Jump to content
  • 0

Trying My First Repair With A 15 Jewel Old Pocket Watch Movement


Edmund
 Share

Question

Dear readers,
 
This is my first post. I hope we will get know one another and with your co-operation we will trade the pleasure of learning for the satisfaction of sharing one's knowledge. To illustrate my story I have added some pictures below. 

 

post-1450-0-86902700-1442621816.jpg

 

You can see some basic tools, a partly disassembled antique 19 lignes (42.8 diameter) lever movement and the removed parts. 

 
post-1450-0-63750400-1442621815_thumb.jp

 

I had never disassembled a movement before and this one seemed like the perfect candidate to experiment, but now that I have learnt to assemble/disassemble this movement, I want to fix it. After all, we are talking of a fully jewelled movement from a century ago.

 

post-1450-0-47650900-1442621811_thumb.jp

 

On close inspection several issues are revealed: broken mainspring, broken balance staff...

 
post-1450-0-46649200-1442622370_thumb.jp

 

...and missing roller jewel. 

 

I have not been able to identify the maker, but the dial and the case (935 silver) confirm it is Swiss. 

 

post-1450-0-88840700-1442622373_thumb.jp

 

The balance cock bears a factory symbol consisting of a five-pointed star connected to three lightning bolts that come out the star each in a different direction.
 
post-1450-0-93852000-1442621817_thumb.jp
 

I am aware that getting spare parts is going to be hard work, but I want to learn to solve these issues. 

 

I have measured the broken mainspring with a Vernier caliper but I cannot find a replacement in Cousinuk.com. Perhaps someone could check for me in the Générale Ressorts catalogue? These are its specifications:

 

Height: 2.2 mm.
Thickness: 0.22 mm.
Length: 24 inch (61 cm).
Barrel: 16.5 mm.
End hole type.

 

Any advice, guidance, comments, support, contributions, collaboration will be greatly appreciated.

 

I will be watching this space!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 answers to this question

Recommended Posts

  • 0

I genuinely appreciate all your comments. 

 

My conclusion is that stripping down this watch and diagnosing its faults was a great lesson, even though the repair will have to be delayed indefinitely.

 

At least now I know that if this watch has any chance of running ever again without major disbursement it must be through a donor movement.

 

Following this experience I have disassembled/reassembled successfully a working 17 jewel Tavannes.

 

P.S.: The photos that I added to my previous post seem to have disappeared. (I wonder why?)

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Hello, Edmund, and welcome. I've been participating in this forum for several weeks now. I can't always tell who's a hobbyist (like me) and who's a professional, but everyone has been helpful, kind, or (when the situation called for it) commiserating.

You can buy a replacement roller jewel at Cousins. You'll need to measure the gap in the pallet fork to get the right size. Look up my previous recent posting, in which I learned how to do that. I'm now working up the courage, and looking for the time, to do the impulse jewel implantation. I am told it is challenging.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Welcome to the forum Edmund, I'm sure you will enjoy being part of this community.

Thank you for posting good quality pictures from the start, it's great to see what you are doing. I hope you don't mind me saying the watch you are working on is not the "perfect candidate" to start on, as the faults that it has are far from easy for someone starting out to fix. My advice would to purchase a fairly large, but fully working movement and practice on servicing it by disassembling and reassembling it a few times.

Fault finding and fixing is best left until you can service a watch properly first. The watch you have just now would be good for acquiring the delicate touch required when handling tools and fitting wheels and bridges without damaging pinions.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

That is a good learning piece you have as it has lots of issues. The problem you might have is the balance staff replacement as it is difficult to source the correct replacement.  Also fitting the staff you will need  the correct tools.

 

I have looked in my "Generale Resorts" catalog and there is not an exact sized spring. However the following may well fit:

 

 

GR 6305  H 2.20  Thickness 0.22  Length 520   Dia. 17 

GR 6307  H 2.20  Thickness 0.22  Length 560   Dia. 18 

GR 6310  H 2.20  Thickness 0.22  Length 620   Dia. 19 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Thank you very much for your encouraging answers.

 

I can't always tell who's a hobbyist (like me) and who's a professional.

 

This reminds me of H. G. Harris's 'Handbook of Watch and Clock Repairs' and its paragraph in recognition of the self-taught hobbyist:

 

But what of the present-day hobbyists who are self-taught and whose interest in their subject is such that their knowledge and skill often surpass those whose full-time occupation it is? (Harris 1972, p. 7)

 

You can buy a replacement roller jewel at Cousins. You'll need to measure the gap in the pallet fork to get the right size. Look up my previous recent posting, in which I learned how to do that.

 

I think I found your thread here: http://www.watchrepairtalk.com/topic/2751-where-do-i-get-a-feeler-guage-and-roller-table-jewels/ I will study this info a.s.a.p.

 

My advice would to purchase a fairly large, but fully working movement and practice on servicing it by disassembling and reassembling it a few times.

 

Do you have any particular model in mind?

 

I have looked in my "Generale Resorts" catalog and there is not an exact sized spring. However the following may well fit:

 

GR 6305  H 2.20  Thickness 0.22  Length 520   Dia. 17 

GR 6307  H 2.20  Thickness 0.22  Length 560   Dia. 18 

GR 6310  H 2.20  Thickness 0.22  Length 620   Dia. 19 

 

The end type for all those references is described as 'Non-Automatic', but I need the mainspring with holes in both ends. Maybe the below references are more fitting?

 

GR 6216 TR 2.20 x .155 x 620 x 15 TR- End
GR 6280 TR 2.20 x .20 x 540 x 17 TR- End

 

WatchMainspring_Pic1_cmyk.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Great pictures, Edmund, and welcome to the site. I hope with all the expert advise here you can have a new "jewel" added to your collection soon. Let us know how it goes. By the way, starting with a working movement on the long road of learning watchmaking, will help you more as Geo said...needless to say that the bigger the movement the better so you don't miss certain details.

 

Cheers,

 

Bob

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Let us know how it goes. [...] the bigger the movement the better so you don't miss certain details.

 

Today I worked on the escapement and I have some more pictures to share below. I agree about the size, but this movement seems big enough for me. In any case, here I am following the advice of the Chicago School of Watchmaking:

 

We will divide the work into two general groups, POCKET WATCHES and WRIST WATCHES [...]. Do not attempt to work upon wrist or bracelet watches until you have thoroughly mastered the pocket size watches (Lesson 1, Sec. 4).

 

GR 6280 TR 2.20 x .20 x 540 x 17 TR- End

This is the best match available with Cousins

 

Much appreciated. With the help of clockboy, now I know which spring to go for. If I order it, I will place it by hand as I have practised how to do it with the broken one. But before taking that decision, I am reviewing the other elements of the movement again to make sure it is worth my while.

 
 
The winding system is in good condition and you can operate the stem to choose between two positions: winding (default) and time setting (pulled).
 
 
The gear train is fine. All the wheels engage and rotate together. No faults here.
 
The escapement is a different matter. The pallet fork engages well with the escape wheel, but a new balance staff is badly needed. So I have removed the broken one.
 

 

As you can see, the impulse pin (also called roller jewel) is actually present. However, the pin is made of brass and is loose, so it will still require attention.

 

I have seen in this awesome video from Mark how to replace a balance staff: http://www.watchrepairtalk.com/page/watch_repair_videos.html/_/balance-escapement-videos/fitting-a-new-balance-staff-to-a-vintage-1940s-cyma-www-military-watch-r19

 

But how do you choose the new one?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

You have to find out which movement it is? Then maybe they have one at balancestaff.com?

15 jewels 19 ligne number 664 on balance bridge and movement plate? Anymore clues?

Edited by rogart63
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

I don't think for one minute you will find a balance staff to fit. I expect you will have to find a watchmaker to make it. I always had a stock of unfinished staffs, so I would select one as near as possible and finish it off or make one. This is the difference between a watch repairer and a watchmaker. The hairspring looks in a fine mess as well, I'd start with that before sorting out the staff because with out the hairspring you are in deep. The only other answer is another movement with a working balance. You are correct about starting on pocket watches before getting into watches, its just a pity you couldn't have started with something that just needed cleaning.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 0

Agree with Oldhippy I am not the best at making balance staffs and so I normally modify one of my many stock/unfinished staffs on my lathe. You can get unfinished staffs from Cousins & on the bay also there are staffs (in packs of 100) on the bay & you could get lucky & get a match.

You could modify one using a jacot tool but it would be a long process.

The main point is this is a learning piece and adjusting the hairspring is a skill in itself.

So my advise is just tinker & learn from this piece before spending to much money 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share



  • Similar Content

    • By VWatchie
      Bergeon Platax No. 2677 How to Guide.pdf
      Bergeon Platax No. 2677.pdf
      Background
      In the old days, before shock protection, I’m sure replacing balance staffs was one of the most common tasks for a watch repairer. They probably replaced several staffs every day. There are many ways to remove a balance staff. One very convenient and quick method is to use a Platax tool. However, this method is considered a destructive method by some repairers, meaning you can only replace the balance staff so many times before the hole in the centre of the balance wheel will become too wide. You can read a more about it here. I guess I would think twice or trice before using use a Platax tool on a Philippe Dufour balance. Anyway, for my standard ETA, Sellita, Unitas, Vostok, etc. balances I have no reservations about using a Platax tool.
      One dilemma with the Platax tool is that it has been discontinued by Bergeon (No. 2677). The offerings on eBay are few and far between, and as with everything else Bergeon, they are silly expensive. I would feel a bit embarrassed to let you know what I paid for my used copy which probably has seen hundreds if not thousands balance staffs in its life. Anyway, as with most everything else Bergeon, the quality of the tool is second to none, so I’m pretty sure I’d get my money back (if not more) should I decide to sell it in the future. That’s a major benefit with quality tools which makes it a lot easier to pull the trigger.
      So, how often do I expect to use this tool? Well, as all my watches so far have been equipped with shock protection and as I expect most future watches that I’ll be working on will be as well, the answer is, not very often. As a matter of fact, I expect it to be so rare that I might forget how to use my Platax tool when I need it the next time. For this reason, I decided to document my findings and that is what you’ll find in the attached PDF document.
      Do note that the document isn’t a tutorial, it is my personal notes, gathered from watching two YouTube videos (see below) and my own thinking and experimenting. For this reason, it is possible I got something backwards. If so, please let me know!
       
    • By khrisph
      So i stumbled upon - it seems to me, a gold filled octagon rolex  26mm and I couldnt find the other information. I think the engravings on the case back say its from 1953 and its got enamel dial? It would be great if someone here was able to identify this 🙂



    • By PaulnKC
      Greetings All,
      Hope that all are doing well - in this crazy COVID world.
      I recently acquired a 1958 Rolex Ref. 6569 with a Cal. 1030 movement. All-in-all very nice and clean for her age - and runs very well.
      The winding pinion and clutch wheel had worn each other out - so I found NOS Rolex parts and replaced those. I though the watch deserved the new parts.
      It appeared to have been serviced in the last 10 years - because everything looked clean and the oil looked good (and present).
      Since the watch seemed to be running well and in good health (other than the winding pinion and clutch wheel) - I didn't do a complete service. I didn't think it was worth the risk.
      However, it seems to me that the watch is harder to wind than I would expect.
      I did do a full service on a 1215 that I bought for my wife (ref. 6694). It needed everything - but an awesome running movement when I was finished.
      The 1215 is of course a manual wind - but similar to the 1030. The 1215 winds lightly and smoothly as one would expect.
      The 1030 is "stiff". I haven't taken the barrel apart - but have just ordered some new mainsprings.
      Is there anything tricky about replacing the auto mainspring in a 1030? Or is more or less like any modern auto?
      Clean the barrel; apply braking grease to wall; fit spring; fit arbor - oil lightly at spring-arbor interface; replace lid?
       
      Also - I was only able to find a parts-list for this movement. Anyone know where a tech/service sheet (or similar) may be found?
       
      Thanks in advance for your suggestions.
      -Paul
    • By Zero
      I'm interested to learn the definition of a pocket and a wristwatch mainspring, in terms of dimensions.
      1) What is the general height range for a wrist watch mainspring? Eg. 1mm to 2mm
      2) What is the general diameter range for a wrist watch mainspring? Eg. 7mm to 12mm
      3) What is the general height range for a pocket watch mainspring?
      4) What is the general diameter range for a pocket watch mainspring?
      5) Is the mainspring eye/hole size generally half the height of the mainspring?
      Reason: I'm looking to classify them correctly for improving the rs winder project releases.
      Will appreciate any help.
    • By Max50916
      Forgive me if this is a dumb question. I'm currently working on an AS 1187 1194 movement which has a broken mainspring. I have a bunch of NOS mainsprings and would prefer to use one of possible. After looking into it, it seems the proper mainspring size for this movement is Denn. 6 x 11 -- 11.5
      I've got ones close to that but not exactly that. So my question is, is it possible to use a mainspring with a slightly different width, strength, or length?
      Is there more wiggle room in regards to any measurements in particular? (by that I mean, maybe there is no wiggle room in width but some wiggle room in strength etc) 
      I've attached some photos with ones that seem to be relatively close, and am wondering your thoughts on using any of them? This is for a personal project so I'm looking to spend as little money as possible, otherwise I would buy a new mainsprings from Jules Borel.
      Thank you for any help you can give!




  • Recently Browsing

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • I found an answer of yours on this from 2018.  Sounds like I may need to break the crystal to get it out.  
    • It is very hard to see that line on my case.  But the ring must be there.  I attached a couple of pics.  One is the top of the case - you can see that the crystal came loose on one side.  I tried to get the same view you did in the other pic.  Not sure if you can see it.  So is it possible to push the ring out from inside? Also what is the best source for a new crystal?  Thanks much for your photo!
    • Welcome to WRT forum.
    • Hello, I have a problem with my ETA2801-2. Initially the watch was running great, but it was skipping while winding. I guess I made a mistake and pulled the train bridge in order to check the mainspring, afterwards I figured that wasn’t necessary. Anyway, after putting everything back together it was running with low amplitude and became impossible to regulate to anything over -120spd. I decided to pull the bridge again, and clean all associated parts in ultrasonic, and re-lubricate. Unfortunately nothing has changed, it still runs with low amplitude - about 230 and there is no way to make it run any faster than -120spd. What could be the reason behind it? Here is how it looks like on a time grapher. 
    • Hi, I’m not new to the watch world by any means, but I’m not a pro neither. I like to occasionally work with my watches as a part of watch collecting hobby 🙂
×
×
  • Create New...