Jump to content

Wrong tool for the job


Recommended Posts

Tonight I ran into a problem winding a left handed mainspring. My mainspring winders are all right handed winders. Luckily, I have two winders in the size I needed. So I wound the spring into one, then carefully pressed it out into the other. Then into the barrel. Not ideal, but it works in a pinch.

  • Like 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember that Marc posted a simple but clever (to me anyway;)) suggestion last year on this. Have a collection of washers in different sizes, then it doesn't matter which way your winder goes. If you need to change orientation it you can transfer the mainspring to a washer, flip it over and press out. Saves having to have spare winders or buying another set going the other way.

 

Stephen

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember that Marc posted a simple but clever (to me anyway;)) suggestion last year on this. Have a collection of washers in different sizes, then it doesn't matter which way your winder goes. If you need to change orientation it you can transfer the mainspring to a washer, flip it over and press out. Saves having to have spare winders or buying another set going the other way.

 

Stephen

That is a good idea, too!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Tonight I ran into a problem winding a left handed mainspring. My mainspring winders are all right handed winders. Luckily, I have two winders in the size I needed. So I wound the spring into one, then carefully pressed it out into the other. Then into the barrel. Not ideal, but it works in a pinch.

That is a great idea. Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember that Marc posted a simple but clever (to me anyway;)) suggestion last year on this. Have a collection of washers in different sizes, then it doesn't matter which way your winder goes. If you need to change orientation it you can transfer the mainspring to a washer, flip it over and press out. Saves having to have spare winders or buying another set going the other way.

 

Stephen

Don't understand

Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, jdrichard said:

Don't understand

Simple. If you only have a right handed winder but your spring needs to be wound left handed, wind it up right handed but instead of installing it into the barrel, install it into a washer. Flip the washer over and then press it into the barrel as you would a new main spring. obviously the hole in the washer needs to be slightly smaller than the inner diameter of the barrel.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Simple. If you only have a right handed winder but your spring needs to be wound left handed, wind it up right handed but instead of installing it into the barrel, install it into a washer. Flip the washer over and then press it into the barrel as you would a new main spring. obviously the hole in the washer needs to be slightly smaller than the inner diameter of the barrel.

Got it, thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/5/2016 at 3:49 AM, UrgurTheGurgur said:

Tonight I ran into a problem winding a left handed mainspring. My mainspring winders are all right handed winders. Luckily, I have two winders in the size I needed. So I wound the spring into one, then carefully pressed it out into the other. Then into the barrel. Not ideal, but it works in a pinch.

Moved to Tutorials & Information section :)

Good tip - thanks for sharing.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Folkvisor said:

I recently found this on YouTube: Servicing an IWC FA Jones watch.

I can't find it on the videos on this site. Just wondering if it's there or will be put up soon. It's a beautiful watch and a very good video.

Dave

Lol - very big change in topic from "Wrong tool for the job" apologies to the OP.

@Folkvisor, I have added the video now: 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your solution to reverse winding was simple but affective like all good ideas.

I'm supposed to take the mainspring out of my 2836-2 movement by hand, clean it, lube it, and put it back by hand. I can see all sorts of problems with this. One of the main problems is that my hand would contaminate the spring with the sweat/oil from my hand and make it susceptible to rusting, etc. So, I'll buy a winder before I attempt this manoeuvre.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your solution to reverse winding was simple but affective like all good ideas.

I'm supposed to take the mainspring out of my 2836-2 movement by hand, clean it, lube it, and put it back by hand. I can see all sorts of problems with this. One of the main problems is that my hand would contaminate the spring with the sweat/oil from my hand and make it susceptible to rusting, etc. So, I'll buy a winder before I attempt this manoeuvre.

I have attempted to wind a couple automatic wristwatch mainsprings by hand. But never been successful. I can't get more than a few coils wound in before the while thing explodes in my hands(twss). I gave up trying and found a cheap set of used winders on eBay.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

But what about the opportunity to exercise the very thing that makes human hands such miracles of evolution - the ability to apply immense forces (clamping that damned bridle against the barrel wall) while dexterously holding a 10mm object and a loose, floppy spring end, and simultaneously winding and guiding the spring into the (virtual) center of the spring? Only to realize that you've wound the thing in backwards...

So on the other hand, humans also invented tools so that work was easier and more productive.  Buy the winder, Folkvisor...

Drat, can't "wriggle out of the crushing grip of reason" (Calvin and Hobbes quote, for those that are fans).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When done with the barrel on the bench is not that difficult. However as mentioned before it's better not to to manipulate the hairspring with bare hands.

Edited by jdm
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, canwdarose said:

But what about the opportunity to exercise the very thing that makes human hands such miracles of evolution - the ability to apply immense forces (clamping that damned bridle against the barrel wall) while dexterously holding a 10mm object and a loose, floppy spring end, and simultaneously winding and guiding the spring into the (virtual) center of the spring? Only to realize that you've wound the thing in backwards...

So on the other hand, humans also invented tools so that work was easier and more productive.  Buy the winder, Folkvisor...

Drat, can't "wriggle out of the crushing grip of reason" (Calvin and Hobbes quote, for those that are fans).

You make hand-winding sound almost appealing - or was that appalling? LOL

I even read Calvin and Hobbes in French; everyone needs a hobby...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...


  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • glad it worked out, those ESA movements are obsolete but new old stock is still out there, now that you know the make/model you could also do a cross reference to see if something more current would line up with the dial feet and hands...for future use if needed 👍
    • I wish they would have done so in this case. The whole story went like this: I sent my speedmaster to an omega service center about 10 years ago (at that point of time I haven't even started watchmaking). After the watch came back to me it had only about 6 months wristtime until january 2024 (not fair for this nice watch but the other pieces of my collection want wristtime too 🙂). So my conclusion is that the barrel was already faulty when it came back from service, can't imagine that amount of wear in 6 months wristtime. In january 2024 the performance on the wrist was quite bad, so I decided to have a look by myself. I have to admit that I didn't check the barrel close enough as I thought it must be ok, couldn't have issues after official omega service. That was a mistake, I will learn from that. Follow the golden rule: Nothing is certain except death and taxes.
    • I am same as you oldhippy I won’t touch anything with a battery, I keep getting requests to but I just say I only do mechanical clocks, there are quite a few errors & omissions with the repair guide have a look at this. https://mb.nawcc.org/wiki/Encyclopedia-Subjects/Torsion-Clocks/Book:Horolovar-400-Day-Clock-Repair-Guide-10th-Edition-Errors-and-Updates
    • Nice experiment. As it will be no problem, please put a twice less mass (half of the two penies) and read the amplitude, will be interesting. I mean to determine what is the relation torque/amplitude.
    • parts touching that aren't supposed to touch definitely would cause an issue. there not supposed to be touching there supposed to be independent which means that @VWatchie is correct that the ratchet wheel has no effect on performance. so if the ratchet wheel in your particular case is touching that is definitely going to be an issue and needs to be addressed. did you know that the Swatch group service centers do not change mainsprings? Swatch group service centers have an infinite supply of spare parts so they just change the mainspring barrel the whole thing. Plus anything else the watchmaker doesn't like just gets replaced like anything related to the escapement they just replace the components because they can.
×
×
  • Create New...