Not yet had a go though, so I'm not your man for advice on the process, only on what I've watched. Definitely  good advice to practice on something  else less valuable. I practised over and over with mainsprings replacing by hand. My grandfather's had a few issues, my first repair. I worked through them and it got me into this hobby. If you have the same movement ordered then it's liable  to be a fit. As a compromise how about just taking the balance staff roller and the balance wheel from the the donor, that way all you are doing is taking off the hairspring and cock. Only a few small procedures to work though, leaving out possibly th e most destructive and risky 🤷‍♂️ I had a similar  dilemma with my first, what to change what not to. Obviously  sentimental and want to retain as much as possible, but you might end up breaking your original balance wheel , roller ,impulse

I thought a few more would have 😉 ⚽️ 

Thanks so much for the feedback. Yes, I watched Marshal replace that balance staff and coupled with Mark’s videos gave me the confidence that I could try it; subject to me getting the tools I’d need. 

Good thinking on the other option for repair maintaining a bit more of the original. I’ll see what the donor looks like and give it some thought. 
 

Really appreciate everyone’s feedback ☺️

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Neverenoughwatches said:

How much have you done on repairing. Do you feel confident removing hairsprings ?

Well it would be my first time, but I’ve watched many tutorials and will practice on something less important to me first. 😎👍🏼 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, watchweasol said:

 Hi Should you be unable to get a staff Have a look at the Jules Borel site under the JBC database the EB(bettelach) is listed and the balance complete is $21.60.

The staff is listed in the  balancestaffs.com catalogue as BS5596 @24.95 euros.

Thanks again. I’ll take a look at that. ☺️👍🏼

Link to comment
Share on other sites

21 minutes ago, RichDavis said:

Well it would be my first time, but I’ve watched many tutorials and will practice on something less important to me first. 😎👍🏼 

Delicate little monkeys they are. This is when you will find out how steady your hands really are. Some very small tweezers and nerves of steel lol. Be as careful as you can, any distortion in the hairspring you create can be a real bugger to sort out later. Just a little tip with the hand shake, make sure your blood sugar is steady. It's so noticeable at this level. Blood sugar is always more stable in the afternoon, I'd be looking at an hour or so after dinner. Sometimes just a glass of good natural fruit juice will help raise it temporarily. Never thought what I knew about diet would be applied to watches.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Neverenoughwatches said:

Delicate little monkeys they are. This is when you will find out how steady your hands really are. Some very small tweezers and nerves of steel lol. Be as careful as you can, any distortion in the hairspring you create can be a real bugger to sort out later. Just a little tip with the hand shake, make sure your blood sugar is steady. It's so noticeable at this level. Blood sugar is always more stable in the afternoon, I'd be looking at an hour or so after dinner. Sometimes just a glass of good natural fruit juice will help raise it temporarily. Never thought what I knew about diet would be applied to watches.

Good advice for sure - thank you. I will try the fruit juice thing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, RichDavis said:

Good advice for sure - thank you. I will try the fruit juice thing.

Hi Rich. I realised my  blood sugar level as soon as I went down to hairspring manipulation, it's so obvious there. If you think you have steady hands wait till you get on with that lol. Definitely  something  you don't want to attemp with a rumbling tummy haha. picked the fruit juice tip up from kalle of chronoglide . 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Drilling is going to be difficult, firstly because the drill bits are so thin and brittle, expect to break a few. The second issue is access to the 'hole', as the other lug will be in the way, meaning that you will have to drill at a slight angle, putting a bending stress on the drill bit and with the slightest drop in concentration .... and back to my first point. I would be tempted to grind them flat with a Dremel type tool or small jewelers file, and then put a center punch in the center of the bit to be drilled so the drill bit doesn't skip around and break... but expect this to be slow and frustrating work. By the time you have done 4 of these you'll be an expert and can come back and tell us all the best way to do it if you go down this route. However, I would seriously consider What @watchweasol said and drill from the outside-in, this will ensure straight holes without having to work around the other lugs. It may be worthwhile making yourself a simple paper template so you can be sure to match the position of each hole before drilling. In the end you will be left with 4 holes on the outside of the lugs, but many cases are made this way and unless you are looking for it you probably won't notice or realise that it's not the way the watch was meant to be in the first place.
    • What works for me (waiting for the villagers to assemble with torches and pitchforks) is to put a liberal (in watch terms) spot of 9010 on one of the pins of the pin pallet, this seems to improve amplitude and beat error.
    • Non-magnetic is a poor description of such a hairspring. A better description would be unmagnetisable hairspring. There are metals and alloys that are attracted to magnets, but don’t become magnetised themselves. A hairspring made out such a material will be attracted to magnetised tweezers, but will not become magnetised. These hairsprings can be disrupted by being in close proximity to a magnet, but the disruption will cease the moment the magnet is moved away. These are hairsprings that could conceivably be disrupted by a magnetised hairspring stud. Best Regards, Mark
    • More than enough. Here's mine at the height I work at. I think the working distance with the included 0.5x Barlow lens is about 9".   So yes, that halves the magnification. The full story is the objective lens goes from 0.7x to 4.5x. The eyepieces are 10x, giving you the advertised magnification of 7x-45x. However the working distance is unacceptably short, so it comes with an 0.5x Barlow lens, reducing the magnification range to 3.5x-22.5x, but giving you a good working distance. What I did was buy a pair of Extreme Widefield 20x Eyepieces for when I need more magnification. You keep your high working distance, but get your 45x magnification back, at the cost of some width of field.
    • Modern ones after blue steel, invar, elinvar and nivarox , the shiny one are not supposed to become magnetised. But i have had them jump to tweezers. And i dont really understand the comment that what can be magnetised is the stud carrier and rate regulator and they can attract the hairspring ? If the hairspring is non magnetic then how can it be attracted to something else thats become magnetise, its non magnetic , that doesn't really make sense to be ?
×
×
  • Create New...