Jump to content

Try to restore the case or not


Recommended Posts

Hi 

I'm working on a diver watch named : Philly Master Mariner I join a photo of the dial 

The question is about the case what do you advise I know it's very personal to restore or not a case some do it other prefer to keep it as is as more authentic.

But here I've in dilemma, the face is not too bad but the back and side are very damaged

So your advises are welcomed even if someone tell me don't think about it because it'll be a catastrophic failure

Thanks

PXL_20220303_142315442.jpg

PXL_20220303_142326398.jpg

PXL_20220303_142340624.jpg

PXL_20220303_142351816.jpg

PXL_20220303_142502920.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi   The condition of the case is woe ful, loss of plating and wear. As the dial its self is in good condition I would think a clean and replate of the case would enhance the watch, as it is it detracts from the general apperance, Its your watch but in my opinion it would be better done than left undone.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, watchweasol said:

 a clean and replate of the case would enhance the watch,

Before replating, the base metal must be brought to a perfectly smooth finish. With deep damage, and on a soft metal like brass, that will deform the shape considerably. Then, good luck to the OP in finding someone that will do a good job, and consider that the cost will largely exceed the material value of the watch. If one is interested in case refurbishing, the only material that makes that relatively easy is Stainless Steel.

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Similar Content

  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Hello, I have a vintage Wittnauer automatic that is running fast.  I took it to my watch guy but he said it wasn’t worth fixing as it had sentimental value only. It’s only a few minutes fast per day so I’m wondering if there is anything I could do, given limited knowledge and tools. Thoughts?
    • @HectorLooi I agree with everything you say, but how does it relate to the topic?
    • When I graduated from dental school, one of my mentor's parting words, which was taken from Dirty Harry, was, "A man's got to know his limitations." This advice has stay with me throughout my career. Although I was certified to practice Implantology and Orthodontics, I have always referred my cases to more experienced colleagues. Just because you have taken a few online courses and watched a lot of YouTube videos, that doesn't make you a watchmaker. There is so much to learn in watchmaking. The more you learn, the more you realise you don't know. My advice to budding hobby watchmakers is to start small. Change batteries, watch straps, crystals, polish some cases and bracelets. Find an experienced watchmaker to be your mentor. In case you mess something up, he's there to bail you out. When you think you've arrived at a milestone in watchmaking, go get a Mumbai special and fix that. That will bring you back down to Earth. In the meantime, learn all you can and practice.
    • Looks exactly the same as the one from my National Electric watch cleaner. Can't help exactly but the max resistance on mine is approx 2500 ohm, let me know if you'd like me to try measure something else.
    • Oh, this is great. Can you post a link to the thread? I hope there are some reference times to compare (and how much it depends on the beat rate of the balance/movement).  While I think this is definitely superior to the blower, I was thinking that the risk of hitting the outside of the fork with the roller isn't actually there --- I only do this test without the pallet fork installed.    Well... I think that was a bit harsh. First, if you really look at what I am doing there, I hope you'll realize that it's actually no real risk. The Robur ensures that the Rolex-specific wrench stays tightly on the serrations of the caseback to eliminate the risk of slipping and damaging the serrations. The wrench with Rolex-style dye and the dye on the caseback (with plastic protection) exert no more pressure or stress on the case than during a crystal change. Yes, the pliers look terrible, I'll admit that! But I only use them to hold the watch steady between the lugs -- no real pressure here and with plastic protection again (if I had felt strong forces on the plier, I'd have stopped). Then I gently turned the wrench as it was held in place by the Robur. It worked like a charm. Not a single scratch. Second, you don't know the arrangement I have with my friend. And I will not get into that. But, trust me, if I made any serious mistake, I'd not hesitate and pay whatever damage from my own pocket.
×
×
  • Create New...