Jump to content

3D printed RS mainspring winder project for hobbyists


Recommended Posts

24 minutes ago, DavidJ said:

 

It's not a pocket watch spring its from a 1960s Russian watch 10mm inner diameter barrel size. I'll do a video tomorrow maybe it will help show the issue better.

@Neverenoughwatches sure i can hand wind the spring back into the barrel no problem, I was kind of hoping this would work as hand winding is always a crap shoot in my experience and as you say not best practice. 

No problem David,  just a thought that gets you out of a pickle. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 hours ago, DavidJ said:

Here is a video am i going about this the right way? Do i just move the spring out the way like this or do i have this all wrong. 

Thanks for taking a look and for helping out 🙂

Sorry could not edit the post but i guess i'm trying to say at the start of the video 90% of the vintage spring is under the winder housing (compared with about 20% of a modern spring ), so i ether have to pull out 90% of the spring to get started or i need to push in 90% of the spring which i can't do.

Hi David, thanks for the video. You seem to be doing it correctly, but the barrel walls are in the way. This is a 10mm spring, so you are using the 10mm winder set, correct?

It seems to me that you have found a limitation with the winder, in the sense that the barrel walls are too thick for your particular mainspring.

Some solutions:
1. If we were to reduce the thickness of the wall, do you think this will solve the issue?
2. If the opening angle was wider, will this work?

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Zero said:

…It seems to me that you have found a limitation with the winder, in the sense that the barrel walls are too thick for your particular mainspring…

That‘s it!

I think that this nice winder design reaches its limit with barrel diameters of about 10mm and below. I recently wound the spring (D=7.5mm) of a ladies watch where the slot for the arbour hook was just 0,25mm wide. No way with a staple pin.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Zero said:

Hi David, thanks for the video. You seem to be doing it correctly, but the barrel walls are in the way. This is a 10mm spring, so you are using the 10mm winder set, correct?

It seems to me that you have found a limitation with the winder, in the sense that the barrel walls are too thick for your particular mainspring.

Some solutions:
1. If we were to reduce the thickness of the wall, do you think this will solve the issue?
2. If the opening angle was wider, will this work?

Hi Zero, yes i'm using a 10mm winder set.

Reducing the thickness of the barrel wall, I think would help and also a slimmer version of the winder base might help to move the spring down and out of the way. I do a lot of vintage stuff and most of it tends to be this sort of spring with 11mm or smaller barrels.

If you make changes i'd be happy to test springs through the new design, great project btw 

All the best

David

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Kalanag said:

I recently wound the spring (D=7.5mm) of a ladies watch where the slot for the arbour hook was just 0,25mm wide. No way with a staple pin.

Yes, a standard staple wont fit a some 7mm+ mainsprings unless you file it down. The other way to do this is to just purchase 0.2mm spring steel, and then fashion it into an arbor hook instead. This should be very easy now with the help of the staple jig. Here is an example purchase link to buy these (choose 0.2mm), hardware shops also sell them: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/4000995284553.html

1 hour ago, DavidJ said:

If you make changes i'd be happy to test springs through the new design, great project btw 

Great, because it is quite difficult for me to come by these type of vintage mainsprings. I do work on a bunch of Vostoks/Raketas, but they are mostly from the 80s. I will send you links to a bunch of experimental 10mm designs via PM. I'm sure you are fully capable of handwinding your way out and moving on, appreciate you spending time to make the video to help the rest of us. Hopefully a better version comes out of this. Thanks.

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

42 minutes ago, Zero said:

Great, because it is quite difficult for me to come by these type of vintage mainsprings. I do work on a bunch of Vostoks/Raketas, but they are mostly from the 80s. I will send you links to a bunch of experimental 10mm designs via PM. I'm sure you are fully capable of handwinding your way out and moving on, appreciate you spending time to make the video to help the rest of us. Hopefully a better version comes out of this. Thanks.

I'm very happy to do the testing i can even video the tests. On this project I'm happy to pitch in however i can.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 minutes ago, JohnFrum said:

Question: the Seiko 7s26 with barrel ID of 10.5 mm would require a 10.5 winder housing? 

It should be a bit smaller than that to allow easy transfert. However no perfectly matching set of housing and arbor exist to be ready purchased. I recommend not to take apart Seiko barrels, because there is no benefit to gain in doing that.

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, JohnFrum said:

Question: the Seiko 7s26 with barrel ID of 10.5 mm would require a 10.5 winder housing? 

I'd use a 10.0 or a 9.5. You usually want to be at least one size smaller than your barrel diameter.

1 hour ago, jdm said:

It should be a bit smaller than that to allow easy transfert. However no perfectly matching set of housing and arbor exist to be ready purchased. I recommend not to take apart Seiko barrels, because there is no benefit to gain in doing that.

Zero's designs allow for ANY size of housing. It can be a little tricky to figure out the steps, but once you do, you can print any size. I am NOT trying to push my stuff, I am just trying to offer solutions. If you don't have  3D printer: I am selling these on eBay, I can print any custom size you may need: https://www.ebay.com/itm/125428348675

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 7/26/2022 at 5:10 PM, AndyShap said:

I am selling these on eBay, I can print any custom size you may need: https://www.ebay.com/itm/125428348675

I have added your eBay link to the README for those who do not have 3D printers, or those who would just rather buy it. I have also added known issues (and workarounds) in the issues section to be on the safe side, eventually I hope to resolve them all: https://github.com/vishnu350/rs-mainspring-winder/issues. Feel free to add workarounds/suggestions to specific issues there.

 

On 7/26/2022 at 3:31 PM, jdm said:

It should be a bit smaller than that to allow easy transfert. However no perfectly matching set of housing and arbor exist to be ready purchased.

@jdm About this. In your opinion, what winder size numbers would truly make sense here? Eg. if the winder was labelled 10mm but has a preset 5% reduced size to be able to properly handle a 10mm mainspring (thus making it 9.5mm or so), or just straight up 10mm?

Edited by Zero
Link to comment
Share on other sites

So i tried the prototype Zero was kind enough to send my way and i have to say it's better for vintage springs.

Alas my spring broke but i think that was due to it being very old not the winder. I still can't say if the walls would have been strong enough but I think it's worth including this small version along with the main files.

Its definitely helpful. Next spring i come across i'll try again should not be long.

David

 

 

IMG_20220729_212939.jpg

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, DavidJ said:

So i tried the prototype Zero was kind enough to send my way and i have to say it's better for vintage springs.

Thanks for testing it out, that is very good news. Though unfortunately your vintage mainspring seems "tired" or "set" (looking at the pics), and needed changing regardless of what you did. Also might explain why you had issues flexing it to fit the winder in the first place, even though the thick walls were of no help.

I will work on integrating this version into the set, need to get the math correct so that all the other winders sizes are also generated correctly. Hope to see a better version yet.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...

@Zero@AndyShap

Hey Guys, I stumbled upon the Github while going through Andy's comments on the Retro Facebook group. I am very excited and eager to try this out as this was one of my stumbling blocks in going ahead with my hobby.

I'll be using a 3rd party 3D printing service in my country (India) and what i wanted to know was whether to get it printed in PLA, ABS or PETG. The costs are not that far apart between them and there isn't a substantial difference between 50% and 100% infill settings. So what print settings do you guys advise?

Thanks 🙂

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Piyush said:

@Zero@AndyShap

Hey Guys, I stumbled upon the Github while going through Andy's comments on the Retro Facebook group. I am very excited and eager to try this out as this was one of my stumbling blocks in going ahead with my hobby.

I'll be using a 3rd party 3D printing service in my country (India) and what i wanted to know was whether to get it printed in PLA, ABS or PETG. The costs are not that far apart between them and there isn't a substantial difference between 50% and 100% infill settings. So what print settings do you guys advise?

Thanks 🙂

As you may know, I am now selling these on eBay.  By this time, I have printed MANY of the kits and housings.  I print in PLA and have no issues whatsoever. I think printing in PETG or ABS shouldn't be an issue at all.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 5/17/2021 at 1:40 AM, Zero said:

Hi guys,

I have started a project in Github to generate all the possible types of mainspring winder sizes from a single base design using a Python script.
https://github.com/vishnu350/rs-mainspring-winder

The STL files can be downloaded from the release section:
https://github.com/vishnu350/rs-mainspring-winder/releases

This project is a 3D printable "Rising Sun" watch mainspring winder for hobbyists. Mainspring winding for hobbyists has always been a problem, as most of us cannot afford the $1000 Bergeon set. Or sometimes, the appropriate size just isn't available. This forces most casual hobbyists to resort to handwinding or other similar stunts, which is not ideal.

This mainspring winder is designed using FreeCAD to be easily 3D printed with no post-processing/finishing required. It will approximately cost $5/set by most 3D print service providers (use eBay to find someone near you). The design is parameterized, allowing you to dynamically change the size/dimensions of the winder and the entire design will be recalculated accordingly. The RS mainspring winder is a pleasure to use when constructed correctly, and can wind in both clockwise and counter-clockwise directions.

I have uploaded a video describing the 3D printed RS winder parts and how to use it.

Will appreciate any help or feedback as to further improve the design, as I actually do not own a 3D printer (I pay for each print). I also do not know the complete range of sizes that is required to be uploaded into the release section. Also, the optimal design parameters may still not be perfect, but it seems to work pretty well for me at the moment.

Thanks.

Hello @Zero,

Great to meet you!

I just came across your really interesting mainspring winder design and I am wondering if I can ask you a few questions about it, and how I might go about producing it without running afoul of any claim(s) that you may have on it from an intellectual or commercial perpective?

I think it's a really great idea but I am wondering if there's any improvements or refinements you would incorporate now that you've received some "in the field" feedback.

I wonder about what sizes would be most popular (in mm) and also how you feel about me making tweaks to the design and materials on my side?

g.
----

Edited by Gramham
Added additional detail
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi @Gramham, nice to meet you. The design is free and open-source (free as in free beer). You are free to use it or change it as you please, you can read the CC 4.0 license to know more. Eg. there is a member here (AndyShap) who prints it as a service, and he seems to have gotten some pretty good feedback on his page.

Yes, it has gone through many iterations and is currently on v0.9, complete changelog is on GitHub. However, v0.86 is currently the most proven and tested version. You can download them here, and read the changelogs if your want to know more: https://github.com/vishnu350/rs-mainspring-winder/releases

Have you started on Mark's classes? You can print anything you want as you need them, just measure the mainspring barrel diameter of your chosen practice movement and go for it.

On 8/23/2022 at 12:46 PM, Piyush said:

I'll be using a 3rd party 3D printing service in my country (India) and what i wanted to know was whether to get it printed in PLA, ABS or PETG. The costs are not that far apart between them and there isn't a substantial difference between 50% and 100% infill settings.

PLA should be the best as most printing services are more familiar with this material and you will get better quality out of it. For infill, i would recommend 100% as I have never tried anything less than that. Do let us know if 50% worked for you.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 hours ago, Zero said:

Hi @Gramham, nice to meet you. The design is free and open-source (free as in free beer). You are free to use it or change it as you please, you can read the CC 4.0 license to know more. Eg. there is a member here (AndyShap) who prints it as a service, and he seems to have gotten some pretty good feedback on his page.

Yes, it has gone through many iterations and is currently on v0.9, complete changelog is on GitHub. However, v0.86 is currently the most proven and tested version. You can download them here, and read the changelogs if your want to know more: https://github.com/vishnu350/rs-mainspring-winder/releases

Have you started on Mark's classes? You can print anything you want as you need them, just measure the mainspring barrel diameter of your chosen practice movement and go for it.

PLA should be the best as most printing services are more familiar with this material and you will get better quality out of it. For infill, i would recommend 100% as I have never tried anything less than that. Do let us know if 50% worked for you.

Hello @Zero,

Thanks for your feedback and I will review the resources you mention.

g.
----

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/23/2022 at 9:43 PM, AndyShap said:

As you may know, I am now selling these on eBay.  By this time, I have printed MANY of the kits and housings.  I print in PLA and have no issues whatsoever. I think printing in PETG or ABS shouldn't be an issue at all.

I'll do that and let you know. One last thing before I go ahead...

I am going to use it primarily for the Seiko 6xxx and 70xx movements so:

(1) Am I correct in choosing the 10.5mm housing/ plunger ?

(2) What size arbour rod is best for it ? I read in a youtube comment that the 2mm base/ rod is not suitable for the seiko 6xxx mainspring.

 

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 7 months later...

This project is a great resource to hobbyists.  Thanks for making it available.

I printed up a couple of winders (9.0 and 10.0), but have yet to test.  When fitting up the winder base to the plungers, there seems to be more slop than I expected between the dowel and hole in the plunger.

I printed these with 0.12 layer height but the text didn't come out too well.  Had you considered eliminating the "M"?  Then you would have some extra space to increase the font size.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I first tried with a manual mainspring and the 9.0 mm winder.  Got it wound into the winder.  When I pulled off the winder base, the staple was bent up some.  I was able to load the mainspring into the barrel successfully.  That go me rather excited.

I next tried with an automatic mainspring and the 10.0 mm winder.  Got it wound into the winder.  When I pulled off the winder base, the two ends were sticking a bit out into one of the pusher slots.  So, I had to remove it from the winder and try again.  Got to the point of getting the bridle into the winder and the eye end of the mainspring broke off.  The staple was quite mangled.  So, I need to source a new mainspring.  Not sure if I was doing something wrong or not.

Now, if there was a way to use the barrel arbor itself to wind the spring into the winder base, then that would seem better than using staples.

20230412_205548.jpg

20230407_135843.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 hours ago, gpraceman said:

I next tried with an automatic mainspring and the 10.0 mm winder.  Got it wound into the winder.  When I pulled off the winder base, the two ends were sticking a bit out into one of the pusher slots.  So, I had to remove it from the winder and try again.  Got to the point of getting the bridle into the winder and the eye end of the mainspring broke off.  The staple was quite mangled.  So, I need to source a new mainspring.  Not sure if I was doing something wrong or not.

Hi. Some points that may be of help:

  1. How did you latch the arbour hook to the mainspring? Please refer to the wiki for diagrams: Attaching-the-Arbour-Hook-to-the-Mainspring.
    If you used incorrect styles when latching, the hook will get mangled and the spring may deform.
  2. From your pictures, its seems like you are working on a vintage mainspring. The old types are made from a different material from modern mainsprings, and get "tired" or "set". They may deform/break no matter what you do, due to age. Please refer to the wiki: Selecting-the-correct-winder-size-for-your-mainspring

 

On 4/17/2023 at 5:38 PM, gpraceman said:

I printed up a couple of winders (9.0 and 10.0), but have yet to test.  When fitting up the winder base to the plungers, there seems to be more slop than I expected between the dowel and hole in the plunger.

This is intentional by design, to allow for varying sizes for the dowel pins (you may choose to use thicker ones), and also to be forgiving to folks with lower end printers. There should be minimal friction between the dowel pin and the plunger to allow unobstructed winding action, so a little slop is better than a tight fit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Recently Browsing

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Didn't you see the impact on your time machine? 🙂 Nobody told me this / or read it in any books but whenever I have a reading like yours one of the first things I check is the plate screws and in the majority of the cases the readings get better after tightening them, smoothing out your curves. If they are tighten enough it makes no sense to tighten them more as it brings no benefit but excessive force might cause the screwheads to brake off. You have the feel for it after a while. I have seen cases where the plate screws were not tight on purpose just to sort out some end shake issues but needless to say that's not the right way to go. Plate screws must be tight enough  just like the critical screws in automotive otherwise you screw up the whole movement in my opinion. I must stress that this is only my own opinion and i am just a hobbyist. 
    • I remember when I was in school the instructor would use whale oil on some problematic little tiny ladies watches because he felt it was a better oil. then for my birthday on my friends gave me a bottle of vintage nye watch oil. Complete with the advertisement inside which I have scanned below and what I find interesting is it hasn't gone bad in the model and it is super super thin I'm guessing the viscosity of water basically. then somewhere in the discussion group within the last year or so somebody purchased one of these bottles off of eBay and was using it on their watch. After all a bottle watch oil is? Apparently it was an expensive I'm guessing or it's what they had or something no idea what the final outcome was other than I found it amusing. then somewhere in the Internet somewhat it made up this interesting chart down below. I believe the first natural oil is there 8000 oil. Notice the friction properties in the first two columns in other words it's really good at reducing friction better than anything else.  But it does have additional specifications like contact angle which is almost never found in any spec sheet which has to do with how likely it is to spread. Big numbers are bad in those two columns and you can see spreading test it's very bad. So basically it's a really outstanding oil for a short period of time before it spreads away and of course being natural it has a habit of probably going bad very soon the best oil of course is Elgin oil at least the second version of their oil very good at reducing friction and very good at staying wherever you place it and still very fluid oil viscosity wise. then one of the most famous oils of all Swiss 9010 that I personally don't like and don't use quite a ways down on the chart personally prefer 9020 which unfortunately is not listed on this chart. It slightly heavier viscosity and has a little nicer contact angle those more likely to stay wherever you put it versus 9010 which universally requires epilam if you would like to stay wherever you putting it. then if you're in the viscosities here's an interesting chart that I found on the discussion group. ou will note there some minor variations between the viscosities listed here and the chart up above which may be attributed to the difference in temperature  universally everything is supposed to be at 20° C and the chart up above is at 40° C. Because what becomes interesting on the chart is 8000 is listed out of viscosity of 95 which does agree with their technical information and the PDF for the oil lists at 40° it is 41 where up above the chart everything is either listed as 50 or light whatever that means? Then Elgin oil is listed on the chart in a clever interesting way. you look on the chart at a viscosity of 125 you'll find Dr. Tillwich LGN oil which is the synthetic version of Elgin oil. Many years ago they had a request and gathered up a whole bunch of samples and synthesize the oil and for a while it was available for sale although it was rather expensive I had seen a bottle for about $100. and as far as viscosities go it does appear to be right in both charts in other words at 20° it's 125 and at 40° it's 50. So unfortunately it brings up the problem of viscosity or better yet contact angle determines the spread ability of your lubrication unfortunately we typically don't get contact angle we just get viscosity. So the casual trend is a heavier oil tends to not spread although as we can see from looking at the chart that isn't hundred percent true. As far as reducing friction goes viscosity doesn't necessarily come into play here either. Or basically we don't have enough of the right tech sheets to make a real proper comparison.
    • Somewhere in the back of my mind i thought you had the jewelled seitz pivot gauge, i was just asking if you had this scaled pin gauge as well. I might have just made up that thought  H. 😅
    • Yes, but the idea was that the OP wanted to be able to measure the diameter of the jewel holes in his collection of unordered jewels. Also, depending on the type of micrometre used one has to be careful not to dent the very small pivots (< 0.12mm) when pinching them in the micrometre. In my experience, the JKA Feintaster is safe to use also when measuring very small pivots. I don't understand your question, which I think was for me, no?
    • I didn't think there were any gauges under 0.1  .  I do like the old art deco tanks which are small sizes. My staff stash amounts to around half a mil. So i think I probably have that base covered. This 0.1mm set seems to be the most expensive, larger 100 piece set are about half the price. For around a 100 quid you can have sizes from 0.1 up to 4mm. Bugs me that they charge shipping for each seperate item so no combined shipping fee available.  Do you have the variable pin gauge as well ?
×
×
  • Create New...