Jump to content

ETA2801-2 low amplitude, running slow


scarab

Recommended Posts

Hello,

I have a problem with my ETA2801-2. Initially the watch was running great, but it was skipping while winding. I guess I made a mistake and pulled the train bridge in order to check the mainspring, afterwards I figured that wasn’t necessary. Anyway, after putting everything back together it was running with low amplitude and became impossible to regulate to anything over -120spd. I decided to pull the bridge again, and clean all associated parts in ultrasonic, and re-lubricate. Unfortunately nothing has changed, it still runs with low amplitude - about 230 and there is no way to make it run any faster than -120spd. What could be the reason behind it? Here is how it looks like on a time grapher. 

0916702C-FFC8-49DC-A8C2-A1ADE075CFD0.jpeg

D8B53706-F8E2-4E68-9494-CB5EB7D54D5D.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Apparently you are sure you had better amplitude before. As Clockboy says, hairspring out of  regulator slot slows  the rate but you should get larger amplitude instead. 

Something might be rubbing,  barrel lid is to sit flush level at wall of the barrel, all arbours should have a little free play, very specially balance staff. in case end stomes are slightly pushing on pivots, you get low amplitude and slow rate.

If adjustment of the pallets aren't anything to be proud of, then oscilation can be poor. Did you put the fork or balance in ultrasonic too? 

Regs 

Joe

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Before I put my hands on it it was running great, with +-3 spd and correct amplitude so I definitely messed up or broke something. The only problem it initially had was skipping while winding. It still has problem with winding but I bet that’s caused by winding yoke. In order to isolate the issue I removed the clutch/crown wheel and wound it with a screwdriver. I’m not sure if the clickspring provides the correct tension but that shouldn’t be causing amplitude/accuracy issues, correct? 

Yes, I put the balance and the fork in ultrasonic as well. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I did Zippo lighter fluid for the wheels, bridge, balance and fork and then followed with IPA for everything except balance and fork as I was concerned about shellac 🙂 It’s not about the wash as it was behaving exactly the same after I reassembled it for the first time, before I did the wash.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, scarab said:

I did Zippo lighter fluid for the wheels, bridge, balance and fork and then followed with IPA for everything except balance and fork as I was concerned about shellac 🙂 It’s not about the wash as it was behaving exactly the same after I reassembled it for the first time, before I did the wash.

I see. So what is the end shake on balance staff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 hours ago, scarab said:

Dang, I didn’t know that, I hope I haven’t ruined it. Then what is the best affordable cleaning solution for balance and pallet fork? 

 

Lighter fluid is OK if you are cleaning by hand, but not in ultrasonic. I discovered that the expensive way.

As for cleaning solutions there is a very very long thread right on this here forum, more helpful than I can possibly be in one post.

Regs

Link to comment
Share on other sites

47 minutes ago, rodabod said:

Are you by any chance trying to regulate using the fine regulator adjustment rather than move if the arm which carries the index pins directly?

I tried both. I can go slower by regulating with the arm but not much faster than -120spd. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Nucejoe said:

Some balance pivots tend to vanish in ul1trasonic, some don't.

 

Well, I hope I was lucky this time. I already let this watch run for a couple of days hoping the amplitude will get better. I haven’t noticed any improvement but at least it didn’t got any worse so maybe shellac is still in place. I will take your advice and do some more research. I was aware IPA is a no go for balance, just didn’t know about lighter fluid. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, scarab said:

Well, I hope I was lucky this time. I already let this watch run for a couple of days hoping the amplitude will get better. I haven’t noticed any improvement but at least it didn’t got any worse so maybe shellac is still in place. I will take your advice and do some more research. I was aware IPA is a no go for balance, just didn’t know about lighter fluid. 

Have you checked all the jewel holes for dirt, and pivots to see if they are fine? Since you only had the issue after disassembling, and reassembling before cleaning (and even after cleaning and re-lubrication) it doesn’t seem to be due to oiling. Maybe something got caught in the jewel hole, or one of the pivots got damaged?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, rodabod said:

Can you check the end-shake of the balance? Let down the mainspring and then grab the rim carefully and lift/drop. 

I’ve seen jewel holes move when cleaning in the past. 

If you are test the end-shake of the balance in this way, wouldn't you only be able to see the (potential) movement of the jewel hole on the balance cock side? Seems quite difficult to manipulate the balance wheel if the dial side of the movement is facing up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites



  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Welcome to the forum, enjoy. It’s highly unlikely you will be able to purchase a new bezel look on eBay for a pulsar watch for repair to find a bezel.
    • just one little minor reminder here this isn't your normal balance wheel.  pages 17 and 18 are what you really want to be looking at. normally studs don't turn but this watch has the etachron system designed for lots of adjustment. Personally I would try to rotate the stud back to where it's supposed to be. If you're lucky you didn't actually bend it at the stud it just looks really bad as the stud has been rotated grossly out of position.. I think things will look a lot better if you put the hairspring back where it's supposed to be by rotating the stud. it's hard to tell if you actually did bend it at the stud or not we won't know until you rotate the stud back more or less where it's supposed to be. Then you want to pay attention to the manual of how to put the hairspring back in the regulator pins because yes they rotate also and they rotated specific directions otherwise bad things will happen to your hairspring. so initially you can open up the regulator as wide as it can go and don't worry about closing it until thing everything is right then you can close them a little bit
    • I need to see photos of the whole movement before I comment. 
    • Hi @Jon, so, from one extreme to another the beat error is 0.1(min.pos) to 0.2(msx.pos), and as you mentioned the rate does up and down dramatically. Also checked the position of the collet, and the collet is not central to the jewel on the balance cock. Balance moves freely, per my understanding.   So, after 24h the ampl. fell down by approx 20 deg, which I would assume is expected. After adjusting the endshake I believe I gained around +10 deg. of balance movement. Which is great, and overall the balance is not at 220'ish deg.   What I did next, some might think is non-orthodox, but was wort a try. I too the mainspring out, checked again for endshake and if the pin moves freely, and cleaned everything. Usually when installing the mainspring I would use some barrel grease on the barrel walls, install the spring and put a 2-3 drops of D-5 oil on top of the wounded spring and in the places where the arbor sits. This time I took the spring and applied a ultra this coat of Molykote Dx paste on the whole spring, before installing it in to the barrel, and added some oil to the arbor as usual.  The result improved, at a full wound the balance produces about 230-237 deg. @JohnR725 I'm getting closer to 300 😃   What I am noticing, there is a fluctuation in amplitude. With time it would rise and drop about total 8-10 deg in an interval about 2 minutes. I assumed this ruled out the power transfer from the barrel itself. So I took the gear train out, cleaned and lubed. 
    • Thank you so much, Hector and CJ. I appreciate the tech sheet and the video. Gasp, I think I will make the attempt. What's the worst that can happen? I think there may be a new balance complete in my future, though.  I'll update the post and let you know the result. R, Frank  
×
×
  • Create New...