Jump to content

Center Wheel Play- how much is too much?


Recommended Posts

Hello All,

I'm looking for a little insight from experience.  I've got a Valjoux 71 movement that I'm working on which has poor amplitude.  The mainspring looks fine (although a replacement will be in shortly) and I haven't found issues with he pivots or jewels yet.  The drum seems okay in it's bushings too.  The center wheel has quite a bit of play in my opinion though.  I've attached a vid from under the microscope as evidence.  Anyone with more knowledge on the subject (or experience) please chime in!   For the rest of us newbies, we can just take a vote- too much side shake?  Yes or No?

Thanks!

M20170616_006.mp4

Edited by RyMoeller
Remove duplicate link
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the input @clockboy, I thought it was pretty bad but appreciate the confirmation.

There is no center jewel for this movement.  I'll pull the center wheel and take a look at it though.  I'll see if I can get some good pictures of the hole too.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I think I see a repair by Mark where he fitted a jewel to support the centre wheel.

That will be helpful as it looks like I may have to go that route too.

Interestingly the hold doesn't really look worn- as you can see from the image attached the silver plating hasn't even worn off yet.

IMG_3021.thumb.JPG.14250f73e8b193b188e76f5d7cd6890c.JPG

The center wheel looks okay too.  Strange how the fit is so poor. 

IMG_3023.thumb.JPG.704d8d470de3dc04d4dc3998c85217d5.JPG

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Is it the original center wheel, or was it replaced by someone with something that was close to fitting?

That did occur to me.  I've spent the afternoon trying to track down an affordable replacement as opposed to modifying the plate (by adding a jewel or bushing).  There are a couple of other issues that suggest a less than stellar repair (one of the chronograph eccentrics has been glued into the top plate).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Hi Ry,

Cousins has a centre wheel but it's £26.

I can't play your video on an iPad, so can't comment on the fit.

S

No luck with Cousins I'm afraid.  They've got the chronograph runner (8000) but not the large center wheel (206).  I've got a few other places to check but thus far the only option is pretty expensive- $74 USD!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have just looked at the video and that is bad. If you decide to fit a jewel or a brass bush be careful when you to pushing the cannon pinion back on, you could push the jewel or bush out. The hole in the plate has some nasty scoring which looks as if at some point a hard piece of dirt has been stuck in the hole and has been rotating. The steel that the wheel has been made of is much harder then the bottom plate.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

No luck with Cousins I'm afraid.  They've got the chronograph runner (8000) but not the large center wheel (206).  I've got a few other places to check but thus far the only option is pretty expensive- $74 USD!

D'oh, sorry, brain not engaged.

Jules Borel lists a Valjoux 71 and a 71GHH; they list a stock number for part 206 against the GHH and a price of $14.30, but the stock code comes back as "no items found". Not sure what this means as I normally encounter in stock or out of stock. May be worth calling them.

At $72, it sounds like a brass bush would be a good option. I would be inclined to solder it in place to prevent the problem Oldhippy describes

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

I have just looked at the video and that is bad. If you decide to fit a jewel or a brass bush be careful when you to pushing the cannon pinion back on, you could push the jewel or bush out. The hole in the plate has some nasty scoring which looks as if at some point a hard piece of dirt has been stuck in the hole and has been rotating. The steel that the wheel has been made of is much harder then the bottom plate.

 

Ah thanks for the tip regarding the cannon pinion and a replacement jewel.  That's a headache I'd sure like to avoid!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

D'oh, sorry, brain not engaged.

Jules Borel lists a Valjoux 71 and a 71GHH; they list a stock number for part 206 against the GHH and a price of $14.30, but the stock code comes back as "no items found". Not sure what this means as I normally encounter in stock or out of stock. May be worth calling them.

At $72, it sounds like a brass bush would be a good option. I would be inclined to solder it in place to prevent the problem Oldhippy describes

I agree, it looks like a jewel or bushing is the way to go at this point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Thanks for the help guys! VWatchie I already found your thread but I'll check it again. Nice to know about acetone, I still have to get the shellac off since I made a little mess. I adjusted the jewel, put new shellac (the so called soldering technique, pallet tool too hot this time so the shellac "wire" melted in air before getting in contact with jewels or fork) rinsed the pallet fork and put it back dry. Amplitude is now in the 240-250 range that I expected in the first place. I guess there's enough oil in the escape wheel teeth already but I'll check that later. The mainspring was pretty beaten so a new one would probably boost the amplitude even further. Nice to learn new things. Now I have another thing to look for while disassembling. I wonder if the watch left the factory that way. 
    • Would be interesting to see it 🙂
    • These are all American movements (with the exception of the "Rubis"), and are all almost certainly "negative set" which means the stem is part of the case. So it's normal that they are all missing- they are with their cases. You will need male square bench keys to wind/disarm them. Vintagewatchstraps has a great writeup on the different systems. But basically, any American "x" size movement will fit any case for that size, possibly with some adjusting of the stem position. With Swiss movements, there is some interchangeability between calibers, usually within the same maker's range, but not really overall- there are thousands of different stems out there.
    • Hi, I'm very new to watchmaking and this is my first time posting here.  I've bought a lot of 10 vintage pocket watches size 0s from e-bay and just got them today.  Most of the balance wheels sprung quite freely and thus seemed like a worthy endeavor as a first batch for exploration.  I've just realized that none of them have any winding stems. Is there any way I could source appropriate winding stems for the movements? There seems to be assortments of various stems selling in bulk on aliexpress, but would any of them fit?  I've read on other threads that some people lathe their own stems (which is waaaay out of my current skill set, which is pretty much nil). Others say that you 'just have to try a few and see if they fit'. I would much appreciate any advice for this matter. Thanks!
    • Nice work.  In the last year, I have been servicing Accutron 218s.  I have the official Accutron hoder that provides electrical contact to the movement.  It is a pretty clever design.  There is a cut in the ring of the holder (shaped like a "C").  When in relaxed state, the holder is slightly smaller than the watch movement.  You spread the cut slightly and drop the movement in and release.  Very clean.  I have made 3D versions of this setup.  Have not explored using it generally for other movements.
×
×
  • Create New...