Jump to content

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 357
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

I've given up on the idea of a comprehensive, affordable set of mainspring winders. A new spring is cheap and goes in so easily! By no means am I  an expert with hairsprings, but repairing them i

You wouldn't. It's about barrel sizes. The ETA set is sized (and I'm sure labeled) according to common ETA movements. Generic sets are sized by unit measurements (mm). If you do a lot of ETA stuff, it

I have purchased cheap mainspring winders in the past and they have been terrible. In the end I plumped for the 5356 Set. It serves both left hand and right hand mainsprings. But I find mostly that I

Posted Images

Sometimes it will be a tight fit. But if it looks like the spring will break then don't use it. Sometimes you can use the next size down crank with the correct size barrel if you are careful.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

But sometimes the arbor does not fit the mainspring for the correct size barrel and/or the other way round so it is useful to have a set - but even my set with 17 barrels both left and right hand cranks will not fit every mainspring/barrel combination, but the more sizes you have, the more chance you will have that you will have a correct combination.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I was looking at this mainspring winder set which is for sale.  Does anyone have any experience with these?  Will they handle most wristwatch sizes?  I am trying to get the model number to see if I can find any more info regarding these.

Cheers!

Roger

Unfortunately, I lost the opportunity to buy the Watch-Craft set shown above.  Has anyone used the K&D 127 or 128 Mainspring Winders shown below?  Will both do wrist watches (I am not working on pocket watches)?  Any insight would be appreciated.

Cheers!

post-38-0-25205200-1388807319_thumb.jpg

post-38-0-85455400-1388807813_thumb.jpg

Edited by 64americandeluxe
Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is another set that I am looking at (see below).  Any advantages or cons to using the KD 126,127 or 128?  It looks like the only difference between the 127 and 128 are the barrel sizes they'll accept.  The 126 is the "Robbins Type" but I am not sure what the significance of that is.

Thank you!

Roger

post-38-0-27942200-1388871537_thumb.jpg

Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh.. anw for some mainspring i managed to fit into the mainspring winder. But when i wind almost gonna complete it and it suddenly pop up and broke the mainspring. Why is that so? Am i doing something wrong? Do i need to flip the mainspring and put it into the mainspring winder? And sorry for this question does flipping the mainspring will causes anything? Thanks. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello. Watchcraft mainspring winders can be used to wind right hand and left hand so they are a good starter to begin with. Some mainsprings are left hand wind or right hand wind so the Watchcraft will work , but they are not the quality of a set of Bergeon winders which come in right and left hand wind sets or combined.

I find the most K&D's winders are ok for pocket watches but not all of them fit most wristwatch barrels.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello. Watchcraft mainspring winders can be used to wind right hand and left hand so they are a good starter to begin with. Some mainsprings are left hand wind or right hand wind so the Watchcraft will work , but they are not the quality of a set of Bergeon winders which come in right and left hand wind sets or combined.

I find the most K&D's winders are ok for pocket watches but not all of them fit most wristwatch barrels.

Excellent information!  Thanks very much!

Roger

Link to post
Share on other sites

Oh.. anw for some mainspring i managed to fit into the mainspring winder. But when i wind almost gonna complete it and it suddenly pop up and broke the mainspring. Why is that so? Am i doing something wrong? Do i need to flip the mainspring and put it into the mainspring winder? And sorry for this question does flipping the mainspring will causes anything? Thanks. 

 

Not quite certain what happened from your description.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 5 weeks later...
  • 1 month later...

Hi I was just looking at mainspring winding tools and as someone who is new to this think they are a big expense for the new coming is there anther way of putting in a mainspring with out the tool, or do new springs come ready to fit ? 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi I was just looking at mainspring winding tools and as someone who is new to this think they are a big expense for the new coming is there anther way of putting in a mainspring with out the tool, or do new springs come ready to fit ? 

To be done correctly and more importantly Safely...you really should use mainspring winders to fit mainsprings. There are instances where they are not needed, when the mainspring is held with a girdle that is smaller in diameter than they barrel. These can be installed directly into the barrel from the girdle. But, then again, I usually remove the girdle and inspect, clean and grease the mainspring before installing it. So, I still use a winder set.

There are some deals on used sets out there but I've bought poor sets along with really good sets. It's hit or miss, to be honest!

Link to post
Share on other sites

I bought a used set of Watch-Craft mainspring winders for wrist watches recently and they were very reasonably priced.  I used them for the first time this past weekend (first time ever winding a mainspring) on a mid-1960s Elgin and found the experience quite easy.  I installed and removed the mainspring about 3 or 4 times dry to get the hang of it and then oiled it and reinstalled it.  With the winder, I found the removal and reinstallation of the mainspring much easier than I was expecting (many comments online left me apprehensive about doing this but I was very eager to learn this aspect of watch repair).  For me, winding and installing the mainspring back into its barrel was much easier than trying to align the three pivots on the train bridge!  

Cheers!

Roger

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 4 weeks later...

I'm looking at getting a mainspring winder, the likely candidate being the Bergeon 5355 there's not a lot else thrown up in searches but before I commit is there a better alternative? Occasionally people can recommend a genius of a Chinese alternative to things...

 

Lee

Link to post
Share on other sites

I have purchased cheap mainspring winders in the past and they have been terrible. In the end I plumped for the 5356 Set. It serves both left hand and right hand mainsprings. But I find mostly that I use sizes 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9

 

Most swiss movements use the clockwise wound handle and cranks and I find the anti-clockwise handle and cranks useful for Japanese (like Seiko).

 

There is a special ETA set, but I find #8 is OK for the 7750 and using size #7 with #6 crank (carefully) works well for 2892-A2 and 2824

 

The rest in the set I rarely use.

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 5 months later...

So, I'm on the market for a set of mainspring winders and I had a few questions. The main options I can see, in terms of second hand or used, winding tools seem to revolve around:

 

1. Watch-Craft Bracelet Winders: Sets of 8 in sizes 5mm to 10mm.

2. Bergeon 2729 Winders: Single handle; set of 7 barrels in sizes 0 (5.6mm) to 6 (9.8mm).

3. JC Schilling Bracelet Winders: Much the same as the Watch-Craft ones.

4. K&D 123/128 Winders: Set of 7 barrels and bench vise base. Their sizes tend to be vague but the 128 seems to start from 8mm.

 

I suppose the worry with 1-3, is how likely is it to need anything larger than 10mm, and how to deal with any left handed mainsprings? Any recommendations or advice? If it helps, I intend working on vintage watches which will primarily date prior to 1970s, so I'm hoping the 10mm upper size on most of these is not an issue for a beginner green looking newbie like me ;).

 

At present, leaning towards the Bergeon though the Watch-Craft's are more readily available from the US (which makes them more expensive as it happens if you throw on customs + VAT).

Link to post
Share on other sites

Then again, I just spotted a Bergeon set that went for close to £260. Seems the Watch-Craft are a fair bit cheaper overall... Checking the non-local ebay sites to find a few more samples. Looking at older forum posts elsewhere, the prices have gone up in the past year or two for used winder tools.

Edited by PadraicB
Link to post
Share on other sites

I have a K&D winder but do have problems with small watch springs. Releasing the winding notch from the newly wound spring can be troublesome & I have destroyed a few with this problem. It might be because it is an old vintage one but I think it is just the design.

If my finances improve hope to purchase a Bergeon or at least a barrel type winder they seem to offer a lot less hassle.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't know guys but in my case I've been pondering about winders and although it would be nice to have a good quality set, the volume I handle doesn't justify the expense therefore I always do them by hand. Somehow it keeps me "closer" to the watch! :)

 

It is good to know about the K&D glitch, clockboy, since I've spotted some on eBay occasionally and I've been tempted!

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • jdm changed the title to Mainspring Winders
  • jdm pinned this topic

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • OK I will be serious no more midnight movies 
    • Not all mainsprings are coated some of them supposedly because of the alloy they don't need Teflon or anything. But you still caught with the same problem basically it's invisible. If you clean the mainspring and it had an invisible lubrication it now does not. The problem with invisible lubrication is you don't know it's there. Which means if you clean it you remove it but since you don't know if it's there or not that doesn't matter. If the mainspring has old oils are greases they definitely have to come off because they will be sticky. if you have a nice clean mainspring it should be lubricated with something. Just don't get carried away with putting too much on otherwise it leaks out of the barrel.
    • Thanks again. They explain the process pretty well and are a great help. Took the back off the watch tonight for a quick look and thanks to the manuals confirming, I need to get my hands on a crystal lift tool before I go any further. 
    • A question that comes up all too often is problems related to hairsprings. Seems like a simple solution the hairspring is removable they can be swapped. But you're going to end up with timing issues each hairspring comes with its balance wheel it's why they're not sold a separate components they come together. I'm attaching a PDF it's not for your watch I want you to go to the very last page. The very bottom of the last page look at how they hairspring looks? Compare that with your hairspring they don't quite look the same. I don't think your hair Springs been destroyed I think it can be fixed but it can't be fixed if you don't grasp what it's supposed to look like. Then even if you grasp what it's supposed to look like hairspring work requires a lot of time to learn. Like everything else in watch repair it requires a heck of a lot of practice. You really should be practicing bending hairsprings every single day preferably not in a watch something disposable. Look on eBay look for cheap movements  Something a don't care about something to practice with because without the practice trying to practice as you go on the watches are working on is not a recipe for success. The reason for the PDF is the last page talks about the etachron system which adds complications perhaps. So the problem is at least for me it's hard to tell where the problem is with your hairspring other than the problem is very visible.  This is because it could be a bend of the hairspring or if the etachron  stud for instance has been rotated and you're not quite the right place that is not be a problem also. Or more likely you have both problems. Seiko 7S26C_36C.pdf
    • Buttoned back up and ticking away nicely. I wonder how many of these are still running? Some Metamec history.  
×
×
  • Create New...