Jump to content

Vulcain Cricket (S2315A cal.120)


Recommended Posts

Hello everyone,  

 

I would like to present to you my latest project, a Vulcain Cricket (yes, another Cricket), model S2315A. I always wanted a Cricket, and it looks to me that Vulcain has made a lot of different variations of dials, watches etc. Cannot really find much info on the one I have. 

 

Initial condition overall: is running, but definitely needs servicing. It has a lot of DNA allover the place. Also, the watch came with its original bracelet (I wonder how that will turn out).

Movement: looks to be a cal.120. Not 100% sure as googling for this caliber brings different results. What do you think? Also had tested it on the timegrapher, results on the picture.

Crystal: needs a new one, as the original is cracked and has oxidation on the tension ring.  

Dial: looks pretty clean.  

Case: gold plating has some ware. Honestly not sure what to do as I have no setup of my own yet. Is it worth sending for replating?  

 

I am a newbie in the trade so any thoughts or suggestions are super welcome!

 

Thank you! 

photo1665483926 (1).jpeg

photo1665483931.jpeg

photo1665483926.jpeg

  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Definitely Cal.120.....and the later version with incabloc balance bridge.  A nice watch. As to whether it's worth the cost of replating, the value is about 400-500 GBP serviced if sold in the UK 'as is' but could rise to 700-900 GBP depending on how the restoration of the case turns out.  

I've owned and worked on a few crickets and they are lovely little watches.  Recently re-released in a much larger contemporary sized case, they look ungainly to me but of course it's each to his own.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

My kind of timepiece!! very nice… we’re up to three in our house- the one I wore today, the new one my wife wanted, and one waiting for me go get the nerve to dive in…

Based on your pics it could be tough call on the case if the dial is great. Wait till you get the scuzz of I’d reckon…

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Day 1. Disassembly or what do we really have. 

Crystal: Definitely needs to be replaced. When measuring I have 30.5-30.6mm, in the Sternkreuz Gezamtkatalog G22 there is only one that might fit is XAG306.697 (not sure how tight it would sit though). Also ho idea how it might look... Is it possible anyone knows the a part number?

Case and dial: Well I seen better dials, but also seen a lot worse. Does it make sense to invest in replanting the case? What do you guys think? 

Movement: Looks clean. But someone had laid his dirty little hands on it. The sprint ring, locker ring, on the alarm hand is damaged. 

msg639303616-45065.jpg

msg639303616-45067.jpg

msg639303616-45068.jpg

msg639303616-45069.jpg

msg639303616-45070.jpg

msg639303616-45066.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That spring is tough to find and seem to be easy to break.  When servicing: the spring, setting lever, and the unlocking wheel should not be disassembled...just keep together as a unit.  That is my humble view.

You can do gold electroplating yourself, but it is a pretty thin coat...costs under $100.  I have plated a few things. Frankly, I would not try to re-plate yours.

Your dial looks fine--leave it alone.

I have replaced several Cricket crystals but it has been a year.  I cannot recall if I used a Sternkreuz, GS Flexo, or some generic.  Do not use a low-dome crystal.  I seem to remember having an issue with the sweep second hitting the crystal.  Here is a side view of the Cricket I am wearing...OH NO...looks like there is a crack!  I know that I have accidentally whacked this thing a few times--I wear it constantly.

2022-10-19 08_07_38-20221019_080236.jpg ‎- Photos.png

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 10/14/2022 at 6:06 PM, swiss2k said:

Day 1. Disassembly or what do we really have. 

Crystal: Definitely needs to be replaced. When measuring I have 30.5-30.6mm, in the Sternkreuz Gezamtkatalog G22 there is only one that might fit is XAG306.697 (not sure how tight it would sit though). Also ho idea how it might look... Is it possible anyone knows the a part number?

Case and dial: Well I seen better dials, but also seen a lot worse. Does it make sense to invest in replanting the case? What do you guys think? 

Movement: Looks clean. But someone had laid his dirty little hands on it. The sprint ring, locker ring, on the alarm hand is damaged. 

msg639303616-45065.jpg

msg639303616-45067.jpg

msg639303616-45068.jpg

msg639303616-45069.jpg

msg639303616-45070.jpg

msg639303616-45066.jpg

Eyup matey thats a nice timepiece that gets a nod from folk in the know. I would leave the dial alone its ok, it looks like a thin coat lacquer that might lift along with some lettering if you try any restoration on it. Good luck with the plating it will be a cracking watch if it restores and polishes up  well.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

Update. 28 Oct. part 1.

From my last post I was searching for the spring that holds the alarm arm wheel. I did find a replacement. A word of advice, do not ever remove it, literally never. Only if its broken, other wise God forbid. Putting it back is such a pain. 

IMG_1570.jpg

Update. 28 Oct. part 2.

Movement. I am pretty sure everyone has this problem once in a while. When you ask your self if watchmaking is really something you want to spend your time on. 

Well this one really really tasted my patience. I had it assembled and disassembled back and forth 3-4 time. Was not running no matter what I do. Turns out the problem was in the balance wheel, with out its jewels it would rattle allover the place and not take up momentum (others that I worked on didn't behave that way).

 

So, from Rate +73, 167 Amp. and 1.5 Beat Error I have the following (check picture). 

 

Now it runs more or less stable, but some times speed up, some times slows down. Why?

Beat error. I could make it 0, but! if I do the balance speeds up so fast that adjusting to max slow position still doesn't help it. It runs +30-50s per day. What are my options? 

IMG_1571.jpg

Edited by swiss2k
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, LittleWatchShop said:

Where did you find rhe spring so quickly??

I assume that's sarcasm, or maybe not. But I couldn't even find a part number for that thing. So I contacted Vulcain, and ordered a couple from their newer models. Turn out they fit older models.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, swiss2k said:

I assume that's sarcasm, or maybe not. But I couldn't even find a part number for that thing. So I contacted Vulcain, and ordered a couple from their newer models. Turn out they fit older models.  

No, I was not sarcastic...truly questioning. 

Vulcain appears to be in somewhat of a revival state.  I have a sneaking suspicion that they are still using the Cal 120 platform.

Next question...will they sell parts to anyone??  It would be great if they did.

If I may inquire...what did they charge for the spring.  I bought one in 2021 for 20 Euro.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

@LittleWatchShop " ... Cal 120 platform" - may be. New movements do look like the old ones. 

"... will they sell parts to anyone??" - yes they do, but from new series. They do not support old ones, I guess I just got lucky with the spring.  

"... 20 Euro." - yeah, that's more or less exactly what I payed. 

 

Any thoughts/advice on the issues I've motioned (with the beat error and balance wheel going fast then slower)? Thnx

Edited by swiss2k
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 minutes ago, swiss2k said:

@LittleWatchShop " ... Cal 120 platform" - may be. New movements do look like the old ones. 

"... will they sell parts to anyone??" - yes they do, but from new series. They do not support old ones, I guess I just got lucky with the spring.  

"... 20 Euro." - yeah, that's more or less exactly what I payed. 

 

Any thoughts/advice on the issues I've motioned (with the beat error and balance wheel going fast then slower)? Thnx

Can you post a readout from the timer?

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, swiss2k said:

2 problems.

1. When I adjust beat error to 0, rate goes to +50-60 and not adjustment helps. 
2. Amplitude jumps from 250 to 290 back and forth, witch affects rate. Does that on its own. 
 

That doesn't sound right !

How does the hairspring look at the regulator pins? Are the pins correctly spaced, is the spring pushing against one of the pins, is the hairspring vertical (not twisted) at the pins?

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yep, looks fine to me. 

It doesn't make sense that adjusting the beat error 1ms makes such a difference in rate - 1ms is only an angular movement of 2°. 

And the amplitude jumping around so much is odd.

I've had similar odd behaviour, and it turned out to be either a loose hairspring collet, or loose roller or jewel. Unlikely as your balance looks to be in original and excellent condition. But worth a check !

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

What if there is some oil between the forth wheel and the escape wheel, and that oil is just on one side of it, I thought. What if its sticking on one side? 

I took off the escape wheel, the pallet fork and the forth wheel. Cleaned them one more time. Removed any oil that might have been on the pallet forks jewels (leaving the pallet fork unoiled). And assembled it all back. 

Results: Amplitude now is jumping from 300 to 320 (I assume that's because the pallet fork is now snappier)... Meaning I was partially right (about the above mentioned), but the problem still persists, only difference its in a higher range 😃 

 

 

B71A3B3A-0699-45B2-8D96-CB5172468142.jpeg

Edited by swiss2k
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • That's an interesting question which I don't think I've seen explained anywhere. But I think the problem will go away just about instantaneously. In other words the  coating is really thin and it should go away almost immediately. So the problem should resolve itself extremely fast.  
    • I experienced that different types of shellac and their ages are affected differently by IPA. Sometimes the shellac dissolves in a few seconds and sometimes several minutes are required. Nowadays I never let shellac come into contact with IPA. It's a hotly debated topic here on WRT if you search. Like John, I don't think you need to worry about the weight of the shellac, but instead that it might start rubbing against something. When I learned how to adjust pallet stones, I tried documenting my experiences in this thread. Hopefully, it can help you. I personally don't believe in the idea of abrading the epilame before oiling so I don't think you need to think or worry about it. The only time I've heard anyone mention this is Alex on the YouTube channel Watch Repair Tutorials but actually no one else. I'm not saying it's "wrong" just that I don't think it's necessary or adds anything.
    • Typically for introductions all you would have to say is hi I am interested in repairing watches and nobody's going to care about the technical details. Then to certain degree the introductions are not life or death in some cases I guess it depends upon what you did when you came to the discussion group. It's good that you're getting a balance complete for variety of reasons and getting a bonus balance bridge. Because I want you to pay attention to something when you get it as your hairspring still has a problem quite an amusing problem in a way. You notice your hairspring stud is a triangle or shape and it fits into a triangular shaped hole. It also notice how your hairspring has some weird bending right around the stud? So when you get your new balance bridge and the balance complete if you look carefully you'll find that I'm pretty sure the stud will be rotated and that they hairspring will come out the end not the way it's coming here you have managed to twist the stud putting it into the hole and that's why it looks so bad in the previous image. If you are skilled at fixing hairsprings which are not you can fix this. On the other hand are getting replacement so that's good. No it's supposed to be straight up and down. So in addition to twisting the stud you also bent it. On the other hand this is the most common place where people like to bend their hairspring and yes if you had practice with bending hairsprings this is all relatively sort of easy to fix. But I would really suggest practicing on another watch or basically scrap of balance wheels off of eBay that nobody cares about. Because practicing on something you care about really isn't the best. Then the reason I wanted the image below was to see how the balance jewel assembly is attached to the bridge. Sometimes it needed jeweling tool to push it out but in this particular case all you have to do is remove the U-shaped clip in the whole thing falls apart. But if you're lucky here replacement balance bridge will solve the problem.
    • I still need to see the complete movement as there are many types of Elgin movements. The part that you are holding is called a snail. 
    • Just a quick update on my T17. I just finished the service and, boy, was this nerve-wrecking.... I bent the hairspring a few times. Stupid accidents. Once it was beyond repair and I had to get a donor movement. The replacement hairspring turned out to be a few millimeters shorter and therefore the watch was running 6min too fast even when the regulator was set to the slowest position. So I needed to get timing washers (see another post here: https://www.watchrepairtalk.com/topic/25505-30t2-adjustment-of-timing-washers/?do=findComment&comment=248100).  After all, I'm now, getting a 310° amplitude (fully wound, dial up, lift angle 54°). About 250 in vertical positions. Quite a drop, but apparently not too abnormal for a 90-year-old watch with a slow beat rate (18000bph) and rather heavy balance wheel. After 24h I still get 280 (horizontal) and 220 (vertical). And now the highlight:  66h of power reserve! You may remember that I posted that I used a slightly weaker, but also slightly longer mainspring than prescribed. See my comments above.  I used GR 3937 (instead of GR 3632). So I recommend this mainspring and ticker oils (9020 on escape wheel and HP1300 on the rest of the train).   Some random pictures..
×
×
  • Create New...