Jump to content

Renata vs Energizer Batteries which is better?


Recommended Posts

I use nothing but Renata as I've yet to have one leak and ruin a watch.  Not that that means anything.  It just has not happened to me yet.  I have had however, several watches with Energizers and others, that have leaked in the watch.  It would be nice if some of you who are in the watch repair field could weigh in on this.    Personally, it's totally unacceptable for a watch battery to leak.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, Khronos said:

 Personally, it's totally unacceptable for a watch battery to leak.

When the charge is exhausted, chemicals become acid and may corrode case and leak. I have never seen any battery manufactured promise in writing a protection for that.

Solution, do not leave discharged batteries in watches.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes, JDM, I totally agree, but the reality is people leave dead batteries in watches and some battery manufactures really do things on the cheap that make the problem way worse.  But yes, it's going to be a continuous problem.  The down side of batteries.  On a side note, I've had problems with AA and AAA batteries but since switching to Lithium the problem is gone.  The point is, I suspect the problem could be solved and yes, I'd be happy to pay twice or three times the price for such a quality battery. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 minutes ago, Khronos said:

The point is, I suspect the problem could be solved and yes, I'd be happy to pay twice or three times the price for such a quality battery. 

For the most common sizes, Renata now offers a Premium type. Among the features they list:

State of the art leak proofness thanks to a new sophisticated sealing process

So I have to stand corrected about makers not making claims in this area.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To  put my 5 eggs in,  I use Renata, Sony and Maxell and have never had a problem. I recently had a Ladies Rotary that the battery had leaked in. A local franchised shoe repairer had forced the battery out and  lost the insulator,  then told the owner that it was BER !. I gave it the treatment and it left me OK. I do not know what the original battery make was. (All made in China I believe) He was probably OK with boots and shoes !!!.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...
On 6/2/2018 at 12:53 PM, Khronos said:

I use nothing but Renata as I've yet to have one leak and ruin a watch.  Not that that means anything.  It just has not happened to me yet.  I have had however, several watches with Energizers and others, that have leaked in the watch.  It would be nice if some of you who are in the watch repair field could weigh in on this.    Personally, it's totally unacceptable for a watch battery to leak.

they both leak, the problem is to leave the dead battery inside to long, or if the watch is not sealed and moisture manages to get inside the watch that would also cause the battery to leak

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've seen many brands of batteries leak. But the question is whether they were original or fakes?

I suspect that some repairers are sourcing for the best bargains online. If you take a look at AliExpress and Amazon, there are batteries that are ridiculously cheap. Once it is out of its packaging, it would be really difficult to tell its authenticity. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Searching on Google according to them Renata are the best. They are also the battery of choice fitted by premier Swiss watch houses including Tag HEUER, Breitling, Chopard and even Rolex for their quartz collections.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Renata are part of the Swatch Group so I assume would have a vested interest in quality required for watches.  I always use Renata and have had no problems with leakage.  Leakage problems encountered usually due to low quality batteries or not silver oxide type fitted. Similarly I would expect Seizaiken (Seiko) batteries would be ok.

Edited by canthus
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 months later...

It depends, if you ask Americans they will tell you renata because Americans hate anything made in the USA, if you ask a outside the US people will tell you energizer because they like American stuff, in my own experience both batteries are good, same quality same battery, no difference.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Having only just started watch repairing I don't have a long history to refer back to, but I have looked a quite a few Quartz watches for friends and neighbours that have been left in draws for in some cases many years, so all the batteries were long dead.  Not one of them showed any sign of leaking, and all sprang into life with a new battery.

I did have some selection packs of Kodak branded watch batteries bought before I knew better, and some of those leaked whilst still in their packaging, so these were never used in a watch, but were used in other gadgets I had that needed small batteries.

I tend to buy Maxell for watches now.

On a side note in the electronic repair world Duracell and Energizer AA batteries are well know for their fondness to leak so don't risk anything from them these days.

Paul

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 years later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I didn't think pulling to set position would work harden the spring, in that position it is stressed where the arm starts. By work hardening i meant rapid polishing at that point, a bit like polishing a pivot work hardens as it compresses the steel. I doubt polishing by hand would achieve much in that respect though. Its finished, arm polished up mostly at the join to the bridge's main body. I'm ok with it, the screw holes aren't great as i had to open them up by redrilling and positioning it was difficult, I'm not much use with a loupe, opening up with a file might be a better option for me or i could just use the correct drill size 😅. And the detent is way too deep, i had to guess that with the stem release out of position and sat on top, but i only took one measure and went for it, no slowly slowly catch your monkey 😅. First go I'm happy , well sort of, it works and thats a big thing for me, next one will have a bit more finesse.  Anyone thats interested, after filing, i used a 2000 grade home made diamond  micro file and then 20 micron film, the film is much better than wet and dry, more stable to use and doesn't shed cheap grade grit everywhere , then auto polish on a sponge pad.
    • I'm assuming that every time you set the watch you are work hardening the detent spring, maximum hardening is  where it meets the plate due to maximum deflection.   That's why it snaps there.  The Young's modulus may be the same but after it's reached its maximum yeid strength it breaks.  My mechanic engineering is very rusty, correct me if I'm wrong. 
    • Ah ok yes that makes sense to polish it where the arm starts to form from the body of the bridge, i thought you meant the underneath of all the arm.
    • this is something I've never quite understood about the some of the Swiss companies. In 1957 Omega was using 9010 for the keyless parts with epilam. there's been a slow migration towards using heavier lubrication's but still typically oils and epilam to keep them in place. When it seems like 9504 works so much better.  
    • OK, welcome in the world of alarm clocks... I guess the 4th wheel is dished because it is from another movement. If it was not dishet, then it would not mesh with the pinion of the escape wheel, am I right? The marks of wear on the 4th wheel pinion doesn't corespond to the 3th wheel table position, at list this is what i see on the picts. Calculating the rate is easy - there is a formula - BR = T2 x T3 x T4 x T5 x 2 /(P3 x P4 x P5) where T2 - T5 are the counts of the teeth of the wheels tables, and P3 - P5 are the counts of the pinion leaves. Vibrating the balance is easy - grasp for the hairspring where it should stay in the regulator with tweasers, let the balance hang on the hairspring while the downside staff tip rests on glass surface. Then make the balance oscillate and use timer to measure the time for let say 50 oscillations, or count the oscillations for let say 30 seconds. You must do the free oscillations test to check the balance staff tips and the cone cup bearings for wear. This kind of staffs wear and need resharpening to restore the normal function of the balance.
×
×
  • Create New...