Jump to content
  • 0
quantieme

correct way to use alum any advice please

Question

hi, i have a broken screw and have tried the usual methods but to no avail so i have bought a 100 gram bag of alum but having never used it before i wondered what the correct method is. the plate is silvered brass from a pocket watch so do i soak the whole plate or just the part with the broken screw and what would be the quantity of alum to water, any advice appreciated, thank you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

15 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

First make sure the part you want to remove is steel and not any other metal. Also make sure no other steel parts are around as the alum is indiscriminate.

Next mix Alum with hot water and soak the part, after several hours try to scrape the broken screw out with a sharp pick, you will find it has turned to a rust like substance.

Repeat again after a few hours. Depending on the amount of alum dissolved you may need to mix a fresh batch. Most guys say that heat helps, personally I am in the tropics and haven't had to reheat, but mine usually takes around 6-10 days to get out completely. Heat may help but I can wait.

Anilv

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Once you are sure the only steel part is the one you want to remove, mix as much alum as will dissolve in a small container (I use a tiny glass jar). I try to keep mine warm in a double boiler on very low (you want the solution warm, not hot), it allows more alum to dissolve in the water. After a couple of days, the broken screw will be gone. I usually only do this on weekends so I can keep an eye on it, and add water if necessary. Starting on Friday evening, the screw is usually gone by Sunday. 

If you don't heat it up, you may have to wait a bit longer as mentioned above. You will see the steel part turn black in a few hours, that's a sign that it's working. Be patient, an it will work.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
10 hours ago, anilv said:

First make sure the part you want to remove is steel and not any other metal. Also make sure no other steel parts are around as the alum is indiscriminate.

Next mix Alum with hot water and soak the part, after several hours try to scrape the broken screw out with a sharp pick, you will find it has turned to a rust like substance.

Repeat again after a few hours. Depending on the amount of alum dissolved you may need to mix a fresh batch. Most guys say that heat helps, personally I am in the tropics and haven't had to reheat, but mine usually takes around 6-10 days to get out completely. Heat may help but I can wait.

Anilv

thank you anilv will give it a go.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
30 minutes ago, frenchie said:

Once you are sure the only steel part is the one you want to remove, mix as much alum as will dissolve in a small container (I use a tiny glass jar). I try to keep mine warm in a double boiler on very low (you want the solution warm, not hot), it allows more alum to dissolve in the water. After a couple of days, the broken screw will be gone. I usually only do this on weekends so I can keep an eye on it, and add water if necessary. Starting on Friday evening, the screw is usually gone by Sunday. 

If you don't heat it up, you may have to wait a bit longer as mentioned above. You will see the steel part turn black in a few hours, that's a sign that it's working. Be patient, an it will work.

thank you, i have plenty of time so will try it out, is it best to soak the whole plate or just the part with the screw.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I just used Alum to remove a broken screw crown screw in this thread. I put 2 teaspoons of Alum to 5 tablespoons of water. I did have to heat the mixture. I sat it in a stainless steel dish on a heating pad. Within two days the screw was gone. With the heat I kept adding a tablespoon of water every 10-12 hours.

Good luck and as others stated any ferrous material will be damaged so be mindful!

Marvin repair and service 

https://www.watchrepairtalk.com/topic/8652-banking-question-not-certain/

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
6 hours ago, Gary said:

I just used Alum to remove a broken screw crown screw in this thread. I put 2 teaspoons of Alum to 5 tablespoons of water. I did have to heat the mixture. I sat it in a stainless steel dish on a heating pad. Within two days the screw was gone. With the heat I kept adding a tablespoon of water every 10-12 hours.

Good luck and as others stated any ferrous material will be damaged so be mindful!

Marvin repair and service 

https://www.watchrepairtalk.com/topic/8652-banking-question-not-certain/

 

many thanks, i now have enough info to give it a go

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

Slightly off watches, but having used this method successfully on broken stems in crowns in the past, I have moved onto larger items, namely removing a broken steel bleed nipple (circled, under the cloud of bubbles) from an aluminium motorcycle disc brake calliper. Not quite there yet after about 5 hours of gentle simmering, but heat certainly speeds things up...

20180417_223646r.jpg.d45e323057593594e0aa59c7da70de51.jpg

Note the item is placed in the alum solution within a glass pyrex bowl or it would eat the steel saucepan!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

I did this recently - made a hot solution of alum. Kept adding crystals until they wouldn't dissolve - so a saturated solution. Put the brass watch plate with broken steel screw in and put the lot in the ultrasonic. Left to cool. Checked the next day and reheated solution and repeated. Took a few days to dissolve the screw but it worked in the end.

Before

P3200009.thumb.JPG.1cf891e68336aed8279dce7073231b02.JPG

During - still a few bits left

P3240002.thumb.JPG.e8d2d200ee4e78babf811a9db4b7ac8b.JPG

After - all gone

 

P3240003.thumb.JPG.f59c07d96d01db5e7c3c631281160992.JPG

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
On 4/17/2018 at 7:57 AM, quantieme said:

thank you, i have plenty of time so will try it out, is it best to soak the whole plate or just the part with the screw.

Soaking the whole thing is usually easier, but as long as the steel part is submerged, you're all set.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0
First make sure the part you want to remove is steel and not any other metal.

Actually, the screw needs to be more closer to iron than a steel alloy for the reaction to be effective. For example if the screw is stainless steel the reaction just will not happen. So the older the movement the better your chances. Chromium, manganese and stainless steels weren’t around in the good old bad old days.

Make the solution as concentrated as possible by adding more and more alum to the boiling water until no more will dissolve. The reaction is faster if the alum solution is kept warm.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

After a total of about 50 hours of simmering in alum solution the bleed screw finally dissolved - the same area circled on the new screw measuring 12x6mm, with no adverse affect on the aluminium calliper:

20180425_183725r.jpg.ba17c07b5efc9e4a17c707512efff1bd.jpg

No drilling, damaged threads or seat, it goes to show how useful the skills learnt from watch making can be.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 0

thanks for all the advice, i have now successfully removed the screw, i soaked it for 3 days in an unheated solution and i have to say i was a bit sceptical as these things never seem to work for me but i checked it yesterday and it had gone black and just dissolved into mush, there was no damage to the thread or plate and i now have a new part and screw fitted. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Answer this question...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • HN Blair appears HERE....he would have been 50 in 1973......
    • Finally... Bush fitted - hole broached to the needed size, and the video below was the test fit to see if it all worked and looked OK. The wheels spins smoothly though all angles (it was not lubricated at this point) and the bearing endplay looks fine too. Not shown in the sequence but done anyway, was my attempt at polishing the pivot from the worn side. It was marked and oldhippy said it really should be done. I did not have any correct tools for this, but did have some hard pith wood and very fine rouge, so had a go with that, using a small hand-drill to spin the wheel. Before and after through the loupe did show a marked improvement, so was worth doing. (Naturally, I polished the pivot before broaching the pivot hole...) All I need to do now is to rebuild the works and sort out the escapement depthing and, hopefully, this old clock will keep time again. I would welcome comments, views on the process etc. as this was a learning task for me. I also have to say thanks to all who commented and gave tips earlier, as you certainly gave me the confidence to "have a go". Re-Bushed.mp4
    • This is an fusee English lever pocket watch. The customer said that it was only running for a few minutes and then stopping. On first inspection the amplitude was almost non existent but strangely was running. I presumed a good service would resolve this issue BUT alas the same issue. I stripped again and inspected every part with a microscope and found a bent safety pin + the banking pins had been bent. Apart from this I could not find anything. The balance pivots show some scoring but just a tiny touch it swings fine. Believe it or not, the amplitude now (see vid) is twice as much as what it was. My suspicion is the pallet is not the original and the horns are just a touch short so the impulse pin is not swinging the hairspring on impulse. Just wondering if anyone has come across this error,I'm a bit lost at present.   IMG_5211 (1).m4v    
    • Next step was to broach the pivot hole out to fit the pivot on the wheel. This was another "first" for me, so I read up, took my time and went for it. Cutting slowly from both sides, bit by bit and constantly try-fitting the wheel to check for fit and to make sure the hole was true. Also, refitting both plates with the wheel fitted to ensure there was no binding points. Finally, using the smoothing broach to harden the pivot hole, bearing surface.
    • The bush was fitted from the inside, again as required, without issue. I have an engineers flat surface which I used to get a true fit. Also, I had an appropriate sized flat headed stake in my staking set, so fitting the bush was a straightforward job. Apologies for the photo from the outside of the plate, as the focus point was off.
×
×
  • Create New...