Jump to content

Would this barrel hold a new spring?


quantieme

Recommended Posts

This might be a stupid question but given the crack in this barrel would it be strong enough to hold a new spring or can the crack be repaired and if so by what method. I will search for a new barrel but just in case I cannot locate one I thought I’d get some opinions. Barrel is 32.6 mm in dia x 35.6 at splined end x 23 mm high if someone knows of one. Thanks.

1503AF3E-5061-414D-B02B-FEFA7E08A1A3.jpeg

909EC141-C4BC-4818-B7F4-6ABA67D771FD.jpeg

446B7AAF-19A4-4C20-AEA1-E061EE92E09B.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Do not put a spring in it with a crack in the barrel like that.

At some point it will fail with spectacular results.

If you cant find a replacement barrel it will need to be repaired.

The tube part is just soft soldered to the wheel, it will need to be desoldered and a new tube and possibly end cap will need to be made to fit unless you can find a donor barrel of the same diameter and height that can also be desldered and fitted to the wheel. The endcap from the donor barrel tube would need to be bushed to fit the arbor too obviously.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That is not the correct way to go. No offence, but if a clock had come to me like that some of these types of repairs that are being suggest I would class them as bodged up repairs. They would be replaced by the method suggested by Tmuir and myself. Clocks should be repaired/restored correctly or not at all.   

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Soft solder would not be strong enough for that anyway. If you really wanted to re-use that barrel wall, then you'd possibly move the hooking point to another part of the wall and then hard solder the crack. A waste of effort when you can do a better job by replacing in my opinion. It was quite possibly caused by a previous mainspring breaking as the sudden expansion of the spring can destroy the barrel. Been there, done that!

Edited by rodabod
Link to comment
Share on other sites

The other issue with the soft solder repair you are suggesting is the crack is up the the hook which has been riveted in place, so the crack will of weakened that too. If you soft solder it you may still find the hook pulls out of the barrel with bad results.

I know its more work but repairing a cracked barrel tube with soft solder is not an option.

Soft solder is great for 'sticking' things together, but is not good for items under stress like a barrel with a spring inside it.

That is why you can use it to soft solder the tube to the wheel as it is not under great stress there like it would be holding the barrel together.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, oldhippy said:

 

That is not the correct way to go. No offence, but if a clock had come to me like that some of these types of repairs that are being suggest I would class them as bodged up repairs. They would be replaced by the method suggested by Tmuir and myself. Clocks should be repaired/restored correctly or not at all.   

no offence taken, that is why i ask questions on this site to get professional opinions. i absolutely hate bodged repairs so i will go with the replacement barrel option. I would never have been 100 per cent happy with a non standard repair.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, rodabod said:

Soft solder would not be strong enough for that anyway. If you really wanted to re-use that barrel wall, then you'd possibly move the hooking point to another part of the wall and then hard solder the crack. A waste of effort when you can do a better job by replacing in my opinion. It was quite possibly caused by a previous mainspring breaking as the sudden expansion of the spring can destroy the barrel. Been there, done that!

yes the spring was broken in that barrel which is what probably caused the crack in the first place.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Finger trouble.

Toothed end                     Dia                        Height

36.6                                    33.3                        25.3

36.1                                     33.6                        25.3

36.3                                      33.3                       25.5

36.5                                     33.3                         23.4

36.1                                       33.2                       25.4

36.6                                       33.4                        25.5

all french clock barrels, mougin feres etc if you want one or two message me ,  I am on facebook and email

 Weasol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Put the movement in a movement holder and it will be supported as you push down on the setting lever post to release the winding stem. Make sure the post is over the shoulder of the movement holder so what you are pressing down on is supported. As a general rule, hold the movement and not the movement holder. Replace the hands when the movement isn't in the case and support the centre jewel (if it has one) on a hard surface or staking block when replacing the hands to stop the jewel accidentally moving or even coming out. A dedicated movement holder with a central jewel support is even better, but pricey
    • It might help us if we knew which watch like model number.
    • Hi, guys I have a bit of a predicament and hopefully, somebody can advise. I'm working on a Roamer MST 521 where the movement is extracted from the crystal side. I'm now at the final hurdle where I need to replace the movement back into its case but I'm not sure of the correct procedure. I still need to fit the hands but that's where the problem lies. If I insert the winding stem to test the hands for correct alignment I will need to turn the movement over to release the stem again it's the spring-loaded type and needs a small bit of force to push down but with the hands fitted, I don't think I can do this on a cushion without causing some damage to the hands and that's the last thing I want to do, this watch has already been a love-hate relationship and I'm so close to boxing this one off which I'm counting as my first major project.  The other option is to case the movement then fit the hands and hope everything is okay. I've already broken the original winding stem but managed to find a replacement, the last one in stock, so I'm a bit reluctant to keep removing it. Any suggestions would be appreciated. 
    • I would go for the dearer spring. You won't need to remove the spring from the carrier ring and then use a mainspring winder to get it into the barrel, for a start. Also that spring is closer to the needed dimensions, especially the length. The length plays a part in the mainsprings strength. If you double the length you will half the force (strength) of the spring and vice-versa. A spring with 20 mm less length would be about 7% shorter, so technically would be 7% more strength, but I find halving this number is closer to real-world findings, so the spring would be about 3 to 4% more strength/force. On a mainspring that ideally kicks out 300 degrees of amplitude, a 3% increase in amplitude would be 309 degrees. Increasing or decreasing the length of the mainspring will affect the power reserve to a greater or lesser degree. It depends how much shorter or longer it is. I've attached a lesson regarding mainsprings, focussing on the size and strength of the spring within the barrel, you might find helpful. Unfortunately it is a PDF converted from a PowerPoint presentation, but only a slide was lost that was originally a video of fitting a mainspring   Lesson 5 The mainspring.pdf
×
×
  • Create New...