Jump to content

Am I Being Ripped Off?


Brian

Recommended Posts

Hi Everyone...

 

I sent my Automatic watch off for repair (crown and stem replacement + pendant replacement) and when it was returned it was gaining 3 to 4 minutes per day.

 

I have sent it back to get it sorted and now am being told that I will have to pay again as the original repair did not go anywhere near the movement.

 

1, I asume a stem would connect directly to the movewent.  Would it??

2, As the watch was NOT gaining before the original repair could anything they did cause the watch to gain time??

 

Basically, am I being ripped off??

 

Cheers

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if it just was the stem and crown, no need to touch to the balance !..... changing a stem with a crown on a Watch tkae about 3 to 5 minutes .. not more...

The repairman has not need to touch the balance at all for this job

Edited by SeikoWatch
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Taking my hand out of my pocket caused the original damage...

The crown (I assume thats what its called- the bit you turn to change the time) broke off.

It was keeping good time before I sent it off for repair.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It is quite possible the watch was exposed to a magnetic field through the postal system - rare, but it can happen.

 

From what the OP has said about the nature of the repair this is what I would think is the most likely cause.

 

The magnets used nowadays are really powerful in so many things. I have had a watch that this has happened to in the mail. I took it to my local watch repairer and he demagnetized it for me.

Another source and one to be aware of are the self check machines that make a knocking  sound when you pass a book over them at libraries. Those things are really powerful. I remember buying a Breitling once and going to the library immediately after as it was next door. Next day the Breitling had gained 5 minutes and of course I was furious so took it back where they explained what happened after asking where I went after leaving them!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

£168 sounds very excessive,  if you can find a small compass and bring it near the watch it should give you an indication if it is magnetized or not.  If the watch had a big shock while in the post it might have moved the regulator slightly, enough to cause what you are seeing.  The other thing is the value of the watch or sentimental value as new automatic watches can be bought on Ebay for around £15. It does not sound like you will get fair treatment from original repair shop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

Truth is that I never do a "short job" for this reason.

 

Some repair shops do short jobs e.g. stem and crowns,  crystals etc and often times it come back to bite them on the rump. I'm sure the repairmen did nothing wrong to the watch but doing short jobs the repairmen only does the repair in requested.

 

There is nothing wrong with owning a RW Parsifal they are good eta watches, the problem is you used a repair center that does short jobs.

 

As to the repair only taking a few minutes I beg to differ. Yes some can do a quicky sloppy job in a few minutes but to do the repair correctly takes much longer.

 

As to magnetism that is a remote possiblilty, but a cheap radio shake demagnetizer can fix that.

 

Hope this helps

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Addendum

 

Sorry,  I did not explain why we call it a short job,

 

A short job is one where a full service is not done, that is the watch is not cleaned, oiled and adjusted.

 

IMHO tradesmen do not do the customer a favor when they do short jobs. The customer expects that the watch will

run and keep time correctly.

 

I can't begin to tell you how many times customers have told me " the watch only need (FILL IN THE BLANKS).

and with out fail God help you if the watch dose not keep good time.

 

3 to 4 minutes a day is a regulation issue, and with the crown missing God knows what got into the watch

and it only takes a small amount of dust or lint to mess up the timing of the watch.

 

Sorry you feel mistreated, the tradesmen is at fault, take it up with him, in all my years I have never sent a customer away unhappy who

had a legit reason to be unhappy. Give him another chance.

 

Good Luck

 

PS have written a few book on watch repair and have stressed doing full service for many years!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's not a phenomenon unique to watches. Any engineered thing (and my speciality is guitars) ages with wear - and all parts will age for the same period of time. So - when one section is replaced, it often (1) shows up defects/wear in other sections and (2) alters the balance of wear and performance on the other sections.

Edited by WillFly
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Similar Content

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • this is something I've never quite understood about the some of the Swiss companies. In 1957 Omega was using 9010 for the keyless parts with epilam. there's been a slow migration towards using heavier lubrication's but still typically oils and epilam to keep them in place. When it seems like 9504 works so much better.  
    • OK, welcome in the world of alarm clocks... I guess the 4th wheel is dished because it is from another movement. If it was not dishet, then it would not mesh with the pinion of the escape wheel, am I right? The marks of wear on the 4th wheel pinion doesn't corespond to the 3th wheel table position, at list this is what i see on the picts. Calculating the rate is easy - there is a formula - BR = T2 x T3 x T4 x T5 x 2 /(P3 x P4 x P5) where T2 - T5 are the counts of the teeth of the wheels tables, and P3 - P5 are the counts of the pinion leaves. Vibrating the balance is easy - grasp for the hairspring where it should stay in the regulator with tweasers, let the balance hang on the hairspring while the downside staff tip rests on glass surface. Then make the balance oscillate and use timer to measure the time for let say 50 oscillations, or count the oscillations for let say 30 seconds. You must do the free oscillations test to check the balance staff tips and the cone cup bearings for wear. This kind of staffs wear and need resharpening to restore the normal function of the balance.
    • Glue a nut to the barrel lid, insert a bolt, pull, disolve the glue.  Maybe someone will have a better answer. 
    • The stress is the force (on the spring) x distance. The maximum stress is at the bottom, and decreases up the arm. That's why they always break at the bottom. I used a round file, then something like 2000 grit to finish. I gave the rest of the arm a quick polish - no need for a perfect finish. Just make sure there are no 'notches' left from cutting/filing. The notches act like the perforations in your toilet paper 🤣
    • It's probably a cardinal rule for watch repair to never get distracted while at the bench. Yesterday, after finishing a tricky mainspring winding/barrel insertion (I didn't have a winder and arbor that fit very well) I mentally shifted down a gear once that hurdle was passed. There were other things going on in the room as I put the barrel and cover into the barrel closer and pressed to get that satisfying snap. But when I took it out I realized I never placed the arbor.  When opening a barrel, we are relying on the arbor to transfer a concentrically-distributed force right where it is needed at the internal center of the lid. However, when that isn't present it's difficult to apply pressure or get leverage considering the recessed position of the lid, the small holes in the barrel and the presence of the mainspring coils. It was a beat-up practice movement so I didn't take a lot of time to think it over and I pushed it out using a short right-angle dental probe placed in from the bottom, but that did leave a bit of a scratch and crease in the thin lid. I had also thought about pulling it using a course-threaded screw with a minor thread diameter smaller than the lid hole and a major diameter larger, but that may have done some damage as well.  Thinking about how this might have been handled had it been a more valuable movement, is there a method using watchmaking or other tools that should extract the lid with the least damage? 
×
×
  • Create New...